LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW 2006 - Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 281 Generation of flat-top beam in a “Mexican hat” Fabry-Perot cavity prototype for advanced GW.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Marcus Ng Mentor: Alan Weinstein Co-mentor: Robert Ward
Advertisements

Marcus Benna, University of Cambridge Wavefront Sensing in Dual-Recycled Interferometers LIGO What is Wavefront Sensing? How does it work? –Detection of.
rd ILIAS-GW annual general meeting 1 VIRGO Commissioning progress J. Marque (EGO)
Thermally Deformable Mirrors: a new Adaptive Optics scheme for Advanced Gravitational Wave Interferometers Marie Kasprzack Laboratoire de l’Accélérateur.
Stefan Hild, Andreas Freise, Simon Chelkowski University of Birmingham Roland Schilling, Jerome Degallaix AEI Hannover Maddalena Mantovani EGO, Cascina.
Stefan Hild, Andreas Freise, Simon Chelkowski University of Birmingham Roland Schilling, Jerome Degallaix AEI Hannover Maddalena Mantovani EGO, Cascina.
TeV Particle Astrophysics August 2006 Caltech Australian National University Universitat Hannover/AEI LIGO Scientific Collaboration MIT Corbitt, Goda,
Generation of squeezed states using radiation pressure effects David Ottaway – for Nergis Mavalvala Australia-Italy Workshop October 2005.
Recent Developments toward Sub-Quantum-Noise-Limited Gravitational-wave Interferometers Nergis Mavalvala Aspen January 2005 LIGO-G R.
GWADW, May 2012, Hawaii D. Friedrich ICRR, The University of Tokyo K. Agatsuma, S. Sakata, T. Mori, S. Kawamura QRPN Experiment with Suspended 20mg Mirrors.
GWADW 2010 in Kyoto, May 19, Development for Observation and Reduction of Radiation Pressure Noise T. Mori, S. Ballmer, K. Agatsuma, S. Sakata,
Status of LCGT and CLIO Masatake Ohashi (ICRR, The University of TOKYO) and LCGT, CLIO collaborators TAUP2007 Sendai, Japan 2007/9/12.
Thermal noise issues Chinyere Ifeoma Nwabugwu Louisiana State University August 05, 2005 Eric Black, Akira Villar, Kenneth G. Libbrecht, Kate Dooley, Royal.
Optical Configuration Advanced Virgo Review Andreas Freise for the OSD subsystem.
Test mass dynamics with optical springs proposed experiments at Gingin Chunnong Zhao (University of Western Australia) Thanks to ACIGA members Stefan Danilishin.
Experimental test of higher-order LG modes in the 10m Glasgow prototype interferometer B. Sorazu, P. Fulda, B. Barr, A. Bell, C. Bond, L. Carbone, A. Freise,
T1 task- update Mike Plissi. 2 Motivation  Thermo-elastic noise is higher than the ‘intrinsic’ noise in crystalline materials  There are several sources.
LISA October 3, 2005 LISA Laser Interferometer Space Antenna Gravitational Physics Program Technical implications Jo van.
Advanced Virgo Optical Configuration ILIAS-GW, Tübingen Andreas Freise - Conceptual Design -
Flat-Top Beam Profile Cavity Prototype
LIGO-G0200XX-00-M LIGO Scientific Collaboration1 First Results from the Mesa Beam Profile Cavity Prototype Marco Tarallo 26 July 2005 Caltech – LIGO Laboratory.
1 Mexican-Hat (Flat-Topped) Beams for Advanced LIGO LIGO-G Z Research by Sergey Strigin & Sergey Vyatchanin [MSU] (with advice from Vladimir Braginsky)
Flat top beam profile cavity prototype J. Agresti, E. D’Ambrosio, R. DeSalvo, J.M. Mackowski, A. Remillieux, B. Simoni, M. G. Tarallo, P. Willems CNRS.
1 Thermal noise and high order Laguerre-Gauss modes J-Y. Vinet, B. Mours, E. Tournefier GWADW meeting, Isola d’Elba May 27 th – Jun 2 nd, 2006.
Beams of the Future Mihai Bondarescu, Oleg Kogan, Yanbei Chen, Andrew Lundgreen, Ruxandra Bondarescu, David Tsang A Caltech - AEI - Cornell Collaboration.
1 The Virgo noise budget Romain Gouaty For the Virgo collaboration GWADW 2006, Isola d’Elba.
LIGO LaboratoryLIGO-G R Coatings and Their Influence on Thermal Lensing and Compensation in LIGO Phil Willems Coating Workshop, March 21, 2008,
1 Reducing Thermoelastic Noise by Reshaping the Light Beams and Test Masses Research by Vladimir Braginsky, Sergey Strigin & Sergey Vyatchanin [MSU] Erika.
Nov 3, 2008 Detection System for AdV 1/8 Detection (DET) Subsystem for AdV  Main tasks and requirements for the subsystem  DC readout  Design for: the.
LIGO-G050XXX-00-R Gingin’s Australia-Italia workshop on GW Detection The Mesa Beam Juri Agresti 1,2, Erika D’Ambrosio 1, Riccardo DeSalvo 1, Danièle Forest.
Advanced LIGO Simulation, 6/1/06 Elba G E 1 ✦ LIGO I experience ✦ FP cavity : LIGO I vs AdvLIGO ✦ Simulation tools ✦ Time domain model Advanced.
S. ChelkowskiSlide 1LSC Meeting, Amsterdam 09/2008.
AdV Thermal Compensation System Viviana Fafone AdV/aLIGO joint technical meeting, February 4, 2004.
Dual Recycling in GEO 600 H. Grote, A. Freise, M. Malec for the GEO600 team Institut für Atom- und Molekülphysik University of Hannover Max-Planck-Institut.
First DR FFT Results on Advanced LIGO Using Perfect and Imperfect Optics By Ken Ganezer, George Jennings, and Sam Wiley CSUDH LIGO-G Z by Ken.
The status of VIRGO Edwige Tournefier (LAPP-Annecy ) for the VIRGO Collaboration HEP2005, 21st- 27th July 2005 The VIRGO experiment and detection of.
1 Virgo Commissioning Status WG1 meeting Potsdam, 21 st July 2006.
Equivalence relation between non spherical optical cavities and application to advanced G.W. interferometers. Juri Agresti and Erika D’Ambrosio Aims of.
Laguerre-Gauss Modes for Future Gravitational Wave Detectors Keiko Kokeyama University of Birmingham 2 nd ET Annual Erice, Sicily, Italy
17/05/2010A. Rocchi - GWADW Kyoto2 Thermal effects: a brief introduction  In TM, optical power predominantly absorbed by the HR coating and converted.
LIGO-G R 1 Mexican Hat developments LMA cantilever measurements Riccardo DeSalvo LIGO Gravitational Wave Observatories California Institute of.
Aspen Flat Beam Profile to Depress Thermal Noise J.Agresti, R. DeSalvo LIGO-G Z.
Optical Spring Experiments With The Glasgow 10m Prototype Interferometer Matt Edgar.
Beams of the Future Mihai Bondarescu, Oleg Kogan, Yanbei Chen, Andrew Lundgreen, Ruxandra Bondarescu, David Tsang A Caltech - AEI - Cornell Collaboration.
LIGO-G Z March 2007, LSC meeting, Osamu Miyakawa 1 Osamu Miyakawa Hiroaki Yamamoto March 21, 2006 LSC meeting Modeling of AdLIGO arm lock acquisition.
Caltech, February 12th1 Virgo central interferometer: commissioning and engineering runs Matteo Barsuglia Laboratoire de l’Accelerateur Lineaire, Orsay.
Some considerations on radiative cooling V. Fafone, Y. Minenkov, I. Modena, A. Rocchi INFN Roma Tor Vergata.
The VIRGO detection system
LIGO-G Z 1 Report of the Optics Working Group to the LSC David Reitze University of Florida March 20, 2003.
The Proposed Holographic Noise Experiment Rainer Weiss, MIT On behalf of the proposing group Fermi Lab Proposal Review November 3, 2009.
Lessons from CLIO Masatake Ohashi (ICRR, The University of TOKYO) and CLIO collaborators GWADW2012 Hawaii 2012/5/16.
1 Cascina – October 19, 2011 ASPERA Forum Laurent Pinard Substrates, Polishing, Coatings and Metrology for the 2 nd generation of GW detector Laurent PINARD.
Thermal compensation issues: sensing and actuation V. Fafone University of Rome Tor Vergata and INFN ASPERA Technological Forum – EGO October, 2011.
LASCAD  - The Laser Engineering Tool The results of FEA can be used with the ABCD gaussian propagation as well as with the BPM physical optics code. FEA.
Talk by Thorne, O’Shaughnessy, d’Ambrosio
The Proposed Holographic Noise Experiment
Time domain simulation for a FP cavity with AdLIGO parameters on E2E
Nergis Mavalvala Aspen January 2005
Generation of squeezed states using radiation pressure effects
Design of Stable Power-Recycling Cavities
The Mesa Beam Update Juri Agresti1, Erika D’Ambrosio1, Riccardo DeSalvo1, Danièle Forest2, Patrick Ganau2, Bernard Lagrange2, Jean-Marie Mackowski2, Christophe.
Ponderomotive Squeezing Quantum Measurement Group
Flat-Top Beam Profile Cavity Prototype: design and preliminary tests
Modeling of Advanced LIGO with Melody
First Results from the Mesa Beam Profile Cavity Prototype
Thermal lensing effect: Experimental measurements - Simulation with DarkF & Finesse J. Marque (Measurements analysis: M. Punturo; DarkF simulation: M.
Equivalence relation between non spherical optical cavities and application to advanced G.W. interferometers. Juri Agresti, Erika D’Ambrosio,
Thermal noise and high order Laguerre-Gauss modes J-Y. Vinet, B
Flat-Top Beam Profile Cavity Prototype
Advanced Optical Sensing
Presentation transcript:

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 281 Generation of flat-top beam in a “Mexican hat” Fabry-Perot cavity prototype for advanced GW detectors Marco G. Tarallo 1 (Universita` di Pisa – INFN Pisa) In collaboration with J.Agresti 1, E.D’Ambrosio 1, R. DeSalvo 1, D.Forest 2, B.Lagrange 2, J.M.Mackowsky 2, C. Michel 2, J.Miller 1, J.L. Montorio 2, N.Morgado 2, L.Pinard 2, A.Remilleux 2, B.Simoni 1, P.Willems 1 1 LIGO Laboratory, Caltech 2 LMA Laboratory/EGO

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 282 Mesa beam for advanced GWID Advanced GWIDs aim: sensitivity beyond the SQL Test mass TN will be the fundamental limit in the frequency band with highest sensitivity Gaussian beams sample a relatively small fraction of the mirror surface  widening and flattening the light probe will depress TN Mirror surface fluctuations Fused Silica TM

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 283 It is possible to have a nearly optimal flat top beam reshaping the FP arm cavity mirrors The “Mesa beam” is a multi-gaussian laser field designed as superposition of minimal Gaussians with w 0 =  (L/k) The obtained wavefront phase gives the “Mexican hat” profile to the phase graded mirror Mesa beam for advanced GWID Profiles normalized for Same Integrated power  EM field second momentum almost x2 larger Slow exponential fall Steeper fall Mesa beam/MH FP Gaussian beam/Spherical FP

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 284 Thermal Noise Prospects [ref. Agresti LIGO-G R] Gaussian beam TN Mesa beam TN Sensitivity Gain: x 1.7 (f=100 Hz) Theoretical investigations: thermal noise reduction NS-NS inspiral Reach 193 Mpc 251 Mpc x 1.3 Detection Event Rate x 2.2 !! Mesa beam noise reduction is an additional factor to any other mirror development (optimized coatings, cryogeny, ecc.)

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 285 Mesa beam cavity prototype Experimental work before a direct application to a GWID : - Starting the design of a prototype to generate flat “Mesa” beams (summer 2003, Willems, D’Ambrosio, DeSalvo) - Design and construction of a suspended rigid FP cavity at Caltech (autumn 2003 – summer 2004, Simoni, DeSalvo et al.) - Manufacturing first test Mexican hat (MH) mirrors ( , LMA laboratory) - Full prototype experimental set up (autumn 2004 – spring 2005, Tarallo, Willems, Agresti, DeSalvo) - Testing MH mirrors and achieving the first flat Mesa beam (summer 2005, Miller, Tarallo, Willems et al. )

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 286 Mesa beam cavity prototype l Necessity to verify the behavior of the mesa beam and study its generation and control before its possible application to GW interferometers l We built a rigid, folded, suspended, 7.32m long FP cavity supporting a MH mirror to investigate the modes structure and characterize the sensitivity to perturbations mirrors imperfections misalignments INVAR rod MH mirror Flat input mirror Flat folding mirror Vacuum pipe Thermal shield Spacer plate 2x 3.5 m

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 287 Input/output optics bench: Nd:YAG Mephisto laser Mode match telescope Fast photodiode for transmitted power readout CCD camera to control the locked TEM Suspended FP cavity, F ~ 100 Profile readout bench (CCD camera, high resolution) Feedback control electronics & cavity mirrors DC driving Mesa beam cavity experimental setup CCD camera

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 288 “Mexican hat” mirrors We can characterize how mirrors imperfections affects the beam in such a interferometer l LMA laboratories provided three mirror samples l C05004 (test run): - Thin substrate (20 mm) - large offset on the central bump l C05008 & C05009: - Thick substrate (30 mm) - Both affected with a not negligible slope on the central bump Mexican hat C05008

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 289 FFT simulations Using paraxial approximation, FFT codes can simulate the propagation of actual TEM patterns on optical cavities A Mathematica FFT routine has been dedicated to simulate our cavity beam behavior: it gave us the best tool to choose the best MH: C05008 First implementation of MH C05008 map FFT EM field on a ideal MH mirror

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2810 The slope on the central bump can be corrected applying the right mirror tilt FFT simulations  5 nm error central area

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2811 MH Cavity Alignment Spherical optics: tilt is translated in a change of the optical axis MH mirrors: only cylindrical symmetry -> resonant beam phase front change with the alignment Folded cavity: no preferential plane for mirrors alignment -> very difficult align within  rad precision

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2812 First Experimental Results Experimental setup (electronics, beam acquisition, locking…) tested with 8m r.o.c. spherical end mirror MH installation: no stable Mesa beam profile was acquired at the beginning Higher order modes were found very easily, good agreement with numerical prediction! ‘TEM10’‘TEM11’ ‘TEM20’

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2813 ‘TEM10’ 1D profile fit: Fit function: Mesa ‘TEM10’ Rsq = Fit function : Laguerre-Gauss TEM10 Rsq = First Experimental Results

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2814 TEM00 tilt simulation TEM00 data First Experimental Results Misalignments and mismatching effects has been modeled to recognize “strange” resonant modes

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2815 Strange evidence: every time we tried to align the cavity, mode shapes became worse and worse (as with spherical end mirror) Central part of the cavity seems “unstable”: maybe the problem is not the MH but the other two mirrors Systematics and following steps Mechanical clamping, PZTs and screws stress ~ 60 nm deformation -> three times the height of the MH central bump - We changed mirrors mounts reinforcing flexible mirrors with aluminum rings

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2816 First Mesa beam observations We were able to stably lock on the Mesa ‘TEM 00 ’ Best Mesa beam CCD Density plot The result is consistent with the best achievable using our current prototype MH mirror

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2817 First Mesa beam observations Comparison with FFT results: - Jagged top due to MH bump imperfections both in FFT and in experimental profiles - Deviation from the ideal Mesa field, almost the same - Still same asymmetry due to flat mirrors imperfections - The beam has the expected size within the experimental uncertainty Input and folding mirrors are the second main limitation

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2818 MH cavity characterization Remarkable agreement between numerical eigenvalues and experimental spectrum Cavity finesse and coupling are unavoidable depressed by flat mirror deviations (F exp  68 instead of 100)

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2819 Tilt sensitivity 2  rad simulated 3.85  rad experiment 2.57  rad experiment A preliminary quantification of beam sensitivity to mirror tilts was carried on Simulations and experimental data shows the same trend but a factor 1.5 of disagreement (TBI)

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2820 Conclusions and Future We are able to produce acceptable flat-topped beams with imperfect optics Alignment more taxing than with spherical mirrors MH “profile deposition” technique is actable, but better for larger mirror radius Next steps: Study MH FP coupled with recycling cavities AdLIGO and future high power detectors: nearly-concentric configuration (MHC )  A new 120m interferometer prototype (EGO?)

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2821 Thermal noise reduction using Mesa Beam (evaluation for Advanced LIGO mirrors) Advanced LIGO Evaluation conditions: The beam radius is dynamically adjusted to maintain a fixed diffraction loss = 1ppm The mirror thickness is also dynamically adjusted as a function of the mirror radius to maintain a fixed 40 Kg mirror mass. Gaussian beamMesa beam mirror Beam rad. (cm) ~2x

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2822 Substrate Thermoelastic Coating Brownian Substrate Brownian Coating Thermoelastic Gain factor Overall thermal noise budget Gaussian beam Mesa beam mirror Comparison between Gaussian and Mesa beam Calculation at the frequency 100 Hz Constraint 40 Kg mirror

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2823 The mirror shapes match the phase front of the beams. Mesa beam Gaussian beam Profiles normalized for Same Integrated power Steeper fall Slow exponential fall Higher peak power 0 Flat “mesa” beam profiles require rimmed “Mexican Hat” mirror profiles

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2824 Thermal shield Vacuum pipe INVAR rod Spacer plate Suspension wires Mechanical setup GAS springs

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2825 Cavity Lock Acquisition Tested with a R=800cm roc spherical mirror Two techniques: - Side locking: control on the injection current -> easier - Dither locking: modulation of the cavity length -> possibility to measure coupling with input beam but more sensitive to noise Results: - TEM patterns characterization - Environment capability to keep a lock

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2826 TEMs with spherical end mirrors Hermite-Gauss TEM set Laguerre-Gauss TEM set TEM00 TEM10 TEM20 TEM30 TEM10TEM20 Resonant beams: experimental data

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2827 TEMs with spherical end mirrors Qualitative analysis: - Cylindrical symmetry gradually lost - Difference between theoretical Hermite-Gauss and actual TEMs beam profiles (structure in the residual map) - Marked unbalance between the two TEM10 peaks: not avoided with fine PZTs adjustments

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M “Mexican hat” mirrors Numerical eigenmodes for a ideal MH Fabry-Perot interferometer: The fundamental mode is the so- called “Mesa Beam”, wider and flatter than a gaussian power distribution Cylindrical symmetry yields TEMs close to the Laguerre-Gauss eigenmodes set for spherical cavities

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2829

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2830 FP spectrum analysis: - TEMs identification and coupling analysis - Non-symmetric spacing: as expected - More peaks than we should see? Experimental Results

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2831 Other resonant TEMs: Experimental Results 2-dimensional nonlinear regression: Definitively not gaussian

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2832 Misalignments and mismatching effects has been modeled to recognize “strange” resonant modes No way to distinguish between them Experimental Results

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2833 Experimental Results

LIGO-G0200XX-00-M GWADW Isola d'Elba (Italy), May 2834 Systematic and next steps Any attempt to “drive” the beam in a centered configuration failed FFT: even cylindrical symmetry is definitely lost FP spectrum analysis: peaks are separated enough -> we are observing the actual cavity modes