A proposal for an APNIC document editorial policy (prop-002-v001) Address Policy SIG APNIC 16, Seoul, Korea 21 August 2003.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Axel Pawlik. 4 th ASO GA Meeting, 24 April 2003, Santiago. Open Policy Process in the RIPE Region Axel Pawlik RIPE NCC.

Advertisements

RIRs, the NRO and ICANN Update - August So far The RIR boards have drafted an agreement to be undertaken between themselves to establish a Number.

Experimental Internet Resource Allocations Philip Smith, Geoff Huston September 2002.

Proposal-062: Use of Final /8 Jonny Martin, Philip Smith & Randy Bush Policy APNIC 26 28th August 2008 Christchurch, New Zealand.

Policy SIG report 29 February 2008 APNIC 25, Taipei Toshiyuki Hosaka Randy Bush Jian Zhang.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E APNIC Members Meeting 27 October 2000 Brisbane, Australia.

Major Activities in JPNIC Since APNIC17 Izumi Okutani Japan Network Information Center NIR 18, Fiji 31 August – 3 September, 2004.

1 RIR Policy Development Update Policy SIG 8 Sep 2005 APNIC20, Hanoi, Vietnam Save Vocea.

A Proposal for a Revised Policy Development Process (prop-001-v001) APNIC16 – Address Policy SIG Seoul, Korea 20 August 2003.

SCI Prague Report Wolf-Ulrich Knoben, SCI Chair 23 June 2012.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E APNIC Open Address Policy Meeting Address Policy SIG October 26th, Brisbane.

1 Overview of policy proposals Policy SIG Wednesday 26 August 2009 Beijing, China.

NRO Number Council Report Jason Schiller Louie Lee Martin Hannigan Jason Schiller Louie Lee Martin Hannigan.

1 [prop-038] Proposal to amend APNIC Lame DNS reverse delegation policy Policy SIG 7 Sep 2006 APNIC 22, Kaohsiung, Taiwan Terry Manderson.

Update on RIPE NCC Inter- RIR Transfer proposal Adam Gosling APNIC 38 Policy SIG Meeting 18 September 2014.

APNIC 33 AMM Policy SIG Report Andy Linton, Policy SIG Chair Thursday 2 March 2012.

APNIC Policy SIG report: Open Policy Meeting Policy SIG Report Masato Yamanishi, Chair.

APNIC Status Report LACNIC V November 2003 Havana.

Election procedure for ICANN ASO Address Council in APNIC Region Sept. 5, 2002 ASO Meeting The 14th APNIC Open Policy Meeting APNIC Executive Council.

Address Policy SIG, APNIC Policy meeting, February 27th, 2003 (1) IPv6 Policy in action Feedback from other RIR communities David Kessens Chairperson RIPE.

Copyright © 2007 Japan Network Information Center Global Policy for the Allocation of the remaining IPv4 Address Space  Japan Network Information Center.

18th APNIC Open Policy Meeting SIG: DB Thursday 2 September 2004 Nadi, Fiji Chair: Xing Li.

Prop-080: Removal of IPv4 Prefix Exchange Policy Guangliang Pan Resource Services Manager, APNIC.

1 APNIC Open Address Policy Meeting Special Interest Group Session March 2nd, Korea, Seoul.

Developing IPv6 Address Guidelines Izumi Okutani Japan Network Information Center Address Policy SIG Aug 2003, Seoul.

Erik Bais, May 13 th 2015 PP – unassigned yet General Transfer Policy Presenter : Erik Bais –

The ASO is a supporting organization of ICANN Report of the ASO Address Council / NRO Number Council ARIN XXVI Louie Lee Chair, ICANN ASO Address Council.

A Review of Policy Development Processes in the Asia Pacific Region Address Policy SIG APNIC 15, Taipei, Taiwan 27 February 2003.

Code review. informal formal ad hoc reviewpair programmingwalk throughinspection/review.

APNIC Policy SIG report: Open Policy Meeting Masato Yamanishi, Chair APNIC 40 Jakarta, Indonesia.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E BOF: APNIC Member Agreement 11 th APNIC Open Policy Meeting Kuala Lumpur, 1 March.

Policy and Procedure for the Handling of Complaints against the AG Consultation with the Standing Committee on the Auditor-General 9 April 2008 Wandile.

Policies for ASN Management in the Asia Pacific Region – Revised Draft Address Policy SIG APNIC14, Kitakyushu, Japan 4 Sept 2002.

Keith Mitchell 1 RIPE 33, May 1999 RIPE NCC Executive Board Report Keith Mitchell ICANN Address Supporting Organisation.

1 Application of the HD ratio to IPv4 [prop-020-v001] Policy SIG 1 Sept 2004 APNIC18, Nadi, Fiji.

30 April 2003 ITU SG2, Geneva, Switzerland Axel Pawlik, RIPE NCC Information Document 21-E ITU-T Study Group 2 May 2003 Question:1/2 Source:TSB Title:The.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E Emerging Registry Criteria ASO General Assembly Budapest, 19 May 2000.

Policy Development Processes in the APNIC Region 4 th ASO General Assembly Santiago, Chile 24 April 2003.

APNIC Status Report ARIN XII October, 2003 Chicago.

IPv4 IXP Address Policy APNIC Policy SIG Meeting Taipei, August 2001 Philip Smith.

SCI Prague Report Wolf-Ulrich Knoben, SCI Chair 23 June 2012.

Madrid Forum 6-7 November 2008 Implementating the 3rd Energy Package: An ERGEG Consultation paper Lord Mogg, ERGEG chairman.

1 IANA global IPv6 allocation policy [prop-005-v002] Policy SIG 1 Sept 2004 APNIC18, Nadi, Fiji.

1 Welcome to the Policy SIG Policy SIG 1 March 2007 APNIC 23, Bali, Indonesia Kenny Huang.

Global IPv6 Address Interim Policy Draft Open Issues and Discussion Summary Address Policy SIG / 13 th APNIC Meeting Kosuke Ito Global IPv6 Interim Policy.

Prop-077: Proposal to supplement transfer policy of historical IPv4 addresses Wendy Zhao Wei, Jane Zhang & Terence Zhang Yinghao.

Advisory Council Shepherds: David Farmer & Chris Grundemann Global Policy for post exhaustion IPv4 allocation mechanisms by the IANA.

1 Welcome to the Policy SIG APNIC 21 Thursday 2 March 2006.

Policy SIG Report APNIC AGM Friday 29 August 2008 Christchurch, New Zealand 1.

1 Welcome to the Policy SIG 6 Sep 2006 APNIC 22, Kaohsiung, Taiwan.

1 APNIC Open Address Policy Meeting Special Interest Group Session March 2nd, Korea, Seoul.

Policy SIG report AMM, APNIC 27 Manila, Philippines.

8 th Address Policy SIG Report Takashi Arano Yong Wan Ju Kenny Huang Chair/co-Chairs of APNIC Address Policy SIG.

APNIC Open Address Policy Meeting

A proposal to deprecate ip6.int reverse DNS service in APNIC

Member Services Report

Regional Internet Registries

IPv6 Address Allocation APNIC

A Proposal for IPv4 Essential Infrastructure

Downstream Allocations by LIRs A Proposal

Joint IPv6 Forum/IPv6 SIG APNIC 15, Taipei, Taiwan 26 February 2003

Policy Development Processes in the APNIC Region

Policy SIG Thursday 26 February Manila, Philippines

Randy Bush & Philip Smith

Overview of policy proposals

IPv6 Address Space Management A follow up to RIPE-261

Database SIG APNIC19 24 February 2005, Kyoto, Japan

APNIC Member Meeting APNIC16 Seoul, Korea

APNIC 29 PDP BoF report Tuesday 2 March /05/10

Presentation transcript:

A proposal for an APNIC document editorial policy (prop-002-v001) Address Policy SIG APNIC 16, Seoul, Korea 21 August 2003

Introduction This proposal is intended to work with the policy development process proposed by Anne Lord and Randy Bush. – programme/sigs/docs/policy/ addpol-prop-apnic-policy-process.txt

Introduction This proposal is about the editorial process to implement consensus decisions This proposal suggests a simpler procedure for writing, amending, and publishing documents The proposed procedure takes full account of consensus decisions reached through policy development process

Background Current document review policy –apnic-083 “APNIC Document review policies and procedures” Describes a system of calls for comments Categorises nature and importance of proposed reviews Review category determines number and length of calls for comments

Problem Current review policy was developed when the role of SIGs was less clear –It does not adequately recognise the role that SIGs and AMM have in making decisions –Current process is complex and time consuming –Categorising reviews is no longer necessary once a decision has reached consensus in the SIG AMM process

Position in other RIRs ARIN, LACNIC, and RIPE NCC –The editorial process is contained within the policy development process So, why separate the processes in APNIC? –The range and diversity of languages is an issue –A separate editorial process will help ensure consistent documentation

Proposal details (1) Include formal recognition of the policy development process –Consensus decisions flowing from SIGs and AMM Remove categories of review –Not necessary for decisions made by SIG-AMM process

Proposal details (2) New editorial policy should describe a simple process to implement consensus decisions: –Secretariat releases draft reflecting SIG-AMM decision –Single call for public review Intended to ensure draft properly represents decision One month for editorial comments –Community can request additional reviews on basis that draft does not properly reflect the consensus from the relevant meeting

Proposal details (3) If a document is required to implement an emergency decision made by the Executive Council between Member Meetings, that document must be reviewed at the next Open Policy Meeting.

Implementation It is proposed to implement this policy as soon as possible so that the editorial process may be applied to any other consensus items arising from this meeting.

Questions

References Current document review policy – doc-review-policy.htmlhttp:// doc-review-policy.html Proposal – mme/sigs/docs/policy/addpol-prop-apnic- doc-review-v4.txthttp:// mme/sigs/docs/policy/addpol-prop-apnic- doc-review-v4.txt