Negating Space June 29 th, 2011. Exploration Beyond Exploration What can we ACTUALLY explore? FX Topicality Not Earth Topicality.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

How to Give an Effective 2ar. 1. Think About the Big Picture  Remember: focus on offense – defend your house  Isolate 1 or 2 Impacts  Decide on impacts.

Advertisements

(Counter) Plans Because they didn’t limit the topic.

Matt Gomez Debating the Disadvantage (DA). 4 Part One: What is a Disadvantage?

Advanced cp competition exercises

2012 GMU Patriot Debate Institute. What is states cp?  Fiats the 50 states governments/Washington D.C./relevant territories to do plan action.  Variations.

Answering Counterplans  Acronym is PLOTS  Permutation  Links to their disads  Other disads to the Counterplan  Theory Objections  Doesn’t Solve the.

Counterplans The Negative’s Best Friend The Affirmative’s Worst Nightmare.

Critiques/Kritiks Baxter MDAW 2013 “Strange things are afoot at the circle k…” --Ted Theodore Logan.

Capitalism Kritik. -AN IDEOLOGY -A MINDSET -“AN ECONOMIC SYSTEM BASED ON THE PRIVATE OWNERSHIP OF THE MEANS OF PRODUCTION, DISTRIBUTION, AND EXCHANGE,

Introduction to Kritiks Ryan Galloway Samford University.

PICs….. In spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace!.  Cp text  Net benefit  Must be competitive ◦ Uniquely beneficial ◦ Mutually exclusive.

NATO’S RESPONSE TO NEW SECURITY CHALLENGES Michael Rühle Head, Energy Security Section NATO Emerging Security Challenges Division ATHENA CONFERENCE Athens,

DISADVANTAGES. What is a Disadvantage?  Disadvantages are offcase positions that the negative advances to prove that the costs of the plan outweigh its.

TOPICALITY James Stevenson, with due credit to Mike Hester.

 A counterplan is a competitive policy option to the affirmative plan.

The 1ar: Debate’s Paramedic Get the patient to the hospital…alive.

Topic Lecture: Disadvantages Rachel Photo Courtesy of BBC.

UNDERSTANDING THE KRITIK by Lurp Lank and Alex Kosmachavelli.

New York Times, Budget Puzzle 1.What is the predicted budget shortfall in 2015? In 2030?( how old will you be then?) 2.List 3 spending cuts you made &

Politics. How to pick your disad 1. Link Debate – certain affs just go a certain way. Gotta win that. In my mind, need to win its unpopular or get another.

Policy Debate Topic Discussion Transportation Infrastructure.

Introduction to Debate -Negative- To access audio: Skype: freeconferencecallhd and enter # Or call and enter # © L. Husick,

Topicality. Our Focus Significance Harms Inherency Topicality Solvency.

Earth’s Oceans Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its non-military exploration and/or development of the Earth’s.

Aspects of the topic to be aware of Technology Empire Resource control and use Desirability of human existence WHY do we want to explore beyond the mesosphere?

Counterplans CODI 2014 Lecture 2. What is a counterplan? A plan offered by the negative to solve some or all of the affirmative’s advantages The negative.

Counterplans?. Debate should be a means of significantly improving one's education through analytical development and extension of advocacy positions.

Prefatory comments  I am not an expert. I hold degrees in political science and communication, not theoretical physics.  The only morally permissible.

Counterplans Debate Central Workshop August 30, 2008.

The Resolution  Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its exploration and/or development of space beyond the Earth’s.

Counterplans on the Topic The Honorable James R. Stevenson, Ph.D, J.D., M.D., Th.D., A.F., A.D.N.

Debate should be a means of significantly improving one's education through analytical development and extension of advocacy positions. The negative strategy.

6/28/2011 Topic Affirmatives. 6/28/2011 Criteria for a Good Aff—Musts  Topicality—little reason to lose on T  Interest—affs take a lot of work, need.

And other things… DISADVANTAGES. BUT FIRST, LETS REVIEW FOR THE QUIZ The quiz on Wednesday will be open note and will cover the two primary topics and.

Counterplans The Negative’s Best Friend The Negative’s Best Friend.

INTRO TO COUNTERPLANS!. WHAT IS A CP? A net beneficial alternative proposal to the Plan Competitive with the Plan Strategic if… The Aff is huge The SQ.

Opposition Strategy NCFA Rookie Debate Camp. Agenda ❖ A Brief Word on Trichotomy ❖ Basic Path to Winning ❖ Opposition Strategies by Position* ❖ Quick.

Religious Moral and Philosophical Studies on Mars 31 st of August 2012.

ItemWhat are the names of the two major political parties in the United States today? ADemocratic and Republican B Democratic and Libertarian C Socialist.

Going Negative The Surveillance Topic. Outline for the topic I. Categories of neg ground -Go over the specific arguments we have II. Dealing.

Policy Debate THISPAD.

Affirmative Strategy Austin Layton. Overview At least, take two things from this lecture Main Advantage of Being Aff: Familiarity – Preparation Matters.

Critiques Brian Rubaie, Debate Central. What is a critique?  Disadvantages question desirability of action  Counterplans question methods of action.

Critical Debate Don’t Fear the Reaper. What Is A Critique? Way of understanding information Aff and Neg Tool.

Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards Baylor University July 2013.

Intro to Counterplans Casey Parsons. Introduction to Counterplans Thus far in debate, we have assumed that the neg defends the status quo In the vast.

SCFI 2011 SJK. Understand how to structure and write basic LD constructives Understand the basic components of contention-level argumentation Begin to.

By Ty.  Space exploration is really important and should not be stopped. Going to space has made us learn a lot and it is good we are capable of traveling.

How to Debate Disadvantages. DA Uniqueness: Status of a key issue in the SQ – Example: The economy is improving Link: how the plan disrupts the SQ – Example:

Prison Negative Pay Fucking Attention. Topicality Topicality Substantial-Not Many People in Prisons, Not Much Money] Topicality Subsets.

Parts of a DA in 1NC2ac answers to a DA Uniqueness1. Non-unique Link2. No link Internal Link3. No internal link Impact4.

GDI 2015 THE NEGATIVE.  The counter to the Affirmative  Negates the course of action proposed  So much variety! Many ways to negate  What makes someone.

Budgets and Businesses Workshop. Budget: is a plan that shows income, spending and saving. Income: Spending: Saving:

AQA E CON 1: M ARKETS AND MARKET FAILURE The impact of government intervention on market outcomes You have now covered all the theoretical content.

POLICY DEBATE. WHAT IS POLICY DEBATE? A structured format for fairly arguing a topic of policy TEAM DEBATE: two teams of two students each 8 speeches.

why we should reduce, reuse and recycle and how this can reduce costs and save us money about different things we can do at home and school to reduce.

Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards & Russell Kirkscey June 2015.

Matt Gomez.  What will occur in the status quo  Factors for good uniqueness  Post-dating – things change  Brink – why is the squo good but not guaranteed.

Mandatory National Service

The Politics DA.

Basics of Debate Damien Debate.

How to be negative Gabi Yamout.

UNDERSTANDING THE KRITIK

What Are Maps?.

The K. Luis M. Andrade ADI, 2014.

Wining the DA Casey Parsons.

The 2AC: Answering Disads

Topicality Casey Parsons.

ТЕМА 3: РАБОТА СО ТЕКСТ Внесување на текст

Introduction to the Neg

Presentation transcript:

Negating Space June 29 th, 2011

Exploration Beyond Exploration What can we ACTUALLY explore? FX Topicality Not Earth Topicality

Uniqueness Direction Inflexible Link Impact Rapidity Tricks What Makes a Good Disad?

Space Disads Debris Militarization Relations Disads China The Rest Boring Shit Politics Spending The DAs

Big Shift From Military Topic Goals of the CP Counterplan as Justification Counterplan for a Disad Counterplan cuz you Cant Beat the Case Counterplanning Space

Half of the real world debate about space What does it do well Saves money Spending Politics Objectivism Encourages competition Uniqueness goes the right way—status quo cp Private CP

What is old is new again Space is what dreams are made of Same old K?

Technological Stuff Heidegger Ellul Surveillance Earth 2.0 Cap Frontier K Space Subjectivity Psychoanalysis Biopower Virilio Kritikal Shizzle