Industrials Stock Recommendation Bernard Hosanna Shawana Jackson Brett Kinkopf Jonathan Kocon Chien-Ying Lee
Agenda Recap of Sector Industrial Holdings Stock Recommendations Summary Q&A
Sector Recap SIM Industrials Weight: 12.76% S&P500 Industrials Weight : 10.28% Overweight by 248bps Class agreed to increase 15bps to overweight the sector by 200bps Positive sector developments Improving global growth Unemployment rate improving Rising GDP data Favorable industrial spending
Industrial Holdings Current Holdings Emerson=1.23% General Dynamics=3.57% Oshkosh=4.01% UTI Worldwide=2.38% First Solar=1.57% Total=12.76% Proposed Holdings Emerson=1.23% General Dynamics=3.00% Oshkosh=3.50% UTI Worldwide=2.38% Bucyrus=2.17% Total=12.28% Sell 57 bps of General Dynamics Sell 51 bps of Oshkosh Sell 157 bps of First Solar Buy 217 bps of Bucyrus
First Solar (FSLR) Overview Produces Cadmium Telluride Solar Panels and provides solar energy solution services Is attempting to attain “grid parity” or a ~$0.70/watt price of electricity Have claimed they hit $1/watt… Much lower than the $4/watt for most solar units Considered a growth stock –Has paid no dividends and has seen massive capital gains since its IPO
FSLR in Relation to XLI
FSLR Valuation Absolute Valuation HighLowMedianCurrent#Your Target Multiple *Your Target E, S, B, etc/Share Your Target Price P/Forward E P/S P/B P/EBITDA P/CF
FSLR DCF and Target Price Terminal DCR of 12% Terminal FCF growth of 4.5% Target price of $ Current price of $ Upside of 36.9%!!! So why sell?
Everything Looks OK- So Why Sell? A considerable portion of FSLR’s revenue is based on purchases backed by international governmental subsidies Recently the German government announced that it would decrease its subsidies for photovoltaic panels On February 18 th, FSLR management announced it would widen its EPS guidance to $ $6.85 So the DCF may still look good, but these forecasts are much less certain now In other words- overnight the volatility of this stock increased greatly. This company is beholden to the whims of foreign governments
Bucyrus International Products: –Draglines –Drills –Shovels & excavators –Mining trucks Demand Drivers: –Coal –Copper –Oil sands –Iron ore –Other minerals Designs, manufactures, and markets mining equipment Supplies aftermarket parts and services for mining equipment
Bucyrus International NASDAQ:BUCY Stock Price:$65.82 Market Cap:$4.80b Revenue:$2.65b Diluted EPS:$4.12 Shares:74.46m Dividend Yield:0.20% Risks Commodities market Mining activity Global economy Foreign currency
GDP & Bucyrus
Crude oil spot price & Bucyrus
International Growth Largest surface markets: –Australia –Canada –China –India –South Africa –South America –US Expected growth in Russian and Indonesian markets Largest underground markets: –Australia –Germany –China –US Germany expected to decline as a market Expected growth in Russian, Indian, and Eastern European markets 70% of sales outside of U.S.
Bucyrus’s Financials
Bucyrus’s Key Financial Stats Low current to D/E ratio at 0.37 compared to industry at 2.63 Low PEG ratio at 1.24 compared to industry at year Historical EPS Growth Rate 86.5% Low P/E ratio at compared to industry at 27.16
BUCY’s Valuations
Absolute ValuationHighLowMedianCurrent Target Multiple Target E,S,B Price Target P/Forward E P/S P/B P/EBITDA P/CF Average Price Target = $90.63 = 38% upside
Joy Global’s Valuation Average Price Target = $62.52 = 11% upside
DCF model & Target Price =(50% ave multiples + 50% DCF) =(0.5*$ *$81.50) =$86 (30% upside) Current Share Price : $65.82 Implied equity value/share : $81.5 Upside/(Downside) to DCF : 23.8% Terminal Discount Rate:10.5% Terminal FCF Growth: 5.0%
What the charts suggests
Industry Charts
BUCY vs JOYG Charts over 5 yrs
Summary Proposed Holdings Emerson=1.23% General Dynamics=3.00% Oshkosh=3.50% UTI Worldwide=2.38% Bucyrus=2.17% Total=12.28% Sell 57 bps of General Dynamics Sell 51 bps of Oshkosh Sell 157 bps of First Solar Buy 217 bps of Bucyrus First Solar Uncertain outlook Highly volatile Germans reduces subsidies Bucyrus Rising global growth driven by emerging markets Improving Asian urbanization should drive commodity prices higher Technical charts bullish
BUCY Sensitivity Analysis
Emerson Electric Emerson is a global diversified technology company The company engages in designing and supplying product technology, as well as delivering engineering services and solutions to various industrial, commercial, and consumer markets worldwide Current Share Price : $48.49 Implied equity value/share : $54.56 Upside/(Downside) to DCF : 12.5% Terminal Discount Rate:10.5% Terminal FCF Growth: 5.0%
Oshkosh Industry: Trucks and Other Vehicles Market Cap: $3.3 B Target Price: $44 Current Price: $37.25 Upside Potential: 18%
Uti Worldwide DCF: –Current Price: $15 –Implied/Equity Value: $17 –Upside/(Downside): 10.3% Discount rate: 10% Terminal growth rate: 3.5% HighLowMedianCurrentTarget Multiple Target / Share Target Price P/E - Forward P/S P/B P/EBITD A P/CF Multiples Target Price: $20 Average Target Price: $18.50
General Dynamics Multiple Valuation Absolute Valuation HighLowMedianCurrentTarget Multiple Target value/share Valuation Opinion P/Trailing E P/Forward E P/B P/S P/CF Recommendations DCFLowHighTarget Price Current Price (04/03/2010) Implied equity value/share Upside/( Downside)12.40%6.31%18.31%12.10% HOLD Price Range: $ $86.26 Target Price: 0.5* Ave of multiple valuation price + 0.5* DCF
General Dynamics--DCF Terminal Discount Rate =11.5% Terminal FCF Growth =4.0% Year2009E2010E2011E2012E2013E2014E2015E2016E2017E2018E2019E Revenue % Growth-3.89%10.29%3% 2% Operating Income Operating Margin11.34%12.37%12.86%12.50% Interest and Other Interest % of Sales-0.441%-0.434%-0.435%-0.434% Taxes Tax Rate31.60% Net Income % Growth5.69%14.80%0.04%3.00%2.00% CFO % of Sales9.41%9.50% Subtract Capital Expense % of Sales1.49%1.50%1.49% 1.48% 1.47% 1.46% 1.45% Free Cash Flow % of Growth-3.02%10.43%3.00%3.13%2.00%2.13%2.00%2.13%2.00%2.13%