Balance Between Audit/Compliance and Risk Management- Best Practices FIRMA 21 st National Training Conference Julia Fredricks, U.S. Chief Compliance Officer.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Organizational Governance
Advertisements

WHO, WHAT, HOW Your Internal Audit Team …by your side. …at your service. …in your best interests.
MSCG Training for Project Officers and Consultants: Project Officer and Consultant Roles in Supporting Successful Onsite Technical Assistance Visits.
VALUE OF INTERNAL AUDITING: ASSURANCE, INSIGHT, OBJECTIVITY A PRESENTATION TO STAKEHOLDERS ABOUT THE VALUE OF INTERNAL AUDITING.
Risk The chance of something happening that will have an impact on objectives. A risk is often specified in terms of an event or circumstance and the consequences.
Internal Control–Integrated Framework
Debt Management Strategy: Governance and Transparency
Chapter 10 Accounting Information Systems and Internal Controls
Risk Management and Internal Controls ASSAL 20 November 2014 Annick Teubner Chair, IAIS Governance Working Group.
Introduction to Enterprise Risk Management (ERM)
Meeting with IESBA CPAB Update Glenn Fagan and Kam Grewal April 7, 2014.
Executive Insight through Enhanced Enterprise Risk Management Leverage Value From Your Risk Management Investment.
Audit Committee in Albania Legal framework Law 9226 /2006 “On banks in Republic of Albania” Law 9901/2008 “On entrepreneurs and commercial companies” Corporate.
“Necessity is the Mother of Invention” Gaining Value from Regulatory Demands Kevin Butcher Senior Vice-President, Enterprise Systems, BMO Financial Group.
Tax Risk Management Keeping Up with the Ever-Changing World of Corporate Tax March 27, 2007 Tax Services Bryan Slone March 27, 2007.
Regulatory Reform and Implications for the Municipal Bond Market RBDA Financial Regulatory Reform Webinar Lynnette Kelly Hotchkiss, Executive Director.
Performing a Fiduciary Review of Trust Administration FIRMA April 2009 Independent Fiduciary Services ® Independent Fiduciary Services, Inc.  th.
Strategic Management & Strategic Competitiveness
Risk Management at ANZ Banking Group Jun 18, 2008 Patrick Zhu Head of Retail Risk China Partnerships.
Viewpoint Consulting – Committed to your success.
From an Operational View Point and as part of the Investment Process and Fiduciary Responsibilities of Trustees Fran Asp Asp Management Consulting
Purpose of the Standards
Corporate Ethics Compliance *
“The Impact of Sarbanes Oxley, An Evolving Best Practice” Ellen C. Wolf Senior Vice President & Chief Financial Officer American Water National Association.
PAINTING THE FULL PICTURE
Session 4: Good Governance: How SAIs influence Good Governance in Public Administration Zahira Ravat 27 & 28 May 2014.
BPM Governance Identifying methods for prioritizing, standardizing, measuring and controlling BPM efforts.
Corporate Governance in Financial Institutions OCDE/IAIS/ASSAL Conference on Insurance Regulation & Supervision in Latin America Punta Cana, Dominican.
WHERE WE ARE 22 member associations in 20 countries Over 4300 individual members who are responsible for risk management and/or insurance in their organisations.
1.  The views expressed are those of the speaker and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors, or the Federal Reserve.
Challenges Faced in Developing Audit Plans and Programs 21 st March, 2013.
DAA and GEP Orlando Audit & Compliance or Audit vs. Compliance.
Presenting The Broker-Dealer Certification Tool The Compliance Department Inc. Broker Dealer Compliance Consultants Compliance SCORE Powered by Keane BRMS.
Your Internal Audit Team …by your side …at your service …in your best interests.
D-1 McGraw-Hill/Irwin ©2005 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Module D Internal, Governmental, and Fraud Audits “I predict that audit.
Risk Assessments/Risk Appetite Judith Gruenbaum 1.
Agenda Purpose and design of board and management committees
Advanced Diploma of Financial Planning Copyright TAFE 2014 Advanced Diploma of Financial Planning.
Chapter 3 Internal Controls.
All information contained within this document is proprietary to Risk Limited Corporation. prepared by Commercial Real Estate Hedging & Risk Management.
responsAbility Social Investments AG
Managing the Privacy Function at a Large Company Kimberly S. Gray, Esq., CIPP Chief Privacy Officer Highmark Inc.
Managing Risk Through Performance Measurement FIRMA Risk Management Training Conference Lori Loken-King - SVP Union Bank, N.A., Operational Risk Management.
Role of the Board of Directors
Private & Confidential1 (SIA) 13 Enterprise Risk Management The Standard should be read in the conjunction with the "Preface to the Standards on Internal.
Oversight of the ERISA Fiduciary April 9, 2008 J. David Thompson Bank of New York Mellon Corporation.
Northern Trust Company Global Risk Management
APPA - Enterprise Risk Management LCRA’s ERM Journey Presented by JoEllen Peterman, ERM Program Manager September.
Divisional Chief Executives Supported by Divisional Risk Committees Executive Committee Group Chief Executive Group Functions Group Finance Director Group.
Where Do We Go From Here: Risk Management after the Financial Meltdown Kevin McCabe Wells Fargo Audit Services EVP & Chief Auditor FIRMA 24 th National.
Balance Between Audit/Compliance and Risk Management – Best Practices FIRMA - 21 st National Training Conference David Bilko Chief Audit Executive SunTrust.
Or How to Gain and Sustain a Competitive Advantage for Your Sales Team Key’s to Consistently High Performing Sales Organizations © by David R. Barnes Jr.
APPA - Enterprise Risk Management LCRA’s ERM Journey Presented by JoEllen Peterman, ERM Program Manager March 29, 2007.
Company: Cincinnati Insurance Company Position: IT Governance Risk & Compliance Service Manager Location: Fairfield, OH About the Company : The Cincinnati.
Health Management Dr. Sireen Alkhaldi, DrPH Community Medicine Faculty of Medicine, The University of Jordan First Semester 2015 / 2016.
Board Chair Responsibilities As a partner to the chief executive officer (CEO) and other board members, the Board Chair will provide leadership to Kindah.
1 Emerging Issues in Internal Audit Charles Ndegwa.
ICAJ/PAB - Improving Compliance with International Standards on Auditing Planning an audit of financial statements 19 July 2014.
1 Vereniging van Compliance Officers The Compliance Function in Banks Amsterdam, 10 June 2004 Marc Pickeur CBFA CBFA.
Strategic development program
Value of internal auditing: Assurance, Insight, objectivity
Value of internal auditing: Assurance, Insight, objectivity
Board of Directors Roles and Responsibilities
2017 Administration and Finance Conference
Value of internal auditing: Assurance, Insight, objectivity
Value of internal auditing: Assurance, Insight, objectivity
Audit and Compliance Coordination
Presentation transcript:

Balance Between Audit/Compliance and Risk Management- Best Practices FIRMA 21 st National Training Conference Julia Fredricks, U.S. Chief Compliance Officer Harris Financial Corp April 19, 2007

1 Background  Harris Financial Corp is owned by BMO Financial Group, based in Toronto. BMO Financial Group provides a broad and comprehensive range of retail banking, wealth management and investment banking products and solutions. Our financial services professionals provide access to services our customers require across our enterprise. We serve our clients through three operating groups: Personal and Commercial Banking, Private Client Group and Investment Banking Group.  Harris’ goal is to be the leading personal and commercial bank in the U.S. Midwest. Our community banking strategy leverages strong local leaders focused on exceptional customer service, offering a broad range of products and services through an expanding distribution network. This approach underlies our successful growth in the highly competitive and fragmented Chicago market and provides us with a strategic advantage when entering new markets. Strategies include:  Provide a best-in-class customer experience by emphasizing a strong performance culture and putting our best people in key positions with clear accountabilities.  Align our retail, business and wealth management offerings to meet all of our clients’ needs.  Expand our distribution network through a combination of acquisitions and new branches.

2 BMO/Harris Structure – Legal, Audit, Compliance, and Risk BMO CEO BMO Chief Administrative and Financial Officer BMO Chief Risk Officer Harris Chief Risk Officer BMO General Counsel Harris General Counsel BMO Chief Compliance Officer Harris Chief Compliance Officer BMO Chief Auditor Harris Chief Auditor  Risk, Legal, and Compliance all report through the same executive chain of command. Audit is independent. This consistency allows for ease of communication, and consistent message in how we work with the Lines of Business (“LOBs”)  Disciplines are aligned enterprise-wide  The U.S. heads of each discipline report independently to Harris Board or Committees of the Board

3 Group Mandates  Compliance Mandate: U.S. Corporate Compliance is responsible for the monitoring and oversight of regulatory risk within the U.S. Compliance performs independent reviews of controls in place to manage regulatory risk.  Audit Mandate: Corporate Audit Division provides an independent assessment as to the effectiveness of internal control within the Enterprise. Audit performs independent reviews of controls in place to manage all risk types.  Risk Management Mandate: Risk Management ensures the organization’s credit, market, liquidity/funding, fiduciary and operational risks are understood, quantified, documented, mitigated where appropriate, aggregated where necessary and constrained in keeping Corporate Policy. Risk management facilitates risk and control self assessment (“RCSA”) sessions with the lines of business.  Legal Department Mandate: Law Department is responsible for management of legal services enterprise-wide across the Enterprise, including (without limitation) the management of litigation matters and external legal counsel management, and providing advice and recommendations to LOBs and other internal groups on their legal (including fiduciary) risks and mitigating their legal (including fiduciary) risk exposure. Fiduciary Risk is a subset of Legal Risk. Legal oversees the resolution of compliance and litigation matters that may result in legal or regulatory sanctions.

4 Is Structure Effective? How to maximize information sharing  Legal, Audit, Compliance, and Risk Management meet on a frequent basis  All new products and revised policies are reviewed by Legal, Audit, Compliance, and Risk  Audit reviews the work performed by Compliance prior to performing a review and adjusts their scope based upon work done by Compliance. To be able to rely on their work, Audit performs a full audit of Compliance every 12 months  Audit and Compliance obtain most current RCSA as part of planning process for reviews  Audit is copied on all Compliance reports, and Compliance is copied on all Audit reports – these reports are used in planning process  Legal, Audit, and Compliance are invited to all independently facilitated RCSA sessions that are managed by Risk  Compliance meets with Legal before reviews. Legal is copied on all Compliance reports  Reports to Audit Committee are coordinated to reduce duplication – Legal and Audit review Compliance Report. One report is produced for Communications with Regulators that includes input from all three areas.  Compliance developed a “universe” document detailing all business units and the regulations applicable to those units. Compliance worked with Legal, Audit, and Risk to review the document in detail, and obtained their concurrence on its completeness. Each group reconciled “universe” to their population document.

5 Is Structure Effective? What to watch out for  Areas that are heavily regulated result in more overlap. Areas such as trust, broker-dealer, and registered investment advisors. We work closely to reduce overlap, but some naturally exists.  Challenge exists in managing the need and desire of primary banking regulator to have an “enterprise-wide” view of compliance risk management, with the separately regulated subsidiary’s primary regulator’s need and desire to have the compliance staff an embedded part of their entity. We manage this through dual reporting structures, which adds complexity.  Legal, Audit, Compliance, and Risk are all “independent” of the line of business, so who works with the LOB to implement corrective action? Need to have the ability to cross that line or LOB ends up having issues that they cannot address.  Issues that are reported to executive management and the Board – need to be careful that as issue is presented by various areas giving their point of view or “spin”, there is consistency in how the issue is portrayed, and that the facts are accurate. Risk having item reported several times and more risky is that item is reported differently based upon who is making the report.  Risk that one area assumes another area is covering something when in fact they aren’t – risk of “white space”. For example, Audit assumed Compliance was doing something or Risk was covering it, when Risk and Compliance thought Audit was covering it.

6 Is Structure Effective? Key to Success COMMUNICATE