Science and Creationism 6. Abiogenesis © Colin Frayn, 2008-2011 www.frayn.net.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Topic D.1 Evolution Origin of Life on Earth.
Advertisements

Biochemical evolution
CHAPTER 25 CAMPBELL and REECE. Conditions on early Earth made the Origin of Life possible Macroevolution : evolutionary change above the species level.
Origin of Life on Earth.
IB Biology Option D Evolution.
Early Origins Chapter 19.1 & 19.3.
Part of the Evolution of Australian Biota Module Biology in Focus, Preliminary Course Glenda Childrawi and Stephanie Hollis Life on Earth Topic 4: Urey.
Origin and Evolution of Life in the Oceans
Unit 5 Evolution Ch. 17 The History of Life.
Chapter 12, Section 3 And parts of 12.4
14.2 The Origin of Life 9(D) Analyze and evaluate the evidence regarding formation of simple organic molecules and their organization into long complex.
Evolutionary History Chapter 20. Before life…  Chemical evolution:  The formation of small organic molecules preceded larger ones  Larger, more complex.
Chapter 17 Section 2 Earth’s Early History
Early Earth. Earth formed 4.6 billion years ago oldest fossil organisms - prokaryotes dating back to 3.5 bya earliest prokaryotic cells lived in dense.
1 Origin of the earth  Big bang happened 14 billion years ago.  Earth and Moon formed 4.5 billion years ago (4.5 X 10 )  Oldest rock is 3.9 billion.
Copyright © 2002 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Benjamin Cummings Origin of Life In 1862, Louis Pasteur conducted experiments that rejected the.
The History of Life Chapter 14. Early Earth Was inhospitable! Very hot due to: Meteoric impact Volcanic eruptions Radioactive decay Early atmosphere contained:
Chapter 25 The History of Life on Earth. Question u How have events in the Earth’s history contributed to life as we know it?
WHERE DID THE FIRST LIVING THINGS COME FROM?
BIOLOGY WORKSHEET CHAPTER 17 HISTORY OF LIFE ON EARTH - NOVAK
Theories on the Origin of Life. When did life form? Age of the Earth: 4.6 billion years Oldest rocks: 3.8 – 4.0 billion years Oceans established > 3.8.
Primordial Earth Theories on the Origin of Life. Early Earth and Evolution A THEORY of the origins of the universe Big Bang When? -Approx Billion.
Homework #5 Due Tuesday, October 25, 6:00 pm Exam #2 date Wednesday, November 2 Exam #3 tentative date Wednesday, November 30.
Modeling Chemical Evolution
ORIGIN OF LIFE SC.912.L Intro This presentation is on benchmark SC.912.L15.8 which covers the origin of life on Earth. Origin of life research is.
The Evolutionist Theory of the Origin of Life Packet #62 Chapter #26 Packet #62 Chapter #26 10/19/2015 6:55 PM1.
Chapter 17 Origins of Life. Astrobiology is study of the origin, evolution, distribution, & destiny of life in the universe. It attempts to answer 3 fundamental.
The Origin Of The Earth SC.912.L Billion years the earth was formed ~3.2 Billion years ago the introduction of Blue-green cyanobacteria ▫Oxygen.
The Origin of Life Early and Modern Ideas.
CH 26: Early Earth and the Origin of Life Presentation by Alisa Gordon, Erica Guo, and Victoria Chen.
Origin of Life on Earth. Formation of Earth Our knowledge of earth’s history Hypotheses about Earth’s early history are based on a relatively small amount.
Prebiotic Chemstry Jeff G. Wardeska, PhD Jan. 24, 2008.
The Secret of Ping-Pong. To get to where you want to go, it helps to know where you have come from.
Foothill High School Science Department The History of Life Earth’s Early History.
History of Life Chapter 14. Biogenesis Biogenesis is the idea that all living things come from other living things. Before the 17 th century it was believed.
History of Life Chapter 14.
Chapter 12 Section 1 How Did Life Begin? Grade 10 Biology Spring 2011.
© Colin Frayn, Abiogenesis Literally, the emergence of life from non-living origins This is organic chemistry, not biological evolution.
THE ORIGIN OF LIFE HOW DID IT ALL BEGIN?. FORMATION OF THE EARTH 4.55 billion years ago Earth formed by accretion of matter. Constant bombardment heated.
Chapter 26 Early Earth and the Origin of Life. Phylogeny Traces life backward to common ancestors. How did life get started?
KEY CONCEPT The origin of life on Earth remains a puzzle.
Origins of Life – Chapter 21. “Other” theories –comets may have delivered organic compounds probably will never prove how life began have narrowed down.
The Origins of Life The Big Bang occurred about 18 billion years ago, creating the universe. The Earth formed about 4.6 billion years ago. Life on Earth.
Intro to the History of Life Age of the Earth = 4.6 billion years Oldest fossils = 3.5 billion years –Prokaryotic type structures similar to spherical.
Origin of Life Today How did life originate? Working back from today The most basic components How DNA and RNA work Working forward from simple molecules.
The History of Life Chapter 14. Early Earth Was inhospitable! Very hot due to: Meteoric impact Volcanic eruptions Radioactive decay Early atmosphere contained:
How could life have begun on a lifeless planet?
Biology Journal 11/6/2013 Describe Louis Pasteur's swan neck experiment. How was this experiment evidence for the cell theory? “I invented Pasteurized.
The Origin of Life Option D1 D1.1-D1.4 Chapter 26 Campbell.
On Hadean-Archean Earth Outcrop of metamorphosed volcano-sedimentary rocks from Porpoise Cove, Canada. Abiotic  Biotic Transition.
Origin of Life. The Earth was around for 1 billion years before we see signs of LIFE…. So…where did it come from?
 Origins: Early Ideas  Spontaneous generation is the idea that life arises from nonlife. Francesco Redi, an Italian scientist, tested the idea that.
Chapter 26. The Origin of Life
Discovering the origins of life on Earth. Organic molecules Before life could begin the organic molecules necessary for life first had to ‘evolve’. These.
Concept 25.1: Conditions on early Earth made the origin of life possible Chemical and physical processes on early Earth may have produced very simple cells.
12.3 Origin of Life KEY CONCEPT The origin of life on Earth remains a puzzle.
Section 1: How Did Life Begin?
Warm-Up (4/4) Describe the essential components of all cells on Earth.
The Basic Chemicals of Life
Unit 9: Evolution 9.2 Life over Time.
Early Earth How old is earth? When did life first appear?
The origin of living systems is explained by natural processes.
Abiogenesis.
Life’s Origin and Early Evolution
Theories on the Origin of Life
Going even further back!
The History of Life Earth’s Early History.
Reading: 12.3 (finish); 3.1, 3.3; test monday Activator: enzymes
Presentation transcript:

Science and Creationism 6. Abiogenesis © Colin Frayn,

© Colin Frayn, Abiogenesis Literally, the emergence of life from non-living origins This is organic chemistry, not biological evolution There are several competing ideas Bottom line: we really don’t know how this happened yet Yes, science has the guts to say “we don’t know”!

© Colin Frayn, Miller-Urey Stanley L. Miller & Harold C. Urey –1953, University of Chicago Experiment designed to simulate the early Earth Synthesised organic compounds –The building blocks of life First of many experiments –Using varying atmospheric assumptions –All 20 necessary amino acids can be synthesised easily

© Colin Frayn, Miller-Urey Apparatus

© Colin Frayn, Reducing Atmosphere (1) Miller & Urey assumed a ‘reducing’ atmosphere –Low in Oxygen, high in Hydrogen Some studies suggested this was not the case on the early Earth Latest studies favour reducing atmosphere –See e.g. Tian et al (2005), Schaefer & Fegley (2007) –Atmosphere was approximately 30-40% Hydrogen –Exactly as required Proofs: –Banded iron, Uraninite, paleosoils, pyrite

© Colin Frayn, Reducing Atmosphere (2) A reducing atmosphere is vulnerable to ultra-violet (UV) radiation –No oxygen to form ozone layer Ozone layer protects against UV radiation –Recent studies Effect of UV is less than was originally thought Aerosol haze can efficiently block UV radiation E.g. Zahnle (1986), Sagan & Chyba (1997) and Pavlov et al (2000) If life developed close to deep-sea hydrothermal vents then the UV was not a problem!

© Colin Frayn, Autocatalysis What came first, DNA or proteins? –DNA is needed as a pattern for proteins –Proteins are needed to catalyse DNA –Chicken and egg? RNA can auto-catalyse –RNA is very similar to DNA –We still have RNA in our body cells –It can catalyse its own reactions –RNA is a plausible precursor to DNA

© Colin Frayn, Hydrothermal Vents Discovered in 1949 First imaged in 1977 Unique ecosystems Under many kilometres of water

© Colin Frayn, How did RNA arise? RNA is (probably) too complex to have arisen in one step –Plausible precursors are required Benefits of RNA –Can replicate itself –Is simpler than DNA –Can self-catalyse –Cell replication apparatus is RNA Formation of RNA through ribonucleotides –Problematic as ribose is difficult to form –Maybe ribonucleotides arose through a different process? –Nature, 459, pp , Powner, Gerland & Sutherland (2009)

© Colin Frayn, From RNA to Cells Lipids spontaneously form bilayer ‘vesicles’ –These are spherical shells on a molecular scale –They can contain self-replicating RNA strands –This provides an ideal, self-contained environment Problems –How to form sufficient concentrations of lipids? –Work is on-going –E.g. Szostak & team (Harvard) –Hydrothermal vents?

© Colin Frayn, A Likely Model Amino acids are formed –See the Miller-Urey Experiment Lipid bilayers form –These are observed to form spontaneously Self-replicating RNA strings arise –This stage is uncertain, but plausible –RNA is able to catalyse its own replication RNA strings merge with bilayer shells –Lipid bilayers form ‘vesicles’ or shells First cells form –All the components are held together in one place –Facilitates chemical processes

© Colin Frayn, Progress Recent studies have made solid progress, but abiogenesis remains a very complicated topic We are very slowly filling in the remaining gaps in our knowledge Don’t expect this to be ‘solved’ any time soon ‘Unknown’ ≠ ‘unknowable’ Don’t give in to intellectual cowardice and say “we can never explain this”!