Comparison: Traditional vs. Outcome Project Educational Paradigms Craig McClure, MD Educational Outcomes Service Group University of Arizona December 2004.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Does Mandating Training Have an Impact on Attitudes About Cultural Competency? Guadalupe Pacheco, MSW Project Officer, Think Cultural Health HHS Office.
Advertisements

Nursing Diagnosis: Definition
Feedback & Evaluation: Quick Tips for Clinical Preceptors (Part 1) Shirley Schlessinger, MD, FACP Associate Dean for Graduate Medical Education University.
The Challenge and Importance of Evaluating Residents and Fellows Debra Weinstein, M.D. PHS GME Coordinators Retreat March 25, 2011.
Effective Feedback Win May, MD, PhD Beverly Wood, MD, PhD Division of Medical Education Keck School of Medicine University of Southern California.
Introduction to Competency-Based Residency Education
Chapter 6 Template Training Requirements for the Specialty of X UEMS Section for Infectious Diseases September 2012.
Standard 22A Curricular Structure HT Accredited Curriculum.
Objective vs. subjective in assessment Jaime Correia de Sousa, MD, MPH Horizonte Family Health Unit Matosinhos Health Centre - Portugal Health Sciences.
Comparison: Traditional vs. Outcome Project Evaluative Processes Craig McClure, MD Educational Outcomes Service Group University of Arizona December 2004.
GME Jeopardy. Compe 10 cies VISA issues ToolboxOversiteAlphabet Soup
Complementary and Alternative Medicine Curriculum: Who Needs It? Educational Challenges and Strategies Victor S. Sierpina, MD W.D. and Laura Nell Nicholson.
Baldwin-Whitehall School District
Family Medicine Program By the end of this session, faculty will 1.Understand what is meant by competence and the competence trajectory expected during.
Triple C Competency-based Curriculum: Implications for Family Medicine Residency Programs.
LECTURER OF THE 2010 FIRST-YEAR STUDENT: How can the lecturer help? February 2010.
Maximally-Invasive Curriculum: A Model Curriculum for Osteopathic Surgical Residencies (ACOS) India Broyles, EdD University of New England College of Osteopathic.
Core Competency Assessment in Emergency Medicine from Design to Implementation Christian Arbelaez, MD, MPH Assistant Residency Director Harvard Affiliated.
ACGME OUTCOME PROJECT : THE PROGRAM COORDINATOR’S ROLE Jim Kerwin, MD University of Arizona.
Fundamentals of Assessment Todd L. Green, Ph.D. Associate Professor Pharmacology, Physiology & Toxicology PIES Seminar
Becoming a Teacher Ninth Edition
Teaching Residents to... Teach Peter DeBlieux,MD LSUHSC Clinical Professor of Medicine LSUIH Emergency Department Director Emergency Medicine Director.
TVET/BCC TOT 2007 Competency Based Education and Training: Implications for Workforce Antonia Coward PhD.
LeMoyne-Owen College December 16, 2009 Mimi Czarnik, Professor of English and Dean of Humanities Becky Burton, Associate Professor of Biology Alverno College,
Using Assessment to Improve Student Learning: Where Assessment and Teaching Collide Kirk J. Armstrong, EdD, ATC Georgia College & State University Program.
Assessment tool OSCE AH Mehrparvar,MD Occupational Medicine department Yazd University of Medical Sciences.
The Role of Culture in the Training of Health Care Professionals: A Multidisciplinary Panel Danny M. Takanishi, Jr., MD, FACS Professor and Chair Department.
1 Ambulatory Pediatric Association Educational Guidelines for Pediatric Residency Tutorial 5 Written by Constance D. Baldwin, Ph.D., Carol Carraccio, M.D.,
Curriculum development and curriculum assessment TEMPUS: Second consortium meeting, Koblanz Landau, Germany, March 2013 Dr. Roxana Reichman Working team.
1Management Sciences for Health Principles of Curriculum Development.
McGaw’s Overview of the Next Accreditation System (NAS)
IMPORTANCE &SKILLS OF GIVING FEEDBACK Dr. A.K.Pathak ELMC,Lucknow.
Writing Narratives Based on ACGME Competencies. Narratives What Are They?  Written Evaluation of Student Performance Formative  Mid-Course Evaluation.
Meaningful Evaluation: Framework, Process, Impact Inis Jane Bardella, M.D., FAAFP Associate Dean for Faculty Development and Global Health Initiatives.
Developing an Assessment System B. Joyce, PhD 2006.
Linda A Headrick, MD, MS, FACP February 26, 2013.
Assessment for learning
What is “Competency” in the New Millennium? Shirley Schlessinger, MD, FACP Associate Dean for Graduate Medical Education University of Mississippi Medical.
“A Truthful Evaluation Of Yourself Gives Feedback For Growth and Success” Brenda Johnson Padgett Brenda Johnson Padgett.
Curriculum Instruction Assessment Aligning Manitoba Physical Education Supervisors Association Linda Thorlakson Manitoba Education February 17, 2010.
Assessing Your Learner Lawrence R. Schiller, MD, FACG Digestive Health Associates of Texas Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas.
Considerations for Curricular Development & Change Donna Mannello, DC Logan University.
What is a Planned Curriculum?
The selection of appropriate assessment methods in a course is influenced by many factors: the intended learning outcomes, the discipline and related professional.
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 21 Evidence in Learning and Teaching.
Assessment Ice breaker. Ice breaker. My most favorite part of the course was …. My most favorite part of the course was …. Introduction Introduction How.
Applying Advances Rosalyn P. Scott, MD, MSHA Professor of Surgery Wright State University Boonshoft School of Medicine.
What are competencies?  Emphasize life skills and evaluate mastery of those skills according to actual leaner performance.  Competencies consist of.
Educational Outcomes Service Group: Overview of Year One Lynne Tomasa, PhD May 15, 2003.
ACGME SIX CORE COMPETENCIES Minimum Program Requirements Language Approved by the ACGME, September 28, 1999 “The residency program must require its residents.
Creating Customized Resident Self-Evaluation Assessments in PharmAcademic TM Andrea Weeks, PharmD PGY1 Residency Co-Director and Preceptor Paoli Hospital.
IDENTIFICATION, DIAGNOSIS & REMEDIATION OF THE STRUGGLING LEARNER Jeannette Guerrasio, MD University of Colorado, SOM Chris Knight, MD University of Washington,
Click to edit Master subtitle style Competence by Design (CBD) Foundations of Assessment.
CBME and CanMEDS 2015 Susan Glover Takahashi, MA, PhD Laura Leigh Murgaski, MScCH Lisa St. Amant Jesse Montgomery Kim O’Hearn.
Integration of generic competencies and content in the Skills for a Changing World Curriculum Key Issues to Consider.
Competency Based Learning and Project Based Learning
Introduction to Evaluation
Effective Outcomes Assessment
NHN member organizations
Evaluating Learners Jennifer L. Middleton, MD, MPH, FAAFP
COMPETENCIES & STANDARDS
Comparison: Traditional vs. Outcome Project Evaluative Processes
Quality Criteria for Cultural Competence Trainings
Evaluation Rating Forms
Gerald H. Sterling, Ph.D. Senior Associate Dean, Education
TESTING AND EVALUATION IN EDUCATION GA 3113 lecture 1
An Introduction to the ACGME
Instructional Program Alignment
Presentation transcript:

Comparison: Traditional vs. Outcome Project Educational Paradigms Craig McClure, MD Educational Outcomes Service Group University of Arizona December 2004

Current Problem Increasing public concerns with quality and safety. Variable patterns of care that are not based on medical science. Poor quality of interpersonal “service.” Public encounters difficulty in assessing physician competence (initial and continuing ) and judging quality.

The ACGME Mission To improve the quality of health care in the United States by ensuring and improving the quality of graduate medical educational experiences for physicians in training.

Problem Plus Mission ACGME responded to the challenge by changing focus to: How well do we learn what is being taught How well do we practice what we learn?

A new way of thinking Competency Structure & process How to change the educational and accreditation system from…

Program Goal OLD: goal was for the Program to comply with the written RRC Requirements NEW: the Program Director must determine if residents achieve the learning objectives set by the Program.

Curriculum Development OLD: Curriculum development follows the historical model (residents learn “X” because it’s always been included) NEW: Curriculum development follows the “Outcomes” model (residents must learn “X” to become a competent physician)

RRC Review OLD: “Minimal threshold” model: Program review identifies whether or not a program has the potential to educate residents NEW: Program Director must offer documentation that the residents achieve the learning objectives set by the Program.

Teaching Model OLD: Instructivist model (“facts” are transmitted from teachers to students) NEW: Interactive model: fosters reflective self- evaluation by the learner, learning experiences clearly aligned with expected competencies

Definition of Knowledge OLD: Knowledge is static, finite, linear, and private NEW: Knowledge is dynamic, open ended, multidimensional, and public

Epigrams OLD: Teacher is the “Sage on the stage” NEW: Teacher is the “Guide on the side”

Educational Experiences OLD: Geared to provide contact time with a variable set of clinical experiences by rotation NEW: The educational process focuses on developing and documenting competency with experiences directed at learner needs

Improving the Teaching Program OLD: The Program should have a process to evaluate residents and itself NEW: The Program Director must offer documentation of continuous improvement in the residency educational process

Educational Process OLD: It was sufficient that the Program have established goals, objectives and expose residents to organized curricular experiences with residents performing at the expected norm NEW: Criterion- referenced assessments translate into formative feedback loops to help the learner achieve competence

Other Outcome Characteristics

“Authentic” Justification for elements included in the curriculum is that competence as a practicing physician requires that skill, knowledge or attitude Evaluation is of the actual skill, knowledge or attitude used by practicing physicians

More Individualized A principle of a criteria-driven physician curriculum is that everyone can become competent with sufficient exposure Residents obtain skills at different rates with requirements for disparate learning experiences An optimal outcome-driven system would have an intake assessment followed by an individualized program of study

Reflection and Self-knowledge Critical Criteria for competence are provided to the learner Impetus for improvement arises from desire to narrow the gap between criteria and performance Accurate self-assessment is essential to the resident gauging personal performance