Capacity mechanisms in Europe The fundamental issues behind the ongoing sector enquiry Session 2 - If a capacity mechanism, which design is most appropriate?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Single Electricity Market in Ireland
Advertisements

Deliverable I.4 Balancing (15th IG meeting, Paris, April 7th 2014)
1 Capacity mechanisms - IFIEC position June 12 th 2012.
Legal Framework, Investment Opportunities and Technical Innovation in the Electricity Sector Security of Supply through competitive markets: Design of.
The Internal Energy Market: Remaining challenges and the role of wind power Paul Wilczek Senior Regulatory Affairs Advisor – Grids and Internal Market.
Strategies for Wind Power Trading in Sequential Short–Term Electricity Markets Franck Bourry and George Kariniotakis Center for Energy and Processes EWEC.
The work of European energy regulators on generation adequacy FTS-CEER workshop on Regulatory Aspects of Power Capacity Markets 7 February 2012.
Resource Adequacy in PJM
Does the Third Package provide the European TSO associations with the tools necessary to find solutions to the European energy challenge ? Pierre BORNARD.
Can markets and RES coexist?
Click to edit title Click to edit sub-title The European Network of Transmission System Operators Stockholm 14th of September 2009 Teun van Biert - Convener.
Kick-off Stakeholder Workshop "Post 2020 framework in a liberalised electricity market with large share of Renewable Energy Sources" 28 April 2014, Brussels.
Electricity interconnectors – next generation Martin Crouch Future Energy Strategies seminar 3 July 2012.
Dias 1 Securing Electricity Generation Capacity An assessment through the lens of EU State aid law Eleni Manaridou, LL.M. Ph.D. Fellow Centre.
P.Labra – EWEA March 2012 ENTSO-E’s & TYNDP’s vision on adapting European Transmission Grid to large amounts of wind power.
EStorage First Annual Workshop Arnhem, NL 30, Oct Olivier Teller.
Recent Trends in Energy Regulation IEA-FTS of Russia Workshop on Global Energy Market Scenarios Paris, 28 May 2009 Kieran McNamara Country Studies Division.
Towards Regional Independent Operators – a main driver for successful market integration.
Global Competitiveness in a Liberalised EU Energy Market The Role of ENTSO-E Ifiec Energy Forum Brussels Daniel Dobbeni.
Utility Regulation March 10, 2011 Raj Addepalli Deputy Director, Electric, Office of Electric,Gas and Water New York State Department of Public Service.
Gent Summer School: Electricity Markets & Trading Gregory Michiels 27 August 2013.
The Convergence of Market Designs for Adequate Generating Capacity Peter Cramton and Steven Stoft 24 March 2006.
Imbalance costs of wind power – how to improve the market integration of wind power Hannele Holttinen Senior Research Scientist, Team leader.
Wind Power in Ireland: Treatment of wind in the Single Electricity Market APEx Conference, Paris 16 th October 2007.
1 Meeting the Regional Electricity Market Opportunities South East Europe Energy Week “Athens Forum” Meeting Rome, March 2003.
NATIONAL GRID Market Evolution in Ireland APEX 2004 Annual Conference Ann Scully Manager, Market Operations ESB National Grid.
1 WHOLESALE ELECTRICITY MARKET DESIGN AND STRUCTURE Massimo Parati Market Department Italian Regulatory Authority for Electricity and Gas Milan, March.
Demand Response in MISO Markets NASUCA Panel on DR November 12, 2012.
Generation Expansion Daniel Kirschen 1 © 2011 D. Kirschen and the University of Washington.
Economic Demand Response Sheldon Fulton Executive Director, IPCAA November 4, 2008.
Costs of Ancillary Services & Congestion Management Fedor Opadchiy Deputy Chairman of the Board.
Novel market designs & KPIs I NSTITUTO DE I NVESTIGACIÓN T ECNOLÓGICA Stakeholder Kick-off Workshop, IEE-Market4RES Brussels, Luis Olmos, Pablo.
1 PRR 776 in the Context of the ERCOT Market Design Eric S. Schubert Regulatory Affairs Advisor BP Energy Company.
Avoided Costs of Generation
(C) NordPool1 The Nordic Power Market Zonal Pricing Jan Vidar Thoresen Managing Director Nord Pool Consulting AS.
Challenges for the SEM.  Day-ahead price coupling is a key feature of the final draft Framework Guidelines on congestion management issued by ERGEG in.
Dr. Ion LUNGU AFEER President. DRIVERS FOR INVESTMENTS Demand; Fuel availability; Market signals; Production costs; Energy mix; Environmental concerns;
ENTSO-E’s Network Development Plans and Network Codes: How a strong European grid supports security of supply, affordable electricity prices through market.
1 IFIEC Energy Forum 22 November 2011 Electricity.
Directorate General for Energy and Transport Euroforenet Conference 20/11/2007 Brussels European Commission Kyriakos MANIATIS Biofuels & Industry DG TREN.
1 Capacity Markets Investment in Generation Capacity Payments October 31, 2005 J. W. Charlton.
Generation and transmission interconnections 4 July, 2013 Virgilijus Poderys CEO of LITGRID AB.
Power System Economics Daniel Kirschen. Money © 2012 D. Kirschen & University of Washington1.
Demand Response Workshop September 15, Definitions are important Demand response –“Changes in electricity usage by end-use customers from their.
Energy Agency of the Republic of Serbia
ENERGY UNION AND SMART ISLANDS EESC, 10 July 2015 EUROCHAMBRES The Association of European Chambers of Commerce and Industry.
UPDATES ON THE LATEST DEVELOPMENTS IN LITHUANIA Aistija Zubaviciute National Control Commission for Prices and Energy 3 April 2007, Riga.
1 Market Evolution Program Long-Term Resource Adequacy Regulatory Affairs Standing Committee Meeting May 14, 2003.
Benoît Esnault Commission de Régulation de l’Energie (CRE) - ERGEG 19th Madrid Forum, March 2011 Preparatory work for Framework Guideline Tariffs.
A new impetus for Europe's energy efficiency policy Paul Hodson Head of Unit DG Energy, European Commission 09/10/2012.
Capacity mechanisms in Europe If there is to be a capacity mechanism, then what is the appropriate design? 28 September 2015 Robin Cohen.
Secondary legislation on renewable today and tomorrow Nicolae Opris Vicepresident, ANRE ANRE ROMANIAN ENERGY REGULATORY AUTHORITY.
PJM© Demand Response in PJM 2009 NASUCA Mid-Year Meeting June 30, 2009 Boston, MA Panel: Price Responsive Demand – A Long-Term Bargain.
PJM © 2006 The Institute for Regulatory Policy Studies Illinois State University Conference May 12, 2006 Jeff Bladen PJM Interconnection.
1 Regional electricity market Belgrade, 23. April Ljiljana Hadzibabic Council member Energy Agency of the Republic of Serbia.
08/12/2015 Developing renewable energy cost effectively EUROPEAN COMMISSION Tom Howes European Commission.
1 May 2012CACM Network Code Capacity Allocation and Congestion Management for Electricity Network Code ROME, 15 th May 2012.
BALTIC BALANCING MARKET Ingrid Arus Baltic Balancing Market Harmonisation WG meeting
All Island Single Electricity Market IWFA Update Laura Brien
Linnfall Consulting Market design: the energy-only market model Linnfall Consulting September 2015.
How to avoid blackouts in Europe?
Ben Voorhorst, President, ENTSO-E
Electricity Wholesale Markets: Designs for a low-carbon future
Background and Process
STATE ENERGY AND WATER REGULATORY COMMISSION
Powering Towards Clean Energy in Europe
Electricity Market Reform (EMR) Explained
Benefits of New England’s Proposed Capacity Market
The work of European energy regulators on generation adequacy
SUMMER OUTLOOKS 2019 Lea Dehaudt, Moderator ENTSO-E
Presentation transcript:

Capacity mechanisms in Europe The fundamental issues behind the ongoing sector enquiry Session 2 - If a capacity mechanism, which design is most appropriate? Andrea Villa – Enel S.p.A. Brussels, 28 th September 2015

Future RES Development RES investments still needed to achieve 2030 targets (*) RES target refers to all sectors (electricity, heating and cooling, transport) Sources: Primes 2013, 2030 Climate Energy Package (**) ENTSO-E Scenario Outlook & Adequacy Forecast 2015, page 27 Renewable share on final gross consumption*RES Generation Capacity** GW 2

Adequacy Forecast Source: ENTSO-E Scenario Outlook & Adequacy Forecast 2015, pages 50 and 58 New capacity needed 3

4 Future Trends in European Electricity Markets Now RES still not dominant in the energy mix Energy prices >0 most of the time RES offer limited balancing services Predictable imbalance costs Near future RES more prominent in the energy mix Energy prices >0 most of the time, but many hours with 0 and <0 prices RES offer some balancing services Imbalance costs increases Next Decade Bulk of energy from RES Energy prices 0 and <0 for many hours RES offer balancing services Imbalance costs very high Shares of Revenues Variability in energy prices increases financing costs for new projects Low revenues for programmable capacity could bring problems of Security of Supply Note: Graphs are illustrative

5 Current Debate Examples Focus on energy-only market : how to foster day-ahead, intraday, and balancing prices Capacity mechanism based on capacity tickets The two sides have started tackling some issues of the current market design BUT they miss the major point: how to foster long-term signals

6 Capacity Remuneration Mechanisms (CRMs) Price-basedVolume-based Capacity Payment Strategic Reserve Capacity Tickets Capacity Auctions Reliability Options CRMs Ability to provide long-term signals

7 Introduction of Reliability Options in Italy Legislative Decree 379/2003 ­Introduction of interim Capacity Payment ­NRA to define an adequate competitive Capacity Remuneration Mechanism 2008 First Consultation on possible models of CRMs Directive 2009/28/EC Today 2009 Second NRA Consultation on CRMs 2010 Two NRA Consultations on details on parameters of Reliability Options NRA Decision 98/2011 Regulators defined criteria to be followed by TSO’s proposal 30/06/2014 Ministerial approval NRA Decision 375/2013 Final NRA approval 1/7/2014 Entry into force Guidelines on State aid for environmental protection and energy First Auction

8 Reliability Options in Italy 1-way CfD between TSO and selected counter-parties Central buyer (TSO) Selected counter-party Spot Price – strike price (if>0) Premium Rights Receive premium (€/MW/year) during delivery period Obligations 1.To submit offers in DAM and Ancillary Service Market (ASM) 2.To pay the difference between spot price and strike price (if>0) Benefits 1.Deliver long-term signals for all capacity 2.Incentives to deliver capacity when is needed 3.Market-defined triggers and penalties

9 Auctions for Reliability Auctions in Italy Lead time 4 years Delivery period 3 years General Auction Lead time 3, 2, 1 year Delivery period 1 year Adjustment Auctions Lead time <1 year Delivery period 1 month Secondary Market Auction yearDelivery period

10 Reliability Options Supply and Demand Supply Voluntary participation of not incentivised new and existing national programmable capacity > 10 MVA (de-rated capacity, calculated by TSO) Possible participation of foreign capacity, distributed generation and demand side management in future auctions Zonal Demands Negative sloped zonal demands defined by TSO considering VOLL, electricity demand and required reserve (netting for foreign interconnection capacity) Q P Note: Graph is illustrative. For existing capacity under discussion the possibility to receive a minimum premium equal to avoidable fixed costs Calculation of de-rated capacity considers average unavailability due to incidents and technical and regulatory imitations VOLL: Value of Lost Load

11 Spot and Strike Prices VOLL Note: the graph is illustrative, table from Terna DAM: System Marginal Price DSM: Pay as Bid Imbalance Costs CO2 and GC Single strike price for all accepted capacity, calculated on variable costs of peak technology – updated

12 Thank you very much for your attention