A Comparative Analysis of Quality of Life of Patients Treated by Radical Cystectomy and Sigmoid Neobladder versus Chemoradiation in Muscle Invasive Cancer.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
No. 091 Bipolar Diathermy for Transurethral Resection of Prostate: 6 year Australian Single Regional Centre Experience Devang Desai (Urology Registrar),
Advertisements

BPH Diagnosis and Medical Treatment
Case 1: George Case 1: George
SHORT-TERM PATIENT REPORTED QUALITY OF LIFE AFTER ROBOT-ASSISTED RADICAL CYSTECTOMY USING THE CONVALESCENCE AND RECOVERY EVALUATION (CARE) Abid Hussain.
MODULE 5 1/26 Case 6: Anthony. MODULE 5 Case 6: Anthony 2/26 Patient History  Anthony is a 55-year old lawyer.  He has been suffering from voiding complaints.
BROOKLYN 2 RADIOTHERAPY Patries HERST Sat 31 st Aug 2013 Session 1 / Talk 1 09:20 – 09:46 ABSTRACT Purpose. Acute radiation-induced cystitis is a common.
Consent for Research Study A study for patients newly diagnosed with advanced glioblastoma (brain cancer): Learning whether a PET scan with F-fluoromisonidazole.
ARTIFICIAL DISC VERSUS FUSION A prospective randomised study with 2-year follow-up on 99 patients.
Chapter 51 Experiments, Good and Bad. Chapter 52 Experimentation u An experiment is the process of subjecting experimental units to treatments and observing.
Spotlight Case Treatment Challenges After Discharge.
Short-term outcomes after endovascular treatment for chronic cerebrospinal venous insufficiency (CCSVI) in patients with multiple sclerosis Kenneth Mandato,
INTRODUCTION TO ICD-9-CM
Hematuria By: Kayla Jahr.
® Introduction Low Back Pain Remedies and Procedures: Helpful or Harmful? Lauren Lyons, Terrell Benold, MD, Sandra Burge, PhD The University of Texas Health.
1 Measuring Patients’ Experience of Hospital Care Angela Coulter Picker Institute Europe
Urological History & Examination Dr. Abdelmoniem ElTraifi.
Disability and Incontinence Patient assessment Patient management.
Therapeutic Education: Cancer Patients on chemotherapy: Shamim Akhter QURESHI MBBS,MPH, Ingénieur d’étude(EHESP) 2 nd June 2012 June 2010.
Copyright © 2008 Delmar Learning. All rights reserved. Unit 36 Subacute Care.
LUTS Shawket Alkhayal Consultant Urological Surgeon Benenden Hospital Tunbridge Wells Nuffield Hospital.
Urology Update Sanofi- Aventis
Amany M. Shebl Professor Of Medical-surgical Nursing Dean. Nursing Faculty, Mansoura University, Egypt.
Clinico-Dosimetric Correlation for Acute and Chronic Gastrointestinal Toxicity in Patients of Locally Advanced Carcinoma Cervix Treated With Conventional.
Conservative treatment of faecal incontinence Jim Hill Manchester Royal Infirmary.
Sandeep Bagla, MD Cardiovascular & Interventional Radiology Inova Alexandria Hospital.
Treating Chronic Pain in Adolescents Amanda Bye, PsyD, Behavioral Medicine Specialist Collaborative Family Healthcare Association 15 th Annual Conference.
PROFESSOR RONA MOSS-MORRIS ADHERENCE TO PSYCHOLOGICAL INTERVENTIONS IN MS.
H. Emama M.D.. (Radiation Therapy) By: H. Emami Assistant professor of Radiation Oncology, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, IRAN.
Neoplasms of the bladder
ROLE OF PERCUTANEOUS TIBIAL NERVE STIMULATION (PTNS) IN THE TREATMENT OF NEUROGENIC OVERACTIVE BLADDER SYNDROME Perugia G., Corongiu E., Borgoni.
Efficacy of sodium hyaluronate in the management of chemical and radiation cystitis Sommariva et al. Minerrva Urol Nefrol 2010.
C-BR- 1 Raptiva ™ (efalizumab) Benefit:Risk Assessment Charles Johnson, MB, ChB Senior Director Head of Specialty Biotherapeutics Genentech, Inc.
Consent for Research Study A study for patients newly diagnosed with advanced glioblastoma (brain cancer): Learning whether a PET scan with F-fluoromisonidazole.
1 Ambassador Program Presentation Prevention & Early Detection PROSTATE CANCER.
The GOLIATH Study ..
1 Impact of Implementing Designed Nursing Intervention Protocol on Clinical Outcome of Patient with Peptic Ulcer By Amal Mohamed Ahmad Assistant Professor,
SEER Data Cancer Project Brett Langsjoen. SEER Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program of the National Cancer Institute (NCI) Purpose: Collect.
The Effect of Hospitals’ Post-Acute Care Ownership on Medicare Post-Acute Care Use 1. Department of Family and Community Medicine, University of Missouri-Columbia.
NHMRC Clinical Trials Centre ANZGOG AGM, 2 April 2009, Noosa NHMRC Clinical Trials Centre Symptom Benefit Study Measuring the Benefit of Palliative Chemotherapy.
CoRPS Center of Research on Psychology in Somatic diseases Multiple myeloma survivors experience a low quality of life and many disease-specific complaints:
Improving Access to Mental Health Services: A Community Systems Approach Leslie Mahlmeister, MBA PhD Student Department of Political Science Wayne State.
Important questions As good or better ? Cost effective ? Overall, safer? Is it safe as a cancer operation? Can all surgeons do it? Compare to open surgery.
Bladder Cancer Mark Browning, M.D. ‘ IUSME.
Medical Drugs, Intoxication Substances, and Somatic Diseases Evgeniya Koshkina Deputy Director for Science Moscow Research and Practical Centre on Addictions.
Experiences and Attitudes of Patients With Terminal Cancer and Their Family Caregivers Toward the Disclosure of Terminal Illness Young Ho Yun, Yong Chol.
BPH The affiliated hospital of TaiShan medical college.
IMPROVING MENTAL HEALTHCARE IN NURSING HOMES Brenda K. Keller, MD,CMD, Cameo Rogers, CTRS, CDP, Jennifer Medlin Hannah Fillman, Thomas M. Magnuson, MD.
The Impact of Swallowing Function Pre- and Post Head & Neck Cancer Treatment Jo Patterson Research Associate / Macmillan SALT University of Newcastle /
The Effects of Intravenous Acetaminophen Use on Robot-Assisted Pelvic Surgery Patients Nichole Witmyer, Pharm.D. St. Dominic Hospital Jackson, Mississippi.
URINALYSIS CASE STUDY Olivia Clements Ray Nelson Alexis Beykke Lily Harvey.
Carcinoma of the urinary bladder in a tertiary care setting in a developing country Farhana Badar, Ambreen Sattar, Fouzia Meerza, Noreen Irfan, Neelam.
Urinalysis in the Elderly
Group Issues Guidelines on Prostate Cancer Screening . . .
Urinary Elimination.
Urinary Symptoms in the Female
Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms Suggestive of Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (LUTS/BPH): More Than Treating Symptoms?  Mark J. Speakman  European Urology Supplements 
The Economics of Robotic Cystectomy: Cost Comparison of Open versus Robotic Cystectomy Douglas Scherr, MD.
European Urology Focus
Institute of Oncology “Ion Chiricuță”, Cluj, Romania
Unveil the importance of pain management in cancer patients
Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms Suggestive of Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (LUTS/BPH): More Than Treating Symptoms?  Mark J. Speakman  European Urology Supplements 
Adherence, attitude to Standard Treatment Guidelines in clinical practice at tertiary care hospitals in Delhi State 1Sangeeta Sharma, 2Sharma KK, 3Sethi.
Quality of Life after Colectomy due to Ulcerative Colitis Katrín Guðlaugsdóttir1, Tryggvi Björn Stefánsson1, Elsa Björk Valsdóttir1,2  1 Depratment of.
P8-2 Rezum water vapour thermal therapy for benign prostatic hyperplasia: early results from the United Kingdom Max Johnston1, Tina Gehring1, James Montgomery1,
Population-Specific Staff
Initial Office Evaluation
Sabaydee.
Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms Suggestive of Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (LUTS/BPH): More Than Treating Symptoms?  Mark J. Speakman  European Urology Supplements 
Women’s & Men’s Health Physiotherapy
Presentation transcript:

A Comparative Analysis of Quality of Life of Patients Treated by Radical Cystectomy and Sigmoid Neobladder versus Chemoradiation in Muscle Invasive Cancer of Urinary Bladder K. P. Haresh, P. K. Julka, R. Prabhakar, S. Senthamilzelvan, A. Seth, G. K. Rath. All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India

PURPOSE Radical cystectomy (RC) and chemoradiation (CTRT) -the present standard treatment options for muscle invasive cancer of urinary bladder (UB) RC has got its own inherent psychosexual issues associated with urinary diversion The new technique of sigmoid neobladder (SNB) provide an artificial bladder fashioned out of sigmoid colon with the patient able to void through their natural urethra. The purpose of our study is to compare the QOL between RC with SNB vs. CTRT.

Material and Methods Prospective non-randomized study May 2001 to June 2005 Transitional cell cancer of UB, T2 to T4, N0/N1, M0 N= 30 A modified questionnaire from EORTC-QLQ and bladder symptom score -(Madsen and Iversen, 1983). The patients were directly interviewed. QOL scores were recorded both before treatment and during follow up.

S.NO.QUESTIONNAIRESCORE 1.How much would you grade your overall physical health in the past week? [Score: till 25=1, = 2, =3, =4] Performance questionnaire: KPS Were you symptomatic in last week? Yes/ no Did you need to put effort for your routine activities ? yes / no Were you able to work in past week ? Yes/ no Did you need any assistance ? yes / no If yes, the assistance type: Occasional / Considerable / Special Care / Hospital Care [KPS score : 0 –20 = 1, = 2, = 3, =4] How would you grade your mental well being in the past week? [Score : till 25=1, = 2, =3, =4] Is the disease / treatment interfering with your family life ? NoMinimalModerateVery much Does the disease / treatment interfere with your social life? NoMinimalModerateVery much Did you have any problem in going out to public ? NoMinimalModerateVery much

QUESTIONNAIRE contd… 7.Did the disease / treatment interfere with your sexual life? NoMinimalModerateVery much Did the disease / treatment cause financial problems? NoMinimalModerateVery much Did you suffer any complication due to treatment? NoMinimalModerateVery much Total inpatient hospital stay <10 days11-15 days16-20 days> 20 days How is your sleep in last 1 week ? NormalMinimally altered Moderate insomniaSevere insomnia

Bladder / rectal symptom score Did you have ? SCORE 12.Hematuria NeverOccasionallyClots in urineClot retention Frequency >3 h2-3 h1-2 h<1 h Nocturia 0-1x2x3-4x>4x Urgency NoneMildModerateSevere Dysuria NilOcc. Burning Burning >50% of timeFrequent and painful burning Diarrhoea NilOccasionalFrequentWith blood

The mean score (as percentage) was calculated for each observation in the two groups separately. Independent t test was performed with the initial individual sample values and the p value was obtained for inter group comparison.

Sx pre tmt vs CTRT pre tmt (p value) Sx pre tmt vs Sx post tmt (p value) CTRT pre tmt vs CTRT post tmt (p value) Sx post tmt vs CTRT post tmt (p value) Physical health90.00/84.61 (0.528)90.00/86.46 (0.477)84.61/90.28 (0.607)84.46/90.28 (0.486) Mental health74.16/84.61 (0.175)74.16/89.58 (0.013)84.61/91.67 (0.059)89.58/91.67 (0.525) Family life60.83/67.31 (0.516)60.83/80.21 (0.051)67.31/97.22 (0.020)80.21/97.22 (0.041) Social life79.16/84.62 (0.585)79.16/83.33 (0.438)84.62/97.22 (0.102)83.33/97.22 (0.128) Public life92.50/96.15 (0.821)92.50/87.50 (0.336)96.15/97.22 (0.564)87.50/97.22 (0.350) Sexual life80.83/78.85 (0.953)80.83/43.75 (0.001)78.85/80.56 (1.000)43.75/80.56 (0.008) Financial70.83/75.00 (0.725)70.83/69.79 (0.603)75.00/91.67 (0.071)69.79/91.67 (0.051) Sleep85.83/88.46 (0.857)85.83/94.79 (0.028)88.46/ (0.180)94.79/ (0.379) Hematuria54.16/55.77 (0.733)54.16/ (0.010)55.77/97.22 (0.010)100.00/97.22 (0.292) Frequency57.50/75.00 (0.076)57.50/70.00 (0.429)75.00/75.00 (0.863)70.00/75.00 (0.422) Nocturia52.50/53.85 (0.934)52.20/65.00 (0.589)53.85/72.22 (0.058)65.00/72.22 (0.496) Urgency83.33/84.62 (0.821)83.33/80.00 (0.058)84.62/97.22 (0.157)80.00/97.22 (0.011) Dysuria76.66/88.46 (0.112)76.66/ (0.041)88.46/94.44 (0.180)100.00/94.44 (0.125) Diarrhoea100.00/ (1.000)100.00/95.83 (0.102)100.00/97.22 (0.317)95.83/97.22 (0.887) RESULTS

RESULTS contd.. Comparison of pre treatment QOL scores showed that the two groups are very well matched. SNB arm there was a statistically significant improvement in the mental well being and sleep of the patient with treatment There was a significant deterioration in sexual activity in the SNB arm. Bladder symptom scores for hematuria and dysuria showed a significant positive improvement in the SNB arm. The striking feature in the CTRT arm is an improvement in the family life and preservation of sexual activity Bladder symptom scores for hematuria showed a significant improvement in the CTRT arm too. A head on comparison of the post treatment status between two arms showed a highly statistically significant improvement in family life and sexual life in favor of CTRT

Chemoradiation yields a slightly better Quality of Life than Radical Cystectomy with Sigmoid Neobladder in the treatment of muscle invasive bladder cancer. Conclusions