Rabello-Soares, Bogart & Scherrer (2013): Comparison of a quiet tile with a nearby active region (5 o to 8 o away) with a quiet tile with no nearby.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SDO/HMI multi-height velocity measurements Kaori Nagashima (MPS) Collaborators: L. Gizon, A. Birch, B. Löptien, S. Danilovic, R. Cameron (MPS), S. Couvidat.
Advertisements

Subsurface Flows from ring-diagram analysis Irene González Hernández National Solar Observatory Tucson, Arizona.
Science Teams. Scientific Coordination Objectives Lessons from GONG An LWS/HMI Case in Point.
Global Dynamics Rachel Howe, NSO Session H10. Synopsis Achievements from GONG/MDI –Nearly a full 11yr cycle of observations –Zonal flow pattern in bulk.
11/10/05 H6: Global Helioseismology Techniques & Data Products Questions for Technique Sessions Chair(s): Hill, Schou, Larsen Status: [draft]
Braun AIA/HMI Feb Helioseismic holography of Solar Subsurface Flows : progress & prospects NorthWest Research Associates Colorado Research Associates.
R. Komm & Friends NSO, Tucson R. Komm & Friends NSO, Tucson Solar Subsurface Flows from Ring-Diagram Analysis.
Solar cycle variation in the peak asymmetry: solar or artefact? S. J. Jiménez-Reyes IAC 13-sept-2004.
Local Helioseismology Laurent Gizon (Stanford). Outline Some background Time-distance helioseismology: Solar-cycle variations of large-scale flows Near.
Frequency dependence of the solar-cycle frequency variation M. Cristina Rabello-Soares Stanford University.
Braun AIA/HMI Feb helioseismic holography of solar subsurface flows : progress & prospects NorthWest Research Associates Colorado Research Associates.
Detection of Emerging Sunspot Regions in the Solar Interior Stathis Ilonidis, Junwei Zhao, and Alexander Kosovichev Stanford University LoHCo Workshop.
Solar Flows From Small and Large Ring Analyses kyky kxkx.
11/10/05 H6: Global Helioseismology Techniques & Data Products Questions for Technique Sessions Chair(s): Hill, Schou, Larsen Status: [draft]
11/10/05 H6: Global Helioseismology Techniques & Data Products Questions for Technique Sessions Chair(s): Hill, Schou, Larsen Status: [draft]
The Sun’s internal rotation Michael Thompson University of Sheffield
Science Requirements for Helioseismology Frank Hill NSO SPRING Workshop Nov. 26, 2013.
Comparing solar internal rotation results from MDI and GONG R. Howe 1, J. Christensen-Dalsgaard 2, F. Hill 1, R. W. Komm 1, J. Schou 3, M. J. Thompson.
1 Status of Ring-diagram Analysis of MOTH Data Kiran Jain Collaborators: F. Hill, C. Toner.
An Introduction to Helioseismology (Local) 2008 Solar Physics Summer School June 16-20, Sacramento Peak Observatory, Sunspot, NM.
Acoustic Holographic Studies of Solar Active Region Structure A. Malanushenko 1,2, D. Braun 3, S. Kholikov 2, J. Leibacher 2, C. Lindsey 3 (1) Saint Petersburg.
Meridional Circulation from ring-diagram analysis Irene González Hernández and the GONG++ team National Solar Observatory Tucson, Arizona.
An Introduction to Helioseismology (Global) 2008 Solar Physics Summer School June 16-20, Sacramento Peak Observatory, Sunspot, NM.
Imaging Solar Tachocline Using Numerical Simulations and SOHO/MDI Data Junwei Zhao 1, Thomas Hartlep 2, Alexander G. Kosovichev 1, Nagi N. Mansour 2 1.W.W.Hansen.
1 Mode Parameter Variations from GONG Ring Diagrams: An Update Rachel Howe, NSO.
Techniques for Active Region Seismology Irene González Hernández National Solar Observatory, Tucson, AZ.
The Sun as a whole: activity as seen by helioseismology
1 Global Helioseismology 2: Results Rachel Howe, NSO.
Using Realistic MHD Simulations for Modeling and Interpretation of Quiet Sun Observations with HMI/SDO I. Kitiashvili 1,2, S. Couvidat 2 1 NASA Ames Research.
Comparison of time- distance and holography Junwei Zhao and Alexander G. Kosovichev W. W. Hansen Experimental Physics Laboratory, Stanford University,
Flows in the Solar Convection Zone David Hathaway NASA/MSFC National Space Science and Technology Center 2004 July 21 David Hathaway NASA/MSFC National.
Global Helioseismology NSO/LPL Summer School June 11-15, 2007
Asteroseismology A brief Introduction
The need for physics-based inversions of sunspot structure and flows D. Braun, A. Birch, A. Crouch NWRA/CoRA M. Rempel NCAR/HAO.
台灣清華大學, 物理系 Helioseismology (II) Global and Local Helioseismology ( , 北京 ) 周定一 Dean-Yi Chou.
Local Helioseismology LPL/NSO Summer School June 11-15, 2007.
The Sun as whole: activity as seen by helioseismology A.C. Birch (Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research)
Tests of the Ring-Diagram Inversions A. Kosovichev.
Acoustic wave propagation in the solar subphotosphere S. Shelyag, R. Erdélyi, M.J. Thompson Solar Physics and upper Atmosphere Research Group, Department.
Rachel Howe.  Why do we need to continue observing?  Why ground-based?  Requirements for a new network.
The Current Status of Sunspot Seismology H. Moradi, H. Schunker, L. Gizon (Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research, Katlenburg-Lindau, Germany)
Horizontal Flows in Active Regions from Multi-Spectral Observations of SDO Sushant Tripathy 1 Collaborators K. Jain 1, B. Ravindra 2, & F. Hill 1 1 National.
Travel Time Measurements Markus Roth 1, Laurent Gizon 1, John G. Beck 2 1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung 2 Stanford University HELAS Workshop.
Flows and Cycles Large scale flows and stellar magnetic cycles Markus Roth Wiebke Herzberg René Kiefer Ariane Schad Guy Davis (UoB) Retreat of the Stellar.
Three-Dimensional Power Spectra of GONG++ High- Cadence Magnetograms F. Hill, J. Bolding, R. Clark, K. Donaldson-Hanna, J. Harvey, G. Petrie, C. Toner.
Inferred rotation rate. Fits to tachocline Kosovichev fit Kosovichev (1996; ApJ 469, L61)
Global Rotation Inversions Profile rotation vs latitude and depth Tachocline, Near-Surface Shear … Monitor evolution during solar cycle Zonal Flows, Tachocline.
Seismic Probing of the Dynamics of the Solar Interior Michael Thompson University of Sheffield.
PERSISTENT STRUCTURES IN NEAR- SURFACE FLOWS FROM RING DIAGRAMS RACHEL HOWE, UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM D. BAKER, MSSL R. KOMM, NSO R. BOGART, STANFORD.
Helioseismology for HMI Science objectives and tasks* Data analysis plan* Helioseismology working groups and meetings *HMI Concept Study Report, Appendix.
Helioseismic Probing of Giant-Cell Flows Nicholas Featherstone Deborah Haber Brad Hindman Juri Toomre JILA / APS University of Colorado at Boulder.
Rachel Howe.  Rotation profile  Rotation changes over the solar cycle  The torsional oscillation  Tachocline fluctuations  Frequency and parameter.
The HMI Instrument. HMI Science Goals Line-of-Sight Observables.
Estimation of acoustic travel-time systematic variations due to observational height difference across the solar disk. Shukur Kholikov 1 and Aleksander.
Helioseismology Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard
Global Rotation Rachel Howe, NSO.
Diagnosing kappa distribution in the solar corona with the polarized microwave gyroresonance radiation Alexey A. Kuznetsov1, Gregory D. Fleishman2 1Institute.
Meridional Circulation from Large Aperture Ring Diagrams
Science Teams.
HMI Data Analysis Pipeline
HMI Data Analysis Pipeline
Validation of Helioseismic Fourier-Legendre Analysis
Measurements of lifetimes of high-l solar p-modes in sunspots
Sushanta C. Tripathy NSO, Tucson
Rachel Howe, NSO December 2005
Something New About Frequency Shifts
travel-time maps of sunspots: surface effects and artifacts?
Sushanta C. Tripathy National Solar Observatory
Time-distance: methods and results
106.13: A Makeover for HMI Magnetic Field Data
Presentation transcript:

Rabello-Soares, Bogart & Scherrer (2013): Comparison of a quiet tile with a nearby active region (5 o to 8 o away) with a quiet tile with no nearby active region at the same disk position (same latitude and Stunyhurst longitude) o using HMI 5 o patches from June 2010 to January o The HMI ring-digram analysis pipeline uses two fitting methods: rdfitc (Basu & Antia 1999) and rdfitf (Haber et al. 2000, which is also used by GONG pipeline). Looking at the magnetic field from a distance… The elephant in the room

U x and U y : zonal and meridional flows  U ⁄⁄ and U perp in relation to the direction of the nearby AR location Flow variation

Control set in black: + fitsc * fitsf Flow variation in the direction of the nearby active region

inflow outflow Quiet region in the vicinity of AR (5 0 to 8 0 away)  fitsf (in red)  fitsc (in black) Best trade-off parameter:  = Small errors  error of the mean of fitted flows. Negative flow means flow away from the nearby AR and Positive towards the nearby AR.

inflow outflow Quiet region in the vicinity of AR (5 0 to 8 0 away)  fitsf (in red)  fitsc (in black) Surface cooling within the plage results in a downdraft which draws fluid in at the surface (Hindman, Haber & Toomre, 2009): Figure 11. Schematic diagram (side view)

F surf (x 10 3 ) * fitsf fitsc AR - Q Q nearbyAR - Q Quiet: MAI < 5 G Active Region (AR): MAI > 100 G * n = 1 * n = 2 * n = 3 In (AR-Q), only a few error bars for fitsc are shown.

We observe an outflow from about 3 Mm until 6 Mm deep in quiet regions which are 5 0 to 8 0 from an active region and some indication of an inflow 0-2 Mm deep. There is a surface term when comparing a quiet region with a nearby active region and a quiet tile (with no nearby AR). The two fitting methods give different slopes for F surf which is mainly a function of frequency. This surface term is similar, but present some differences with the surface term for AR – Q.

Frequency shift as a function of solar activity (20 < l < 900) Figure 1 of Rabello-Soares (2011) Medium-l: MDI Structure Program – Schou (1999) and Larson & Schou (2009) High-l: MDI Dynamics Program – Rabello-Soares, Korzennik & Schou (2008)  Solar-radio 10.7-cm daily flux (NGDC/NOAA)

Baldner, Bogart & Basu (2012): analysed 264 regions (from 1996 to 2008) and applied Principal Component Analysis. Fig. 9 of Rabello- Soares (2012) Baldner, Bogart & Basu (2012) Two-layer structure Global helioseismology: variation between solar max and minimum

 MDI Dynamics 2001 Two different peak-fitting algorithms were used to fit the power spectra and obtain the mode frequencies: Medium-l modes : known as the MDI peak-fitting method, is described in detail by Schou (1992) and improved in Larson & Schou (2008, 2009). High-l modes : At high degrees, the spatial leaks lie closer in frequency, resulting in the overlap of the target mode with the spatial leaks that merge individual peaks into ridges, making it more difficult to estimate unbiased mode frequencies (also at large frequencies): Korzennik et al. (2013). Data used: n > 0

The spatial leaks merge individual peaks into ridges Figure 1 of Rabello-Soares, Korzennik & Schou (2001) Medium l Medium l, but high frequency High l

Instrumental effects affect the amplitude of the leaks Figure 7 of Rabello-Soares, Korzennik & Schou (2001) Observed power spectra Simulated power spectra where the leakage matrix was calculated without and with a plate scale error of -0.1%

MDI (2001) - model S a "surface term" developed by Brodsky & Vorontsov (1993) using a higher- order asymptotic theory suitable for high-degree mode frequencies is used: To suppress the uncertainties in the surface layers in helioseismic models,

F surf (observed) – F surf (fitted) x 10 3  = 8 (  Hz) l  (  Hz -1 ) n =

observed error frequency (  Hz) (  Hz) degree  Medium-l fitting  High-l fitting

Errors for l>200 are divided by sqrt(10), to taken into account that we are fitting every 10 th l.

 = 5e-7,  = 10 Averaging Kernels

Figure 15 of Basu et al. (2009)

Error correlation function Howe & Thompson (1996) Figure 1 of Rabello-Soares, Basu & Christensen-Dalsgaard (1999): Error correlation at r 1 = 0.5 R sun for sound speed based on a medium-l mode set.

The sound speed inversion using Korzennik et al (2013) high-degree (l = ) mode frequencies agrees with (old) MDI medium-l results (from Basu et al. 2009). Good averaging kernels until R . More work needs to be done: oscillation in the results are likely due to error correlation  invert for every l.

Only fitsc F surf (x 10 3 ) * F surf (AR - Q). F surf (Q nearbyAR - Q) x 15 * n = 1 * n = 2 * n = 3 Comparison

Variation of the mode parameters with solar cycle It is well known that amplitudes decrease while mode widths increase in the presence of magnetic fields (for example, Rajaguru, Basu, and Antia, 2001). Rabello-Soares, Bogart, and Basu (2008) have reported that the relation between the change in width and mode amplitude was very nearly linear. Figure 4 of Rabello-Soares, Bogart & Basu (2008) NSO 2013

Fig.3 of Rabello-Soares, Bogart & Scherrer (2013): colors are n=0, n=1, n=2, n=3, n=4 Relative amplitude variation between: Active and quiet regions Quiet region with a nearby AR and with no nearby AR. in the direction of the nearby AR perpendicular to it For frequencies larger than ≈4.2 mHz, the modes are amplified (acoustic halo) if there is an active region nearby with very little dependence on their propagation direction. NSO 2013

fistc ic=0 ic=1 (transparent: black)