Consultant Selection Missouri Local Programs How to Evaluate Consultant Proposals, Complete the Rating Sheets & Make a Selection.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Solicitations/Advertisements Solicitations/Advertisements
Advertisements

Office of Purchasing and Contracts Research Funded Procurement Outreach Training Level III Procurements $50,000 and Above.
How Much Do You Know? Consultants -- Test Your Knowledge! Civil Rights Requirements on Federal-Aid Transportation Agreements How Much Do You Know?
Change Order Missouri Local Programs How to Complete a Change Order & Get it Approved.
1 Texas Department of Agriculture The Food Service Management Company Contracting Process Food and Nutrition Division Texas Department of Agriculture.
RFP AND CONTRACT PHASE Jeff Wassenaar, P.E., HQ Project Development Benjamin Acimovic, P.E., Region 1.
Agenda Introduction Advisory Circular Changes Consultant Selection Procedures Contract Format and Provisions Methods of Contracting and Allowable Costs.
Grant Reviews A Tutorial on How to Participate on a DD Council Grant Review Panel Play.
Subchapter M-Indian Self- Determination and Education Assistance Act Program Part 273-Education Contracts under Johnson-OMalley Act.
Request for Proposal - Best Value Generally RFP’s are created for large dollar technical purchases, services and consultants.  Consideration in addition.
U.S. Pretrial Services and Probation Office Northern District of Ohio.
Procurement: What Everyone Needs to Know. What is Procurement? “The act of obtaining something”
Advanced DBE Tutorial June 10, DBE Program FAQ Why does BRMA have a DBE program? Federal law requires that airports that receive federal funding,
Hiring & Evaluating the Library Director Presenters: Dora U. Sims, Trustee, Birmingham Public Library Trustee at Large, United For Libraries Board Assisted.
Documenting Cash and In-Kind Match Project Director Training & Annual Meeting.
How-To-Tutorial for MoDOT’s Consultant Prequalification Process
Footer Text PROFESSIONAL SERVICES CONTRACTING. Footer Text PROFESSIONAL SERVICES CONTRACTING.
1 Last update: February 12, 2009 Is Your Selection Process Attracting the Right Consultants? Best Practices, Benefits and Insights to Using a Qualifications.
Department of Public Works Robinson Park Recreation Center Renovation – Revised Selection Process for Design Services November 4, 2013.
Marcy Mealy Procurement Specialist CDBG Program
PROCUREMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT “How We Do Business”
Staffing Special Education Positions for Benton Stearns Education District Supervision of Special Education EDAD 609 Margy Bailey.
Special Education Accountability Reviews Let’s put the pieces together March 25, 2015.
On Site Review Process Office of Field Services.
Effort Reporting: A Departmental Approach to Meeting Audit Requirements Dianne Valdez, MBA, CIA, CISA, CCSA Enrique Valdez Jr., MBA.
Using QBS A Qualifications-Based Selection Process Presenters: Ron Brenke, PE - QBS Manager.
Design Build, Job Contracting, or Construction Manager at Risk In early 2000 the legislators added an alternate way to accelerate construction project.
Professional Services Contracting System PSCS Version 4.0 Prequalification Application Presented by Karen Macdonald Prequalification Engineer, INDOT April.
Purchasing Overview. Fundamentals of Purchasing Procedures.
PROCUREMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT “How We Do Business”
Closing Out a Federal Aid Construction Project Missouri Local Programs How to Close-Out a Federal Aid Construction Project.
Catherine C. Dunn, P.E., N.PE, P.PE Deputy Director Port Development Prt of New Orleans Catherine C. Dunn, P.E., D.NE, D.PE Director,
Business Intelligence Reginald K. Diamond, Executive Director Office of Diversity and Equal Opportunity Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority.
State Advisory Group Pre Bid Conference Formula Grant Application.
Transportation Enhancements Application Workshop Welcome!! October 3 & 4, 2012.
ADEPT 1 SAFE-T Judgments. SAFE-T 2 What are the stages of SAFE-T? Stage I: Preparation  Stage I: Preparation  Stage II: Collection.
United Nations Procurement Division
1 Procurement. 2 Overview Every municipality should keep procurement records that allow an auditor or other interested party to track the specific nature.
Two Heads are Better Than One Patrick Callahan, Snyder & Associates Handouts and presentation are available online at
Customer-Supplier Division Supplier Selection & Qualification A Podcast presentation for members of the Customer-Supplier Division and ASQ Presented by.
Catherine C. Dunn, P.E., N.PE, P.PE Deputy Director Port Development Prt of New Orleans Catherine C. Dunn, P.E., D.NE, D.PE Director,
State of Connecticut Consultant Selection Office 2015 Consultant Prequalification Process Presented by the Connecticut Department of Transportation (CT.
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH CARE SERVICES Audits & Investigations – Financial Audits Branch.
Title III Desk Monitoring Oregon Department of Education September 24,
Request For Qualifications (RFQ) Missouri Local Programs How to Complete the RFQ & Get it Advertised.
Carrie Murphy, Contracts Specialist Advanced DTSD/Bureau of Project Development Consultant Services Section September 30, 2015.
Request for Proposals Notification When to use?. When to use….. Federal funds to be used as reimbursement for PE, R/W, CE. 100% local funds for PE and/or.
College of Engineering CIVE 4750 Using QBS A Qualifications-Based Selection Process Adapted from a presentation by QBS, Inc. 215 N. Walnut St. Lansing,
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION TARGETED GROUP/VETERAN OWNED BUSINESS DISADVANTAGE BUSINESS ENTERPRISE CONSULTANT CONTRACT REQUESTS Joyce Brown-Griffin.
Professional Services Collaborative Forum January 14, 2016.
Contracting Process Overview Agenda Item #12 July 2007.
4-1 Use of Feasibility Studies and Consultants National Food Service Management Institute The University of Mississippi.
March 23, SPECIAL EDUCATION ACCOUNTABILITY REVIEWS.
March Nunavut Wildlife Research Trust & Nunavut Wildlife Studies Fund  There are a number of documents that relate to the NWRT and NWSF:  1.)
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Each Submitter’s Responsibility for Outreach Efforts.
Compliance with CCNA F.S..  Advertisement  Longlist  Shortlist  Request for Proposal  Scope of Services Meeting  Technical Proposal Review.
The Port of New Orleans - As-Needed Consultant Selection Process for Professional Services June 9, 2016.
Award Management Services
Sound Financial Management
QBS: The Process Selecting a Design Firm
Call for competition process
Request for Proposal - Best Value
Consultant Selection Training
“How We Do Business”.
THE OFFICE OF PROCUREMENT CONTRACT TRAINING MAY 2018
Stepping Forward Together Financially
Request for Proposal - Best Value
Procurement.
2018 AASHTO Civil Rights Conference
OCPS CCNA SELECTION COMMITTEE TRAINING
Presentation transcript:

Consultant Selection Missouri Local Programs How to Evaluate Consultant Proposals, Complete the Rating Sheets & Make a Selection

Consultant Rating  Collect all letters of interest and statements of qualification after RFQ expires.  If less than 3 letters are received then consider re-advertising.  Consider inviting MoDOT District Representative to rating and scoring meeting.  Identify LPA staff who will rate/score the consultants. –Use two or more people to rate/score the consultants.  Discuss the advertised scoring criteria and how it will be applied to the ratings. Although individual scores will vary, it’s important to be consist in the thought process. –Each LPA staff member should rate independently, then collaboratively decide an overall score or simply average the individual scores. –Only criteria that was in the advertisement can be used in the scoring process and the weighted values associated with them.

Consultant Rating Cont.  List and rate ALL firms that submitted letters of interest. –There is an example rating sheet located at: Fig Consultant Selection Criteria. –This form can be customized to account for additional approved rating criteria if necessary. –Consider contacting surrounding LPA’s and/or the consultants references to get feedback for consideration. –Provide brief written explanation of how the scores for the top firms were determined.  Short Listing –If you receive more than 10 interest letters and statements of qualifications you may short list to your top 3 – 5 firms –All firms must still be reviewed & considered, and you must document why firms were shortlisted (or not shortlisted) in your documentation. –Shortlisted firms must be rated.

Common Non-Compliance Findings for Consultant Ratings  These practices can result in loss of funds –Scoring 100% or 0% in every category. –Several firms score exactly the same. –Inconsistency in rating numbers ex: extreme variances between ratings. –Same consultant being hired for the majority of projects with the LPA. –Primary reason for selecting a consultant was based on their location. –No supporting documentation (written text indicating how the scores were obtained)

Consultant Selection  Determine the most qualified consultants.  Consider interviewing at least 3 of the top rated firms (optional) –Use scripted questions for each firm. –Document discussion for each firm interviewed.  Discuss & Select the most qualified firm. –Review discussion documentation for each firm. –LPA will need to provide MoDOT a description of why the top firm was selected.

Consultant Selection Cover Letter Completion  Use EPG Fig to ensure the following: –The project was solicited for 14 days or more on the MoDOT internet webpage –A Statement of Qualifications are on file or was received for all consultants submitting a Letter of Interest as required by the Brooks Act –An Affidavit of Compliance in the Federal Work Authorization Program and a copy of the E-Verify Memorandum of Understanding is included in the project file, as required by Code of State Regulations 15 CSR copies are enclosed for your use

Consultant Selection Cover Letter Completion Cont. - All consultants submitting a Letter of Interest were considered based on the criteria listed in the Brooks Act. The consultant rating sheet is included in the project file. - Management Representation and Certification form(s) received from the prime and sub-consultants if the firms are not listed on the Approved Annual Financial Pre- Qualification List - DBE requirements have been met and are shown in the contract.  Submit cover letter and all supporting documentation to MoDOT

The End! Thank You!!