Ethics review and other approval review of research involving humans (Chapter 3) Group 2 Ethics of technology and science: Seminar I 2015-09-17.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Introduction to Stem Cells
Advertisements

Group 1.3 Relationships between RECs in multi-centre, international studies –problems and solutions.
Chapter 20 REGULATIONS IN BIOTECHNOLOGY. Regulations Are intended to allow us to safely use the benefits of biotech. Help in developing and using biotech.
Animal Experimentation – an Introduction Made in the interest of Animals by FIAPO. Please direct any queries to Alokparna Sengupta at
U.S. Food and Drug Administration Notice: Archived Document The content in this document is provided on the FDAs website for reference purposes only. It.
Assessment for learning In a Sport Culture class.
Post Research Benefits Mandika Wijeyaratne MS, MD, FRCS Dept. of Surgery, Colombo.
World Society for the Protection of Animals Indicators for Enforcement – a global perspective Enforcement of European Animal Welfare Related Legislation.
The moral importance of agency Frederike Kaldewaij Philosophy Department, Utrecht University Expert Meeting Fish welfare:
Moral  the person’s individual set of values Ethics  consensus of a social system Both try to define what is good and what is bad CUDOS (Robert Merton.
By Mr. Abdalla A. Shaame.  The rights and wrongs of science and technology.
A patent is a license for a sole right to exclude others from making, using or selling an invention. A small company has had an idea for, and wants to.
Behavioral Research Chapter Three Ethical Research.
Obtaining Informed Consent: 1. Elements Of Informed Consent 2. Essential Information For Prospective Participants 3. Obligation for investigators.
Integrating Ethics in EU Research
CORE COMPETENCIES IN CLINICAL & TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH: The Child Health Perspective I. Clinical & Translational Research Questions: Extract information.
Chapter 13 Data Collection ♣ ♣ Introduction   Research Participants   Sample Size   Apparatus and/or Instruments   Instructions   Scheduling.
1 Arja Kuula, Development Manager, Finnish Social Science Data Archive, University of Tampere Ethics Review in Finland IASSIST conference 2010 Cornell.
Experimental Psychology PSY 433
Ethics in Research Stangor Chapter 3.
By: Monica Pilarski David Bernstein Jenny Smith. The Sciences Cloning comes from the Greek word “klwn” meaning twig. The reason? It’s simple, every plant.
Understanding Data-Intensive Science Sabina Leonelli Egenis & Department of Sociology and Philosophy
Ethics in Biotechnology Angela Copeland Martin Proctor Kelly Van der Sande Leadership and Ethics Professor Kent Rhodes July 27, 2005 MBAM
Activity 9  By researching cell division, I can explain its role in growth and repair and can discuss how some cells can be used therapeutically SCN 4-13a.
 Stem Cells. Understandings  Specialized tissues can develop by cell differentiation in multicellular organisms.  Differentiation involves the expression.
Ethical Issues in the Use of Animals in Xenotransplantation Rui-Peng LEI Center for Bioethics Central China University of Science & Technology Wuhan, China.
Genetic advances will only be acceptable if their application is carried out ethically, with due regard to autonomy, justice, education and the beliefs.
Advanced Technical Writing
Oviedo Convention impact for legislation and practices Cristina Gavrilovici, MD, PhD Romanian Bioethics Committee Bratislava, 2009.
Chapter 1 The Science of Biology What will we be studying this year? Let’s start with the word science shall we…..
We have reviewed this material in accordance with U.S. Copyright Law and have tried to maximize your ability to use, share, and adapt it. The citation.
Kathrine Kleveland, president of The Norwegian Society of Rural Women ” Norwegian GMO regulation” 6 th European Conference of GMO-Free Regions September.
Ethics: The Challenges in International Research Prof Wendy Moyle, Deputy Director RCCCPI, Griffith University Asia-Pacific Research Symposium, Gold Coast.
Chapter 21 Jeffery D. Evans, Pharm.D. Associate Professor of Clinical and Administrative Sciences University of Louisiana, College of Pharmacy.
OES  The Flora and Fauna Guarantee Act of 1988 is a Victorian Government act administered by the Department of Sustainability and Environment.
Unit 3 – Health psychology: substance misuse The use of animals in drug research.
Embedding Science and Society in FP-6 Brussels, CCAB, October 2002.
Stem Cells and Society  Catalyst:  Describe one example of how genetic testing could be used to help someone.  Describe one example of how gene therapy.
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt Ethical.
Ewe were always on my mind….
DEFENSE THREAT REDUCTION AGENCY JOINT SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY OFFICE CHEMICAL AND BIOLOGICAL DEFENSE create collaborate communicate Click to add title of.
Human Embryos and Gene-editing Research and regulation in China Prof. Zhihong Xu, Peking University & Chinese Academy of Sciences.
Objective 9/23/15 Today we will be completing our research methods unit & begin reviewing for the upcoming unit assessment 9/25. Agenda: -Turn in all homework.
1 Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display. Chapter 1 Exploring Life and Science Lecture Outline Part.
Stem Cells and Society  Catalyst:  Is it ever acceptable to take a life to help someone? Explain your answer.  Is it acceptable to use parts from a.
Cloning Cloning is the process of producing genetically identical individuals Use a single cell from an adult to grow an entirely new individual The new.
Seminar 7 Eugene de Silva Ph.D. FRSA. Introduction Welcome Welcome SC300 Course – Unit 7 – week 7 SC300 Course – Unit 7 – week 7 Discussion points Discussion.
Genome editing: What lessons can we learn from the mitochondrial donation debate? Peter Thompson Human Fertilisation & Embryology Authority.
G E N E T I C E N G I N E E R I N G By Szymon Stańczak.
Biology 0610.
Seminar I: Ethical analysis of a study case
What do we need to know to become stem cell literate?
Genetic Engineering and Animal Research
A review of supporting literature and demonstration of the game
Gene Editing: Ethics and Governance
Research on human biological materials: Lithuanian perspective
Advanced Technical Writing
The Flora and Fauna Guarantee Act of 1988 (Vic)
HOW TO READ AND WRITE A SCIENTIFIC PAPER
Genetically Modified Organisms
Being an effective consumer of preclinical research
Ethics in Research and International Cooperation
Animals used in medical research
What is the advantage of knowing what each of your genes codes for?
Homework: Homework Packet 12 Biotech QUEST on Friday
Technical Writing Abstract Writing.
FIVE BLOCKS SPECIAL REPORT 5/7/2019
Use of Human Embryos: Law
Ethical issue in research work.
Ethics of the Use of Animals in Scientific Research: Legislation
Presentation transcript:

Ethics review and other approval review of research involving humans (Chapter 3) Group 2 Ethics of technology and science: Seminar I

Outline Introduction Highlights Conclusion

Ethics Committee Research on humans requires approval from an ethical review board The ethics review board For research involving humans, other approval can be required, eg if the effects of a new drug should be studied Withdraw of consent

Research on Animals “Use animals (non human) in experiments, because they are sufficiently like humans, - and - since they are sufficiently different from us (to motivate the suffering caused).” Minimum and maximum levels of Animal Welfare in EU. Swedish legislation is only applicable on Swedish territory.

Application for ethics review Up to the researcher to justify the importance of the study and whether animals are necessary Conflict of interest…? –Scientific clarity vs laymen description –Honesty vs scientific drive –Assigning levels of suffering caused to the animals –Circumvent ethical pitfalls on paper?

What counts as an aminal? Ethics review in Sweden required for experiments on vertebrates… and squid Classification by phylogeny somewhat arbitrary for this purpose? How to estimate pain in animals? "Fried calamari" by Chensiyuan at the English language Wikipedia. "Nacktmull" by Roman Klementschitz, Wien - Own work. CC BY-SA 3.0

Animal use – ethics vs scientific rigor What animals should a scientist use and how relevant will this be to the eventual scientific results? –Eg. Human disease –Always aim at vertebrates? –“Golden standard” experiment perhaps not always right? 1 macaque = 10 mouse = 100 chickens… = X worms?

Ethics of raw materials Ethical permit required only for experiment itself, not antibodies or serum Antigen+adjuvant injection Inducing immune response Repeated bleeding of animal for harvesting antibody Ethical responsibility on manufacturer, no longer on researchers (yay!)

Research involving Humans Have to be ethical approved if biological material can be traced to an specific individual –How should studies on HeLa cells be treated? –Organs from dead patients or operations Sensitive personal data can be processed scientifically without consent (but always requires ethical review) An removal of consent requires only the researcher to remove the trace to the individual

GMO Genetically modified organisms –Inserting/removing/manipulate genetic material in organisms Not black and white –The term is too wide that it looses meanongin talking in those terms Are the regulations too strict or too loose? –Department wide regulations which enables everyone to handle such kinds of organisms (low scale, low taxanomy) –Open culture batches but retained inside the walls of the department. –Shipping (=spreading) an issue or advantage?

Different ethical standards, rules and regulations in different countries ”Ethical standards that are self-evident in Sweden can be difficult to find support for in international research environments.” Too strict laws in your country – collaborate with groups in countries with more relaxed ethical standards Conversely, if Swedish regulations are more relaxed, it may cause difficulties in collaborations But! In our global research community, collaborations is necessary and expected!

Responsibilities of journals and funding agencies? Should unethical high impact work be rewarded by e.g. publication and/or funding? Gene editing in human embryos rejected by Nature and Science partly due to ethical reasons How much influence should journals and funding agencies exert? Some requirements already in place by journals and funding agencies – should there be more? Less?