PPP and Outsourcing of government e-services : lessons and experience in Latvia Andris Anspoks, Adviser to the Minister of eGovernment affairs.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Stimulating the demand for innovation – Futuris Conference April 1st 2009 Henriette van Eijl Coordinator, Lead Market Initiative EC, DG Enterprise, Innovation.
Advertisements

OpenCities is based on a concept developed by British Council in collaboration with a network of European Cities. OPENCities – a driver for successful.
WP4 – 4.1 and 4.2 Preparatory activities for the creation of the WATERMODE permanent network 1 Technical Committee Meeting Venice, June 24-25, 2010 VENETO.
Ainars Bruvelis, Lursoft Ltd. Information re-use by enterprises and national registers in Latvia. E-services in ECR.
European CommissionDG Education and Culture Methods and Technologies for Learning ICMTL 2005 Palermo (Italy) March 9-11, 2005 EU Policies and Programmes.
03/06/2015 Master CESPEM Studente: Ornela Zylyfi 1 Preparation of Territorial Pact for Local Development in Area of Shkoder Ideas for the II Phase of SVILOPIM.
The National Innovation System in Kosovo
Insight into the e-ASEM Whitepaper: e-Learning for Lifelong learning in Latvia Iveta Gudakovska, assist.prof., University of Latvia.
1 Computerised National Land Book of Latvia Ints Lukss Project Manager MikroKods Ltd.
The Italian Institutional Design for Administrative Simplification HIGH LEVEL REGIONAL SEMINAR ON “STRATEGIES, TOOLS AND CAPACITIES FOR ADMINISTRATIVE.
Investment and integrated strategies supporting towns Raivis BREMSMITS Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development of the Republic of.
PPP in Brazil Procedures & Methodology Marcelo de Lima e Souza PPP Unit – Economic Advisory Ministry of Planning, Budget and Management Mexico, February.
Girts Kebers, Lursoft IT PSI reuse – Lursoft’s experience in Latvia.
Driving Improvements in Efficiency & Effectiveness North West Centre of Excellence Stakeholder Event Martin Fokinther Executive Consultant, Global Public.
Opportunities of ICT sector The Ministry of Information Technologies & Communications Ms. Dona ŞCOLA, Deputy Minister.
1 ICT industry development in Latvia Janis Bergs, CEO, MicroLink Latvia Chairmen of Board of IS Cluster.
CIO Training Model Pravit Khaemasunun College of Innovation Thammasat University.
Bratislava, June 16-17, 2003 Getting Development Cooperation Work: Cooperation between the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and UNDP Inita Paulovica Assistant.
© SMWI, 2005 The Re-use of PSI policy, Legal Framework and Good Practice in EU and Romania, Bucharest, 8th June 2005 Wojtek SADOWICZ TROUBLESHOOTING THE.
SWITCH – ASIA POLICY SUPPORT COMPONENT 1. What is about? 2  Create an enabling environment to strengthen or initiate policies helping to mainstream SCP.
Review on development of SDI as a basis of E-government in Croatia Ivan Landek, assistant director State Geodetic Administration of RoC International Workshop.
GovernEE GovernEE – Good Governance in Energy Efficiency Legal constraints and opportunities for improving EE of public and historic buildings.
София European Experts for Development. София COMPANY PROFILE „Kavangard” Ltd. is a consultancy company, working in the sphere of the regional development,
Increasing innovation capacities of companies Taking the Challenge – promotion of innovation in IT sector SMEs Riga, April 20, 2007 Valdis Avotins, Knowlege.
III ASTANA ECONOMIC FORUM INTERNATIONAL INNOVATIVE CONGRESS Innovative potential development in SME`s in region Dr. Karl-Heinz Klinger Technostart GmbH,
Workshop on the Legal Framework of EU Structural Funds’ Management for the Period Riga – Latvia, 4 & 5 December 2006 Head of Division, Preben.
European Broadband Portal Phase II Application of the Blueprint for “bottom-up” broadband initiatives.
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP – CROATIAN EXPERIENCE Kamilo Vrana, B.Sc.E.E. Managing Director Beograd, November 18, 2010.
1 Latvian Information Technology and Telecommunications Association LITTA an Information Society project October 2004.
LIKTA project: a true PPP example Imants Freibergs, President Imants Freibergs, PresidentLIKTA.
1 Asian Regional Workshop on “Capacity Development for the Clean Development Mechanism” October 2005 AIT, Bangkok, Thailand Institutional Building:
Library Public Access Computing Program : A Step Towards eParticipation in Latvia Līga Kursīte Project Coordinator and Manager’s Assistant Library Public.
EInclusion Policies and facilitation of Motivation: Experience in Latvia Agrita Groza Deputy State Secretary Ministry of Welfare, Latvia.
Building Blocks for a Successful Public- Private Partnerships Presented by Igor Abramov Counsel & Co-chair, Eurasia and Russia Practice Group, Heenan Blaikie.
The Bulgarian ICT Cluster The European Day Of The Entrepreneur – Sofia, 2005.
NETWORK STRUCTURE AND COOPERATION BETWEEN UNIVERSITIES AND INDUSTRY Prof. Ing. Tatiana Čorejová, PhD. Prof. Ing. Ján Čorej, PhD.
International Cooperation and Capacity Building William E. Kovacic U.S. Federal Trade Commission Competition Policy & Law New Delhi, 17 November 2009.
Right to Complain – Brussels30 November 2006 Right to complain Complaint mechanisms at the European Investment Bank 30 November 2006.
The State Procurement Agency of the Republic of Azerbaijan Welcomes the participants of the 9 th Public Procurement Exchange Platform “Efficient Implementation.
Innovation potential of the CR Pavel Švejda International ICSTI conference, Alexandria Motto: Science makes knowledge out of money, innovations.
B R U S S E L S Partnership of local authorities in sciences and business Best practices of Brussels-Capital Region Sofia, 31st October 2008.
Institutional structures for Structural Funds assistance Ministry of Finance September 10, 2003.
" Economy of enterprise " Olga Zborovskaja. The purpose of a course The purpose of a course “Economy of enterprise” is formation a complex of knowledge.
© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Ensuring Good Quality PPP Projects Martin Darcy United Kingdom.
© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Introducing a New Concessions System – Latvian Experience.
Public Private Partnership + EU Funds in Poland general overview and the future outlook.
1 Workshop of the Ministry of Finance of the Czech Republic How to use European funds within a PPP project? Jana Maláčová Ministry for Regional Development/
Innovation and Economic Infrastructures DIMETICS Pecs July Keith Smith Australian Innovation Research Centre.
Role of Smart Grids in the Italian Energy Policy Strategy Marcello Capra General Directorate for Electricity Market, Renewables, Energy Efficiency and.
Austrian Development Cooperation (ADC) with Bosnia and Herzegovina Managing Director Brigitte Öppinger-Walchshofer Austrian Development Agency,
The Register of Enterprises of the Republic of Latvia Amsterdam, Latvia’ s presidency in ECRF Ina Panasova Deputy Chief State Notary.
Information Society and eGovernment Development in Latvia Īpašu uzdevumu ministra elektroniskās pārvaldes lietās sekretariāts Ina Gudele Special Assignments.
PPP Legal & Regulatory Framework. PPP Policy In July 2008 GOK approved the PPP policy directive through which: PPPs are identified as a method for investing.
Lithuanian Education Quality Management: System of School Internal and External Audits Ričardas Ališauskas Head of Education Development Division of the.
Development of Education Quality Management System Ričardas Ališauskas Ministry of Education and Science of Lithuania Rotterdam.
Learning & Development professionals What can we learn from each other in Europe? DVWO, Germany March 2011.
LIKTA 1 eCompetence Centers : I nstrument of Development and Sustainability of eInclusion Projects and Initiatives Initiative LIKTA – Latvian.
PIC EU-28 Conference Paris, 25 – 27 November 2015 PIC An EU Approach Brazil’s Public Internal Control Victor Godoy Veiga Audit Director of the Social Area.
Croatian Example: PPP as a Frame for Cooperation TAIEX Workshop, Milan, Italy October 24-26, 2011 Kamilo Vrana, B.Sc.E.E. Managing Director.
Information Society and Development Applying Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) in the Finnish development co-operation.
Dashnyam TSETSEGMAA Head of Promotion and Consulting Division Investment Environment in Mongolia.
SIMONA MURRONI Bruxelles - June 27th 2013 Bridging lessons learned from the past with new planning and delivery approaches in the energy sector.
Inese Vilcane Social inclusion department Senior expert
Pacific Regionalism and Stronger Regional Institutions: Paving Opportunities for ADFIP Presentation by the Pacific Islands Private Sector Organization.
The National Innovation System in Kosovo
Implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) in the Republic of Uzbekistan Geneva, April 12, 2017.
INFORMING THE PUBLIC ABOUT THE ESF Juris Vigulis Department of communication, Ministry of Welfare LATVIA.
The Role of Bilateral Donors in supporting capacity-building in the area of ICT Open Consultations on Financing Mechanisms for Meeting the Challenges.
Ad hoc Group of Experts on Better Regulation
Country Report of the Statistical Center of Iran for Workshop on Integrated Economic Statistics and Informal Sector for ECO Member Countries November.
Presentation transcript:

PPP and Outsourcing of government e-services : lessons and experience in Latvia Andris Anspoks, Adviser to the Minister of eGovernment affairs

Early days There are 2 PPP IT projects in Latvia which have born in early 90th and nobody knew at that time that this is PPP:  Enterprise register  NAIS – Latvian Legislation Database

Enterprise Register First register with electronic database Since early 90th ER Information System is operated and developed by Lursoft  No government investments  Added Pledge Register and Court Decision Register  Electronic services available for ER, public and private sectors and general public  Integrated with major public IS and European Business Register Many value added services, for example  Newspaper library  Statistics  Search capabilities

Latvian Legislation Database NAIS: database for all laws and regulations Private Information System and Service Public sector decided to use NAIS, not to create own system

No chance to replicate These are good, but not replicable examples  Different procurement regulations  EU regulations e.g. Reuse Problems:  No comprehensive Service Level Agreement

Recent PPP projects Concession agreements  1 of 14 is in IT (Bauska district WAN)  All other examples I know are in Construction Business initiative is PPP example in human capital development

Digital and Intrenet skills development Partners:  NGO (ICT industry) – LIKTA  Government Ministry of Welfare, e-Governement Secretariat, Ministry of Culture, Ministry of Regional Development  Local Municipalities Coordinate, assist, motivate, local NGO Local network  Private Training centers, sponsors

The Question Why there are no other IT/IS PPP examples?

PPP policy Ministry of Economics is responsible for PPP policy, legislation and information dissemination  Latvian Investment and Development Agency Support for PPP Consultancy Methodology Information dissemination Concession – 2nd phase of regulation development Other – no policy, no guidelines State program for facilitating of PPP No PPP in NSID Operational Programs

Conclusions Good idea always emerges from private sector  Innovation  Taking risk  Efficiency  Goals oriented

Conclusions There are no formal obstacles for PPP in any sector PPP is too complex for public sector  Public part political leadership changes too often  Very complex definitions of PPP object and contract: Terms of Reference and Partner Selection Criteria, Service Level Agreement (balanced with available money, Measurable) Key Performance Indicators (Measurable)  Complex calculations of ROI  No policy and guidelines for anything outside Concession  No guidelines for IT PPP (even in Concession such are needed)  Fear from State Audit Office (Valsts kontrole) Why you are not doing it yourself? What is ROI?... other hard questions

Thank you for attention!