The Stock Issues of Debate 5 Things Every Debater Needs, and Needs to Know!

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Affirmative Cases Database Created By Stuart S. Bottom Modesto Debate Club.
Advertisements

(Counter) Plans Because they didn’t limit the topic.
A Firm Foundation: CX Debate Basics (Part I) A N INTRODUCTION TO P OLICY D EBATE - The Minnesota Urban Debate League -
Welcome to the Dark Side of the Force Introduction to Policy Debate.
A Firm Foundation: CX Debate Basics (Part II) A N INTRODUCTION TO P OLICY D EBATE - The Minnesota Urban Debate League -
POLICY DEBATE Cross-Examination (CX). POLICY DEBATE  Purpose of policy debate is to compare policies and decide which is best  Affirmative: Supports.
Cross Examination (CX) Debate
Debating Case and Disadvantages CODI 2014 Lecture 1.
AUDL Middle School Debate Team Tournament Handbook Debate Tournament Schedule Arrive at tournament & wait in cafeteria. Round 1 Round 2 Lunch Break in.
Theory CODI 2014 Lecture. Rules of Debate Debate has surprisingly few rules Time limits and speaking order There must be a winner and loser No outside.
+ Debate Basics. + DEBATE A debate is a formal argument in which two opposing teams propose or attack a given proposition or motion in a series of speeches.
Building Government Cases. Preliminary Steps Follow critical decision making. –Analyze the proposition. Look at all alternatives with as much knowledge.
Introduction to Debate -Negative- To access audio: Skype: freeconferencecallhd and enter # Or call and enter # © L. Husick,
Everyone’s ‘Favorite’ Debate! Topicality. Define the word (or phrase) the Affirmative is not topical under.
Topicality. Our Focus Significance Harms Inherency Topicality Solvency.
POLICY DEBATE Will look like CX on the sign up sheet.
Debate Notes: Arguments Building the Affirmative and the Negative Constructive Arguments.
Introduction to Debate -Affirmative- To access audio: Skype: freeconferencecallhd and enter # Or call and enter # © L.
Counterplans Debate Central Workshop August 30, 2008.
Constructive Speeches (1AC)- 6 MINUTES CX 1A to 2N- 3 MINUTES (1NC)- 6 MINUTES CX- 1N to 1A- 3 MINUTES (2AC)- 6 MINUTES CX- 2A to 1N- 3 MINUTES (2NC)-
Most important things Keep your personal views outside the room Debaters must adapt to you Be honest about your judging experience.
 The 2 nd stock issue is Inherency.  The term INHERENCY is a noun derived from the base word “INHERENT” which is an adjective and means: “…EXISTING.
ORDER AND PURPOSE OF THE SPEECHES
Debate. What is debate? Formalized Public Speaking Contest to find out which side has better logical reasons.
Debate Tournaments.  Competitive High School Debate involves preparing for, and attending Tournaments, where you will debate against teams from other.
And other things… DISADVANTAGES. BUT FIRST, LETS REVIEW FOR THE QUIZ The quiz on Wednesday will be open note and will cover the two primary topics and.
11/12/2015 Aim: To determine qualities of a good argument Topic: The Stuff of Good Argument.
Opposition Strategy NCFA Rookie Debate Camp. Agenda ❖ A Brief Word on Trichotomy ❖ Basic Path to Winning ❖ Opposition Strategies by Position* ❖ Quick.
The Affirmative And Stock Issues By: Matt Miller.
The Disadvantage Provides an added measure to vote against the affirmative plan and vote for the present system.
Debating Michael Cheng National Chengchi University
Getting Started in CX Debate Julian Erdmann. What is CX debate? Team debate made up by two students from the same school. They will defend either Affirmative.
Debating the Case GDI Glossary Aff case Advantage Offense Defense Card Analytic.
Policy Debate THISPAD.
Introduction to Policy Debate The Forensics Files.
Debating the case.
POLICY DEBATE Training Tomorrow’s Leaders How to Think Today!
Debate The Essentials Ariail, Robert. “Let the Debates Begin.” 18 Aug orig. published in The State, South Carolina. 26 Sept
Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards Baylor University July 2013.
TOPICALITY DALLAS URBAN DEBATE ALLIANCE DEBATE CENTER SMU
 4 th stock issue  Significance means that the issue addressed by the Affirmative team is a major force affecting a large group.  The penalty for not.
Individual Policy Debate Orientation. Volunteers Make it Happen! 2 We can’t do this without you. You are making an investment. You are performing a teaching.
Intro to Public Forum Debate. What is Public Forum Debate? Partner debate Purpose- for the “common man” Much easier to understand, and thus to judge,
POLICY DEBATE. WHAT IS POLICY DEBATE? A structured format for fairly arguing a topic of policy TEAM DEBATE: two teams of two students each 8 speeches.
Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards & Russell Kirkscey June 2015.
Beginning Policy Debate: I ain’t scared ! NSDA Nationals 2014 Jane Boyd Grapevine HS, TEXAS.
Hays Watson Head Debate Coach UGA.  It is the counterpoint to the Affirmative – instead of Affirming a particular course of action (i.e. the resolution),
Topicality “That sounds good. That’s a good skill to have.” –Julia Marshall “Naw. Advantages don’t matter when it comes to Topicality.” –Humza Tahir.
Chapter 16,17,18 Negative Terms. Debate Terms-Negative Must directly clash with the affirmative Must directly clash with the affirmative Negative wins.
Mariner Speech and Debate Club Meeting #3 Tuesday, October 23, 2012.
Affirmative vs. negative
KRITIKS Melissa Witt.
CROSS-EXAMINATION DEBATE: THE AFFIRMATIVE CASE
Debate: The Basics.
Negative Strategies.
The Affirmative Adapted from:.
Introduction to the aff
Policy Analysis in Cross-ex Debate
Debate What is Debate?.
Negative Block:.
ORDER AND PURPOSE OF POLICY SPEECHES
DEBATE So you like to argue?.
Informative, Persuasive, and Impromptu Speaking all rolled into one!
5 Planks of a Plan.
Negative Attacks.
Stock Issues.
A Firm Foundation: CX Debate Basics (Part I)
Building Affirmative Case Template
Getting To Know Debate:
Introduction to CX Debate: Part I
Presentation transcript:

The Stock Issues of Debate 5 Things Every Debater Needs, and Needs to Know!

What are Stock Issues? Stock issues are 5 basic categories of information that must be provided in every debate round.

Inherency  The thing that is preventing the Status quo from changing. Structural Barrier: A law or rule that prevents a change. Attitudinal Barrier: Attitudes of people are preventing a change.

Harms are the bad things that the status quo does, and what the affirmative plans to solve. Remember, The affirmative must solve for all of the harms they list!

Plan The plan is the affirmative’s ideas to solve the harms listed earlier in their case. The Plan also has several steps that the affirmative must consider. 1.Mandates: 2.Funding: 3.Enforcement:

Solvency Solvency is the place in which the affirmative proves that their plan will solve for the harms they talked about earlier. Remember ! You must solve for all of your harms.

Topicality Topicality is an argument made by the negative team that says the affirmative is not debating the resolution. To develop a topicality argument the negative must show how the affirmative is non-topical (not debating the current topic).

Parts of Topicality 1. Definition- Define the word(s) that they are violating. 2. Violation- Explain how the negative’s case does not meet that definition. 3. Standards- Ways in which definitions can be used to check for topicality. 4. Voting- Explain why the judge should vote on topicality.

Web Sites of Interest Debate Central Cross-x.com Debate Links