Human identification: the anthropologist’s role Dana Austin, Ph.D. Diplomate, American Board of Forensic Anthropology Tarrant County Medical Examiner District Fort Worth, TX
12/17/2008 Traditional Forensic Anthropology Identification Comparative Osteology/Human Osteology Craniometry/Osteometry Ancestral morphology Sex identification Age estimation Radiological comparison Facial reconstruction
12/17/2008 Traditional Anthropology Method Limitations Generalizations only Biological Profile Individualizing Traits Exclusions are possible Positive identification not possible
12/17/2008 Unidentified Skeletal Remains 1963 White Female years of age 5’5” to 5’7”, lbs Light brown or dark blond hair Large nose with high bridge 8 dental restorations Ladies jacket, green with gold lining Blue teen-age type socks PMI greater than 6 months
12/17/2008 Death Investigation thru 1964 D.P.S., Crime Briefs Bulletin Newspaper story with facial drawing of female Case submitted to Dallas PD, DPS Austin, FBI, LA State Police, Am. Dental Assn, OK DPS, Comparison of dental records with missing women in OK, LA, TX, CA, PA
12/17/ Analysis White MALE years of age 5’4” to 5’11” Long term infection of middle ears PMI less than 1 year
12/17/2008 Male Features
12/17/2008 Postmortem Interval
12/17/2008 Infection Lesions of Skull
12/17/2008
Facial reconstruction by Suzanne Baldon, MA Presented to Media
12/17/2008 Generalizations Kenneth Glaze White male 35 years old Relative tells detective that Kenneth always suffered with his ears Disappeared August 1963 (PMI=4 mos) Unidentified Skeleton White male years of age 5’4” to 5’11” Long term infection of middle ears PMI less than 1 year
12/17/2008 And….the facial reconstruction looks great Its not enough for a scientifically proven positive identification
12/17/2008 Positive Identification Identification confirmed via mitochondrial DNA comparison with maternal relative
12/17/2008 What did we do in the old days? Decedents with a good tentative id were buried as John & Jane Doe A lot of time and resources were used to try to locate obscure medical or dental records
12/17/2008 Jane Doe 1991 Biological profile, clothing & jewelry description released to media
12/17/2008 Unidentified Female 1991 Body was mummified Fingerprints were obtained from some fingers Fingerprints were compared to known missing white females, but the quality of the print wasn’t good enough Body buried as unidentified
12/17/ Identification Fingerprints sent to Department of Homeland Security, Biometric Support Center They were able to confirm identity with an IAFIS hit This female was a possible match in 1991
12/17/2008 Today we have more resources Digital radiographs Improved clarity Retention by hospitals Amelogenin marker tells us the sex CODISmp
12/17/2008 Isolated Skeletal Elements C Arlington PD B Fort Worth PD A Euless PD
12/17/2008 A B C
Robust Skeleton
12/17/2008 Large mastoid process Brow Ridge
12/17/2008 Long mid-face
12/17/2008 Inca Bone Elliptical Palate Shape
12/17/2008 Slight Lipping of Joint Surfaces
12/17/ & 1999 cases Amelogenin marker tells us all are male XY This eliminates half of our possibles (in theory) CODISmp associated these bones with one another This allowed a more detailed UNID entry including dental and stature information and allowed for a modified age estimation.
12/17/2008 Resources