Coalitions: Building Partnerships to Promote Agricultural Health and Safety l
Authors Teri Palermo, NIOSH Janet Ehlers, NIOSH Acknowledgments Jie Chen, NIOSH Intern Robert McKnight, Southeast Ag Center, Susan Jones, Western Kentucky University, Brian Day, NIOSH All those who responded to requests for information via list servers
of AG Safety and Health Promotion of AG Safety and Health Diverse problems, priorities and values Access to populations Identification of feasible interventions Effective dissemination
Coalitions Alliances of factions for specific purpose Issue oriented Formally organized Unite individuals and groups Specific goals Diverse talents and resources
Historical Guidance AG at Risk Surgeon General’s Conference NIOSH Ag Program Extramural Review Report
Ag at Risk Expand communication among all parties Increase communication > public/private sector Include professionals of diverse disciplines Promotion of coalitions
Surgeon General’s Conference Coalition Building Within professional community Between professional and agricultural communities Communicating to those affected Concern Help available Contributions are important
NIOSH External Review Report Create linkages between researchers & communities Involved affected communities
Types of Coalitions Agricultural at Risk National Committee for Childhood Injury Prevention North American Guidelines for Children’s Agricultural Tasks National Adolescent Farmwork Occupations Health & Safety Committee Tractor Risk Abatement & Control: The Policy Conference Consensus Development
Philanthropic Kellogg funded - 11 Projects Promote and support partnerships between institutions & communities Empowered women to reduce risks Developed community leadership Implemented Agromedicine training Developed targeted programs Identified stress, implemented interventions
Philanthropic… Initiative evaluated Set of generalized lessons developed Five barriers to success identified
Federally Funded NIOSH Agricultural Centers Advisory boards, task forces Support coalition development Occupational Health Nurses in Agricultural Communities (OHNAC) Enhance surveillance, Facilitate intervention
Federally Funded … Community Partners for Healthy Farming Surveillance & Intervention Research Components Researchers & stakeholders active partners
Response to Tragedy Farm Safety 4 Just Kids Promotes safe farm environments SHAUN Provides mental health services
Legislative I-CASH Fostered other coalitions Agrisafe Network Farm Safety 4 Just Kids SHAUN
Grass roots Located in all regions of the country Target local issues Share resources, expertise Develop, plan, and implement interventions Provide funding Often lack evaluation
Farm workers hospitals clinics Labor unions Farm Bureau Legal Advocacy groups schools teachers media Health Depts Local National State Regional Fire Depts Universities Mental Health Ag org Banks Local businesses Insurance Companies Tool manufacturers Board of Education Seed Salespeople Equip Dealers vets nurses FFA 4-H agribusiness Co-op ext Migrant clinics Producer Groups Trade Pubs Farm magazines physicians Corporate Farm mgt Family farms Faith Based org Commodity groups Ag Centers Co-ops
Impact Provided legitimacy and acceptability of messages Reached large numbers Increased community ownership of problem Developed problem solving skills within community
Impact… Increased research capacity Created new & innovative approaches Increased credibility of researchers Access to target populations
Impact… Educated rural health care providers Enhanced understanding of issues Developed consensus recommendations Increased number of effective & acceptable interventions Replicated successfully
Impact… Played role in policy and legislation Promoted open dialog and understanding Critical issues Differences in stakeholders priorities
Impact… Coalition members Increased personal knowledge and skills Increased self esteem Increased personal satisfaction Involved out of concern for future of Agricultural lifestyle
Ag at Risk Develop and promote collaborative projects Community Partners Annual scientific forum and journal JASH Ag Centers National and Regional Conferences
Ag at Risk … Develop grass roots organizations Farm Safety 4 Just Kids Develop state legislative agenda I-CASH Private sector initiatives Certified Safe Farms Kentucky ROPS
Challenges Evaluation Sustainability Minority Populations
Challenges… Evaluation Promote rigorous evaluation Emphasize importance, e.g. Encourages re-direction of energy & funds Plan evaluation at the beginning Partner with existing coalitions Determine extent of effectiveness
Challenges... Sustainability Support and active participation by all stakeholders Clear mission Effective leadership Adequate resources Integrate into all activities Plan for sustainability early
Challenges… Coalitions in minority and migrant communities Active participation Leadership roles Intervention, implementation and evaluation Literacy issues
“ “Individuals change their behaviors - only in response to some event or reinforced message - that has particular meaning to them... Peer and family pressure can create personal messages” Awareness and involvement of the community can provide the motivation and reinforcement to change health and safety behaviors Rowley (1990) Rowley (1990)
Coalitions have been successful… in moving individuals, communities & organizations… to action to reduce or prevent ag-related disease and injury