Working Group: National Transfer Accounts for Population Subgroups Cássio M. Turra & Maurício Holz Seventh Global Conference of the NTA Network East-West.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Projecting NTAs Tim Miller Third NTA Workshop Honolulu, Hawaii January 20, 2006 Thanks to the United Nations CELADE for support.

Advertisements

Two NTA indicators we are thinking about using in the wall chart for Latin America and the Caribbean Tim Miller NTA Working Group on Indicators June 8,

Income and Child Development Lawrence Berger, University of Wisconsin Christina Paxson, Princeton University Jane Waldfogel, Columbia Univerity.

Resource reallocations across generations: the state, the market and the household Robert I. Gal Conference on „Demographic Change.

National Transfer Accounts: Brazil Cassio Turra & Bernardo Queiroz NTA Workshop Berkeley, January 15, 2005.

The Direction of Intergenerational Transfers and Demographic Transition: Findings from Lee & Mason Robert J. Willis University of Michigan.

May 13, 2005Mason, Lee, Tung, Lai, and Miller1 Population Aging and Intergenerational Transfers: Introducing Age into National Accounts Andrew Mason, University.

Macroeconomic Consequences of the Aging Baby Boom Ronald Lee UC Berkeley PAA Session “The Baby Boomers Turn 65” Thanks to Gretchen Donehower for help,

Opening Remarks 2 nd Workshop on National Transfer Accounts Ronald Lee.

United States Country Team Report Third NTA Workshop Honolulu, Hawaii January 20, 2006.

PROJECTIONS OF PUBLIC EXPENDITURES ON EDUCATION, HEALTH CARE, AND PENSIONS IN TEN LATIN AMERICAN COUNTRIES: Tim Miller (CELADE,

How Population Aging Affects the Macroeconomy

Wall chart for Latin American Countries Mauricio Holz UN-CELADE/ECLAC.

Population aging and intergenerational transfers: a global perspective Ronald Lee, University of California, Berkeley Sept 26, 2011 University of Pennsylvania,

Copyright © 2006 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved. Chapter 15 Instability in the Private Economy: Consumption Behavior.

N ational T ransfer A ccounts Comments on Intergenerational Transfers, Age Structure, and Macroeconomics Sang-Hyop Lee University of Hawaii at Manoa WEAI.

“Analyzing Health Equity Using Household Survey Data” Owen O’Donnell, Eddy van Doorslaer, Adam Wagstaff and Magnus Lindelow, The World Bank, Washington.

Distribution of Income and Wealth

David McCarthy NIESR, London, UK Centre for Macroeconomics National Transfer Accounts.

1 Distributional Impact of VAT Reform in the Dominican Republic By Anna Fruttero and Omar Arias LCSPP Frontiers in Practice Reducing Poverty Through Better.

Fiscal Impacts of Korean Public Pension System: A Generational Accounting Approach Young Jun Chun University of Incheon, Korea January 2006.

1 NTA country report China’s Case Ling Li China Center for Economic Research at Peking University Beijing, China

Some economic and fiscal implications of the demographic transition in Latin America. Tim Miller CELADE - Population Division of United Nations Economic.

The consumption effect of the renminbi appreciation in rural China UNCTAD-Vi Trade and Poverty Analysis 2014 Dahai Fu a and Shantong Li b a Central University.

Reflections: Pitfalls and Possibilities A View from the South Cassio M. Turra Princeton University.

April 1, Presentation in Honor of Richard Easterlin’s Continuing Contributions: A Macro- Perspective on Intergenerational Transfers Ronald Lee UC.

N ational T ransfer A ccounts 1 The Lifecycle Deficit: A Review Sang-Hyop Lee University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Manual on National Transfer Accounts: Lifecycle Account Training Workshop 10 th NTA Meeting Beijing, November 2014 Andrew Mason University of Hawaii at.

The Impact of Health Expenses on Older Women ’ s Financial Security Juliette Cubanski, Ph.D. The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation AcademyHealth 2007 Annual.

National Transfer Account 1 National Transfer Account China NTA Workshop I NUPRI, Tokyo, Japan Qiulin CHEN 陈秋霖 CCER, Peking University Beijing, China October.

Time Use and Gender Working Group Gretchen Donehower The Tenth Meeting of Working Group on Macroeconomic Aspects of Intergenerational Transfer Beijing,

Aging and Social Policy: An International Perspective Andrew Mason Sang-Hyop Lee Ronald Lee Chong-Bum An.

Assessing the Distributional Impact of Social Programs The World Bank Public Expenditure Analysis and Manage Core Course Presented by: Dominique van de.

Family Health Program Brazil Coverage and access Aluísio J D Barros Andréa D Bertoldi Juraci Cesar Cesar G Victora Epidemiologic Research Center, UFPel.

Presented at The 129th Annual Meeting of the American Public Health Association Atlanta, GA, October 21–25, 2001 Presented by Kristine R. Broglio Thomas.

Exploring The Determinants Of Racial & Ethnic Disparities In Total Knee Arthroplasty: Health Insurance, Income And Assets Amresh Hanchate, PhD Health Care.

Demographic Dividends: Past, Present, and the Future Andrew Mason University of Hawaii and East-West Center Support: NIA R01-AG

NTA by SES (NTASES, N project) Sang-Hyop Lee University of Hawii at Manoa East-West Center November 12, 2014 NTA 10, Beijing, PRC.

Using Adjusted MEPS Data to Study Incidence of Health Care Finance Thomas M. Selden Division of Modeling & Simulation Center for Financing, Access and.

Constructing a base-line NTA for Chile: preliminary findings Jorge Bravo with the assistance of Mauricio Holz ECLAC/CELADE-Population Division Presented.

How will income security and health care financing be affected by population aging; how should they change? An International Perspective Andrew Mason University.

Measuring Economic Performance Su, Chapter 4. What do we do with all that data? Measure the performance of the economy Learn more about economic performance.

Canadian Public Health Association 2008 Annual Conference Halifax, Nova Scotia, May 31 – June 4, 2008 Does Province of Residence Matter to the Health and.

Fourth Annual Meeting of NTA Project University of California in Berkeley January 2007 CONSTRUCTION OF NATIONAL TRANSFER ACCOUNTS FOR INDIA: METHODS,

N ational T ransfer A ccounts National Transfer Accounts: An Overview Andrew Mason East-West Center University of Hawaii at Manoa.

March 2005Mason et al.1 Population Aging and Intergenerational Transfers: Introducing Age into National Accounts Andrew Mason, University of Hawaii and.

National Transfer Accounts: Brazilian Case Cassio M. Turra Cedeplar/UFMG Bernardo L. Queiroz Cedeplar/UFMG Elisenda R. Perez Cedeplar/UFMG Berkeley, 01/19/2007.

What do we know about the causes of regional growth? Part 3 ECON 4480 State and Local Economies 1.

Obesity, Medication Use and Expenditures among Nonelderly Adults with Asthma Eric M. Sarpong AHRQ Conference September 10, 2012.

Macroeconomic Aspects of Intergenerational Transfers Brazil Cassio M. Turra Bernardo L. Queiroz Elisenda Renteria-Perez.

Four Levels of Intergenerational Indicators Lili Vargha (HDRI, and Robert I. Gal (HDRI) NTA10 - Tenth Meeting.

Public Sector and Population Aging 10 th Global NTA Meeting Beijing, China Andrew Mason.

Equity issues in non-contributory transfer programs PEAM course May 2006, Washington DC Emil Tesliuc Sr Economist, HDNSP.

Economic Impacts of Population Change After Malaria Eradication Conference on Health Improvements for Economic Growth Cambridge, Massachusetts May 30,

The Most Important Graph in the World: US Life Cycle Deficits, Gretchen Donehower UC Berkeley Department of Demography September 27, 2006.

Public Expenditures in NTAs in Comparative Context Introductory remarks by Jorge Bravo 4 th Annual National Transfer Accounts Workshop Berkeley, California,

Public Transfers in NTA Countries Tim Miller Nov 5, 2007 Fifth Annual NTA Seminar and Workshop.

Ageing and the Changing Nature of Intergenerational Flows in Thailand

IG Index (or something like that) AM. Aging and transfers Population aging has two important effects on transfer systems – The balance between inflows.

National Transfer Accounts: Concepts and results for Chile Jorge Bravo, U.N. Population Division Mauricio Holz, ECLAC/CELADE Presentation at the Expert.

Changing Patterns of Intergenerational Transfers and Life-Cycle Consumption in Finland and Sweden The 3rd EuroNTA Workshop 28 October 2010 Institute.

NTA Costa Rican case Luis Rosero-Bixby University of Costa Rica.

1 Consumption and Production Profiles Andrew Mason Sang-Hyop Lee Maliki January 14, 2005 NTA meeting at Berkeley.

Intergenerational Transfers and National Transfer Accounts In honor of Ronald Lee 2016 IUSSP Laureate.

Cervical cancer among Asian subgroups in California, Janet Bates, MD MPH California Cancer Registry NAACCR Annual Meeting Denver, Colorado June.

The Lifecycle Deficit: A Review

Comparing Consumption: inter-national and inter-temporal

National Transfer Accounts: Singapore 2013

Demographic transition and economic growth in Benin

Lifecycle Deficit (Consumption & Labor Income)

Presentation transcript:

Working Group: National Transfer Accounts for Population Subgroups Cássio M. Turra & Maurício Holz Seventh Global Conference of the NTA Network East-West Center, Hawaii, June 2010

Main Motivations The NTA project has examined how resources are allocated in the life cycle by comparing mean flows across age groups  However, compositional effects may affect the estimation of mean flows  Also, mean flows by age may cover different patterns of intergenerational allocations within each country

Central Question Are we interested in a cross-sectional analysis (incidence, progressiveness), in a life cycle analysis (net transfers by SES at birth) or in both?

Research questions for the cross-sectional (period) analysis 1.What is the incidence of public and private transfers by population subgroups? 2.How much different are NTA mean flows by age groups from NTA weighted mean flows by age groups?

Research questions for the cross-sectional (period) analysis 3.How progressive are taxes and spending (net public transfers) by age groups? Should we also look at distributional measures for private transfers? 4.What are the roles played by unit costs of providing public transfers and the use of these services in the incidence and progressiveness analyses?

1) Incidence of public and private transfers (Turra and Queiroz 2006)

1) Incidence of public and private transfers (Lee and Miller 2007)

1) Incidence of public and private transfers (Turra, Holz and Cotlear 2010)

2) Mean flows vs. weighed mean flows Aggregating unit costs may mask real economic age profiles The unit costs for certain types of public transfers may vary by income groups, geographic regions and races For example, in Brazil, (types and costs) of public health services my differ between high and low income groups, residents in the SE and NE, blacks and whites Of course, this discussion is over when we are able to estimate individual values in the micro-data(e.g. pensions)

2) Mean flows vs. weighed mean flows (Lionel Demery)

3) Progressiveness of public and private transfers Several progressivity measures are available for public transfers: –transfers as a % of income or expenditures –Lorenz curves –Index of progressivity (based on Lorenz curves) –Linear regression analysis (spending on income quintile as a function of income quintile) Estimate progressivity measures by large age groups and types of public transfers? Should we also use distributional measures for private transfers?

3) Progressiveness of transfers (Roach 2003)

3) Progressiveness of transfers (Breceda et al. 2009)

4) Decomposing the flows by unit costs and utilization rates (PT xi /N xi )= (PT xi / B xi ) x (B xi / N xi ) Should we simulate the effect of changing units costs or utilization rates on incidence and progressivity?

4) Decomposing the flows by unit costs and utilization rates (Turra, Holz and Cotlear 2010)

Other issues for the cross-sectional (period) analysis  What are the best SES measures to use (not a big issue in the period analysis)?  Individual behavior is not considered (we need to be careful with counterfactual analysis)  Average benefit vs. marginal benefit  We should avoid any life cycle implications from period estimates

Research questions for the life-cycle (cohort) analysis 1.What are the Net Present Value of public transfers for population sub-groups? Are there any transfers between population subgroups over the life cycle? 2.Integrate period and life cycle estimates (Lee 2000)

Lee and Miller (2007)

Life Cycle + Period estimates Zorzin, Wajnman and Turra, following Lee(2000) MenWomen Life Cycle Ratio Period Ratio

Main issues for the life cycle (cohort) analysis  What are the best SES measures to use?  How biased would be the estimates based on a hypothetical cohort (period) data?  Should we include transition rates among SES (from birth to death) in the calculation of NPVs?