Strengthening Authentic Assessment of Social Work Practice in a Climate of Economic Accountability Denise E. Dedman Susanne Chandler Kathleen Woehrle July.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Conclusion Emily McIntyre. Agenda Tourism Planning Sustainable Development Bali Summary.
Advertisements

Results-Based Management (RBM) and the UNDAF Results Matrix.
The Canadian Partnership Model of Immigrant Settlement and Integration Services: Perspectives from ISO’s outside Ontario Lucia Lo Professor Department.
CHAPTER 2 Client-Adviser Relationship. Introduction A vast amount of information is available to clients, but an adviser’s judgement is needed. Building.
Service Learning through Community Inquiry: A Campus-Community Partnership Robin Ringstad Valerie Leyva John Garcia Kelvin Jasek-Rysdahl California State.
Dr Tatiana Sotirakou (BA, MA, PhD)
2025 Planning Contacts Meeting November 8, 2012 K-State 2025.
ASSIGNED LEADERS IN UNIONIZED ENVIRONMENTS: COPING WITH THE ECONOMIC RECESSION AND ITS AFTERMATH IN ACADEMIC LIBRARIES 1 Adriene Lim, Ph.D. Dean of Libraries,
Project Monitoring Evaluation and Assessment
Discerning Futures COURSE LEADERS’ CONFERENCE 2013.
Smarter Regulation and Competitiveness The Scottish Perspective Prof Russel Griggs, OBE Regulatory Review Group, Chair July 2013.
University of Vermont, School of Business Administration, Rubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources, Gund Institute for Ecological Economics.
Results-Based Management: Logical Framework Approach
Towards a diversified review model for FE colleges First and second thoughts with no formal status! Dr Iain MacRobert and other HMI thinking out loud!
Discussion Questions November 1, 2012 POSTECH Strategic Management of Information and Technology Laboratory (POSMIT: Dept.
Critical Thinking Test Selection - Process & Evaluation Frances Dearing, PhD Assistant Dean of Assessment, Academic Support and Placement, Westchester.
Lecture VII Country Risk Assessment Methodologies: the Qualitative, Structural Approach to Country Risk.
Quality Grading Physical Education August 29, 2013 Evaluating Student Achievement-OAISD Workshop Colleen Lewis,Ph.D and Ingrid Johnson, Ph.D. Grand Valley.
School Nurse Case Management: The Importance of Process and Outcomes Maria M. Bonaiuto, RN,MSN,NCSN Mecklenburg County Health Department 249 Billingsley.
Experimental Design. Learning Targets I can… Identify the three types of variables in an experiment Identify quantitative and qualitative data Decide.
Corporate Social Responsibility- do we need a Statutory Instrument? Presented to the Zambia Alternative Mining Indaba conference- July 17, 2013 Sombo Chunda,
Dr. G. Johnson, Program Evaluation and the Logic Model Research Methods for Public Administrators Dr. Gail Johnson.
INTRODUCTION TO OPERATIONS RESEARCH Niranjan Saggurti, PhD Senior Researcher Scientific Development Workshop Operations Research on GBV/HIV AIDS 2014,
Goal setting : involves establishing specific, measurable, achievable, realistic and time-targeted goals.
Departmental Learning Assessment Developing Strategies to Assess Value NMLA Annual Conference, April 19, 2013.
Leading with Intentionality: Using Core Values to Build Culture and Develop Your Business.
Overview Continuous Improvement & Focus Monitoring.
CHAPTER 10 Technology Issues.
Lesson 8: Effectiveness Macerata, 11 December Alessandro Valenza, Director, t33 srl.
Initial Allocations in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative: Alternatives and Implications Presented by David Harrison, Jr., Ph.D. Senior Vice President.
The impact of the financial and economic crisis on European welfare policy – The new governance of European policy Anna Michalski Department of Government.
Methods: Pointers for good practice Ensure that the method used is adequately described Use a multi-method approach and cross-check where possible - triangulation.
Chapter 4 Identifying and Selecting Systems Development Projects Modern Systems Analysis and Design Sixth Edition Jeffrey A. Hoffer Joey F. George Joseph.
Performance-Based Assessment HPHE 3150 Dr. Ayers.
PRESENTERS: Nancy L. Dianis, RN, MS, Westat Vice President and Associate Director of the Clinical Trials Area Kathleen Ludewig Omollo, MPP, MSI, Program.
Program Evaluation.
ACP S&T Programme - Stakeholder conference October Implemented by the ACP Secretariat Funded by the European Union EDULINK - ACP Science and.
Humanitarian aid evaluation at Medecins sans Frontieres
ISO (C)SR Standard: Implications from a market access perspective Tom Rotherham International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
EDP125 Action Research Assignment 2 Group C1 Patricia Chandler, Denise Coffey, Sarah Collins, Karen Cook, Lisa Cooke.
Chapter 3 Identifying a Research Problem Novia Rianty ( ) Suparni ( )
Thomas G. Cummings Christopher G. Worley Chapter Seventeen : Performance Management Organization Development and Change.
Communimetrics and CQI Stephen Shimshock PhD Michael Martinez MSW Amy Edwards LMSW Yakiciwey Mitchell MSW Angelina Garcia MSW.
Kefira Philippe – Librarian Amy Wharton – Assistant Principal.
Defining Clear Goals and ObjectivesDefining Clear Goals and Objectives Barbara A. Howell, M.A. PAD 5850.
Presented at the Leadership Symposium on Evidence-Based Practice in Child Welfare Services June 28, 2007 Davis, CA It Can Work! Lessons Learned from a.
University community engagement: Social Work in high poverty communities within developed nations
CHAPTER 18 How Community Organizations Affect Change.
For over 20 years, the Government Accountability Office, Office of Management and Budgets, Congress, a variety of stakeholders and various administrations.
Creating Taxpayer Awareness: Corporate Social Responsibility and the Forums for Taxpayer- Tax Administration Dialogue Inter-American Center of Tax Administrations.
Chapter 1 Toward Accountability. The Faces of Accountability Professional Accountability.Service Delivery Accountability.Coverage Accountability.Cultural.
Introduction to Participatory Monitoring & Evaluation (PM&E): A Practical Approach to Engaging Stakeholders and Communities in Monitoring & Evaluation.
Homosexual Professional or Professional Homosexual? The Relationship between Sexual-Professional Identity Integration and Social Influence in the Workplace.
Evaluation What is evaluation?
Scientific Method. What is the scientific method? A process that is used to find answers to questions about the world around us.
Enacting Multiple Strategies and Limiting Potential Successes: Reflections on Advocacy Evaluation, Competing Objectives, and Pathways to Policy Change.
Template for a 48”x36” poster
International Energy Agency
Opportunity Identification and Creation: Using the Capability Approach in Social Entrepreneurship Practice and Research Rasheda L. Weaver PhD Candidate.
Strategic Planning for Learning Organizations
Introduction to Program Evaluation
HEALTH IN POLICIES TRAINING
The Importance of Measuring Outcomes
D-Lab Fall 2004.
Children & Young People’s Trust Board
A Family Support Approach to Family Support Evaluation
Critical Analysis of Rankings of Universities
A Focus on Strategic vs. Tactical Action for Boards
TCG Invest in People, Invest in Outcomes
CAP AND TRADE VS CARBON TAX
Presentation transcript:

Strengthening Authentic Assessment of Social Work Practice in a Climate of Economic Accountability Denise E. Dedman Susanne Chandler Kathleen Woehrle July 11, 2012 Joint World Conference on Social Work and Social Development: Action and Impact Stockholm, Sweden Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

Weissman, s- increasing responsiveness to clients & direct workers 1970s- bottom-up strategies likely to be inefficient –More efficiency, less effectiveness –More control, less support 1980s- concern that accountability decreases service –Adversarial relationship with funders Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

Curvilinear nature of accountability Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

Weissman Implications –All stakeholders have a voice (openness) –True accountability assists workers in obtaining best, realistic, outcomes –Rewards and costs weighted toward effectiveness –Fair criteria related to varying goals vs single measurement Dedman – Social Work Dept.

Johnson, Rochkind, & DuPont, 2011 Attempts at accountability are perceived by the public as “complicated and perhaps marginally informative” and may cause the public to become more distanced and negative about the institution. Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

How does that happen? Funders/leaders Efficiency Quantitative data on targets; Performance of individuals within institutions; Faith in numbers Disclosure/transparency via massive reporting Public Effectiveness Qualitative data on interactions; Individuals behaving thoughtfully & responsibly; Concern that numbers are manipulated; Confusion at piles of data, multiple reports/perspectives Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

Authentic accountability What are our purposes? –Problem solving –Human relationships –Social change/empowerment How might this be measured? Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

How might this be measured? Problem solving –Chronic  crisis Human relationships –Facebook  dinner table Social change/empowerment –Transformational  social control Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

Contact: Denise E. Dedman, Ph.D., LMSW –Assistant professor University of Michigan-Flint 303 E. Kearsley Flint, MI Kathleen Woehrle, Ph.D., MSW –Associate professor University of Michigan-Flint 303 E. Kearsley Flint, MI Collins & Dedman, 2012

Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012

Koppell, 2005 Public administration literature Typology of accountability: transparency liability controllability responsibility responsiveness Dedman & Woehrle, July 11, 2012