USING A SPOKEN DIARY AND HEART RATE MONITOR IN MODELING HUMAN EXPOSURE TO AIRBORNE POLLUTANTS FOR EPA’S CONSOLIDATED HUMAN ACTIVITY DATABASE Curry I. Guinn,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Tuning Jenny Burr August Discussion Topics What is tuning? What is the process of tuning?
Advertisements

1 COMM 301: Empirical Research in Communication Kwan M Lee Lect4_1.
VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY
EE3P BEng Final Year Project – 1 st meeting SLaTE – Speech and Language Technology in Education Martin Russell
Lessons from Tanzania and Namibia Experiences September 19, 2012 Jacqueline Ndirangu – Pact Namibia Daisy Kisyombe – Pact Tanzania Pact MERL webinar series.
United Nations Statistics Division Scope and Role of Quarterly National Accounts Training Workshop on the Compilation of Quarterly National Accounts for.
CSCI 4163/6904, Summer Diary studies…  Participants collect data about events  As they happen  In the context of the event (in situ)  Can think.
The Islamic University of Gaza
Dissemination and Critical Evaluation of Published Research Peg Bottjen, MPA, MT(ASCP)SC.
Topics: Interviewing Question Type Interviewing techniques
Chapter 29 conducting marketing research Section 29.1
Chapter 7 Correlational Research Gay, Mills, and Airasian
Selection of Data Sources for Observational Comparative Effectiveness Research Prepared for: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)
DIVINES – Speech Rec. and Intrinsic Variation W.S.May 20, 2006 Richard Rose DIVINES SRIV Workshop The Influence of Word Detection Variability on IR Performance.
Validity and Reliability Dr. Voranuch Wangsuphachart Dept. of Social & Environmental Medicine Faculty of Tropical Medicine Mahodil University 420/6 Rajvithi.
Business and Management Research
SoundSense: Scalable Sound Sensing for People-Centric Application on Mobile Phones Hon Lu, Wei Pan, Nocholas D. lane, Tanzeem Choudhury and Andrew T. Campbell.
Housekeeping  Seminar topics  Requirements  Sign up by Feb 3rd :  Bonus.
The Challenges of Health Care Today Growing Government Regulation Increasing Insurance Requirements Staff Reductions & Shrinking Labor Pool Need to Cut.
UNIT D MARKETING INFORMATION MANAGEMENT 7.02 Interpret information to make effective business decisions.
Copyright © 2008 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited SECONDARY DATA RESEARCH IN A DIGITAL AGE Chapter 6 Part 2 Designing Research Studies.
IR Evaluation Evaluate what? –user satisfaction on specific task –speed –presentation (interface) issue –etc. My focus today: –comparative performance.
Descriptive and Causal Research Designs Copyright © 2010 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
McMillan Educational Research: Fundamentals for the Consumer, 6e © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Educational Research: Fundamentals.
1 Welcome: To the second learning sequence “ Data Base (DB) and Data Base Management System (DBMS) “ Recap : In the previous learning sequence, we discussed.
Improving Upon Semantic Classification of Spoken Diary Entries Using Pragmatic Context Information Daniel J. Rayburn Reeves Curry I. Guinn University of.
Evaluating a Research Report
Chapter 29 conducting marketing research Section 29.1
Copyright © 2007 Pearson Education Canada 1 Chapter 13: Audit of the Sales and Collection Cycle: Tests of Controls.
UNIVERSITAS SCIENTIARUM SZEGEDIENSIS UNIVERSITY OF SZEGED D epartment of Software Engineering New Conceptual Coupling and Cohesion Metrics for Object-Oriented.
RESEARCH METHODS Lecture 37. Use of secondary data.
©2010 John Wiley and Sons Chapter 6 Research Methods in Human-Computer Interaction Chapter 6- Diaries.
Games Analysis Collecting Data to improve performance.
E CON 432--C HAPTER 2 Tools of Positive Analysis.
Database What is a database? A database is a collection of information that is typically organized so that it can easily be storing, managing and retrieving.
Quality Software Project Management Software Size and Reuse Estimating.
The Four P’s of an Effective Writing Tool: Personalized Practice with Proven Progress April 30, 2014.
The effect of peer feedback for blogging on college Advisor: Min-Puu Chen Presenter: Pei- Chi Lu Xie, Y., Ke, F., & Sharma, P. (2008). The effect of feedback.
6: Descriptive and Causal Research Designs. 6-2 Copyright © 2008 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Hair/Wolfinbarger/Ortinau/Bush,
© (2015, 2012, 2008) by Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved Chapter 11: Correlational Designs Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating.
A COMPARISON OF HAND-CRAFTED SEMANTIC GRAMMARS VERSUS STATISTICAL NATURAL LANGUAGE PARSING IN DOMAIN-SPECIFIC VOICE TRANSCRIPTION Curry Guinn Dave Crist.
Marketing Information Systems and Marketing Research Chapter 5 Kotler, Bowen and Makens Marketing for Hospitality and Tourism.
Non-Experimental Design Where are the beakers??. What kind of research is considered the “gold standard” by the Institute of Education Sciences? A.Descriptive.
Psychology As Science Psychologists use the “scientific method” Steps to the scientific method: - make observations - ask question - develop hypothesis.
MEASURING PHYSICAL ACTIVITY Week 3. What you need to know The difference between subjective and objective methods The difference between subjective and.
Multi-institutional collaborative research program. Established in 1988 to document the composition and status of natural vegetation of the Carolinas.
Collecting time use data Social and Housing Statistics Section United Nations Statistics Division International Workshop on Social Statistics, Bejing,22-
Quantitative Data Collection In Advertising Research.
Colby Smart, E-Learning Specialist Humboldt County Office of Education
Sports Market Research. Know Your Customer How do businesses know their customers needs and wants?  Ask them/talking to customers  Surveys  Questionnaires.
Conducting Marketing Research Chapter 29. Sec – The Marketing Research Process The steps in conducting marketing research The difference between.
RESEARCH MOTHODOLOGY SZRZ6014 Dr. Farzana Kabir Ahmad Taqiyah Khadijah Ghazali (814537) SENTIMENT ANALYSIS FOR VOICE OF THE CUSTOMER.
Section 29.1 Marketing Research Chapter 29 conducting marketing research Section 29.2 The Marketing Survey.
Chapter 29 Conducting Market Research. Objectives  Explain the steps in designing and conducting market research  Compare primary and secondary data.
Pruning Analysis for the Position Specific Posterior Lattices for Spoken Document Search Jorge Silva University of Southern California Ciprian Chelba and.
MANAGING CUSTOMER INFORMATION TO GAIN CUSTOMER INSIGHTS Chapter 5 Kotler, Bowen, Makens and Baloglu Marketing for Hospitality and Tourism.
NS 210 – Unit 3 Seminar Interview Techniques Leslie Young MS RD LDN.
English for EAP Practice activities Reading more efficiently Lesson 4 Different text types English for Academic Purposes Practice activities Reading more.
© Prentice Hall, 2005 Excellence in Business CommunicationChapter Planning Business Reports and Proposals.
Learn Mercury Load runner as an Online Training. The advanced reality of a digital transformation in the digital world always been on a threshold in terms.
Information for marketing management
RESEARCH METHODS Lecture 37
Chapter 3: risk measurement
Descriptive and Causal Research Designs
Business and Management Research
OBSERVATION.
Conducting Marketing Research
Information Gathering
11/1/2016 Take out a pencil Take out your “Social Media Use” packet
Chapter 10 Content Analysis
Presentation transcript:

USING A SPOKEN DIARY AND HEART RATE MONITOR IN MODELING HUMAN EXPOSURE TO AIRBORNE POLLUTANTS FOR EPA’S CONSOLIDATED HUMAN ACTIVITY DATABASE Curry I. Guinn, UNC Wilmington Daniel J. Rayburn Reeves, UNC Wilmington

Collecting Human Activity Data Purpose: To develop a method of generating an activity/location/time/energy expenditure database of sufficient detail to accurately predict human exposures and dose.

Goals of our study To Evaluate To Evaluate the use of digital voice recordings the use of digital voice recordings the use of the ambulatory heart rate monitor the use of the ambulatory heart rate monitor participant/instrumentation interactions participant/instrumentation interactions To Develop To Develop a protocol for automating the processing of voice recordings a protocol for automating the processing of voice recordings an autocoding program that will be able to map the text of the diary entries to CHAD an autocoding program that will be able to map the text of the diary entries to CHAD

Problems with Collecting Human Activity Data Recall Data Recall Data Failure to recollect many daily activities Failure to recollect many daily activities Lack of detail Lack of detail Real-Time Paper Diaries Real-Time Paper Diaries Increased number of reports/better detail Increased number of reports/better detail Burdensome Burdensome Direct Observation Direct Observation Greatest number of reports/most detail Greatest number of reports/most detail Inefficient and expensive Inefficient and expensive

The Experimental Platform Data Collection Data Collection Audio diary using a digital voice recorder Audio diary using a digital voice recorder Ambulatory Monitoring System that monitors heart rate and prompts subjects to provide diary entries when heart rate increases by a specified criterion level. Ambulatory Monitoring System that monitors heart rate and prompts subjects to provide diary entries when heart rate increases by a specified criterion level.

Digital Voice Recorder Allows “Real-Time” Activity/Location Data to be Collected Easily Allows “Real-Time” Activity/Location Data to be Collected Easily Reduce burden of paper or computerized diary entries Reduce burden of paper or computerized diary entries Relies on efficient, simple naturally spoken reports Relies on efficient, simple naturally spoken reports Potentially richer, more detailed reports Potentially richer, more detailed reports No restrictive diary format No restrictive diary format Electronic format Electronic format

Ambulatory Monitoring System Provides an objective measure of exertion that is more reliable than self-reported respiratory rates Provides an objective measure of exertion that is more reliable than self-reported respiratory rates Prompts subjects to report activity when heart rate variation exceeds criterion levels Prompts subjects to report activity when heart rate variation exceeds criterion levels

Natural Language Processing Application Applies contextual language constraints to facilitate speech-to-database conversion Applies contextual language constraints to facilitate speech-to-database conversion Speech  Text  Database Encoding Processes and codes the diary reports using the CHAD code scheme Processes and codes the diary reports using the CHAD code scheme Reduce need for manual transcription and coding Reduce need for manual transcription and coding

Spoken Diary From an utterance like “I am on the bus on my way to South Square Mall”, map that utterance into From an utterance like “I am on the bus on my way to South Square Mall”, map that utterance into 18400: Travel for goods and services 18400: Travel for goods and services 31140: Travel by bus) 31140: Travel by bus) Text abstraction Text abstraction Technique Technique Statistical language processing using n-grams and Bayesian statistics Statistical language processing using n-grams and Bayesian statistics

Subjects IDSexOccupationAgeEducation 1F Manages Internet Company 52 Some College 2F Grocery Deli Worker 18 Some College 3M Construction Worker 35 High School 4F Database Coordinator 29GraduateDegree 5F Coordinator for Non-profit56 Some College 6MUnemployed50 High School 7MRetired76 8MDisabled62 9MEnvironmentTechnician56GraduateDegree

Voice Diaries Average: 29 entries/ day Average: 29 entries/ day With average monitoring time of 8.56 hours, 3.39 recordings/hour With average monitoring time of 8.56 hours, 3.39 recordings/hour First 3 days of trial: 34.44/ day First 3 days of trial: 34.44/ day Last 2 days of trial: 20.65/ day Last 2 days of trial: 20.65/ day 1 out of 63 reporting periods data lost (1.6%) 1 out of 63 reporting periods data lost (1.6%)

Recordings Per Day

Quality of Diary Entries Advantages Advantages High Entry Rate High Entry Rate Timed correlation with heart rate data Timed correlation with heart rate data Disadvantages Disadvantages Little prompting Little prompting Unformatted data Unformatted data Variable reporting of subjects Variable reporting of subjects

Quality of Diary Entries Entry Length Entry Length 9.39 words average 9.39 words average Some entries invalid because of length (subject failed to turn off recording) Some entries invalid because of length (subject failed to turn off recording) 1/30 recordings (3%) 1/30 recordings (3%)

Heart Rate Change Indicator Tones and Subject Compliance S Number of Tones Per Day (Avg.) % of Times Subject Made a Diary Entry Corresponding to a Tone % % % % % % % % %

Statistical Processing Accuracy of Hand- Transcribed Data with Threshold of 0.3 Subject Act. Prec. Act. Recall Loc. Prec. Loc. Recall Total75.5%51.6%69.5%63.7%

Threshold values affect the precision and recall: The higher the threshold, the greater the precision but the lower the recall

Time, Activity, Location, Exertion Data Gathering Platform

Research Topics How do we fuse data from other sources (gps, beacons, heart rate monitor, etc.)? How do we fuse data from other sources (gps, beacons, heart rate monitor, etc.)? How do we provide interactive prompts to the subject to improve reporting? How do we provide interactive prompts to the subject to improve reporting?