PTAB Trial Proceedings Tips from the Bench October 16, The Honorable Brian Murphy (PTAB) Louis W. Beardell, Jr. (Morgan Lewis & Bockius) Michael F. Snyder (Volpe and Koenig)

Trial Proceeding Timeline 2

AIA Progress (as of October 2, 2014) AIA Monthly Filings Total2,094 IPR1,852 CBM 234 PGR2 DER6

AIA Progress (as of October 2, 2014) AIA Petition Technology Breakdown

AIA Progress (as of October 2, 2014) Cumulative Patent Owner Preliminary Responses FiledWaived IPR1, CBM14920

AIA Progress (as of October 2, 2014) AIA Petition Dispositions Trials Instituted Joinders Percent Instituted Denials Total No. of Decisions on Institution IPR FY %26203 FY % FY %415 CBM FY %317 FY %26104 FY %-2 DERFY14--0%33

Discovery 7 Discovery Period

AIA Progress (as of October 2, 2014) AIA Final Dispositions Settlements Adverse Judgments Final Written Decisions IPR FY FY FY CBM FY FY FY15 ---

Settlements * (As of 6/18/2014) CBMIPR 9 * Pool is taken from 169 cases that have settled since inception.

Final Written Decisions: Basis for Unpatentability (As of 6/18/2014) CBM (11 decisions) IPR (67 decisions) 10 * Multiple bases can be reported for a single Final Written Decision

Thank You 11