Believed Cues to Deception: A Qualitative Investigation 1 Rachel Taylor 2 – University of Glamorgan Crystal Rolfe – University Hospital Wales, Cardiff.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The people Look for some people. Write it down. By the water
Advertisements

Here’s an interesting conversation. It’s a little lengthy
LETS LOOK AT HOW THE NEWS IS MADE! WHY ARE NEWS SOURCES BIASED?
Practitioner Research for Older People
A.
S3 Useful Expressions.
Lesson 10: Dealing with Criticism
© 2011 wheresjenny.com Conversations. © 2011 wheresjenny.com Conversations Conversation 1 Kate: Hey Tina. Tina: Hello Kate. Kate: I heard that you and.
Team Meeting Communication Skills
Making Sense of Resemblances: Accounting for sensory experience and in/tangibility Katherine Davies Based on Mason, J. and Davies, K. (2009) ‘Coming to.
Investigating the decision making process in patients with non-curative cancer who have been invited to join a clinical research trial Student: Mary Murphy.
REFUSAL SKILLS GETTING OUT OF PERSUASIVE SITUATIONS.
1 Florida 4-H Leadership Series Communications The activities in this lesson are taken from Unlock Your Leadership Potential, Leader’s Guide, Florida 4-H.
WRITING CRITIQUE GROUP GUIDELINES Writing responses to your group members’ work and receiving responses from others is the most important step in revising.
How young people position selves and others in discussing everyday risks Dave Merryweather - ESRC 2012.
What children think about having a thyroid disorder: a small scale study By Shannon Davidson Age 10.
USING AND PROMOTING REFLECTIVE JUDGMENT AS STUDENT LEADERS ON CAMPUS Patricia M. King, Professor Higher Education, University of Michigan.
Mathematics Support Centres: Who uses them & who doesn’t? Why and why not? 1.
Writing a website article to give advice
Help and Hindrance in Apprentice Progression to HE David E Berry Tamsin Bowers-Brown.
Perceptions of the Role of Feedback in Supporting 1 st Yr Learning Jon Scott, Ruth Bevan, Jo Badge & Alan Cann School of Biological Sciences.
TELEPHONE INTERVIEWS : Telephone Interviews are very popular in modern fast work culture. Telephone interviews are often conducted by employers in the.
Science and the Public Conference 19th May 2007 Public engagement as a socio-cultural learning process science communication research using drama and discussion.
Page 22. Writing Page 22 A. 1. Have you ever watched a quiz show on television? What did you think of it? 2. Would you ever participate in a quiz show?
Supporting Families with LGBT Children Calderdale & Kirklees Women ’ s Centre and Gay and Lesbian Youth in Calderdale: a joint project.
OB : Building Effective Interviewing Skills Building Effective Interviewing Skills Structure Objectives Basic Design Content Areas Questions Interview.
৳ Look, I’ve got a leaflet about it.
A Good Start: Resilience in Families With a first Baby Irene de Haan BRCSS/SPEaR Colloquium.
PUPPETS: talking science, engaging science, learning science Stuart Naylor Nature and Learning Conference Vordingborg, May 2010.
Sight Words.
Fan Letter Mrs. Flowers. Step 1 Give a little 2-3 sentence introduction about yourself. Don't lie to make it sound better. Be honest with them. Who are.
Youth Advocacy Annual questionnaire 2012 Results.
Exactly what you ordered. Terry created a key to change her husband’s personality. She thought she was doing the best for both of them, but it might open.
The Sixth Period Reading & Listening. Questionnaire (3m) Step 1: In your group, think of four situations among friends. Design four questions accordingly.
Ways of Collecting Information Interviews Questionnaires Ethnography Books and leaflets in the organization Joint Application Design Prototyping.
Decision making following deceptive interactions Rachel Taylor and Paul Nash University of Glamorgan This research was supported by a Social Sciences Small.
Interviews What not to do and what may be okay.. Preparing for Job Interviews Accepting an Interview Congratulations! Your application, resume, cover.
Mentoring in primary education Marieke Jaspers Under supervision of Theo Wubbels and Paulien Meijer Research in Teaching and Teacher.
Resource 20a. Scenario 1 Rachel was a quiet 16 year old. After listening to her friends she thought she was the only one of her peer group who hadn't had.
1©2015 Public Impact OpportunityCulture.org Flip through each thought bubble until you get to a card that says stop. Then pause for the next talking interchange.
If It Was My Last Lecture.. By: Daisy Lozano. My Childhood Dreams.. When I was younger I had different dreams. I always wanted to be the pink power ranger.
Exploring the expectations and experiences of ‘widening participation’ students admitted to health professional programmes Presenter: Alison Draper Lecturer.
MYJ - Strengthening Family Relationships. Activities: View stories from p ‘You and Your Family’ article Discuss key points List the guidelines.
Seek First to Understand, Then to Be Understood
FAMILY ISSUES №WordsDefinitions 1caringathe state of being free from public attention 2sharing (mutual)bthe state of being protected from the bad things.
Lesson 19 – Problem Solving Skill 3: Set a Goal and Gather Information.
Slide 1. Slide 2 AT THE SCHOOL BUTOP! ONE FEAR AND ONE HOPE FOR MY CHILD AND.
Active Listening Skills
Two love songs by Billy Joel. Greatest Hits Volume III Released: 1997 Keeping The Faith An Innocent Man.
Habit 5 Seek First to Understand, Then to Be Understood.
High Frequency Words.
STRATEGIES FOR GIVING ORAL PRESENTATIONS. TIPS FOR IMPROVING YOUR PUBLIC SPEAKING 1. Do your homework. Nobody can give a good presentation without putting.
Mann, Vrij & Bull. When people are lying… What behaviours do you expect them to have?
Skills For Effective Communication
 It’s overly complicated, simply because my mother wanted it to be.  The “Maria” part was only added to balance the next two names. “Mayumi” is actually.
© 2015 albert-learning.com How to talk to your boss How to talk to your boss!!
An Interview Dialogue Name: Period:. Step Five Interview- An Interview Dialogue You are going to read the question and pick the best response. The person.
Showing Up Accompanying SES; Strategies for Process Reflection and Guided Practice for Engaging Emotionally Charged Situations Like ACPE Certification.
2015 年下学期 湖南长郡卫星远程学校 制作 13 Grammar and usage 年下学期 湖南长郡卫星远程学校 制作 13 Look at some idioms and change idioms to plain English in each sentence. Jack.
This I Believe Essay Writer’s Workshop: Introductions, Juicy Details, & Conclusions 8 th ELA St. Joseph School.
A Brief Guide to Historical Interviews English 8.
WHAT IS PEER PRESSURE? Pressure from people of one’s own age to behave in away that is similar or acceptable of them.
Created By Sherri Desseau Click to begin TACOMA SCREENING INSTRUMENT FIRST GRADE.
课标人教实验版 高二 Module 6 Unit 3. Listening on workbook.
Words That Attract Women: Your Unfair Advantage Over Rich, Good-Looking Guys...
Verbal listening: Listening.
Genius Hour Answering Your Questions. Goals/Intentions of Genius Hour To learn something or achieve something Make a change in your life or in the world.
Damned if you do and Damned if you don’t
Lesson 19 – Problem Solving Skill 3: Set a Goal and Gather Information.
Presentation transcript:

Believed Cues to Deception: A Qualitative Investigation 1 Rachel Taylor 2 – University of Glamorgan Crystal Rolfe – University Hospital Wales, Cardiff 1: This project was funded by a postdoctoral seedcorn grant from the European Association of Experimental Social Psychology 2:

Background research Theoretical approaches to lie detection (e.g. Vrij, 2000)  Emotional approach  Cognitive approach  Control approach  Some support for control/cognitive approaches in terms of actual cues to deception (e.g. Vrij, Edward and Bull, 2001; Vrij, Edward, Roberts and Bull, 2001)  NB: Beliefs about deceptive behaviour fit best with the emotional approach! Even when lie detectors are experts and situations are low stake Fitting into a self-presentational perspective (DePaulo, 1992; DePaulo et al., 2003)

So why qualitative?..The use of a qualitative methodology may yield different results  Heath (2000) – use of an open-ended questionnaire = more flexible (less stereotyped) beliefs about the cues to deception

The current study Piloted the use of a semi-structured interview method  27 interviews conducted  Participants presented lies in either an intimate, acquaintance or stranger context  Generated four lies – high/low stake and easy/difficult  Discussed verbal and non-verbal cues as well as general issues around lying.

Results and discussion Deception is a STRATEGIC activity  Awareness of nervousness (AND the importance of control)  Importance of detail  Awareness of other person’s expectations  Use of other person in collusion  Distraction of self/deflection of other

Results and discussion Awareness of nervousness (AND the importance of control)  “He’s, he is doing his damnedest to look her in the eye, although he’s feeling nervous…” (P24) “He’d be, goodness, don’t know really, suppose, trying to keep a straight face, not show anything on his face, he wouldn’t want to look worried or anxious because that would give it away…” (P4) “When I’m nervous, I bite the side of my lip anyway, so when I’m talking I usually do that, but again, what I try to do is I try to incorporate maybe before she asks me…” (P18)

Results and discussion Importance of detail “Yeah, not to get any further into the lie because y’know you’re digging a deeper hole aren’t you?” (P19) “I’ll usually just try and, try and sort of get off the subject without seeming too dismissive of what she’s asking me, so I’ll just give her a straightforward answer…” (P7) “Leaving a bit of a break in order to assess how much information to give. So as not to give too much and too detailed a response, but more of a, not a scatty response but a you know, you know how it is’…fairly vague but then maybe with one example of strong detail” (P17)

Results and discussion Awareness of other person’s expectations “I’d have probably thought about it to be honest. The minute I decided to lie about it…As soon as I’ve decided I’m going to pretend it’s not going to happen, I’d have already thought about it in my mind. I’d imagine them saying ‘where did that scratch come from?’” (P5) “And I’ll talk quickly and I’ll mumble a lot and she’ll get fed up in the end. ‘Cos I know what she’s like and she hasn’t got time to listen and she’ll go like, ‘ah, tell me later’ and she’ll forget about it…” (P18)

Results and discussion Use of the other person in collusion “I: So if he asked you ‘what were you doing last night’ what would you say? P: ‘I went out with G. or someone’ mention people he knows.” (P15) “…possibly, um, I would pick up on the similar things she might have encountered during the day, I’d know where this lecturer lives so I’d know she’d have to come along the same route…” (P17) “They are basically still denying, you’re asking the questions and they are denying it to you saying, ‘he’s got it in for me, he’s saying I’ve done this, that and the other,’ making up stories to cover their own trail.” (P21)

Results and discussion Distraction of self/deflection of other “I imagine he, he would, erm, he would become more brief, he’d try and skip over facts that he doesn’t have the answers to, that he can’t lie about so much, so he’s skipping over things, he’s trying to divert attention.” (P24) “I was trying to well, sort of remind her that during the time I was there with her, that I was contacting L. all the time and that I missed her very much. This was all truth as well…” (P15) “Just either carry on with whatever you’re doing…make sure you carry on with what you’re doing.” (P6) “…I’d carry on with whatever I was doing. So if I was doing the dishes or something, I wouldn’t stop doing the dishes…” (P5)

Conclusions Qualitative method = promising for investigating beliefs about the cues to deception Support for a self-presentational perspective on believed as well as actual cues Further analysis – roles of stakes and target Further research – extension of qualitative approach to perceived cues, inclusion of personality variables, links to self-reported deception/detection ability.