Shanker Iyer Shanker Iyer & Co 30 th May 2008 NEXIA INTERNATIONAL – TAX CONFERENCE Cross Border Transactions
Agenda Case Study I Case Study II Questions
1 Case Study I
Case Study – 1 Singapore Company (Singapore Co.) Liberian Holding Company (Liberian Co.) 100% Share ownership Loan Loan = 30% of (Capital + Loan) 2 Switzerland Cos. (Swiss Co.) 100% Share Ownership i.e. 70% of (Capital + Loan) Dividend Interest Dividend Interest
Case Study – 1 Singapore Company (Singapore Co.) Liberian Holding Company (Liberian Co.) 100% Share ownership Loan Loan = 30% of (Capital + Loan) 2 Switzerland Cos. (Swiss Co.) 100% Share Ownership i.e. 70% of (Capital + Loan) Dividend Interest Dividend Interest Without Singapore SPV - Swiss distribution WHT 35% Singapore tax treaty benefits Singapore territorial tax system Singapore foreign income exemption scheme Singapore’s one tier dividend system
Dividends Case Study – 1 Singapore Company (Singapore Co.) Liberian Holding Company (Liberian Co.) 100% Share ownership Loan Loan = 30% of (Capital + Loan) 2 Switzerland Cos. (Swiss Co.) 100% Share Ownership i.e. 70% of (Capital + Loan) Dividend Interest Dividend Interest
Case Study – 1 Singapore Company (Singapore Co.) Liberian Holding Company (Liberian Co.) 100% Share ownership Loan Loan = 30% of (Capital + Loan) 2 Switzerland Cos. (Swiss Co.) 100% Share Ownership i.e. 70% of (Capital + Loan) Dividend Interest Dividend Interest
Case Study – 1 Singapore Company (Singapore Co.) Liberian Holding Company (Liberian Co.) 100% Share ownership Loan Loan = 30% of (Capital + Loan) 2 Switzerland Cos. (Swiss Co.) 100% Share Ownership i.e. 70% of (Capital + Loan) Dividend Interest Dividend Interest Capital gain
1 Case Study II
Case Study – 1I Marshall Islands (“MI Co.”) Singapore (“Sing Co.”) Netherlands (‘Dutch Co.) Ukrainian Properties Bank Loan Finance US$ 53mn Investment US$ 9mn Investment US$ 62mn
Singapore tax treaty benefits Singapore territorial tax system Singapore foreign income exemption scheme Marshall Island (“MI Co.”) Singapore (“Sing Co.”) Netherland (‘Dutch Co.) Ukrainian Properties Bank Loan Finance US$ 53mn Investment US$ 9mn Investment US$ 62mn Case Study – 1I
Marshall Island (“MI Co.”) Singapore (“Sing Co.”) Netherland (‘Dutch Co.) Ukrainian Properties Bank Loan Finance US$ 53mn Investment US$ 9mn Investment US$ 62mn Where it went wrong in this structure One condition to foreign source income exemption : not in favor “Exemption with Progression” not incentive
Marshall Island (“MI Co.”) Singapore (“Sing Co.”) Netherland (‘Dutch Co.) Ukrainian Properties Bank Loan Finance US$ 53mn Investment US$ 9mn Investment US$ 62mn Negative Ruling by IRAS Proper planning and interpretation of law at preliminary stage Additional cost burden for client Case Study – 1I
Questions