1 Patient safety indicators Yolanda Agra Varela. MD; Ph.D Sennior Adviser National Quality Agency. Ministry of Health Dublin 29 June 2006 Patient Safety.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
National Reporting & Learning System (NRLS) Reporting systems are vital in providing a core of sound, representative information on which to base analysis.
Advertisements

Adverse Patient Safety Events: Costs of Readmissions and Patient Outcomes Following Discharge Didem M. Bernard, Ph.D. William E. Encinosa, Ph.D.
Epidemiology and benefit to patients from accurate coding Heather Walker CHKS Consultancy and Marketing Director 4 th May 2012.
Standard 6: Clinical Handover
Leifur Bardarson MD Landspitali - University Hospital ICELAND A SSESSING P ATIENT S AFETY T HROUGH A DMINISTRATIVE D ATA A DAPTING AND I MPROVING E XISTING.
Risk Management / CQI Nutr 564: Management Summer 2002.
Ministero della Salute 1 Sentinel Event System The Italian Experience Giuseppe Murolo, MD Ministry of Health, Department of Quality General Directorate.
{ ADVERSE DRUG REACTIONS To ensure patient, family/caregiver and home health personnel are instructed to identify adverse reactions to medications and.
Calculating & Reporting Healthcare Statistics
Documentation for Acute Care
+ Global Challenges in Patient Safety Reshma Ramachandran November 17, 2020.
Systems for Safety June Much has Been Done … Trend in Age-Adjusted 30-Day In-Hospital Death Rate Excludes NL, QC, BC.
a judgment of what constitutes good or bad Audit a systematic and critical examination to examine or verify.
Nursing Assistant Program Bradwell Institute
William B Munier, MD, MBA, Director Center for Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality AHRQ Annual Conference.
Safety Basic Science December 22 nd, Safety Attitudes Questionnaire (SAQ) I am encouraged by my colleagues to report any patient safety concerns.
Patient Safety and Public Health Informatics Iona Thraen, ACSW Patient Safety Director.
M Purpose Improvement Tools/Methods Limitations / Lessons Learned Results Process Improvement Improving Hospital-Acquired Pressure Ulcers at Discharge.
OECD Health Care Quality Indicator Project Prague March 5th 2009 Sandra Garcia Armesto on behalf of the HCQI team.
The Spanish National Health System Ministry of Health and Consumer Affairs JOINING EFFORTS TO REACH OPTIMAL QUALITY AND EQUITY Bernat Soria, MD, PhD Minister.
Knowledge Driven Care – Realised Through Transformation Dr Simon Wallace Medical Executive Cerner UK.
Adapting AHRQ Patient Safety Indicators to QIO Data Jocelyn Andrel, MSPH Charles P. Schade, MD, MPH Patricia Ruddick, RN, MSN.
ICD-9-CM Hospital Inpatient Coding
Hospital acquired VTE Alert system Caroline Baglin Thrombophilia CNS.
1955 when Codman who is also known as father of Patient safety looked at the outcome of patient care 1984 Anaesthesia patient safety foundation established.
Module 3. Session DCST Clinical governance
The National System of Health Quality Assessment Álvaro Moreira da Silva Board of Direction ERS Porto, 08 May 2014 SINAS.
History of patient safety : 1955 when Codman who is also known as father of Patient safety looked at the outcome of patient care 1984 Anaesthesia patient.
South Tees Hospitals Hospital Discharge Bev Walker Assistant Director of Nursing and Patient Safety Patients are central to everything we do.
Patient Safety in Primary Care The Linneaus Collaboration www. linneaus-pc.eu Aneez Esmail Professor of General Practice University of Manchester (UK)
How Much Does Medicare Pay Hospitals for Adverse Events? Building the Business Case for Investing in Patient Safety Improvement Chunliu Zhan, MD, PhD,
A Regional Approach to Improvement Julie Branter Associate Director for Clinical Governance and Patient Safety 21 September 2010 South West Strategic Health.
Safety and Quality in Maternity Care
1 Implementing a Comprehensive Functional Model of Care in Hospitalized Older Adults Denise Lyons, MSN, GCNS, BC Clinical Nurse Specialist in Gerontology.
Performance Data: From Both Sides Now Gail R. Bellamy, Ph.D. AHRQ 2007 Annual Conference “Improving Health Care, Improving Lives.
ARE YOU READY? For HAC’s – October 1, 2008 Kathy Whitmire September 2008.
European Union Network for Patient Safety and Quality of Care BMJ Forum. Paris. April 10, 2014 Good Organisational Practices for Exchange Mechanism Work.
What do we know about overall trends in patient safety in the USA? Patrick S. Romano, MD MPH Professor of Medicine and Pediatrics University of California,
1 1 Survey of Patient Safety Culture in U.S. Hospitals: External Validity Analyses Russ Mardon, Ph.D. Westat 2008 AHRQ Annual Conference Westat 1650 Research.
ADVANCES oN PATIENT SAFETY IN MEXICO Dra. Odet Sarabia González Advisor of the Under Secretary of Quality and Innovation, Ministry of Health Mexico, Mexico.
Patient Safety Issues in Gynaecology Joanna Thomas & Louise Samworth Saint Mary’s Hospital Manchester.
Hospital-Acquired VTE: What We Have Learned Martha J. Radford, MD Chief Quality Officer NYU Langone Medical Center September 2009.
Risk Management / CQI Nutr 564: Management Summer 2005.
Going Public Ben Yandell, PhD, CQE Clinical Information Analysis Norton Healthcare, Louisville, KY
Place picture here Potentially Preventable Readmissions RARE Mental Health Collab. Mark Sonneborn February 2014.
AHRQ Quality Indicators NQF Update Marybeth Farquhar, PhD, MSN, RN QI Users Meeting AHRQ 2 nd Annual Conference Rockville, MD September 10, 2008.
Excellence in Obstetrics A MULTI-SITE AHRQ DEMONSTRATION PROJECT Ann Hendrich, RN, PhD, F.A.A.N Vice President, Clinical Excellence Operations Executive.
National Patient Safety Goals (NPSGs)
© Copyright, The Joint Commission 2015 National Patient Safety Goals.
UNDERSTANDING AND DEFINING QUALITY Quality Academy – Cohort 6 April 8, 2013.
Code of Conduct and Ethics Scope of Practice Eileen Quinn
Anne Mette Dons, MD Head of Department Supervision and Patient Safety
MEDICAL SERVICE ADMINISTRATION VIETNAM MINISTRY OF HEALTH
HealthPartners: One Approach to Improving Quality and Safety George Isham, M.D.,M.S. Medical Director and Chief Health Officer HealthPartners
BlueCross BlueShield of Illinois a Division of Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC), a Mutual Legal Reserve Company Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois.
Risk Management / CQI Nutr 564: Management Summer 2005.
1 Quality of Care and Patient Safety: Impact on Healthcare January 22, 2009 Presenter: F. Lisa Murtha, Practice Leader and Managing Director, Huron Consulting.
Canadian Best Practice Recommendations for Stroke Care Recommendation 1: Public Awareness and Patient Education (Updated 2008)
Governance & Standards What is happening internationally Triona Fortune, March 2016.
Dr. Rashida Abdelfattah FACULTY OF NURSING SCIENCES University of Khartoum.
We’re counting the benefits of EPR Find out at: epr.this.nhs.uk We’re counting the benefits of EPR Find out at: epr.this.nhs.uk The introduction of EPR.
AHRQ QI Guide to Comparative Reporting AHRQ Annual Conference September 10, 2008 Bethesda, MD Presented by Sheryl Davies.
Clarifying "never events" and introducing "always events"
Overview of current services
Venous Thromboembolism Prophylaxis (VTE)
2017 National Patient Safety Goals
Inpatient Quality Coding It’s Not Just About What you Get Paid
The 5th Annual Lorraine Tregde Patient Safety Leadership Conference “The Will to Pursue Excellence” June 14, 2012.
Presentation transcript:

1 Patient safety indicators Yolanda Agra Varela. MD; Ph.D Sennior Adviser National Quality Agency. Ministry of Health Dublin 29 June 2006 Patient Safety. A national priority for the Spanish Health System

2 STRATEGY Nº 8: To improve patient safety in the NHS To improve awareness and culture To improve awareness and culture To develop an information system on PS To develop an information system on PS To perform best practices in all Health Regions To perform best practices in all Health Regions STRATEGY Nº 8: To improve patient safety in the NHS To improve awareness and culture To improve awareness and culture To develop an information system on PS To develop an information system on PS To perform best practices in all Health Regions To perform best practices in all Health Regions PATIENT SAFETY: A PRIORITY FOR THE SPANISH NHS

3 AWARENESS AND CULTURE INFORMATION -Communication campaign -National Conference: ENEAS -International Conference: November 2006 RESEARCH -Sponsoring National RP -Review Group on PS (agreement with Iberoamerican Cochrane Collaboration) PROFESSIONAL PERCEPTION Validated questionnaire “Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture” TRAINING -Basic training in all Regions -Risk Management Tool Kit: on-line -Training for managers and directors -Advanced Qualification on PS -Medication and safety -Material for University training

4 Incidence of Patients with AE INTERNATIONAL ADVERSE EVENTS INCIDENCE STUDIES SPAIN 2005

5 INFORMATION SYSTEMS ADVERSE EVENTS ADVERSE EVENTS  Comparative Analysis of the International Information Systems of AE  Design a notification system of Adverse Events for the NHS, taking into consideration legal aspects INDICATORS INDICATORS  Agreement on national indicators on PS (AHRQ, OCDE)

6 TO IMPROVE BEST PRACTICES IN ALL REGIONS  To improve patient identification  To implement PS Units  To prevent nosocomial infections  To promote good practices in clinical settings to prevent: -Anaesthesia-Related Complications -Hip Fractures in Surgical Patients -Pressure ulcers in Hospital Patients -Pulmonary Thromboembolism (PTE) and Deep Venous Thrombosis (DVT) in Surgical Patients -Infection in Surgical Wounds -Wrong-Site Surgery -Medication Errors and -Ensure Last Wishes of patients

7 NATIONAL HEALTH SYSTEM

8 PUBLIC HEALTH CARE Population covered 0.6 % 200,000 people Population not covered High income people De facto universal coverage 99.4 % 40 million people UNIVERSAL COVERAGE NATIONAL HEALTH SYSTEM

9 779 HOSPITALS 157,926 BEDS 4 Beds per 1,000 inhabitants 326 (42%) 103,736 (66%) 574 Acute Care Hospitals 92 Mental Health Hospitals 113 Long-Term Care Centres 69,000 Physicians 103,000 Nurses 65% 85% PUBLIC FUNDED CENTRES IN-PATIENT HEALTH CARE (40 %)

10 PUBLIC HOSPITALS 1 consultation / per inhab. 55 million 55 million consultations 85% 17 million 17 million emergency cases 335 emergency case / 1,000 inhab. 77% 3 million 3 million surgeries 51 operations / 1,000 inhab.62% 4.5 million 4.5 million admissions 80 admissions / 1,000 inhab.70% STRUCTURE AND ORGANISATION SPECIALISED CARE NATIONAL HEALTH SYSTEM

11 MINIMUM BASIC DATA SET Mandatory Administrative data Hospital Data Base Quarterly (MBDS) Health Region Data Base validation Regional Data Base National Data Base Hospital activity + Discharge records (ICD9-CM)

12 SURGERY-RELATED COMPLICATIONS OBSERVATIONSINDICATOR CODE CASES PER YEAR Total (%) and discharges D: All surgical discharges Underreporting OECD: all hospitalized patients Underreporting: other sources are needed Wound Infection 998.5, , ,960 (2.14) 1,117,478 25,537 (2.15) 1,186,381 26,573 (2.20) 1,203,129 27,888 (2.26) 1,230,378 D: All surgical discharges. Excl. obstetrics and newborn OECD adn AHRQ: also exlclude vena cava procedures Underreporting: other clinical records needed PTE-DVT 415.1, 11, ,4519,4511, 4512, ,010 (1.96) 1,018,443 20,957 (1.94) 1,078,437 21,268 (1.95) 1,088,100 22,978 (2.07) 1,109,453 D: All surgical discharges > 18 OECD: some diseases excluded Should we excluded them? Hip fracture 820 1,479 (0.14) 1,025,416 1,411 (0.13) 1,093,463 1,474 (0.13) 1,113,593 1,586 (0.14) 1,140,475 D: All surgical discharges OECD: all medical and surgical discharges Underreporting: surgical record should be reported Foreign body (0.015) 1,117, (0.017) 1,186, (0.016) 1,203, (0.016) 1,230,378 Wrong site E

13 OBSTETRIC-RELATED COMPLICATIONS OBSERVATIONSINDICATOR CODE CASES PER YEAR Total (%) and discharges D: all newborn OCDE and AHRQ: live birth excluding subdural or cerebral hemorrage, injury skeleton, (767.3, 767.4) preterm and osteogenesis imprefecta (756.51) Not all Hospitals have clinical records for the newborn Birth trauma 767.0, 7673, 7674, ,332 (1.22) 272,470 3,423 (1.17) 291,558 3,379 (1.11) 303,918 3,202 (0.98) 320,903 D: 650, Not all included OECD: vaginal delivery Vaginal DRGs: ,646 (9.07) 271,527 27,534 (9.8) 279,561 29,740 (11.36) 261,622 35,518 (12.75) 278,483 D: procedures 74.0, OECD: cesarean delivery Cesarea DRGs: (0.47) 56, (0.43) 63, (0.46) 67, (0.50) 73,644

14 OTHER MEDICAL CARE COMPLICATIONS OBSERVATIONSINDICATOR CODE CASES PER YEAR Total (%) and discharges D:All discharges> 5 days.Excl: neonates and obstetrics Hemiplegia, paraplegia, quadriplegia Should be excluded? Underreporting: Nurse records should be included Pressure ulcers (0.75) 1,516, (0.83) 1,552, (0.86) 1,572, (0.95) 1,610,410 D: All discharges. Excl: neonates and neoplasm Underreporting OECD: also exclude immunocompromised (codes?) Underreporting: other sources are needed Infections 999.3, 996, (0.24) 2,859, (0.23) 2,932, (0.25) 2,979, (0.28) 3,073,553 D: All discharges. Excl: neonates Underreporting: other data base needed Transfusional reactions 999.6, 999.7, not: E8760 ( % 0 ) 14 (0.004) 3,148, (0.005) 3,237, (0.006) 3,287, (0.006) 3,386,01 3

15 ADVANTAGES OF MBDS Agreement at National level for a Minimum Basic Data Set Common standards for codification at national level (ICD-9-CM) Resources exists in the Hospitals (clinical documentation units) High Coverage: Almost 100% discharges are codified in public Hospitals and >25% in private (depending on the Region) High Coverage: Almost 100% discharges are codified in public Hospitals and >25% in private (depending on the Region) High qualification of the experts in codification in public hospitals Exhaustive codification: adverse events could be detected through MBDS Useful for identifying problems for further analysis

16 LIMITATIONS OF THE DATA Clinical records: incomplete diagnosis information (comorbidity and elderly patients) Discharge records are the usual source of codification (not all diagnoses and procedures are included e.g.surgery discharges) Private acute care Hospitals (60%) not included in the MBDS Variability in codification related with qualification and DRG,s use of the data for reimbursement Second diagnosis: Prehospitalization vs in-patient complication Variability among Regions

17 CONSEQUENCES Differences in the quality of codifications among Hospitals Lower rates of complications in comparison with specific studies: Underreporting Unknown variability among Regions National Specific software in development : delay in data reporting Oriented to assess cost and not quality of care

18 ACTIONS FOR IMPROVEMENT To increase the number of private Hospitals with codification To improve professional awareness (managers and clinicians) Feed-back : Give to them to improve the quality of care, not as punishment To improve expert skills in codification in all Hospitals Systematic quality control for clinical records and MBDS Review all clinical records (not only discharge records) should be a requirement to perform the MBDS For a real picture we would need: review other data bases and clinical records and develop specific adhoc audits and studies For a real picture we would need: review other data bases and clinical records and develop specific adhoc audits and studies

19 The challenge: Comparing these Indicators among the OECD countries