©Lehr, 2007 The 700MHz Auction -- What role does wireless play in a liquid world? (2:00PM-3:20PM)  William Lehr (MIT)  Dale Hatfield (UofColorado, Boulder)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
WAPECS - A more flexible spectrum management approach Isolde Goggin Chairperson of COMREG, Ireland, and RSPG Rapporteur on WAPECS.
Advertisements

About GSMA Europe We represent the interests of the worldwide mobile communications industry and have nearly 800 operator members covering over 200 countries.
The Implications of Convergence on Spectrum Management Mike Goddard Director, Spectrum and International Policy Radiocommunications Agency, UK.
ITU Regional Development Forum - Warsaw 7 May The Radio Spectrum Policy Programme & the Spectrum Inventory Pearse ODonohue Head of Radio Spectrum.
Policy and Regulatory Challenges – Technology Providers View February 14 Challenges for Successful Implementation of ICT Projects Challenges for Successful.
Shared Use of Radio Spectrum in the EU
Towards a Connected Continent: How to achieve a European Single Market for Telecommunications? Speeding up NGN ubiquity: a pillar for digital growth Athens,
Applying New Technologies to Old Spectrum Management Problems Presentation by Dale N. Hatfield Adjunct Professor, University of Colorado at Boulder at.
1 National Spectrum Managers Association Industry Round Table Christopher Guttman-McCabe Vice President, Regulatory Affairs CTIA – The Wireless Association®
UK Spectrum Management Strategy: tomorrow’s challenges today Chris Woolford Director, International Spectrum Policy Radcomms 2014.
RadComms 2014: Innovations in Spectrum Management Lynne Fancy Senior Director Spectrum Development and Operations Industry Canada September 2014.
Policies for the Broadband Digital Migration Barbara A. Cherry Senior Counsel Office of Strategic Planning & Policy Analysis Federal Communications Commission.
Connectivity as raw material of Digital Economy 'Challenges for telecoms in the new Internet ecosystem' BEREC-EMERG-REGULATEL-EaPeReg Summit Barcelona,
National Science Foundation Symposium Ed Thomas Chief, Office of Engineering and Technology Federal Communications Commission.
Utilizing White Spaces for broadband access Where do we go from here? Fanny Mlinarsky octoScope.
© M2Z Networks Inc. All rights reserved. Advances in Wireless Technology and Impacts on Broadband Deployment National Broadband Policy Workshop August.
COPYRIGHT © 2012 ALCATEL-LUCENT. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 1 Latin American Spectrum Conference 2012 Mexico City October 24-25, 2012 Session on The Possibilities.
Program for Development of Broadband Internet Access in Republic of Moldova and results of its implementation.
Growth in Mobile Broadband and its Implication for Spectrum
International Telecommunication Union Committed to Connecting the World The World in 2009: ICT Facts and Figures Jaroslaw K. PONDER Strategy and Policy.
Slide title In CAPITALS 50 pt Slide subtitle 32 pt 700 MHz: Spectrum Issues Wg Cdr Arif Khan (Retd) Director – Regulatory Affairs, Ericsson India Ltd.
Office of Engineering and Technology Agenda Meeting January 13, 2005.
Radio Frequency Spectrum Management in Indonesia - 3G/IMT 2000, TV Digital and other Wireless Activities And Issues - 3G/IMT 2000, TV Digital and other.
1 COMMUNICATIONS REGULATION COMMISSION Republic of Bulgaria MOBILE BROADBAND EUROPE – BULGARIAN EXPERIENCE IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOBILE BROADBAND ACCESS.
Digital Dividend and the Internal Market The “Information Society Parliament” Conference June 2, 2011 | Budapest.
Wireless Broadband Service in Rural America Rural TeleCon ‘06 October 24, 2006 Paul D’Ari Spectrum Competition and Policy Division Federal Communications.
A;sldkfj1 Wireless Telecommunications Bureau Agenda Meeting January 13, 2005.
U.S. Telecommunications Regulation and Market Developments September 2008.
Promoting Competition, Innovation, and Public Safety with Wireless Broadband May 2007.
National Communications Commission 2006 International Digital Cities Convention - Broadband Policies and Regulatory Reform - NCC Chairman, Dr. Su Yeong-Chin.
Wireless Technology - Rural Networks FCC Broadband Plan Workshop Washington, DC August 13, 2009 Brett Glass LARIAT.NET P.O. Box 1693 Laramie, WY
©Lehr, 2007 Spectrum Policy Working Group William Lehr Communications Futures Program Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Georgetown University. Congruity and Incongruity in the Evolving Telecommunications Industry John W. Mayo Georgetown University (202)
Office of Engineering and Technology Agenda Meeting January 15, 2004.
Title II Reclassification What it means to rural communities.
Slide 1 The National Broadband Plan and Public Safety The Need for More 700 MHz Spectrum Bill Schrier, Chief Technology Officer, City of Seattle 28 May.
Wireless Access Services ACMA/ITU International Training Program 5 September 2006 Nevio Marinelli & Christine Allen Wireless Access Services Planning Team.
1 National Spectrum Managers Association Spectrum Management 2004 Diane Cornell Vice President, Regulatory Policy CTIA-The Wireless Association May 19,
Request For A New 3GPP2 TDD TSG Eric Jacks LinkAir Communications Santa Clara, CA 3GPP2 SC Meeting Sapporo, Japan Oct. 31, 2002.
Telecommunication Regulatory Authority Investing In Infrastructure Telecom & ICT Opportunity 13 April 2008 ألاقتصاد والأعمال Al-Iktissad Wal-Aamal Conference.
Wireless Telecommunications Bureau Wireless Telecommunications Overview January 2009.
Prague, April 16, 2009 Future-plating the new Framework: View from a European-born Internet success on making the most of the web 2.0/3.0 world of innovation.
1 WIRELESS ACCESS FOR THE 21ST CENTURY Anywhere - Anytime WIRELESS ACCESS FOR THE 21ST CENTURY Anywhere - Anytime IMT-2000 STANDARDIZATION Michael H. Callendar.
2.Global trends and underlying forces determining the progress on the world IC sector 2.1. Reforms of IC sector - evolution of legislation and regulations.
Forum on Internet of Things: Empowering the New Urban Agenda Geneva, Switzerland, 19 October 2015 The Role of Regulators and Governments in realizing the.
1 International Bureau 2008 Annual Report January 15, 2009.
1 WiMAX and the Canadian Radio Spectrum April 28, 2006 Angela Choi Communications Engineer Pacific Region Industry Canada
Accelerating a broadband future: Designing spectrum awards to meet mobile broadband requirements Peter Dunn – Cullen International © Cullen International.
1 TINF 2010 Tuesday 30 November 2010 Present and Future Regulation of Electronic Communications Vesa Terävä European Commission Information Society & Media.
Wireless Telecommunications Bureau 1 The Necessary Conditions for the Flexible Use of Spectrum Dow Jones Wireless Ventures Redwood City, CA April 21, 2004.
Decisions that Lead to the Internet and Wireless Boom Draft
Emerging and New Issues in Broadband Delivery Michael Koch Goodmans LLP.
Wireless Telecommunications Bureau 2007 Annual Report.
6 March 2016TCS Public Global Market Demands Panel Discussion Paper – CSL-UIUC K Ananth Krishnan Vice President and CTO Tata Consultancy Services Sep 6,
- 1 - Philip Marnick Chair, Radio Spectrum Policy Group Enhanced RSPG.
Impact of New Technologies October We are seeing the start of an OTT world  OTT - Delivery of video content over IP, typically on open networks,
© Lehr, 2015 Mobile Broadband Working Group Spectrum Policy Working Group William Lehr MIT CFP Responsible Innovation Meeting MIT April 18,
Use of Spectrum Bands Above 24 GHz For Mobile Radio Services ‘5G’…
Yerevan, Republic of Armenia, 27 June 2016ITU Regional Workshop for CIS and Georgia Place and role of radiocommunications in the information society François.
Fondazione Ugo Bordoni Evolution of Wireless Access systems Maria Missiroli.
SPECTRUM IN TRANSITION
Mario Maniewicz Deputy Director, Radiocommunication Bureau
Cristian Gomez Head, Validation Group, Space Services Division, ITU-R
Satellite Industry Association Spectrum Priorities and Objectives May 20, 2008 S I A M E M B E R C O M P A N I E S.
Realizing the Full Potential of Government-Held Spectrum to Spur Economic Growth PCAST May 25, 2012 Update.
Brett Tarnutzer GSMA.
Internet Interconnection
Radio Spectrum Policy in Europe
Spectrum Management in a Converged Ecosystem Velamah Cathapermal-Nair
The case for delivering C-Band services
Presentation transcript:

©Lehr, 2007 The 700MHz Auction -- What role does wireless play in a liquid world? (2:00PM-3:20PM)  William Lehr (MIT)  Dale Hatfield (UofColorado, Boulder) “Applying New Technologies to Old Spectrum Mgmt Problems”  Andy Lippman (MIT) “Spectral Opportunities” CFP Meeting hosted by Cisco San Jose, Ca January 21-22, 2008

©Lehr, (4) Public Safety national broadband network -- Emergency response coverage (post-Katrina, 9-11 world) -- Interoperability -- Govt/Commercial sharing (pre-emptible models) -- Frontline, Cyren Call… Why 700MHz auction? “Digital Dividend” : DTV-transition of 62MHz of prime spectrum -- $10B reserve ($0.54/MHz-POP) “C” block $0.70/MHz-POP, “D” block $0.44/MHz-POP Mobile ($1-$4+/MHz-POP, transactions) AWS ( GHz, 2006) $0.73/MHz-POP -- Starts January 24th (2) Convergence -- Satellite (DBS, MSS-ATC) -- Cable (value of AWS licenses?) Potential implications for Telecom/Internet value chain? (1) National broadband competitor -- Ubiquitous coverage (“Digital Divide”) -- New (more open?) plaform (“Net neutrality”) -- Google? Frontline? (3) 3G/4G services: AT&T, VZ (roaming)

©Lehr, “D Block”  National broadband network to interoperate with and support public safety/emergency responsiveness  UHF (700MHz) spectrum: good distance, NLOS performance  Adjacent to 12MHz public safety-dedicated spectrum  Interoperable, national BB platform  10MHz with reserve price $1.33B ($0.44/MHz-POP)  $128 million non-recoverable down-payment  Must reach negotiated agreement with Public Safety folks  Lots of additional (and unclear) provisions  Frontline shuttered doors on January 11, 2008  Reed Hundt, John Doerr, et al.  Vision: open wireless platform, shared commercial/public safety  Ubiquitous BB (others….M2Z, etc.)

©Lehr, FCC Commissioner Michael Copps New America Foundation panel): “Wireless needs to be as open as the Internet if that industry wants to be as “vibrant” as consumer electronics… A “handful” of wireless carriers now pick devices and content, limiting consumer choice and hampering handset makers from selecting features. The system is set up so each carrier can protect [its] revenue stream. European wireless designers think our system is nuts… Maybe they’re right. Recent carrier support for openness “sounds good,” but the FCC has to do more, Copps said … urging a “trust, but verify” stance at the [FCC] agency. He plans to study industry open initiatives’ price, portability, certification requirements and effects on the wholesale market, he said. The FCC also must ensure that wireless networks are neutral, making sure carriers don’t “selectively downgrade” service for applications. The commission should conduct a “rigorous investigation” of how well the wireless wholesale market is functioning. A proposed wholesale mandate intended for the 700 MHz auction was dropped after carriers said they would encourage wholesaling on their own. The FCC should hold them to it.”

©Lehr, Wireless Research Questions of Interest? What is the value of spectrum? -- Elasticity of demand? -- What is value of flexibility (e.g., ATC for satellite)? -- Economic impact BB, wireless, …. (data informed analyses…)? -- Issues: band planning (e.g., paired v. unpaired, national v. regional,.. ) When will spectrum regime no longer determine industry structure? -- How to get to robust secondary spectrum markets? Enable technology innovation (entry, re-purposing of spectrum) Promote competition (avoid hoarding) -- How to separate interference management from industrial policy? Minimize regulatory distortions to market processes Building the ecosystem for open wireless? -- Liquid market for spectrum: supply and demand -- Frequency agility: Unbundling frequency, services, and business models -- Agile devices (software radio)

©Lehr, Building the Ecosystem: making wireless resources liquid Observation: need to access intelligence, resources at edge -- Smarter wireless edges are a fact -- Interference is a local phenomenon (lots of “white” space) -- Empower end-users (viral growth) -- Analogy: P2P taps CPU resources in edge…. Challenges: unbundling the wireless edge Spectrum management reform -- Flexibility instead of harmonization -- Anti-hoarding provisions -- Shared/open access Frequency Agile Devices -- Global Scale economies -- Unbundle devices (open interfaces) -- Not provider subsidies -- iPhone, GooglePhone, etc. Secondary Markets -- Liquidity! -- Sellers? (anti-hoarding) -- Buyers? (chicken/egg => bus cases) -- Transaction costs -- Markets are a public good -- Too cheap to meter => open access

©Lehr,