Universality in W+Multijet Production David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration Z. Bern, L.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Search for Large Extra Dimensions at the Tevatron Bob Olivier, LPNHE Paris XXXVI ème Rencontre de Moriond Mars Search for Large Extra Dimensions.
Advertisements

Recent Results on the Possibility of Observing a Standard Model Higgs Boson Decaying to WW (*) Majid Hashemi University of Antwerp, Belgium.
Constraining the polarized gluon PDF in polarized pp collisions at RHIC Frank Ellinghaus University of Colorado (for the PHENIX and STAR Collaborations)
Determination of and related results from B A B AR Masahiro Morii, Harvard University on behalf of the B A B AR Collaboration |V cb | MESON 2004, Krakow,
Top Turns Ten March 2 nd, Measurement of the Top Quark Mass The Low Bias Template Method using Lepton + jets events Kevin Black, Meenakshi Narain.
Kevin Black Meenakshi Narain Boston University
Top properties workshop 11/11/05 Some theoretical issues regarding Method 2 J. Huston Michigan State University.
T-CHANNEL MODELING UNCERTAINTIES AND FURTHER QUESTIONS TO TH AND NEW FIDUCIAL MEASUREMENTS Julien Donini, Jose E. Garcia, Dominic Hirschbuehl, Luca Lista,
Universality in W+Jet Production David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration Z. Bern, L. Dixon,
Inclusive Jets in ep Interactions at HERA, Mónica V á zquez Acosta (UAM) HEP 2003 Europhysics Conference in Aachen, July 19, Mónica Luisa Vázquez.
W/Z PRODUCTION AND PROPERTIES Anton Kapliy (University of Chicago) on behalf of the ATLAS collaboration PHENO-2012.
W properties AT CDF J. E. Garcia INFN Pisa. Outline Corfu Summer Institute Corfu Summer Institute September 10 th 2 1.CDF detector 2.W cross section measurements.
Perturbative Stability of V + Jets Ratios and “Data Driven Background” Analyses Lance Dixon (CERN & SLAC) & for the BlackHat collaboration C. Berger, Z.
Universality in W+Jet Production David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration Z. Bern, L. Dixon,
Measurement of α s at NNLO in e+e- annihilation Hasko Stenzel, JLU Giessen, DIS2008.
1 Jets in diffraction and factorization at HERA Alice Valkárová Charles University, Prague On behalf of H1 and ZEUS collaborations.
W + /W - and l + /l - A Means to investigate PDFs T. Schörner-Sadenius, G. Steinbrück Hamburg University HERA-LHC Workshop, CERN, October 2004.
Universality in W+Jet Production David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration Z. Bern, L. Dixon,
16/04/2004 DIS2004 WGD1 Jet cross sections in D * photoproduction at ZEUS Takanori Kohno (University of Oxford) on behalf of the ZEUS Collaboration XII.
Possibility of tan  measurement with in CMS Majid Hashemi CERN, CMS IPM,Tehran,Iran QCD and Hadronic Interactions, March 2005, La Thuile, Italy.
Searches for the Standard Model Higgs at the Tevatron presented by Per Jonsson Imperial College London On behalf of the CDF and DØ Collaborations Moriond.
NEW RESULTS FROM JET PHYSICS AT HERA Thomas Schörner-Sadenius Hamburg University 2 nd HERA-LHC Workshop June 2006.
DIJET (and inclusive-jet) CROSS SECTIONS IN DIS AT HERA T. Schörner-Sadenius (for the ZEUS collaboration) Hamburg University DIS 06, April 2006 Tsukuba,
Precision Cross section measurements at LHC (CMS) Some remarks from the Binn workshop André Holzner IPP ETH Zürich DIS 2004 Štrbské Pleso Štrbské Pleso.
7 th April 2003PHOTON 2003, Frascati1 Photon structure as revealed in ep collisions Alice Valkárová Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics Charles University.
Higgs Reach Through VBF with ATLAS Bruce Mellado University of Wisconsin-Madison Recontres de Moriond 2004 QCD and High Energy Hadronic Interactions.
LHCb: Xmas 2010 Tara Shears, On behalf of the LHCb group.
Jet Physics at CDF Sally Seidel University of New Mexico APS’99 24 March 1999.
Search for the Higgs boson in H  ZZ (*) decay modes on ATLAS German D Carrillo Montoya, Lashkar Kashif University of Wisconsin-Madison On behalf of the.
Z, W bosons: well calibrated probe in pp LHC energies: access to Z, W in pA and AA Electroweak bosons in dilepton channel: No final state modification.
DIS Conference, Madison WI, 28 th April 2005Jeff Standage, York University Theoretical Motivations DIS Cross Sections and pQCD The Breit Frame Physics.
Γ +Jet Analysis for the CMS Pooja Gupta, Brajesh Choudhary, Sudeep Chatterji, Satyaki Bhattacharya & R.K. Shivpuri University of Delhi, India.
Twistor Inspired techniques in Perturbative Gauge Theories-II including work with Z. Bern, S Bidder, E Bjerrum- Bohr, L. Dixon, H Ita, W Perkins K. Risager.
1 Diffractive dijets at HERA Alice Valkárová Charles University, Prague Representing H1 and ZEUS experiments.
Jets and α S in DIS Maxime GOUZEVITCH Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet Ecole Polytechnique – CNRS/IN2P3, France On behalf of the collaboration On behalf of.
DIJET (and inclusive-jet) CROSS SECTIONS IN DIS AT HERA T. Schörner-Sadenius (for the ZEUS collaboration) Hamburg University DIS 06, April 2006 Tsukuba,
NLO Vector+Jets Predictions with B LACK H AT & SHERPA David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration.
Jet Studies at CDF Anwar Ahmad Bhatti The Rockefeller University CDF Collaboration DIS03 St. Petersburg Russia April 24,2003 Inclusive Jet Cross Section.
1 Heavy Flavour Content of the Proton Motivation Experimental Techniques charm and beauty cross sections in DIS for the H1 & ZEUS Collaborations Paul Thompson.
Jet + Isolated Photon Triple Differential Cross Section Nikolay Skachkov: “Photon2007”, Paris, 9-13 July 2007 DO Measurement of Triple Differential Photon.
October 2011 David Toback, Texas A&M University Research Topics Seminar1 David Toback Texas A&M University For the CDF Collaboration CIPANP, June 2012.
Charged Particle Multiplicity, Michele Rosin U. WisconsinQCD Meeting May 13, M. Rosin, D. Kçira, and A. Savin University of Wisconsin L. Shcheglova.
1 Measurement of the Mass of the Top Quark in Dilepton Channels at DØ Jeff Temple University of Arizona for the DØ collaboration DPF 2006.
April 7, 2008 DIS UCL1 Tevatron results Heidi Schellman for the D0 and CDF Collaborations.
CT14 PDF update J. Huston* PDF4LHC meeting April 13, 2015 *for CTEQ-TEA group: S. Dulat, J. Gao, M. Guzzi, T.-J. Hou, J. Pumplin, C. Schmidt, D. Stump,
Moriond QCD March 24, 2003Eric Kajfasz, CPPM/D01 b-production cross-section at the TeVatron Eric Kajfasz, CPPM/D0 for the CDF and D0 collaborations.
V +Jets at Next-to-Leading Order with BlackHat David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the BlackHat Collaboration Carola.
LHC Higgs Cross Section Working Group: Vector Boson Fusion Sinead Farrington University of Oxford Co-contacts: A. Denner, C. Hackstein, D. Rebuzzi, C.
Costas Foudas, Imperial College, Jet Production at High Transverse Energies at HERA Underline: Costas Foudas Imperial College
Jessica Levêque Rencontres de Moriond QCD 2006 Page 1 Measurement of Top Quark Properties at the TeVatron Jessica Levêque University of Arizona on behalf.
RHIC-PV, April 27, 2007 M. Rijssenbeek 1 The Measurement of W ’s at the CERN and FNAL hadron colliders W ’s at RHIC ! W ’s at CERN – UA2 W ’s at FNAL -
F Don Lincoln f La Thuile 2002 Don Lincoln Fermilab Tevatron Run I QCD Results Don Lincoln f.
Maximal Unitarity at Two Loops David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay work with Kasper Larsen & Henrik Johansson; & work of Simon.
Vectors + Multijet Theory with B LACK H AT and Sherpa David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration.
The B LACK H AT ( 黑帽 ) Library for One-Loop Amplitudes David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration.
1 R JETS Predictions at NLO with MCFM James Buchanan.
Moriond 2001Jets at the TeVatron1 QCD: Approaching True Precision or, Latest Jet Results from the TeVatron Experimental Details SubJets and Event Quantities.
Search for Standard Model Higgs in ZH  l + l  bb channel at DØ Shaohua Fu Fermilab For the DØ Collaboration DPF 2006, Oct. 29 – Nov. 3 Honolulu, Hawaii.
Inclusive jet photoproduction at HERA B.Andrieu (LPNHE, Paris) On behalf of the collaboration Outline: Introduction & motivation QCD calculations and Monte.
Proposals for near-future BG determinations from control regions
Measurement of SM V+gamma by ATLAS
First Evidence for Electroweak Single Top Quark Production
QCD Radiative Corrections for the LHC
Sílvia Bravo i Gallart IFAE, Barcelona Moriond-QCD, 18 March 2002
W Charge Asymmetry at CDF
ATLAS 2.76 TeV inclusive jet measurement and its PDF impact A M Cooper-Sarkar PDF4LHC Durham Sep 26th 2012 In 2011, 0.20 pb-1 of data were taken at √s.
New d+Au RHIC data show evidence for parton saturation
W/Z and Di-Boson Results from ATLAS Srivas Prasad Harvard University On behalf of the ATLAS Collaboration Pheno Madison, Wisconsin May 09, 2011.
W/Z and Di-Boson Results from ATLAS Srivas Prasad Harvard University On behalf of the ATLAS Collaboration Pheno Madison, Wisconsin May 09, 2011.
Top mass measurements at the Tevatron and the standard model fits
Presentation transcript:

Universality in W+Multijet Production David A. Kosower Institut de Physique Théorique, CEA–Saclay on behalf of the B LACK H AT Collaboration Z. Bern, L. Dixon, Fernando Febres Cordero, Stefan Höche, Harald Ita, DAK, Adriano Lo Presti, Daniel Maître, Kemal Ozeren [ , , , , & work in progress] Rencontres de Moriond, La Thuile March 27, 2014

Theory for Many Jets

NLO Revolution: On-Shell Methods Formalism Known integral basis: Unitarity in D = 4 On-shell Recursion; D-dimensional unitarity via ∫ mass

B LACK H AT + SHERPA B LACK H AT – One-loop matrix elements – Software library and its eponymous collaboration – Automated, numerical implementation of unitarity method COMIX – Born + real-emission matrix elements – Catani–Seymour subtraction terms SHERPA – Process Management – Phase-space integration – No showering

Running at High Multiplicity Managing a high-multiplicity computation is complicated – Many different contributions with wide dynamic range – Split up into parts of different significance to compute with different statistics – Many pieces to baby-sit & combine – Computationally intensive – Would need to repeat for each scale choice; each PDF within an error set; each new observable Computing matrix elements overwhelmingly dominates computation time at given scale Computing new observables is cheap Varying μ R, μ F also cheap once terms within matrix element are known Likewise for choice of parton distributions

n -Tuples Solution: recycle! Compute matrix elements once, save phase-space configurations with weights & coefficients needed to recompute for different μ R, μ F, PDFs Save these as ROOT n-tuple files Analyses done with lightweight C++ or ROOT codes Bonus: distribute these to experimenters, who can do their own analyses Only real restriction is to preselected set of jet algorithms Jet, lepton/photon p T, rapidity cuts can be tightened PDFs, scales can be chosen differently Now available publicly for W,Z+  4 jets, QCD  4 jets, γγ+2 jets (std & VBF)

W+4 Jets

W+5 Jets Scale-uncertainty bands shrink dramatically Last jet shape is stable, harder jets have steeper spectrum at NLO Last three jet shapes look similar, just getting steeper

Jet-Production Ratios Ratios reduce uncertainties both in experiment and theory W+1: missing subprocesses W+2: kinematic restrictions ( W cannot be close to leading jet ) Looking differentially: relaxation of kinematic restrictions leads to substantial NLO corrections at large p T in W+3/W+2, corrections smaller for higher multiplicity Ratio is not constant as a function of jet or W p T Studies suggest similarities of shapes of ratios

Let’s try extrapolating ratios to larger n We know the W+2/W+1 ratio behaves differently from W+n/W+(n − 1) ratios, because of kinematic constraints & missing processes (especially at LO) We could extrapolate from W+4/W+3 & W+3/W+2 — but with two points and two parameters, how meaningful is that? With the W+5/W+4 ratio, a linear fit (with excellent χ 2 /dof) makes the extrapolation meaningful: W − + 6 jets: 0.15 ± 0.01 pb W jets: 0.30 ± 0.03 pb Extrapolations Uncertainty estimates from Monte-Carlo simulation of synthetic data

Look at distribution of total transverse energy in jets: good probe into high-p T physics Let’s try to extrapolate the distribution to W+6 jets Different thresholds Different peaks

Extrapolating

Summary Study of an important Standard-Model process at high jet multiplicity: W+4,5 jets Study of Standard-Model signals in widely-varying kinematic regimes gives confidence in our ability to understand backgrounds quantitatively at high multiplicity Reliability of ratios, signs of universality for  3 jets Extrapolations to W+6 jets