Dynamics of Extra-solar Planetary Systems with Hot Jupiters C. Beaugé (UNC) S. Ferraz-Mello (USP) T. A. Michtchenko (USP) USP-UNC team on Exoplanets:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Star & Planet Formation Minicourse, U of T Astronomy Dept. Lecture 5 - Ed Thommes Accretion of Planets Bill Hartmann.
Advertisements

Planetary Migration and Extrasolar Planets in the 2:1 Mean-Motion Resonance (short review) Renate Zechner im Rahmen des Astrodynamischen Seminars basierend.
Resonance Capture generalization to non- adiabatic regime Observatoire de Cote d’Azur, Jan 2007 Alice Quillen University of Rochester.
Tidal Dynamics of Transiting Exoplanets Dan Fabrycky UC Santa Cruz 13 Oct 2010 Photo: Stefen Seip, apod/ap At: The Astrophysics of Planetary Systems:
Multi-planetary systems:.  Binaries  Single Star and Single Planetary Systems  Multi-planetary systems.
Planet Formation Topic: Resonances Lecture by: C.P. Dullemond Literature: Murray & Dermott „Solar System Dynamics“
Asteroid Resonances [1]
“Spin-orbit resonances: our Solar System in context” Alexandre Correia (University of Aveiro / Paris Observatory) IAU Symposium 276, Turin, 14 th October.
1 Determining the internal structure of extrasolar planets, and the phenomenon of retrograde planetary orbits Rosemary Mardling School of Mathematical.
Tidal Influence on Orbital Dynamics Dan Fabrycky 4 Feb, 2010 Collaborators: Scott Tremaine Eric Johnson Jeremy Goodman Josh.
Extrasolar Planets More that 500 extrasolar planets have been discovered In 46 planetary systems through radial velocity surveys, transit observations,
Planetary Rings. Rings are swarms of orbiting particles Orbits have to be very circular Elliptical orbits will result in collisions, destroying the ring.
1 Why exoplanets have so high eccentricities - By Line Drube - November 2004.
The `Nice’ Model Öpik approximation Planet migration in a planetesimal disk The Nice model Consequences of the Nice Model: Epoch of Late Heavy Bombardment,
Some 3 body problems Kozai resonance 2 planets in mean motion resonance Lee, M. H
Observed Properties of Multiple - Planet Systems.
Are there Planets outside the Solar System ? First answer : 1992 Discovery of the first Extra-Solar Planet around the pulsar PSR (Wolszczan &Frail)
Ge/Ay133 What effects do 1-10 M Earth cores & Jovian planets have on the surrounding disk? Or, … Migration & Gaps.
Reflected Light From Extra Solar Planets Modeling light curves of planets with highly elliptical orbits Daniel Bayliss, Summer Student, RSAA, ANU Ulyana.
Extra-Solar Planets Astronomy 311 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 24.
Eccentric Extrasolar Planets: The Jumping Jupiter Model HD217107b as imagined by Lynette Cook Stacy Teng TERPS Conference Dec. 9, 2004.
Based on the definition given by Kasting et al. (1993). The Habitable Zone.
PX437 EXOPLANETS Solar wobble Displacement of the Sun over 45-year period, as observed from 33 light-years away. NASA JPL.
8 Exoplanets Worlds Without End Copyright Lynette Cook, used with permission.
Extra-Solar Planets Astronomy 311 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 24.
COMETS, KUIPER BELT AND SOLAR SYSTEM DYNAMICS Silvia Protopapa & Elias Roussos Lectures on “Origins of Solar Systems” February 13-15, 2006 Part I: Solar.
Extrasolar Planets Z:\exo\presentations\EGS2001_exo.ppt, :54AM, 1 Tidal interactions of close-in extrasolar planets with their host stars.
A coherent and comprehensive model of the evolution of the outer solar system Alessandro Morbidelli (OCA, Nice) Collaborators: R. Gomes, H. Levison, K.
 formation of non-resonant, multiple close-in super-Earths (which exist around 40-60% (?) of solar type stars)  N-body simulation (Ogihara & Ida 2009,
Exoplanets Astrobiology Workshop June 29, 2006 Astrobiology Workshop June 29, 2006.
Gravity & orbits. Isaac Newton ( ) developed a mathematical model of Gravity which predicted the elliptical orbits proposed by Kepler Semi-major.
Predicting the Future of the Solar System: Nonlinear Dynamics, Chaos and Stability Dr. Russell Herman UNC Wilmington.
Lecture 3 – Planetary Migration, the Moon, and the Late Heavy Bombardment Abiol 574.
Chaotic Case Studies: Sensitive dependence on initial conditions in star/planet formation Fred C. Adams Physics Department University of Michigan With:
The Doppler Method, or the Radial Velocity Detection of Planets: II. Results.
Stability of Extra-solar Planetary Systems C. Beaugé (UNC) S. Ferraz-Mello (USP) T. A. Michtchenko (USP) USP-UNC team on Exoplanets:
The law of orbits:  All planets move in elliptical orbits, with the sun at one focus.
Planets in Debris Disks Renu Malhotra University of Arizona Planet-Debris co-evolution Where can debris exist? Cases: Solar system, upsilon Andromedae,
Jean-Pierre needs to be brought up to date on what’s really going on in astronomy these days!
Planetary Rings. Rings are swarms of orbiting particles Orbits have to be very circular Elliptical orbits will result in collisions, destroying the ring.
Astronomy Chapter Seventeen: The Solar System 17.1 About the Solar System 17.2 The Planets 17.3 Other Solar System Objects.
Testing Planet Migration Theories by Observations of Transiting Exoplanetary Systems 1/39 University of Tokyo Norio Narita.
Extra-Solar Planet Populations Stephen Eikenberry 4 November 2010 AST
Dynamics of comets and the origin of the solar system Origin of solar systems - 30/06/2009 Jean-Baptiste Vincent Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung.
in protoplanetary discs and OUTER SOLAR SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE
Institute for Astronomy University of Vienna Stable planetary orbits in multiple planetary systems.
Formation of the Solar System. A model of the solar system must explain the following: 1.All planets orbit the sun counterclockwise 2.All planets orbit.
Planets in exotic Locations. Exotic I: Planets around Pulsars.
Alice Quillen University of Rochester Department of Physics and Astronomy Oct, 2005 Submillimet er imaging by Greaves and collaborato rs.
Stellar Classification & Planet Detection
Lecture 34 ExoPlanets Astronomy 1143 – Spring 2014.
Late Work Due 12/20/13 Remember ain’t no butts about it! Sticking your head in the sand won’t make the deadlines go away 11 Days Remain.
Neptune’s Resonances With Kuiper Belt Objects and What It Tells Us About the Early Solar System The Origin of Pluto’s Orbit: Implications for the Solar.
DYNAMICAL EVOLUTION OF THE SEINAJOKI ASTEROID FAMILY Vladimir Đošović Bojan Novaković The sixth Symposium "Mathematics and Applications" 17. October2015.
Space Telescope Symposium May 2005 Planetary Dynamics: Chaos & Cleanup 1 Space Telescope Symposium May 2005 From observations of our own and other systems.
Timing Transits to Find Extrasolar Earths Eric Agol, Jason Steffen (UW) Re’em Sari (Caltech) Will Clarkson (Southampton) (MNRAS, in press)
2012 Spring Semester Topics in Current Astronomy - Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems - Course ID: Building 19 / Room number 207 for.
The peculiar properties of the Solar System Alessandro Morbidelli CNRS/Observatoire de la Cote d'Azur, Nice, France.
PX437 EXOPLANETS Solar wobble Displacement of the Sun over 45-year period, as observed from 33 light-years away. NASA JPL.
O n t h e T r a c k o f M o d e r n P h y s i c s
Figure 4. Same as Fig. 3 but for x = 5.5.
Figure 1. Orbital evolution of the planetesimals and Jupiter-mass planet in simulation S1. The solid points show the planetesimals. The radii of the planetesimals.
Planetary system dynamics
Internal structure and atmospheres of planets
Protoplanetary Formation efficiency and time scale
Ge/Ay133 What have radial velocity surveys told
Planetary Orbits Recall eccentricity e defined by:
The Structure of the Solar System
Resonance Capture generalization to non-adiabatic regime
Presentation transcript:

Dynamics of Extra-solar Planetary Systems with Hot Jupiters C. Beaugé (UNC) S. Ferraz-Mello (USP) T. A. Michtchenko (USP) USP-UNC team on Exoplanets:

Why do we study the Dynamics of Extrasolar Planetary Systems ? To know how stable they are ! Ref: Brasil CoRoT week, Natal 2004

3 (4) classes Ia – Planets in mean-motion resonances Ib – Low-eccentricity Non-resonant Planet Pairs II – Non-resonant Planets with a Significant Secular Dynamcis III – Weakly interacting Planet Pairs

Period ratio of consecutive planets in a system I II III

Class Ia – Planet pairs in Mean-Motion Resonance Star Period m.sin i a Period Eccentricity planets ratio (m_Jup) (AU) (days) HD c,b GJ c,b HD b,c Cnc b,c(?) HD b,c

GJ 876 (0,  ) apsidal corotation resonance

SYMMETRIC APSIDAL COROTATIONS  (0,0) Ref: Beaugé et al., Lee and Peale Hadjidemetriou et al

M0=1.15 Msun m1=1.7 Mjup/sin i m2=1.8 Mjup/sin i

Ref: Ferraz-Mello et al. (ApJ 2005) The orbits of the least-squares solution are bound to a catastrophic event in less than 100,000 years.

The planets of 47 UMa M = 2.9 M M = 1.1 M 1 Jup 2 Jup

Class Ib – Low-eccentricity Near-resonant pairs Star(MS) Period m.sin i a Period Eccentricity planets ratio (m_Jup) (AU) (days) 47 UMa b,c(?) Planets Period Mass a Period Eccentricity ratio (m_Jup) (AU) (years) Jupiter Saturn Uranus Neptune Outer Solar System

Solar System with Saturn initialized on a grid of different initial conditions 50 Myr Collision Chaos Order Grid: 33x251 Ref: Michtchenko (unpub.) 2/1 7/3 5/2 8/3.

Star Period Mass a Period Eccentricity (PSR) ratio (m_Earth) (AU) (days) Class Ib – Low-eccentricity Near-resonant pairs Near Resonant Pulsar Planets

Grid: 21x101 Neighborhood of the 3 rd planet of pulsar B Pulsar system initialized with planet C on a grid of different initial conditions. The actual position of planet C is shown by a cross. (N.B. I=90 degrees) collision

One question: (Brasil CoRoT week, Natal 2004) Is it possible to find a system of two close-in planets with period ratio close to 2.5?

Dynamical Map of the Neighborhood of the 5:2 MMR e2= x40 px cf TAM e1

TIDAL EVOLUTION OF SYSTEMS OF HOT JUPITERS DIVERGENT MIGRATION If the star rotation is slower than the orbital motion of the inner planet, the migration is divergent.

INTERACTION WITH RESONANCES Consequences: Enhancement of eccentricities and inclinations, semi-major axis discontinuities, but no capture into the resonance.

Example (highly hypothetical) --2: crossing Time units ~ 2 x 10 4 to 5 x 10 5 years t41227.dat Masses 0.82 Sun 1.1e-4 star 7.2e-4 star

(same example as before) 3: : :1 7:4 ---

(same example as before)

One more realistic example t41223.dat Masses 0.82 Sun 1.1e-4 star 7.2e-4 star Time units ~ 2 x 10 4 to 5 x 10 5 years

(same example as before) 3: t23e

(same example as before)

SCALING : Adopted value of k 2 / Q ~ 2 x Actual values cf. Paetzold & Rauer, x < k 2 / Q < 2 x Hence, the scaling is in the range 10 3 to 3 x 10 4

Synchronization (due to tides raised on the planet) Scaling ~ 10 3 t41231.dat

The tidal theories fail to give the right period for large satellites (oceans ?) The spin-orbit synchronization weakens the action of torques due to planet tides. Only remaining effect: fast circularization

Masses 0.82 Sun 8.2e-5 star 7.2e-4 star t50323.dat A new example. start: 2:1 ACR Tides on both star and planet Time unit ~ 4 x 10 3 yrs

Astro-ph/0511xxx / v2 / / / / Planet systems data (+ updates): See:

Data from: Ferraz-Mello et al (2005) [HD 82943], Laughlin et al (2005) [GJ 876], Vogt et al. (2005) [HD12831, HD and HD 37124], McArthur et al.(2004) [55 Cnc ], Correia et al. (2005) [HD ], Gozdziewski et al. (2005) [mu Ara = HD ], Santos et al. (2004) [HD e], Mayor et al. (2004) [HD ], Fischer et al (2002) [HD 12661], Ford et al. (2005) [upsilon Andromedae], Konacki & Wolszczan (2003) [PSR ].