What PBF can achieve; Example from Rwanda Claude SEKABARAGA, MD, MPH World Bank, Nairobi Hub. January 2010.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
UNDP RBA Workshop on MDG-Based National Development Strategies Module 4: Health Strategies UN Millennium Project February 27-March 3, 2006.
Advertisements

21 July 2005 UNDG Policy Network On the MDGs UNDG Policy Network on the MDGs.
Impact of Large-Scale Infant Feeding Promotion on Child Survival and Health in Madagascar.
Governance and local development A Framework for Rural Poverty Reduction.
Scaling up Family Planning through Performance-Based Financing in Rwanda Dr. Louis Rusa, Director PBF support Cell Ministry of Health, Rwanda.
Changing Policy- Rwanda's change in guidelines African Regional meeting on interventions for Impact in essential obstetrics and new born care Addis Ababa.
How did Rwanda Operationalize Performance-based Financing ? Results Based Financing Workshop October 20-24, 2008 Gisenyi, Rwanda.
Local Government Development Program and Poverty Reduction in Uganda: Lessons from Aid Policies Shuaib Lwasa Department of Geography Makerere University.
Group Work 2 Lessons Learned in Social Protection in Health Group No. 9 Facilitator: Elly Van Kanten.
1 Averting Maternal Mortality Situation, Strategies and Future Dr. Dileep Mavalankar MD, Dr. P.H. Public Systems Group Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad.
NATIONAL LEVEL MINISTRY OF HEALTH Community Health Desk NATIONAL LEVEL MINISTRY OF HEALTH Community Health Desk DISTRICT HOSPITAL District Hygiene and.
Presented by Melene Kabadege MCH Regional Technical Advisor, World Relief December 9, 2010.
Dr. Richard B. Munyaneza, MD, Rwanda Ministry of Health.
Paying Health Care Providers for Performance: Evidence from Rwanda Paul Gertler UC Berkeley January 2009.
Process of Development of Five Year Strategic Plan for Child Health Development Dr Myint Myint Than Deputy Director (WCHD) Department of Health.
Elizabeth Mason Department of Child and Adolescent Health and Development New Strategic Directions Tracking progress in child survival Countdown to 2015.
Prioritizing Performance Problems and Choosing Recipients Benjamin Loevinsohn Lead Public Health Specialist The World Bank June 2008.
Community PBF in Rwanda CHD STRUCTURE MOH MCH DESK NUTRITION DESK COMMUNITY HEALTH DESK FP DESK EHDMNH MCH UNIT.
Performance-Based Financing in Rwanda
RWANDA PERFORMANCE BASED SYSTEM: PUBLIC REFORMS Claude SEKABARAGA, MD, MPH Director policy, planning and capacity building Ministry of Health October 2008.
1 Influence of PBF Indicators on Health Coverage Kathy Kantengwa M.D, MPA; PBF advisor, MSH Montreux, November 2010 Rwanda IHSS Project.
February 2010 Petra Vergeer, Health Specialist RBF Team, World Bank At a glance… Verification of performance linked to financial incentives by Joe Naimoli.
Working in partnership Countdown for Child Survival in Ethiopia London December 2005 Federal Ministry of Health of the Democratic Republic of Ethiopia.
Republic of Rwanda Kivu 2010 Leadership Retreat Reporting on progress since the Leadership Retreat, and looking ahead to the next quarter Domestic Funding;
Debriefing for the Study Tour of the Malian and Senegalese Delegations to Rwanda October 25-30, 2009.
Measuring the cost-effectiveness of providing Family Planning and MNCH services as part of the basic package of health services in Cambodia David Collins.
Health Planning and Implementation in post-conflict Afghanistan by Laurence Laumonier-Ickx, MD November 8, 2006.
Global Learning Process for Scaling Up Poverty Reduction: Shanghai Conference May 25-27, 2004.
RBF through the Public Health Sector in Low-Income Countries Essential Design Elements for a Health Center RBF model György Fritsche HDNHE RBF Seminar.
Health System and Health System Strengthening in Nepal Dr BR Marasini, MBBS, MPH Senior Health Administrator Ministry of Health and Population.
What is RBF? A paradigm shift for health systems in low-income countries Cape Town – 30 th September 2014 Bruno Meessen, Institute of Tropicale Medicine,
3 August 2004 Public Health Practice III: FINANCING PUBLIC HEALTH REFORM Thomas E. Novotny MD MPH University of California San Francisco Institute for.
Performances Based Financing scheme in Rwanda INVESTING MORE STRATEGICALLY 1.
Political Commitment for Family Planning in Rwanda
Primer on Monitoring and Evaluation. The 3 Pillars of Monitoring and Evaluation  Identifying the Performance Indicators  Collecting information using.
Helping Nigeria make Rapid Progress Through Performance-Based Financing World Bank June 5, 2014 Health Center Storage Room Before and After Introduction.
UNDP Serbia Capacity Development at the local level in Serbia Tomislav Novovic UNDP Serbia.
Organizational Reforms Gaston Sorgho, Harvard School of Public Health Reproductive Health and Health Sector Reform.
Results-based financing Why? What? How?. Jagaman district just erected a new health center and the health workers have started work. What are health workers.
Paulin Basinga Rwanda School of Public Health A collaboration between the Rwanda Ministry of Health, CNLS, SPH, INSP Mexico, UC Berkeley and the World.
PERFORMANCE BASED FINANCING FOR HEALTH IN RWANDA Dr RUSA U. Louis Ministry of Health Kigali-Rwanda Montreux 16th- 19th.
República de Bolivia Ministerio de Salud y Deportes 1 Bolivia: Child Survival with Dignity Dr. Álvaro Muñoz-Reyes Navarro Minister of Health and Sports.
Community Approaches to Child Health. Why Community Approaches? To reach unreached families To mobilize additional resources and partners (including communities.
Paulin Basinga Rwanda School of Public Health Christel Vermeersch World Bank A collaboration between the Rwanda Ministry of Health, CNLS, SPH, INSP Mexico,
Nigeria, January 2010 Petra Vergeer Health Specialist, RBF Team.
National Community Health Performance-based Financing: design and implementation of supply-side model PBF workshop Bujumbura February 16 th, 2011 Ludwig.
Dr. Miguel Székely, Deputy Minister for Social Developement Cape Town, South Africa, 2005.
Home Grown Incentives in Katete District Harrison Mkandawire District Director of Health Katete District.
PBF CONFERENCE 14 TH -17 TH FEBRUARY 2011 BUJUMBURA, BURUNDI DESIGNING OF Sierra Leone simple performance based financing Scheme (PBF) Presented by Michael.
HEALTH FINANCING MOH - HPG JAHR UPDATE ON POLICIES Eleventh Party Congress -Increase state investment while simultaneously mobilizing social mobilization.
Strategy on creation of the system for continuous professional training of staff employed in social assistance system (for ) draft Ministry of.
11 Isolating the incentive effect PBF  Performance incentives  Additional resources Compensate control facilities with equal resources  Average of what.
Overview of Steps to Design and Implement Results Based Financing Schemes Susna De, MSc, MPH Results Based Financing to Reduce Maternal, Newborn, and Child.
Objectives “To improve maternal and child health in Zimbabwe”. “by improving the availability, accessibility and quality of key reproductive and child.
RWANDA INTERGRATED HEALTH MANAGEMENT INFORMATION SYSTEM Ministry of Health.
PRIMARY HEALTH CARE IN PRACTICE: PROVISION OF PREVENTIVE AND BASIC CURATIVE CARE AT THE COMMUNITY LEVEL THROUGH HEALTH EXTENSION WORKERS Neghist Tesfaye.
SPECIAL SESSION COUNTDOWN TO 2015 IN ETHIOPIA SIX BUILDING BLOCKS OF THE HEALTH SYSTEM: PROGRESS TOWARDS THE INTEGRATION IN ETHIOPIA Dereje Mamo Tsegaye.
Endris Mohammed Seid 1,2, Arjanne Rietsema 1 1: CORDAID-Zimbabwe 2: Ministry of Health and Child Care- Zimbabwe Improving Maternal, Neonatal and Child.
Right to health in Rwanda: role of health workers and their training Dr Alex Hakuzimana East African Consultation on the Right to Health Nairobi, Sept.
NASARAWA STATE GOVERNMENT NIGERIA STATE HEALTH INVESTMENT PROJECT (NSHIP) PROJECT PERFORMANCE REVIEW JANUARY TO JUNE 2015.
"Learning and achievements of SWA Global platform and its relevance to achieving Hygiene and Sanitation Development in India" India WASH Summit 17 th February.
Coordinator of Project management Unit of Global fund and MAP projects
Regional, District Leadership and Facility Pediatric Quality Improvement Teams (PQITs) as Champions of Implementation Sustainability 3rd NQIF 26th - 28th.
Afghanistan Now: On the Path to Better Health
CBHI in Vientiane Capital The way forward
RWANDA PERFORMANCE BASED SYSTEM: PUBLIC REFOMS
What do we know and don’t know…
A Scalable Model for Community Health Worker Motivation
Descriptive Analysis of Performance-Based Financing Education Project in Burundi Victoria Ryan World Bank Group May 16, 2017.
April 2011.
Presentation transcript:

What PBF can achieve; Example from Rwanda Claude SEKABARAGA, MD, MPH World Bank, Nairobi Hub. January 2010

U5MR (per 1,000) in sub-Saharan Africa – MDG4 Target and Actual Source: Global Monitoring Report 2008

Actual U5MR (DHS) vs. MDG4 target in Rwanda – 35% reduction from

REDUCTION OF INFANT MORTALITY 1/3 in years

63% of increase in three years

25% of increase in three years

IMIHIGO: Performance based services for territorial administration Strong political commitment to results Contract between the President of the Republic and the district mayors and different local administration levels; Key health indicators integrated in the contract (in 2007: ITNs, Mutuelles, FP, safe deliveries, hygiene..) Quartely review with Prime Minister, President attending twice a year

Autonomy of providers institutions Based on Bamako Initiative Delegation of management Health centers and hospitals fully autonomous Subsidized by the government: PBF, needs based block grant (initially for wages) Support to planning: Strategic and operational planning are the fundament of the approach.

Human resources management Decentralization of wages; Community through facility committee have the authority to hire and fire; Community through facilities receive block grant from government; “People follow the money”; Retention of health personnel in rural areas increased.

Trend in the financing of district health personnel

Evolution of the number of selected staff in rural and urban districts (public sector)

RESULTS BASED FINANCING PRINCIPLES

What is Results Based Financing? Incentives targeting provider’s behavior to produce more results and to comply on quality standards; Incentives targeting household or individual behavior to use more services Financing mechanism for defined quantity and quality outputs and outcomes. PURCHASER PROVIDER Health Results Financial Incentives

Verification of quantity and quality Why to finance results vs. inputs? Payment result Financing strategy Actions for results Objective Result Equipment, consumables, Drugs, salaries, etc. Supervision, training, audit and Sanction? Investment? TIME

RBF PRIORITY AREAS AND BENEFITS Based on major bottlenecks; Priority to composite indicators and avoid selective performance; Quantity preventive interventions and quality of both prevention and curative services; Promotion of local creativity and spirit for performance; Improvement of remuneration of personnel and equipment linked to services to community: ACCOUNTABILITY.

How to finance results? Evaluator/ verificator Regulator Provider Purchaser Beneficiary

What systems are needed to implement RBF successfully? Does the regulatory framework require change? How will results be routinely monitored (HMIS?) and verified? How to sustain? How will the government decide if it will continue to fund through RBF mechanism? How will you show impact? How will you show cost-effectiveness? Concerns

THE PERFORMANCE FINANCING SYSTEM

SUSTAINABILITY OF RWANDA PBF FINANCING

Results: Services produced (after 27 months of extention ) Results: Services produced (after 27 months of extention ) Indicateurs FBRJanvier 2006 moyenne mensuelle par centre pour 258 centres de santé Mars 2008 moyenne mensuelle par centre pour 286 centres de santé Pourcentage d’augmentation Accouchements Assistés % Nouvelles consultations curatives 9851,48951% CPN: 2ième dose Anti-tétanique % Nouvelles utilisatrices PF % Utilisatrices de PF à la fin du mois %

Impact on quality of prenatal care 24

Impact on institutional delivery 25

COMMUNITY, HEALTH CENTER and DISTRICT HOSPITAL Development Partners in kind transfers Total amount: 60.6 M USD GoR In kind transfers Total amount: 12.2 M USD

COMMUNITY PBF To reduce child mortality: Malaria, pneumonia, diarrhea and monitoring of malnutition), and family planning; Five CHW (a lady and a man for IMCI package) by village; Organized in cooperatives and paid based on a package of services produced and checked by health center in term of quantity and quality.

Conclusion BUILDING CULTURE OF RESULTS MORE THAN INPUTS AND PROCEDURES For ACCOUNTABILITY: 1. Separation of functions: Purchasers, providers and direct beneficiaries; 2. Clear link between public funds and direct services to community; Priority on high impact interventions (Family planning & reproductive health, prevention interventions and family & community services)