3-D Imaging with STEREO STEREO Science Working Group Meeting, Dec 15-16, 2003 Space Science Laboratory (SSL), University of Berkeley Markus J. Aschwanden.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Summary of 2008 Science Team Meeting. Collaboration With Dr. Wiegelmann 1. NLFFF extrapolation, leading person: Ju Jing. Objective: adapt codes to BBSO.
Advertisements

The magnetic nature of solar flares Paper by E.R. Priest & T.G. Forbes Review presented by Hui Song.
The Relationship Between CMEs and Post-eruption Arcades Peter T. Gallagher, Chia-Hsien Lin, Claire Raftery, Ryan O. Milligan.
CME/Flare Mechanisms Solar “minimum” event this January For use to VSE must be able to predict CME/flare Spiro K. Antiochos Naval Research Laboratory.
A flare compilation Lots of people including Louise Harra, Lidia van Driel Gesztelyi, Chris Goff, Sarah Matthews, Len Culhane, Cristina Mandrini, Pascal.
Orsay, th SECCHI Consortium Meeting: Wiegelmann et al.: SECCHI-3D reconstruction software Wiegelmann, Inhester, Feng, Ruan, Thalmann, Podlipnik.
Coronal Loop Oscillations and Flare Shock Waves H. S. Hudson (UCB/SSL) & A. Warmuth (Astrophysical Institute Potsdam) Coronal loop oscillations: introduction.
Integrating Global MHD Models with SECCHI Observations Pete Riley, Zoran Mikic, Jon Linker, Roberto Lionello, and Slava Titov SAIC, San Diego, California.
Vincent Surges Advisors: Yingna Su Aad van Ballegooijen Observations and Magnetic Field Modeling of a flare/CME event on 2010 April 8.
1 Determination of 3D CME Trajectories using Stereoscopy Paulett Liewer, Jeff Hall, Eric DeJong, JPL Vahab Pournaghsband, UCB Arnaud Thernisien and Russ.
Understanding Magnetic Eruptions on the Sun and their Interplanetary Consequences A Solar and Heliospheric Research grant funded by the DoD MURI program.
Incorporating Vector Magnetic Field Measurements into MHD models of the Solar Atmosphere W.P. Abbett Space Sciences Laboratory, UC Berkeley and B.T. Welsch,
Magnetic Helicity • Magnetic helicity measures
Magnetic Shear in Two-ribbon Solar Flares Yingna Su 1,2 Advisors: Leon Golub 1, Guangli Huang 2 Collaborators: A. A. Van Ballegooijen 1, E. E. Deluca 1,
5 th SECCHI Consortium Meeting, May Tomographic Reconstruction of CMEs from White Light Coronagraph Data Tomographic Reconstruction of CMEs from.
2007 March 61 The SECCHI Campaign Jean-Pierre Wuelser SECCHI Consortium Meeting Orsay.
Magnetic Stereoscopy of the Coronal Loops L.Feng, T.Wiegelmann, B.Inhester, S.Solanki, P.Ruan Max-Planck Institute for Solar System Research.
Measuring, Understanding, and Using Flows and Electric Fields in the Solar Atmosphere to Improve Space Weather Prediction George H. Fisher Space Sciences.
Coronal Loop Oscillations and Flare Shock Waves H. S. Hudson (UCB/SSL) & A. Warmuth (Astrophysical Institute Potsdam) Coronal loop oscillations: (Fig.
Paper Review Special Issue of Solar Physics (I) STEREO Science Results at Solar Minimum Volume 259, Numbers 1-2 / October 2009 Yan Xu 2010 Nov. 02.
SDO/AIA science plan: prioritization and implementation: Five Objectives in 10 steps [C1]1 I: C1/M8/C10 Transients: Drivers & Destabilization Chair(s):
Session C8 Coronal Data Products AIA/HMI Science Team Meeting 16 February 2006 Marc DeRosa.
RHESSI and global models of flares and CMEs: What is the status of the implosion conjecture? H.S. Hudson Space Sciences Lab, UC Berkeley.
WG 1 Summary Techniques and Applications. WG1 sessions New algorithms: UV smooth, electron maps Source locations Source sizes Source fluxes (imaging spectroscopy)
Twist & writhe of kink-unstable magnetic flux ropes I flux rope: helicity sum of twist and writhe: kink instability: twist  and writhe  (sum is constant)
1 Interpreting SECCHI White Light Images: FOV Sensitivity & Stereo Viewing Paulett Liewer, JPL; Russ Howard & Dennis Socker, NRL SECCHI Consortium Meeting.
3D Heliospheric Reconstructions from the SECCHI White Light Coronagraphs Onboard STEREO: Overview of the NRL Approach J. Newmark, J. Cook, P. Reiser, P.
STEREO Space Weather Group update Dave Webb ISR, Boston College and Air Force Research Laboratory STEREO SWG October 2009 Meredith, NH.
SECCHI SPD D ELECTRON DENSITY RECONSTRUCTION FROM THE SECCHI CORONAGRAPHS and EUVI ONBOARD STEREO Jeffrey Newmark, John Cook Naval Research Laboratory.
Assessing Predictions of CME Time- of-Arrival and 1 AU Speed to Observations Angelos Vourlidas Vourlidas- SHINE
Instant Tomography of Active Regions Markus J. Aschwanden Jean-Pierre Wuelser, Nariaki Nitta, & James Lemen (LMSAL) STEREO Science Working Group Meeting.
Will it Fit? A Comparison of Asymmetric Magnetic Reconnection Models and Observations Drake Ranquist Brigham Young University Advisors: Mari Paz Miralles.
08__050610_SCIP/SEB_PSR_Delivery.1 SECCHI Data Processing, Analysis and Access Jeff Newmark Naval Research Laboratory
PCL SECCHI - 1 SECCHI - Visualization & Analysis Tools for Images from Two Spacecraft Paulett Liewer-JPL, John Cook-NRL and SECCHI Team STEREO Science.
Solar System Physics Group Heliospheric physics with LOFAR Andy Breen, Richard Fallows Solar System Physics Group Aberystwyth University Mario Bisi Center.
1 Determination of CME 3D Trajectories using COR Stereoscopy + Analysis of HI1 CME Tracks P. C. Liewer, E. M. DeJong, J. R. Hall, JPL/Caltech; N. Sheeley,
3-D Perception of Coronal Loop Structures
Simulation of stereoscopic EUVI image pairs Markus J. Aschwanden David Alexander Nariaki Nitta Thomas Metcalf Richard Nightingale James Lemen (LMSAL) 2nd.
Newark, Wiegelmann et al.: Coronal magnetic fields1 Solar coronal magnetic fields: Source of Space weather Thomas Wiegelmann, Julia Thalmann,
Heliospheric Imager – Scientific Operations  HI Operations Document – R. Harrison  HI Image Simulation – C. Davis & R. Harrison  HI Operations Scenarios.
Space Science Activities at NRL Presentation to the National Space Weather Assessment Committee Herbert Gursky Superintendent, Space Science Division Naval.
Using potential field extrapolations of active region magnetic fields, observed by SOHO/MDI, as a representation of a real active region, we apply hydrostatic.
Heliospheric Imager – Scientific Operations  HI Operations Document – R. Harrison (presented by Dave Neudegg – SciOps for Cluster, Mars Express, Double.
1 3D Sun Loop Trace: A Tool for Stereoscopy of Coronal Loops for STEREO Jean Lorre Jeff Hall Paulett Liewer Parth Sheth Eric DeJong Jet Propulsion Laboratory.
New STEREO/SECCHI Processing for Heliospheric Transients David F. Webb ISR, Boston College, MA, USA New England Space Science Consortium.
Flare Energy Build-Up in a Decaying Active Region Near a Coronal Hole Yingna Su Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory Collaborators: A. A. van Ballegooijen,
Forward-Modeling for 3D Reconstruction from STEREO Observations Markus J. Aschwanden & LMSAL team FIRST STEREO WORKSHOP, Carre de Sciences, March 18-20,
1 Solar stereoscopy - where we are and which developments do we require to progress? Thomas Wiegelmann, Bernd Inhester, Li Feng, Judith de Patoul.
2004 AGU Fall Meeting, San Francisco, 3-5 Nov 2004 STEREO/SECCHI Simulations of CMEs and Flares Using TRACE images Markus J. Aschwanden Markus J. Aschwanden.
KASI Low atmospheric reconnections associated with an eruptive flare Yong-Jae Moon(1), Jongchul Chae(2), Young-Deuk Park(1) 1: Korea Astronomy and.
SECCHI 3D Reconstruction Efforts at NRL Angelos Vourlidas Naval Research Laboratory With inputs from: R. Howard, J. Newmark, J. Cook, P. Reiser.
Algorithm Preparation and Data Availability 1. Mullard Space Science Laboratory, University College London. 2. Physics and Astronomy Department, University.
11. Assessing the Contribution of Heliospheric Imaging, IPS and other remote sensing observations in Improving Space Weather Prediction Bernie Jackson,
1 Stereographic Analysis of Coronal Features for the STEREO Mission Eric De Jong, Paulett Liewer, Jeff Hall, Jean Lorre, Shigeru Suzuki and the SECCHI.
1 Global magnetic connectivity in the Hollween events of 2003 (Zhang et al. 2007; Zhou et al. 2006)
DFW, STSWG,Caltech, 13Nov07 STEREO Space Weather Group Update Space Weather Group Website: - Group leaders: Dave Webb & Doug Biesecker - Website being.
Doug Biesecker NOAA/Space Environment Center. Beacon Ground Station Network Almost together –CNES – signed letter of agreement received Toulouse – 9m.
SWG040322SECCHI_STATUS.1 SECCHI Status R.A. Howard Presentation to STEREO SWG 22 March 2004 Boulder, Colorado.
1 P. C. Liewer, E. M. DeJong, J. R. Hall, JPL/Caltech; K. E. J. Huttunen, Y. Li, J. Luhmann, B. Lynch, UCB/SSL; Angelos Vourlidas & R. A. Howard, NRL;
Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, University of California, San Diego 9500 Gilman Drive #0424, La Jolla, CA , U.S.A
Three-Dimensional Structure of Coronal Mass Ejections From LASCO Polarization Measurements K. P. Dere, D. Wang and R. Howard ApJL, 620; L119-L
Using STEREO/EUVI to Study Active Region Magnetic Fields Anne Sandman (Rice/LMSAL) Markus Aschwanden, Jean-Pierre Wuelser, Marc DeRosa (LMSAL), David Alexander.
Global coronal seismology and EIT waves Istvan Ballai SP 2 RC, University of Sheffield, UK.
1 Determination of CME 3D Trajectories using Stereoscopy STEREO CMES of 16Nov2007 and 31AUG2007 P. C. Liewer, E. M. DeJong, J. R. Hall, JPL/Caltech; R.
Multiwavelength Study of Solar Flares Chang Liu Big Bear Solar Observatory, NJIT Seminar Day November 2, 2007.
LWS Proposal 3D Reconstruction of White Light Coronagraph Images from Multiple Viewpoints PI John Cook, Co-I’s Jeffrey Newmark, Paulett Liewer, Collaborators.
SECCHI - Visualization & Analysis Tools for Images from Two Spacecraft
Combining Geometric- and View-Based Approaches for Articulated Pose Estimation David Demirdjian MIT Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory.
Solar Eruption Onset: Where Does the Action Begin?
N. Nitta1, J.-P. Wuelser1, J. Lemen1, M. Aschwanden1, G. Attrill2
Presentation transcript:

3-D Imaging with STEREO STEREO Science Working Group Meeting, Dec 15-16, 2003 Space Science Laboratory (SSL), University of Berkeley Markus J. Aschwanden (LMSAL) Session 2: Issues for Discussion

1) How does Science drive the STEREO 3D Imaging & Analysis ?

1) How does Science drive the STEREO 3D Imaging & Analysis ? Theoretical concept or model Image analyis, modeling, fitting

Philosophy: 1)Scientific question expressed by quantifyable observables 2)Development of data analysis tools that quantify observables and are sensible to answer the question 3) YES/NO answer would ideally confirm/disprove model

Philosophy: 1)Scientific question expressed by observables 2)Development of data analysis tools that are sensible to answer the question 3) YES/NO answer would ideally confirm/disprove model Example: 1)Does “Magnetic Break-out” or “loss-of-equilibrium” model trigger eruption of filament and lead to a CME ? 2)Develop tool to derive 3D magnetic field from STEREO data and forward-fit 3D evolution with MHD codes. 3)None, one, or both models yield a good fit to data,  disproves both models, confirms one model, or ambiguous choice

Magnetic breakout model (Antiochos 99) Data modeling: 1) pattern recognition (“finger-printing”) 2) 3D-parameterization of field lines 3) Reconstruct time evolution B(x,y,z,t)

“loss-of-equilibrium” model (Forbes & Priest 1995) Data Analysis: (1)Measure footpoint convergence (driver ?) (2)Measure vertical motion [h(t), v(t), a(t)] (3)Fit theoretical model of h(t) to data.

Required Data Analysis Tools: 1)Automated pattern recognition for curvi-linear structures (2D parameterization of magnetic field lines) 2) Tie-point finding algorithm of individual field Lines in two STEREO images 3) Combining 2D projections from 2 STEREO images into 3D coordinate of field lines 4) Volumetric modeling of CMEs by tomography, algebraic backprojection, or geometric forward-fitting

2) Methodology, Strategy, and Approach of 3D Imaging Data Analysis

2) Methodology, Strategy, Approach of 3D Imaging Data Analysis Forward-Fitting

2) Methodology, Strategy, Approach of 3D Imaging Data Analysis Forward-Fitting -Requires parameterization of model -Number of parameters could be large -2D projection is given, only 3D coordinates need to be constrained by 2 nd STEREO image -Strategy: develop tool with automated 2D-parameterization of curvi-linear features (loops, filaments, fluxropes, sigmoids, postflare loops, etc.) -3D coordinate can be first constrained by a-priori model (potential field, force-free, simple geometries, and then iteratively refined with projections from 2 nd image, starting with the most unique and unambigous tie-points.

2) Methodology, Strategy, Approach of 3D Imaging Data Analysis Forward-Fitting Inversion

2) Methodology, Strategy, Approach of 3D Imaging Data Analysis Inversion Inversions generally are coarse because of data noise, ambiguities, non-uniquneness Advantage of inversions: they are model-independent Inversion methods for STEREO images: e.g. 3D tomography (SMIE, Bernie Jackson) 3D Pixon reconstruction (SECCHI, John Cook; commercially available)

Choise of 3D-modeling method: Tomography, 3D-Pixon, Forward-Modeling ?

STEREO - ASTEREO - B STEREO Timing: Small stereo angles (1 st year, <45 deg) most suitable for stereoscopy Large stereo angles (2 nd year, <90 deg) better for volume tomography

Forward-fit Algorithm for Stereo Image Pair: 1. Selection of structure-rich multi-wavelength image from TRACE, EIT, and/or Yohkoh database (with filament, flare, CME, fluxropes, etc.) 2. Tracing linear features (loops, filaments, fluxropes) in 2D: s(x,y) 3. Inflation from 2D to 3D with prescription z(x,y) s(x,y) -> s(x,y,z) 4. Physical model of structures: T(s), n(s), p(s), EM(s) 6. Line-of-sight integration EM(x’,y’)=  EM(x’,y’,z’)dz’ and convolution with instrumental response function 5. Geometric rotation to different stereo angles EM(x,y,z) -> EM(x’,y’,z’) 

Simulation of STEREO images at different stereo angles

Volumetric Forward-Modeling of Stereo images versus Inversion with tomography EITSMIE

Pixon reconstruction of CME structures in STEREO images:

(Bernie Jackson) 3D tomography reconstruction of SMIE data

3) Interfacing 3D Imaging: SECCHI – HI – SMEI – SDO - …

3) Interfacing 3D Imaging: SECCHI – HI – SMEI – SDO - …

Discussion – Session 2:  HI Image Simulation – Chris Davis  HI Operations – Davis Neudegg  HI/SECCHI – Sarah Matthews  SMEI – Dave Webb, Bernie Jackson (accomplished tomography at low resolution)  VSO (Virtual Solar Observatory) – Bill Thompson

Other Input:  SECCHI high/low telemetry rate vs. stereo separation angle (Wuelser)  Automated Detection and 3D Reconstr. EUV Prominences (Claire Fullon)  LASCO, Automated detection of CMEs (David Berghmans)  SECCHI White-light Coronograph 3D heliospheric reconstruction/pixon (Reiser, Cook, Newmark, Crane, Yahil, Gosnell, Puetter)  Image tomography based on magnetic field input (Bernd Inhester, Maxim Kramer; Stereo meeting 2002)  Automated pattern recognition used for finding tie-points (Paulett Liewer and Eric de Jong)  Multiscale Vision Model  multi-scale tie-points ? global matching, local w. epipolar lines (Fabrice Portier-Fozzani, 2001) optical flow methods (T.Papadopoulo et al. 2000) – (Thierry Dudok de Wit, Image processing meeting 2003)

Web-sites related to STEREO 3D Imaging: