A-16 Data Theme Gaps for Homeland Security and Homeland Defense Mike Lee - FGDC Homeland Security Working Group January 15, 2008

2 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  TOPICS oBackground oWhy Act? oNSDI Data Theme Lead Responsibilities oSSA Responsibilities oCI/KR Sectors and the DHS GDM oStructured Visualization of Gaps & Recommended Changes to A-16 oIssues and Considerations

3 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Background oHomeland Security Presidential Directive (HSPD)-7 establishes a national policy for Federal departments and agencies to identify, prioritize, and protect U.S. Critical Infrastructure (CI) and Key Resource (KR) assets oHSPD-7 describes 17 CI/KR Sectors and their corresponding lead Sector-Specific Agencies (SSAs)

4 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Background oHSPD-7 Assigns Mapping Responsibilities  (31) The Secretary [DHS] will collaborate with other appropriate Federal departments and agencies to develop a program, consistent with applicable law, to geospatially map, image, analyze, and sort critical infrastructure and key resources by utilizing commercial satellite and airborne systems, and existing capabilities within other agencies. National technical means should be considered as an option of last resort. The Secretary, with advice from the Director of Central Intelligence, the Secretaries of Defense and the Interior [FGDC], and the heads of other appropriate Federal departments and agencies, shall develop mechanisms for accomplishing this initiative. The Attorney General shall provide legal advice as necessary.

5 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Background oThe current list of NSDI data themes and associated lead agencies is incomplete from a Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) mission perspective  13 of 17 CI/KR Sectors lack NSDI data themes  Data theme gaps are problematic for those SSAs responsible for CIP programs that rely on sector-specific information (including geospatial) to accomplish their mission

6 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Why Act? o Databases such as the Homeland Security Infrastructure Program (HSIP) continues to grow (layers now over 300)  No other Federal collection of national geospatial data for Homeland Security (HLS) and Homeland Defense (HD) exists  Loosely organized by CI/KR Sectors with multiple data layers from different authoritative sources o Sector layers lack common data schemas and often don’t spatially integrate  Queries often difficult to impossible to perform  Different compilation scales/accuracies o HSIP content issues demonstrate a need for leadership and facilitation that will satisfy data needs of CI/KR Sectors  NSDI Data Theme Leads Responsibilities  Improved Coordination with Authoritative Sources

7 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  NSDI Data Theme Lead Responsibilities (from Circular A-16) o Provide leadership and facilitate the development and implementation of needed FGDC standards, especially a data content standard for each data theme. Assess existing standards, identify anticipated or needed data standards, and develop a plan to originate and implement needed standards with relevant community and international practices. o Provide leadership and facilitate the development and implementation of a plan for nationwide population of each data theme. o Prepare goals that support the NSDI strategy and, as needed, collect and analyze information from users about their needs for spatial data, including these in strategies related to their theme responsibilities.

8 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Sector-Specific Agency Responsibilities from HSPD-7 o Collaborate with all relevant Federal departments and agencies, State and local governments, and the private sector, including with key persons and entities in their infrastructure sector; o Conduct or facilitate vulnerability assessments of the sector; and o Encourage risk management strategies to protect against and mitigate the effects of attacks against critical infrastructure and key resources.

9 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  CI/KR Sectors and the DHS Geospatial Data Model o SSA responsibility to collaborate and define mission information needs across all levels of Government and the private sector will strengthen the content definition of the DHS GDM o DHS GDM application schema for Infrastructure Protection currently under construction o National, State and Local views of asset vulnerabilities and risk mitigation will improve CI/KR feature and attribute descriptions

10 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Structured Visualization of Gaps oCritical Infrastructure/Key Resources Sectors ( Agriculture and Food Defense Industrial Base Energy (except comm. nuclear power) Public Health and Healthcare National Monuments and Icons Banking and Finance Drinking Water and Waste Treatment Systems Chemical Commercial Facilities Dams Emergency Services Nuclear Reactors, Materials and Waste Information Technology Communications Postal and Shipping Transportation Systems Government Facilities CI/KR Sector

11 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Structured Visualization of Gaps oSector-Specific Agencies Agriculture and FoodUSDA and DHHS Defense Industrial BaseDOD Energy (except comm. nuclear power) DOE Public Health and HealthcareDHHS National Monuments and IconsDOI Banking and FinanceDOTreas Drinking Water and Waste Treatment Systems EPA ChemicalDHS Office of Infrastructure Protection Commercial FacilitiesDHS Office of Infrastructure Protection DamsDHS Office of Infrastructure Protection Emergency ServicesDHS Office of Infrastructure Protection Nuclear Reactors, Materials and Waste DHS Office of Infrastructure Protection Information TechnologyDHS Office of Cyber Security and Telecommunications CommunicationsDHS Office of Cyber Security and Telecommunications Postal and ShippingDHS Transportation Security Administration Transportation SystemsDHS Transportation Security Administration and US Coast Guard Government FacilitiesDHS Immigration/Customs Enforce and Fed Protective Service CI/KR SectorSector-Specific Agencies

12 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Structured Visualization of Gaps oNSDI Data Theme Lead Alignment with CI/KR Sectors Agriculture and FoodUSDA and DHHS Defense Industrial BaseDOD Energy (except comm. nuclear power) DOE Public Health and HealthcareDHHSDHHS (Public Health) National Monuments and IconsDOIDOI/NPS (Cultural Resources) Banking and FinanceDOTreas Drinking Water and Waste Treatment Systems EPA ChemicalDHS OIP Commercial FacilitiesDHS OIP DamsDHS OIP Emergency ServicesDHS OIP Nuclear Reactors, Materials and Waste DHS OIP Information TechnologyDHS OCS&T CommunicationsDHS OCS&T Postal and ShippingDHS TSA Transportation SystemsDHS TSA and USCGDOT/BTS and USACE (Trans/Marine) Government FacilitiesDHS ICE and FPSGSA (Buildings and Facilities) CI/KR SectorSSANSDI Data Theme Lead

13 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Structured Visualization of Gaps oNSDI Data Theme Gaps with CI/KR Sectors Agriculture and FoodUSDA and DHHSGAP Defense Industrial BaseDODGAP Energy (except comm. nuclear power) DOEGAP Public Health and HealthcareDHHSDHHS (Public Health) National Monuments and IconsDOIDOI/NPS (Cultural Resources) Banking and FinanceDOTreasGAP Drinking Water and Waste Treatment Systems EPAGAP ChemicalDHS OIPGAP Commercial FacilitiesDHS OIPGAP DamsDHS OIPGAP Emergency ServicesDHS OIPGAP Nuclear Reactors, Materials and Waste DHS OIPGAP Information TechnologyDHS OCS&TGAP CommunicationsDHS OCS&TGAP Postal and ShippingDHS TSAGAP Transportation SystemsDHS TSA and USCGDOT/BTS and USACE (Trans/Marine) Government FacilitiesDHS ICE and FPSGSA (Buildings and Facilities) CI/KR SectorSSAGaps

14 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Recommendation - Establish a Starting Point for Discussions oPotential Changes to A-16 NSDI Data Themes & Lead Agencies Agriculture and FoodUSDA and DHHS Defense Industrial BaseDOD Energy (except comm. nuclear power) DOE Public Health and HealthcareDHHSDHHS (Public Health) CR & Nat’l Monum and IconsDOIDOI/NPS (Cultural Resources) Banking and FinanceDOTreas Drinking Water and Waste Treatment Systems EPA ChemicalDHS OIP Commercial FacilitiesDHS OIP DamsDHS OIP Emergency ServicesDHS OIP Nuclear Reactors, Materials and Waste DHS OIP Information TechnologyDHS OCS&T CommunicationsDHS OCS&T Postal and ShippingDHS TSA Transportation SystemsDHS TSA and USCGDOT/BTS,USACE, DHS/TSA/USCG Build & Government FacilitiesDHS ICE and FPSGSA, DHS/ICE and DHS/FPS New ThemesSSANew Theme Leads

15 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Issues and Considerations oThese Recommendations are Not Consistent with Homeland Infrastructure Foundation Layer Database (HIFLD) Working Group Proposals  Tend to be Off-the-Shelf Authoritative Sources  Lack Consistency in Data Definition and Integration oDHS Common Operating Data Requirements for the National Response Plan  How Do Data Needs for Protection Overlap with Response? oOMB Geospatial Line of Business Membership Fees  Unsure How New Themes Affect Funding Algorithm for FGDC Program Management Office  FY08 - One (1) Data Theme Agency Lead (Flood) = $64K oFGDC Lifecycle Working Group  HSWG Particpation

16 A-16 HLS/HD Data Theme Gaps  Back-up Slides - FGDC HSWG and HIFLD A-16 Recommendations