Good Scientific Practice Helga Nolte, Hamburg, Gerlinde Sponholz, Berlin Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
This project has been funded with support from the European Commission. This publication reflects the views only of the author, and.
Advertisements

Developing the Teaching Portfolio Carol Tresolini, Ph. D
Rimas Norvaiša 30 June 2011
Research Integrity Graduate Research : Quincy Brown Doctoral Candidate Richard Podemski Dean, Graduate Studies Carla Thompson Faculty, Professional & Community.
Overall Layout of Curriculum Development System in Organization of Educational Research and Programming.
NATIONAL PROJECT ACTIVITIES, EVALUATION , Ankara EUROFACE CONSULTING, CZECH REPUBLIC.
Distance pre-service teachers’ perceptions of the effectiveness of their pedagogical courses in preparing them for their practicum By Asst. Prof. Belgin.
ESOL Science 2 at BHS Richard Meyer Suzy King. Rationale To prepare targeted students for further science courses – Provide background knowledge – Provide.
Schools’ Data Collection for National Partnerships Agreements (NPA) Educational Measurement and School Accountability Directorate (EMSAD)
 A practical development course for primary school teachers of English who want to develop their knowledge and skills in primary English teaching  The.
International Week 2012, March 19-23, TUT Library Information Literacy developments at Tallinn University of Technology Library Gerda Koidla Deputy Director,
Becky Smerdon Council of Great City Schools October 21, 2010
AWARE PROJECT – AGEING WORKFORCE TOWARDS AN ACTIVE RETIREMENT Alberto Ferreras-Remesal Institute of Biomechanics of Valencia IFA 2012 – Prague – May 31th.
Koolituskeskus Dialoog ESTONIA EuroIntegrELP The first project year Studying of various data on the ELP.
Clinical Teaching/Student Teaching
SYSTEMATIC APPROACH TO IBSE IMPLEMENTATION Testimony from Trnava, Slovakia.
Instructional System Design
UNIKE Survey on Doctoral Education By Corina Balaban and Sue Wright Ljubljana Summer School 7-11 July 2014.
Changing classroom procedures The effect of EU tenders on Hungarian education.
Supporting Children with Challenging Behaviors Refresher Training.
Institutional Evaluation of medical faculties Prof. A. Сheminat Arkhangelsk 2012.
DEBBIE FRENCH EDCI 5870 OCTOBER 30,  Title of research project:  “An Investigation of the NITARP/ SSTPTS Astronomy Research Experience for Teachers”
2014 China-EU High Level Forum “China and EU Dialogue: Rule of Law” Subtopic reforming the System of law enforcement: development of administrative oversight.
Food Safety Professional Development for Early Childhood Educators Evaluation Plan.
Ove Edvard Hatlevik and Ingrid Radtke An Application of Standard-Setting Methods in a Formative Assessment in Digital Responsibility.
The Bologna process and post- graduate education in Belarus (on the example of the Grodno State Medical University) Head of the Department of General Hygiene.
Professional Qualifications System in Estonia European Bank for the Development of Modular Curricula and Educational Technologies EMCET-2 Svetlana Kozlovskaja.
Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) What is RCR? New Requirements for RCR Who Does it Affect? When? Data Management What is the Institutional Plan? What.
Research Ethics and Research Conduct Karen Moorehead Human Research Ethics Officer Office for Research Photo: Australian HES 11/11/09 Office for Research.
Research Integrity: self-evident or not? James Parry Chief Executive, UK Research Integrity Office University of Warwick April 2014
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice in Germany Prof. Ulrike Beisiegel Chair of the DFG Ombudsman DFG Ombudsman Germany Director of the Institute of Molecular.
Why editors need to be concerned about publication ethics Elizabeth Wager, PhD Chair, Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
国 家 科 技 部 评 估 中 心国 家 科 技 部 评 估 中 心 National Center for S&T Evaluation Recent Experiences and Challenges of Research Program Evaluation in China: An Introduction.
Action Plan Guidelines
‘Sujala’ Karnataka Watershed Development Programme Developing the Training Strategy Introduction for the “Brainstorming Workshop 1st of October 2003.
Publication and Research Misconduct Stephanie Harriman Deputy Medical Editor.
Transnational meeting Göteborg 28. Sept Jutta Schneider Prof. Klaus Fischer Uni Köln A Joint Effort for More Scope of Action: Play Area Design -
Guidelines for LDS preparation for Croatian LAG’s Estonian Leader Union Kadri Tillemann and Kristiina Timmo 28 th of September, Zagreb.
LLP Multilateral Comenius Partnership FUTURE EUROPEAN TEACHERS:TRAINING KIT ACCORDING TO THE LISBON STRATEGY ESkillsKit.
Jean Monnet Activities in Erasmus+ Programme - Information on Jean Monnet Activities - Next Call for proposals Selection results Call 2015 (EAC/A04/2014)
Conducting Professional Development Programme LEADING TO LEARN, LEARNING TO LEAD.
Project Title: Supported Reading in English (SuRE) Project Code: NT0513 Section: NET Section, CDI 2 March 2013 Officers In-charge: Alice Wong Kathryn Davis.
Individual Education Plans.
Job Analysis. The process of collecting and organizing information about jobs performed in the organization and the principle elements involved in performing.
Statistical Fundamentals: Using Microsoft Excel for Univariate and Bivariate Analysis Alfred P. Rovai Data Ethics PowerPoint Prepared by Alfred P. Rovai.
Content and Curriculum ….. Information from Chapters 3 and 9 and from the North Carolina Standard Course of Study.
Curriculum Implementation Support Program (CISP).
Inquiry Primer Version 1.0 Part 4: Scientific Inquiry.
Public sector whistleblowing: Ombudsman Victoria’s experience 10 June 2010 Glenn Sullivan, Director Ombudsman Victoria.
Coaching and Peer-Assisted Learning Course for Obstetric and Gynaecology Membership Presented by Dr Alexandra Tillett Educational and Clinical Leadership.
Monitoring Visit to NatRisk Project
1st Steering Committee Meeting activities from WP3 –
INITIATIVES IN TEACHER EDUCATION
MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF BANDS
Quality of Education System
SUPERVISION IN DOCTORAL EDUCATION AT UNIVERSITY OF LJUBLJANA
MUHC Innovation Model.
Mojtaba Farjam, MD PhD, member of ethics committee for research
NCATE Standard 3: Field Experiences & Clinical Practice
The science subject knowledge
Induction workshop Fostering creativity in early years science teaching Discovering the use of creative and inquiry-based approaches in early years.
1st Steering Committee Meeting activities from WP3 –
Planning a Learning Unit
Session 1: Initial training
Curriculum design.
How can good publication standards influence research integrity Sabine Kleinert Vice-Chair of COPE Senior Executive Editor The Lancet First World Conference.
DFG Ombudsman Germany Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice Recommendation of the Germany Research Foundation Prof. Ulrike Beisiegel Chair of the DFG Ombudsman.
Ethics in scholar publishing: The journal editor's role
Good Scientific Practice
Evaluation – Our activities and experiences in the pilot phase
Presentation transcript:

Good Scientific Practice Helga Nolte, Hamburg, Gerlinde Sponholz, Berlin Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn

Preventive measures in all university guidelines Educating young researches Fostering awareness Role model of experienced researchers Responsible Mentoring Organizational measures to foster GSP Open and transparent systems of decision making Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn

N. Steneck (2009): Introduction to the responsible Conduct of Research. DIANE Publishing, Darby PA Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn

Fanelli D (2009) How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data. PLos ONE 4(5): e5738. doi: /journal.pone Studies included Fabrication, falsification or alteration of results admitted, 2 % ( 1 % - 4 %) directly observed, 14 % (9 % - 20 %) Questionable research practices admitted, 10 % (5 % - 34 %) directly observed, 29 % (6 % -72 %) Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn

Experience with Misconduct Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn Gommel et al (2015) Teaching Good Scientific Practice: Results from a Survey and Observations from Two Hundred Courses. JUNQ 5/2: 11-16

Curriculum for Teaching Good Scientific Practice Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn October 2009: first German version October 2011: English Version Curriculum “Good Scientific Practice” for Courses in Science and Medicine October 2012: revision and extension wissenschaft.de

GSP-Courses since 2009 For students, doctoral and junior scientists/ PhD-students Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn workshopshort workshop intro-lecture (01-08) 25 2

Contents of GSP Workshops Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn Process of Research Good Scientific Practice - data management Scientific Misconduct- publication process - authorship Local, national- mentoring international- cooperation rules, codes- conflict of interest - (research with human subjects and animals) Dealing with conflicts; ombudssystem; potential consequences

GSP Teachers‘ Training planned planned7 Different extent and intensity Different requests and target groups Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn

Teachers’ Training „Good Scientific Practice“ Goals The participants learn to develop and conduct workshops on good scientific practice. The participants will  acquire specific knowledge on good scientific practice  acquire specific knowledge on questionable practice and on scientific misconduct, and learn how to deal adequately with both  develop their teaching concepts  train their teaching skills  reflect their role as researchers, supervisors and mentors Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn

Teachers’ Training „Good Scientific Practice“ Content GSP: historical background; local, national and international guidelines, rules and recommendations Scientific misconduct: causes, definitions, types, frequency and paradigmatic cases Data management: generation, documentation, storage, ownership and safeguarding Authorship and the process of publishing Supervision and mentoring Conflicts of interest and scientific cooperation Dealing with conflicts and scientific misconduct: ombudspersons, whistleblowing, investigative commissions, procedures and consequences National and international resources on “good scientific practice” Teaching concepts: methodology, structure, case discussion, team teaching, evaluation Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn

Problems of implementation Additional teaching load Compensation for additional work (money, time..) Teaching task voluntary or obligatory Voluntary vs. mandatory participation of students “Lone fighter” or network Missing overview about the real demand / need Discomfort in view of too much insider knowledge ! Estonian Research Council – September 17th/18th, 2015 – Tartu and Tallinn