JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 XBT Data Acquisition System Intercomparison JCOMM/SOT-4 Scientific and Technical Session Derrick Snowden Gustavo Goni Molly Baringer.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Revisiting the XBT Fall Rate Equation (Sippican Deep Blue):Implications and Recommendations JCOMM/SOT-4 Derrick Snowden Gustavo.

Advertisements

Acknowledgements:Steve Cook and Robert Molinari TSG-SEAS: Paul Chinn and Janet Roseli Operations: Derrick Snowden, James Farrington, and Carrie Wolff Data.

Argo Technologies Argo TC Inputs by S. Riser (UW) DBCP #22, Technical Workshop La Jolla, California.

SIO 210: I. Observational methods and II. Data analysis (combined single lecture) Fall 2013 Remote sensing In situ T, S and tracers Velocity Observing.

First Analysis of the Nares Strait CT-String Data Berit Rabe & Helen Johnson.

Instrumentation types, data and metadata (accuracy, biases and known issues) CTD problems/metadata J. Swift, UCSD Scripps Institution of Oceanography "The.

Zunino P. (1), Tsimplis M. (2), Vargas-Yáñez M. (1), Moya F. (1), García-Martínez M. (1) (1) Instituto Español de Oceanografía. Centro Oceanográfico de.

AOSC 634 Air Sampling and Analysis Lecture 1 Measurement Theory Performance Characteristics of instruments Nomenclature and static response Copyright Brock.

Lecture161 Instrumentation Prof. Phillips March 14, 2003.

28 Feb 2000ISAT 3001 Resistance Temperature Detectors (RTDs)

CSIRO Marine Research Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, Australia.

GDC Data Processing Tui Malila Expedition, Leg 6 (TUIM06MV)  Dates: May 13, June 5, 2005 Chief Scientist: Robert Vrijenhoek Tui Malila Expedition,

Work Package 3 PROCEDURAL HARMONISATION Task 3.1: Assessment of procedures FixO3 General Assembly 14 th to the 16 th October 2014, Heraklion-CRETE Pericles.

Results of the WMO Laboratory Intercomparison of rainfall intensity gauges Luca G. Lanza University of Genoa WMO (Project Leader) DIAM UNIGE September.

Characterization of Model Rockets in Flight Section 4, Team 1 Student 1, Student 2, Student 3 and Student 4.

The Partnership between the Maritime Industry, Marine Forecasting and Science.

SeaHARRE-3 : the third SeaWiFS HPLC Analysis Round Robin Exercise History 2 previous SeaHARRE exercises, coordinated by S. Hooker (NASA) and LOV:  1999:

Define Problem Select Appropriate Methods Obtain and store sample Pre-treat sample Perform required measurements Compare results with standards Apply necessary.

Climate quality data and datasets from VOS and VOSClim Elizabeth Kent and David Berry National Oceanography Centre, Southampton.

XBT Fall Rate Problem A Historical Perspective Bill Emery, Univ. of Colorado Bob Heinmiller (deceased 2005)

ESRI Ocean Data Model Working Group, Oct. 4-5, 2001 Dawn Wright Oregon State U. Additional Ideas for the ArcGIS Ocean Data Model.

1 Leonardo Pinheiro da Silva Corot-Brazil Workshop – October 31, 2004 Corot Instrument Characterization based on in-flight collected data Leonardo Pinheiro.

NOAA/CPO Climate Observation Division 6th Annual System Review, September 3-5, 2008 AOML South Atlantic MOC related Observations and Plans Silvia L. Garzoli.

A Comparison of Six Expendable Bathythermograph Data Acquisition Systems Derrick Snowden Molly Baringer Gustavo Goni.

Propagation of Error Ch En 475 Unit Operations. Quantifying variables (i.e. answering a question with a number) 1. Directly measure the variable. - referred.

Statistics Presentation Ch En 475 Unit Operations.

Monitoring Heat Transport Changes using Expendable Bathythermographs Molly Baringer and Silvia Garzoli NOAA, AOML What are time/space scales of climate.

Purpose Probe construction Field and laboratory measurements Data processing, applicational example Conclusions, outlook A NEW METHOD TO DETERMINE in.

EGA Technical World Leaders in Combustion Management Solutions Mk7 EGA.

CTD - Salinity and Temperature at Depth Jonathan Walter University of North Carolina at Wilmington CHM Jonathan Walter University of North Carolina.

World Leaders in Combustion Management Solutions Module Gas Setup Introduction The Mk7 E.G.A Cell Status Further Information.

1 Global Ocean Heat Content in light of recently revealed instrumentation problems Syd Levitus, John Antonov, Tim Boyer Ocean Climate Laboratory.

CHAPTER 5: Data sampling design, data quality, calibration, presentation Sampling Physical variables are continuous, but samples (water samples) and digital.

A novel methodology for identification of inhomogeneities in climate time series Andrés Farall 1, Jean-Phillipe Boulanger 1, Liliana Orellana 2 1 CLARIS.

Evaluation of the Real-Time Ocean Forecast System in Florida Atlantic Coastal Waters June 3 to 8, 2007 Matthew D. Grossi Department of Marine & Environmental.

Thermal Lag problems in Slocum CTDs – a MATLab correction algorithm (OR: why does our salinity data have so many outliers?) Charlie Bishop PhD Candidate.

? INFORMATION CONTENT IN LOW DENSITY XBT TRANSECTS RELATIVE TO OCEANIC GYRES ROBERT L. MOLINARI FORMERLY: NOAA/AOML PRESENTLY: UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI- CIMAS.

Statistics Presentation Ch En 475 Unit Operations.

ENG4000 Monitoring Capacitance Changes over Various Materials and Fluids Aysar Khalid, Hassan Chehaitli, Mohammad Aryanpour Group 5 Course Director & Advisor:

XBT FALL RATE EQUATION WORKSHOP National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory, Miami, FL March 10-12,

XBT Fall Rate Equation – A Review Pankajakshan and Gopalkrishna, National Institute of Oceanography, Goa, India.

AOML: Acknowledgements: Steve Cook Science support: Molly Baringer and Silvia Garzoli Data support: Gary Soneira, Derrick Snowden and Joaquin Trinanes.

LM Sippican T5 and T10 XBT accuracy measurements preliminary results F.Reseghetti 1, L.Cheng 2, M.Borghini 3, J.Zhu 2 Outlines T5-T10 characteristics Data.

A review on systematic differences between Sippican's XBT and TSK's XBT Shoichi Kizu (Tohoku University, Japan) The 4 th XBT workshop November 2014,

The IQuOD initiative International Quality-Controlled Ocean Database Current international partners: Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Canada, China, France,

XBT fall rate corrections Summary of pre-meeting discussions Step 1: Making recommendations for future XBT data collection Step 2: Correction of the historical.

Satlantic HyperPro II Freefalling hyperspectral radiometer Can be deployed in “floater” mode 16 bit ADC at 12 Hz (maximum) 0 - ~100 m depth rating, descent.

Time, probe type and temperature variable bias corrections to historical eXpendable BathyThermograph observations 1. International Center for Climate and.

SeaDataNet Technical Task Group meeting JRA1 Standards Development Task 1.2 Common Data Management Protocol (for dissemination to all NODCs and JRA3) Data.

TT(n) = -bT(n-1) + a[T(n) – T(n-1)]

The global XBT network Gustavo Jorge Goni(1), Shenfu Dong(1,2), and Francis Bringas(1) With contributions and work of many in the XBT community (1) NOAA/AOML,

SUR-2250 Error Theory.

AOML and the Global XBT Network

Paper under review for JGR-Atmospheres …

THE TSURUMI SEIKI CO., LTD.

XBT Data Acquisition System Intercomparison

Presentation for 2017 Argo Steering Team

Y. Xue1, C. Wen1, X. Yang2 , D. Behringer1, A. Kumar1,

AVHRR and Ship IR sensor versus in situ SAIL, BOOM and CTD instruments

Present Status of APEX Float Technology

Operational Oceanography Cruise February 2003

Characterization of Sound Speed Profiles

XBT/CTD Comparisons LCDR. Chin-lung Fang OC 3570

Comparison of XBT vs CTD Data

Comparison of CTD vs XBT data

CTD/XBT Comparison, Quality of JJYY Data and XBT Data Analysis of the Mixed Layer Depth by LT Mike Roth OC MAR01.

Comparison of CTD/XBT Temperature Profiles and XBT/GDEM Sound Speed Profiles LT Annie Laird 08 March 2006.

Density Ratios and Heat Flux within the Beaufort Sea Utilizing WHOI Ice-Tethered Profiler Data By LCDR Greg Caro.

Galaxy Cluster Mass from Spectroscopic Magnification Measurements

Study Identification and Selection Process

Presentation transcript:

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 XBT Data Acquisition System Intercomparison JCOMM/SOT-4 Scientific and Technical Session Derrick Snowden Gustavo Goni Molly Baringer

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Cruise Purpose/Participants Assess the impact of changing two elements of the standard xbt data collection system by comparing the results from six distinct systems with each other and with a higher accuracy Conductivity Temperature Depth (CTD) system. NOAA/AOML, SIO, CSIRO

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 XBT Data Collection System 1.AOML/DOS 2.Scripps/DOS 3.SEAS CSIRO Devil 1.AOML Autolauncher 2.Scripps Autolauncher 3.Sippican LM3A Hand launcher 1.MK12 2.MK21 3.CSIRO Devil Controller SoftwareDigitizer/Recorder Launchers

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 CTD System SBE 25 Internally logging CTD Sample rate 8 Hz raw data, reduced data 1m Pressure offset on deck is negligible (-.08 to.06 dbars)

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Instruments List System NameLauncher TypeRecorder TypeController Software (PC) aomlautoAOML Autolauncher MK-12AOML (DOS 386 PC) devilhandSippican LM-3ADevilDevil Software (Win XP PC) seasautoAOML Autolauncher MK-21SEAS2000 (WinXP PC) seashandSippican LM-3AMK-21SEAS2000 (Win XP PC) sioautoSIO Autolauncher MK-21SEAS2000 (Win XP PC) siok98SIO Autolauncher MK-12 K98 Software (DOS 386 PC)

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Station Drop Plan 7 CTD Stations 366 XBT profiles

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Drop Summary InstrumentTotal ProfilesTrimmed at z< 500m Trimmed at z<150m aomlauto6522 devilhand5233 seasauto6852 seashand5410 sioauto59101 siok Totals

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Regional Characteristics Depth (m) Mean CTD T(z) 5 20 Approx Station Catalina Island SCMI/Port of LA

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 MSE Bias Variance

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Partitioning XBT Error XBT differs from the CTD due to : A: inaccurate depth measurements B: inaccurate temperature measurements A B Probe fall rate error Thermistor calibration error Signal digitization error Geophysical noise

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Magnitude of Expected Errors Temperature accuracy 0.1 deg C (red curve) Depth (m) Depth accuracy is 2% of the total depth

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 XBT/CTD Profiles

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Temperature Error: Isostads Attempt to isolate the temperature error by concentrating on depths where the temperature gradients are minimal After Heimiller et al 1983

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Isostad Analysis (cont’) 1.aomlauto 2.devilhand 3.seasauto 4.seashand 5.sioauto 6.siok98

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Corrected Profiles: Isostads 1.aomlauto 2.devilhand 3.seasauto 4.seashand 5.sioauto 6.siok98

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Conclusions Temperature error is within manufacturer specs for all instruments (In the deepest thermostad the mean offset was less than degC for all instruments). There is a detectable bias that is in part due to fall rate error. Correcting the fall rate equation reduces the mean differences well below manufacturer specs and published results in all cases. Two instruments (aomlauto, and devilhand) had mean offsets that were appreciably lower than the other four instruments.

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 Participants NameAffiliationEquipment/Responsibility Steve CookNOAA/AOMLSEAS2K Hand Launcher Derrick SnowdenNOAA/AOMLData collection and analysis/Backup CTD Janet RoseliNOAA/AOMLSEAS2K Software support and Autolauncher operation Uli RiveroNOAA/AOMLAOML/DOS Autolancher Carrie WolfeSCMIAOML/SEAS2K Autolauncher Glenn PezzoliUCSD/ScrippsSIO/SEAS2K Autolauncher Valerie CannonUCSD/ScrippsSIO/SEAS2K Autolauncher/Backup AOML/SEAS2K Autolauncher Bob BeattieCSIROCSIRO Devil Handlauncher Adam WillinghamSCMISBE-25 CTD

JCOMM SOT-4 April 2007 MSE Bias Variance