Handling Problem Manuscripts The nature of the problem Common ethical issues What to do.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Authorship APS Professional Skills Course:
Advertisements

Being a Reviewer APS Professional Skills Course: Writing and Reviewing for Scientific Journals.
Choosing a Journal APS Professional Skills Course: Writing and Reviewing for Scientific Journals.
Peer Review and Publication in APS Journals Submission and ContentD. Benos Peer Review & Manuscript ProductionM. Reich Ethics D. Benos & M. Reich.
Copyright 2005, Journal of Young Investigators, Inc. Writing Scientific Manuscripts a guide for undergraduates.
Authorship & Peer Review and Research Misconduct ( Plagiarism, Falsification & Fabrication) 650:270 Principles of Scholarly Integrity The University of.
Ethical publishing by doing the right things Moderated by Mirjam Curno Presented by Thomas Babor and Joseph Amon.
Duplicate Submission: Journal Roles and Responsibilities Diane M. Sullenberger Executive Editor, PNAS.
The Publishing Cycle Closing the Ethical Loop October 2011, University of Maryland Gert-Jan Geraeds, Executive Publisher
1) You as the publisher, submit the article directly to PubMed Central after acceptance. 2) The publication contract sent to the author,
Publication Issues GCP for clinical trials in India R.Raveendran Chief Editor Indian Journal of Pharmacology.
PUBLISH OR PERISH Skills Building Workshop. Journal of the International AIDS Society Workshop Outline 1.Journal of the International.
How to Create a Simple Network Diagram
Publishing 101 Dos and don’ts of publishing in APS journals
Research Integrity: Collaborative Research Michelle Stickler, DEd Office for Research Protections
Authorship, plagiarism, preventing and resolving conflicts: Ethical issues in the research arena Jay Heinecke
Responsible Conduct in Research
Writing Scientific Manuscripts. Table of Contents Introduction Part I: Publication & Peer Review –Deciding to Publish –Submitting Your Paper –After Submission.
Elsevier and the publisher role in supporting publishing ethics practices October 2011, University of Maryland Presented by: Mark Seeley, General Counsel.
Scientific Data as Research Infrastructure: The Biomedical Sciences Strategies for Economic Sustainability of Publicly Funded Data Repositories Board on.
Shobna Bhatia.  Telephone instrument  Computer  Software Instructions nearly always provided However, frequently not read At least, not until things.
A Spreadsheet Program for Use in the Detection of Anomalous Numerical Data of the Type Frequently Encountered in Cell and Radiation Biology Colony Survivals.
So you want to publish an article? The process of publishing scientific papers Williams lab meeting 14 Sept 2015.
Declaring the Publication Ethics (Scopus Comments) Razieh Moghadam, Kowsar Corporation,
The Committee on Publication Ethics: Promoting integrity in research publication Sabine Kleinert Senior Executive Editor, The Lancet Ex-Vice-Chair, Committee.
Integrity in Scientific Journal Publications Heather Goodell Director, Scientific Publishing American Heart Association Chair, CSE Editorial Policy Committee.
Why editors need to be concerned about publication ethics Elizabeth Wager, PhD Chair, Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
Developing Responsible Authorship and Publication Practices Thomas C. Chiles Research and Scholarship Integrity Program March 21, 2015.
Session Schedule Welcome (5 mins) Presentation (20 mins) Presentation Q & A (5 mins) Interactive Session (8 mins) Report Back from the Discussions (12.
So You’ve Just Become the Boss… Skills to Deal with Difficult Situations Virginia M. Miller, MBA, PhD Professor, Surgery and Physiology Director, Office.
How to detect non-obvious changes Some of the following slides will illustrate how Photoshop can be used to help our eyes visualize alterations to images,
Ethical Issues in Journal Publication Barbara Gastel, MD, MPH Texas A&M University
Scholarly Publication: Responsibilities for Authors and Reviewers Jean H. Shin, Ph.D. Director, Minority Affairs Program American Sociological Association.
REVIEWING MANUSCRIPTS TIPS FOR REVIEWING MANUSCRIPTS IN PEER REVIEWED JOURNALS Bruce Lubotsky Levin, DrPH, MPH Associate Professor & Head Dept. of Community.
Dealing with retractions A discussion Jigisha Patel Medical Editor.
Passive vs. Active voice Carolyn Brown Taller especializado de inglés científico para publicaciones académicas D.F., México de junio de 2013 ETHICAL.
Original Research Publication Moderator: Dr. Sai Kumar. P Members: 1.Dr.Sembulingam 2. Dr. Mathangi. D.C 3. Dr. Maruthi. K.N. 4. Dr. Priscilla Johnson.
Publication and Research Misconduct Stephanie Harriman Deputy Medical Editor.
INANE Meeting –Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing Charon Pierson Geraldine Pearson August 5, 2015.
Retracted publications in the era of open access Armen Yuri Gasparyan, MD, PhD, FESC Associate Professor of Medicine Member, WAME Council Member, EASE.
Ethics and Scientific Writing. Ethical Considerations Ethics more important than legal considerations Your name and integrity are all that you have!
Avoiding Research Misconduct Center for AIDS Research, Mentoring Program May 15th from 9-10:30 AM at 1700 Owens (Mission Bay Campus), 4th Floor Conference.
Ethics and Plagiarism AAHEP8 -- Amsterdam 2015 Erick Weinberg -- APS.
Ethical Conduct of Research for New Faculty, Post-Docs and Graduate Students Brief Overview.
Submission of a Manuscript Journal of Forestry uses Rapid Review.
Professional Development Workshop: Ethics in Science and Publishing Overview presentation: Defining the problem: What is research misconduct and why is.
HOW TO WRITE A PAPER FOR PUBLICATION IN A SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL.
Publication Ethics Webinar: Jan 2016 A Publisher’s View on Research Integrity Paul Peters CEO, Hindawi Publishing Corporation President of OASPA
ETHICS – FROM CODES TO PRACTICE KARIM MURJI, THE OPEN UNIVERSITY, UK.
Prof. Dr. Saw Aik Chief editor Malaysian Orthopaedic Journal University Malaya Medical Centre, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia Ethical Issues and Publication Misconducts.
1 Getting published University College London February 2009 Robert West.
Dr.V.Jaiganesh Professor
“Scientific Misconduct: Falsification, Fabrication and Plagiarism”
Data Fabrication and Falsification
The Seven Deadly Sins in Addiction Publishing and How to Avoid Them
The peer review process
Publication ethics PU 7, March 15, 2017
Farmington Consensus Tom Babor  .
Writing Scientific Manuscripts
Role of peer review in journal evaluation
Ethics for Authors Dr. Bahaty.
Writing for Publication
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of
What Are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics?
Will become a charity (?end of 2007) Strengthen role in education
Ethics in Research Rebecca Lunstroth, JD, MA
Updated NIH Public Access Policy
The Image The pixels in the image The mask The resulting image 255 X
Changing Background Will Schafer.
Allegation.
Presentation transcript:

Handling Problem Manuscripts The nature of the problem Common ethical issues What to do

Reasons for retractions Fang FC, Steen RG, Casadevall A., PNAS 2012

Percent of published articles retracted for fraud or suspected fraud Fang FC, Steen RG, Casadevall A., PNAS 2012

JBC Problem Manuscripts Number of manuscript problems

Common Ethical Issues 90% of problems found in gel images Gel splicing Duplicate image Dropped background Cloning, masking, cleaning up (J. Krueger, ORI)

GEL SPLICING AND DUPLICATION ORI gradient tool Common Ethical Issues

DUPLICATE IMAGE Common Ethical Issues

DUPLICATE IMAGE Common Ethical Issues ORI gradient tool

DUPLICATE IMAGES IN MICROGRAPHS Common Ethical Issues

DROPPED BACKGROUND Were these bands just copied onto a white(-ish) background? YES Common Ethical Issues

ORI gradient tool What’s missing? Common Ethical Issues MASKING AND “CLEANING UP”

90% of problems found in gel images Gel splicing Duplicate image Dropped background Cloning, masking, “cleaning up” 99% of these problems were image preparation errors NOT FRAUD Common Ethical Issues (J. Krueger, ORI)

Prior publication Simultaneous submission to more than one journal Plagiarism Human / animal protocols Statement of conflict of interest Authorship issues Other Kinds of Ethical Issues

Finding problems BEFORE publication

Find problems before publication Be alert to image manipulation

Increase brightness Zoom Zoom in on blots

Find problems before publication Be alert to image manipulation-Zoom, enlarge figures Be alert to prior publication-Check PubMed Review manuscripts for compliance with JBC policies Human/animal protocols Conflict of interest statement

What to do Report suspicions promptly to the associate editor Maintain confidentiality

Feedback: Privacy Policy Feedback
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
About project: SlidePlayer Terms of Service

© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc. All rights reserved.