Actel RTAX-S FPGA Reliability Summary Kangsen Huey, HiRel Program Manager Ravi Pragasam, Senior Marketing Manager.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
IHP Im Technologiepark Frankfurt (Oder) Germany IHP Im Technologiepark Frankfurt (Oder) Germany ©
Advertisements

FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array)
©2006 The Aerospace Corporation Activities Associated With Working With Xilinx to Develop A Space Flow for Virtex Family of FPGA’s Larry Harzstark The.
C3 / MAPLD2004Lake1 Radiation Effects on the Aeroflex RadHard Eclipse FPGA Ronald Lake Aeroflex Colorado Springs.
HPEC 2012 Scrubbing Optimization via Availability Prediction (SOAP) for Reconfigurable Space Computing Quinn Martin Alan George.
Reliability. Introduction Introduction to Reliability Historical Perspective Current Devices Trends.
Chapter 4 Quality Assurance in Context
Relex Reliability Software “the intuitive solution
RTSX-S and RTSX-SU Reliability Test Vehicles Daniel K. Elftmann Director Product Engineering Richard Katz Head Grunt Office of Logic Design Igor Kleyner.
Maintaining Data Integrity in Programmable Logic in Atmospheric Environments through Error Detection Joel Seely Technical Marketing Manager Military &
Objectives of Pletronics Quality System Providing well defined quality metrics for each department within Pletronics, bringing problem areas into the open.
Partial discharge analysis of defective three-phase cables An overview of an ongoing project involving the generation and analysis of PD within distribution.
Robust Low Power VLSI ECE 7502 S2015 Burn-in/Stress Test for Reliability: Reducing burn-in time through high-voltage stress test and Weibull statistical.
BURN-IN, RELIABILITY TESTING, AND MANUFACTURING OF SEMICONDUCTORS
SE 450 Software Processes & Product Metrics Reliability: An Introduction.
Swami NatarajanJuly 14, 2015 RIT Software Engineering Reliability: Introduction.
EE 587 SoC Design & Test Partha Pande School of EECS Washington State University
Chip Carrier Package as an Alternative for Known Good Die
Submission 1003Baranski1 Reliability Studies on Aeroflex’s RadHard ViaLink TM PROM Brian Baranski, Anthony Jordan, and Craig Hafer Aeroflex Colorado Springs.
®. ® Rad Hard Products for Satellites and Space ® QPRO for Avionics  Standard QPRO products immune to upsets in avionics environment.
LHC Beam Screen Heaters: System overview, consolidation needs and project planning 4 February TE-CRG/JCC (Beam Screen Heater Review) 1.
2005 MAPLD, Paper 240 JJ Wang 1 Total Ionizing Dose Effect on Programmable Input Configurations J. J. Wang, R. Chan, G. Kuganesan, N. Charest, B. Cronquist.
Radiation Effects and Mitigation Strategies for modern FPGAs 10 th annual workshop for LHC and Future experiments Los Alamos National Laboratory, USA.
FLASH Mitigation Strategies for Space Applications Charles Howard Southwest Research Institute.
MAPLD 2005 / E134 Rockett A 0.15  M Radiation-Hardened Antifuse Field Programmable Gate Array Technology The RH AX250-S production installation effort.
1SAS 03/ GSFC/SATC- NSWC-DD System and Software Reliability Dolores R. Wallace SRS Technologies Software Assurance Technology Center
Platform ASICs Reliability Bob Madge Miguel Vilchis LSI Logic, Milpitas, CA Vish Bhide.
A comprehensive method for the evaluation of the sensitivity to SEUs of FPGA-based applications A comprehensive method for the evaluation of the sensitivity.
MAPLD 2009 Presentation Poster Session
Mission Assurance Concepts and Discussion NEPTUNE Power CoDR Richard Kemski June 10, 2002.
RTAX-S Qualification and Reliability Data September 7-9, MAPLD International Conference Minal Sawant Ravi Pragasam Solomon Wolday Ken O’Neill.
2004 MAPLD, Paper 190 JJ Wang 1 SEU-Hardened Storage Devices in a 0.15 µm Antifuse FPGA – RTAX-S J. J. Wang 1, B. Cronquist 1, J. McCollum 1, R. Gorgis.
FPGAs in the CMS HCAL electronics Tullio Grassi 21 March 2014.
Actel Power Supply Transient Evaluation on RTAX-S/SL and RTSX-SU Devices Solomon Wolday, Roopa Kaltippi, Antony Wilson September 2, 2009.
TRAD, Tests & Radiations 13/09/2011 LHC POWER CONVERTER Radiation analysis.
J. Christiansen, CERN - EP/MIC
FPGA-Based System Design: Chapter 3 Copyright  2004 Prentice Hall PTR Topics n FPGA fabric architecture concepts.
ATMEL ATF280E Rad Hard SRAM Based FPGA SEE test results Application oriented SEU Sensitiveness Bernard BANCELIN ATMEL Nantes SAS, Aerospace Business Unit.
J1879 Robustness Validation Hand Book A Joint SAE, ZVEI, JSAE, AEC Automotive Electronics Robustness Validation Plan The current qualification and verification.
An Unobtrusive Debugging Methodology for Actel AX and RTAX-S FPGAs Jonathan Alexander Applications Consulting Manager Actel Corporation MAPLD 2004.
Mil/Aero Logic for the 21 st Century The Future is Programmable High Reliability Products Committed to Leadership.
P/MAPLD 2004 King Permission to copy or reprint is not required, but appropriate credit must be given to The Aerospace Corporation for the generation of.
High Performance Embedded Computing (HPEC) Workshop 23−25 September 2008 John Holland & Eliot Glaser Northrop Grumman Corporation P.O. Box 1693 Baltimore,
CHAPTER 8 Developing Hard Macros The topics are: Overview Hard macro design issues Hard macro design process Physical design for hard macros Block integration.
Nov 28, 2013 Power Converters Availability for post-LS1 LHC TE-EPC-CCE.
1 Leakage Power Analysis of a 90nm FPGA Authors: Tim Tuan (Xilinx), Bocheng Lai (UCLA) Presenter: Sang-Kyo Han (ECE, University of Maryland) Published.
1 Carnegie Mellon University Center for Silicon System Implementation An Architectural Exploration of Via Patterned Gate Arrays Chetan Patel, Anthony Cozzie,
FPGA-Based System Design: Chapter 1 Copyright  2004 Prentice Hall PTR Moore’s Law n Gordon Moore: co-founder of Intel. n Predicted that number of transistors.
Trends in IC technology and design J. Christiansen CERN - EP/MIC
126 / MAPLD2004Lake1 Life Test Effects on the Aeroflex ViaLink™ FPGA Ronald Lake Aeroflex Colorado Springs.
12004 MAPLD/1002Katz Propagation Delay Stability in Logic Devices Richard B. Katz NASA Office of Logic Design 2004 MAPLD International Conference September.
PIONEERING WITH PASSION ©Tesat-Spacecom GmbH & Co.KG PIONEERING WITH PASSION PROPRIETARY INFORMATION ©Tesat-Spacecom GmbH & Co.KG reserves all rights.
Actel A54SX-A and RTSX-SU Reliability Testing Update Antony Wilson, Minal Sawant, and Dan Elftmann.
FPGA-Based System Design: Chapter 3 Copyright  2004 Prentice Hall PTR Topics n FPGA fabric architecture concepts.
Power Matters.™ Precision Commercial of the Shelf ( COTS) Oscillators for Space Applications Peter Cash, Mike Silveira and Matt Stanczyk April 13, 2016.
COTS PEMs Procurement & Acquisition Concerns and Issues Dr. Henning W. Leidecker GSFC/Code Nov 2002.
Actel Antifuse FPGA Information – Radiation Tests Actel Antifuse FPGA – A54SX72A 72K gates 208 pqfp package 2.5v to 5.0v I/O tolerant $62 each for tested.
1 MAPLD2005/1004 sakaide Evaluation of Actel FPGA Products by JAXA Yasuo SAKAIDE 1, Norio NEMOTO 2 Kimiharu Kariu 1, Masahiko Midorikawa 1, Yoshiya Iide.
LVDS Project: A RAD-HARD 500 Mbps LVDS Bus for Space June 12-16, 2016
An Unobtrusive Debugging Methodology for Actel AX and RTAX-S FPGAs
CFTP ( Configurable Fault Tolerant Processor )
Maintaining Data Integrity in Programmable Logic in Atmospheric Environments through Error Detection Joel Seely Technical Marketing Manager Military &
Propagation Delay Stability in Logic Devices
Manufacturing Screens for Assuring FPGA Operating Reliability
Reliability Analysis of the Aeroflex ViaLink™ FPGA
J1879 Robustness Validation Hand Book A Joint SAE, ZVEI, JSAE, AEC Automotive Electronics Robustness Validation Plan Robustness Diagram Trends and Challenges.
Design of a ‘Single Event Effect’ Mitigation Technique for Reconfigurable Architectures SAJID BALOCH Prof. Dr. T. Arslan1,2 Dr.Adrian Stoica3.
Life Test Effects on the Aeroflex ViaLink™ FPGA
DARE180U Platform Improvements in Release 5.6
ATMX150RHA Circuit Design Platform
Presentation transcript:

Actel RTAX-S FPGA Reliability Summary Kangsen Huey, HiRel Program Manager Ravi Pragasam, Senior Marketing Manager

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 2 Agenda : RTAX-S  Introduction  Qualification  MIL-PRF-38535, Class Q  Actel Antifuse Reliability Studies  EAQ ( Enhanced Antifuse Qualification)  HSB (High Single S, Single B) Design  New Processes and Procedures  ELA : Enhanced Lot Acceptance  XSEM : Die Cross Sections at Antifuse  Reliability Data and FIT Rate  Summary  Actel Flash Product Roadmap

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 3 RTAX-S Product Lineup  Introduced in 2004 and QML class Q level Qualified in 2005  Wafers fabricated on 0.15 µm process at United Microelectronics Corp (UMC), Taiwan Releasing in 2007

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 4 RTAX-S New Technology Features  First Antifuse FPGA that offers up to 4 Million system gates with enhanced features:  Embedded RAM blocks  Extensive I/O standard support  Hardened charge pump, clock trees, Power On Reset circuit  TMR Flip Flops  RTAX-S Antifuse Technology  Implemented with 0.15 μm CMOS process with new circuits designed to improve programming current and reduce net loading  Antifuse is similar in structure, but thinner than RTSX-SU generation due to the lower programming voltage  Results in less distance for material transport of the plate material during programming, resulting in better I PEAK tolerance for net loading  Single S-Antifuses get 67% less I PEAK stress during switching compared to RTSX-SU  Designer software has SAL (S- Antifuse Loading) to dramatically reduce Single S-Antifuse count  Single B-Antifuses have 50% less I PEAK vs. RTSX-SU  Architecture includes adding buffers to reduce net loading on long nets  Programming Current  B, I, S, K antifuses have 10% to 20% more programming current

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 5 RTAX-S QML Qualification with Enhanced Testing for Antifuse RTAX-S QUALIFICATION MIL-PRF-38535, Class Q Qualification Actel Antifuse Reliability Studies (Enhanced Antifuse Qualification + HSB) &

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 6 RTAX-S Qualification (1/3)  MIL-PRF-38535, Class Q Level Compliant Qualification  Qualification Burn In (QBI) Design was developed for qualification life test  Tests the overall CMOS and Antifuse technology  Maximizes resources utilization like the Flip Flops, IOs, SRAM, FIFO, Carry chains, etc.  Functional test vector developed to for 3-temp FT  Uses fully class Q level screened devices  Group C test  87 RTAX2000S and 98 RTAX1000S devices passed 1,000 hours of group C at 125 o C  Pass/Fail criteria tightened to LTPD(3) equivalent of 129(1) of the largest RTAX2000S devices  Assuming every 2 RTAX1000S equals to one RTAX2000S  Added LTOL (Low Temp Operating Life) test  78 RTAX1000S devices passed 1,000 hours of LTOL at -55 o C  Group A, B, D, ESD, Latch-Up, IO Capacitance also performed  6 parts (2 RTAX2000S and 4 RTAX1000S) in Group C and 1 part in LTOL failed due to equipment failures  FA reports available upon request

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 7 RTAX-S Qualification (2/3)  EAQ (Enhanced Antifuse Qualification)  Objective is to uncover antifuse failure modes and determine antifuse failure rate  Uses highly perceptive and stressful designs for antifuse evaluation  Similar to the antifuse studies employed for RTSX-SU  The EAQ design is capable to detect small (pico to nano seconds) shifts in net propagation delay, which can be detected through analyzing the delta delays  High and Low Temperature Operating Life tests (HTOL/LTOL) performed with RTAX1000S-CG624 devices  291 units passed 1,000 hours of HTOL at +125 o C and 250 hours of LTOL at -55 o C  One unit had CMOS process related failure (non-antifuse related) after 500 hours of HTOL  6 units failed due to equipment (BIB data contention)  Devices did not go through the Burn-In screening required for QML class Q level devices  120 units carried on and all passed 6,000 hours of HTOL with No failures

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 8 RTAX-S Qualification (3/3)  High single S-Antifuse and high single B- Antifuse (HSB) utilization design  Testing was conducted after the completion of QML qualification activity  HSB design maximized the utilization of both single S-Antifuse and single B-Antifuse  High and Low Temperature Operating Life tests (HTOL/LTOL) performed with RTAX1000S-CG624 devices  298 units passed 1,000 hours of HTOL at +125 o C and 250 hours of LTOL at -55 o C  Two units had CMOS failure due to electrical over-stress (non-antifuse related) at 250 hours pull point of HTOL  Devices did not go through the Burn-In screening required for QML class Q level devices

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 9 RTAX-S Qualification Designs  Design utilization for QBI, EAQ and HSB Reliability Testing  Qualification designs represent the worst case end-use condition  User designs have generally less utilization than the above qualification designs

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 10 Antifuse Usage Statistics  The EAQ and HSB designs were created to study specific Antifuse types like:  The Critical K-Antifuse  Single S-Antifuse  Single B-Antifuse  Number of critical antifuses utilized in the various RTAX1000S Reliability Test Vehicles  NO antifuse faults have been observed in RTAX1000S-CG624 reliability studies with these designs

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 11 RTAX-S Production Process Enhancement RTAXS Wafer specific XSEM Standard Quality Control Monitor Extended Lot Acceptance (ELA)Standard B, E Flow processing Actel Specific E-test Thermal Runaway Characterization XY Programming New Process StepsOld Process Steps

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 12 RTAX-S Processes and Procedures (1/2)  Standard Quality Control Monitor (QCM)  Programming & functional test using LTPD 30 (8 samples, 0 failures)  Design is identical to QBI (targeted for general CMOS/Antifuses)  Test is done per assembly build for the RTAX250S  Extended Lot Acceptance (ELA)  Test is done per wafer lot  168 hours of burn in at 125 ºC with stringent EAQ design  Sample size:  RTAX250S – 100 units  RTAX1000S – 24 units  RTAX2000S – 14 units  Wafer lot acceptance criteria allows Zero antifuse related failures  If any failures or outliers are detected, failure analysis is performed to determine root cause  XY Programming  Wafer number and die location on wafer is now programmed into each unit during wafer sort  Silicon Sculptor Programming SW revision also programmed into device at final design programming

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 13 RTAX-S Processes and Procedures (2/2)  Wafer-specific cross section inspection (XSEM)  Two samples per wafer are cross-sectioned at antifuses  XSEMs are inspected for anomalous antifuse construction  Wafers are scrapped if found to be beyond the specification  Susceptible wafers are required to be used as ELA samples  All the wafers that pass are built for shipments  Thermal Runaway Characterization  This test is required per wafer lot (starting with 2007 fab out lots)  2 sample units are programmed with ELA design and characterized at oven temperature of 125 o C, 130 o C, and 135 o C  Lots that exhibit thermal run-away phenomena are scrapped  Actel E-test  In addition to wafer foundry provided E-test data, Actel runs additional E-test after wafers arrive  Provides more in depth information on antifuse related parameters

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 14 RTAX-S Reliability FIT Rate  NO Antifuse faults have been observed to date in any of the reliability testing (QBI, EAQ, ELA, HSB) thus far  1.7 Million device hours have been accumulated to date  Refer for details (updated as needed)  Failure rate estimation: Device FIT = Tj = 55 ºC  Using the chi-square distribution and a minimum upper confidence limit of 60% per JESD74  CMOS Activation Energy: Ea = 0.7 eV  Includes 1 CMOS process related failure  The remaining failures were identified as EOS or equipment related  FA reports available upon request

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 15 RTAX-S On-Going Quality and Reliability Improvement  Process Change Notification through GIDEP Problem Advisory  SC7-P (PCN0608), Elimination of RTAX-S ICCA Current Increase Due to Heavy Ion-Induced Upset  SC7-P (PCN0606), EDAC Macro modification to correct simultaneous reads and writes occur to a single address.  SC7-P (PCN0625), to correct routed clock timing under- estimation  All issues were associated with software bugs and discovered through internal and customer failure analysis  Silicon has remained the same since qualification  On-Going Process Improvement After Qualification  X-Y Programming, Thermal Run-Away Analysis  High Frequency SET, High Temperature SEL, Prompt Dose  Completed ESD Testing

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 16 RTAX-S Reliability Summary  Actel has enhanced its Qualification Procedure to include both MIL-PRF QML-Q and Enhanced Antifuse Qualification (EAQ)  New processes have been implemented to ensure high quality and highly reliable RTAX-S product is shipped  NO antifuse failures detected with almost 1.7M device-hours of testing which showcases robustness of this technology  Parts have been baselined in many programs  Has started to develop QML class V level qualification/certification with the RTAX4000S qualification process

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 17 Planning to Fly RTAX-S MUOSAdvanced EHFNPOESSGalileo Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter James Webb Space Telescope Mars Science Lab Bepi Colombo GOES-R GAIA

© 2007 Actel Confidential and ProprietaryHuey/Pragasam January 2007New Technology Insertion Workshop 18 New Technology Plans: Space-Flight Flash FPGAs  Actel continues to develop new technology for Space applications such as Flash based FPGAs  Unique Flash advantages  Non-Volatile and Live at Power-Up  Reprogrammable  RTA3PE (130nm)  Based on the commercial Flash product line  Radiation projections – suitable for LEO / short duration payloads  Immune to SEL  TID to ~ 15 to 20 Krad, parametric and functional  To implement Soft TMR for protection against data SEUs  Flight units expected 2008 to 2009  Mil-Std-883 qualified  RT-G4 (90nm)  Project founded by DTRA  In architecture concept phase  Expect flight units 2010 to 2012  Target TID to 300 Krad  5M to 10M system gates

Thank You