Coherence and Legitimacy Can a group of people who disagree come to a consensus? How would this work? Why would we believe that the “consensus” is any.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
How do you view Propaganda? Propaganda PR or Propaganda/PRNews.
Advertisements

ECONOMICS.
Meditation IV God is not a Deceiver, Truth Criterion & Problem of Error.
Proposal That all laws be enacted by the general will. This is not mere absolute democracy, as the will is ‘general’ in two senses:
Consider: Can anarchism work? Give one reason why it might. The Last Word: Assignment 1 for tomorrow.
Government.
Week 2: Major Worldviews January 10, 2007
19.0 Conclusion Debate over intervention vs. non-intervention goes back two hundred years Jean-Baptiste Say (1803) – market system can and does.
WHOSE LINE IS IT? Comparing Hamilton and Jefferson.
Economic Thought of Aristotle and Plato By Ahmad Qazi.
ATTITUDES TOWARDS DEMOCRACY UNDERSTANDING DEMOCRACY.
Handling Differing or Opposing Points of View in your Essay.
STATES AS THE PROBLEM The Predatory State 1. Power to Protect Property = Power to Take Property 2. Fiscal Illusion (citizen’s limited information) Accountability/Responsiveness.
Pearson Education, Inc. © 2005 Democracy in the United States Chapter 1 Pearson Education, Inc. © 2005.
Politics: Who Gets What, and How?
Philosophy A philosophy is a system of beliefs about reality.
Cluster 2 Unit 6.  Democracy is: 1) A process 2) People listen to one another 3) People say what they think 4) People make decisions together by accepting.
Capitalism and Free Enterprise
Economics Introduction:
LEVADA-CENTERLEVADA-CENTER “From opinions to understanding” LEVADA-CENTERLEVADA-CENTER.
The Thing….Itself Michael Munger Duke University November 7, 2005.
Questions and answers on Bill C-4, Budget Implementation Act.
Economics for Leaders The Ultimatum Game. Proposal Selection Form Proposer Identification Code __________________ Circle a proposal: 9/1 8/2 7/3 6/4 5/5.
People and Government. Principles of Government  Population, the most obvious essential feature of a state. ◦ State: a political community that occupies.
The Calculus of Consent Ch 6: A Generalized Economic Theory of Constitutions Alexander Tabarrok January 06.
Political Science and International Relations Political system of the state.
American Government and Politics Introduction. Who is the government? And what should “they” do?
Government and the State
The Federalist Papers #10 and #51. The Fundamental Question How do we create a government that protects liberty, achieves justice, ensures stability,
Judging a book by its cover
Review Questions 1)List four weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation 2)What was the fundamental question that the founders faced when designing the.
American Government and Organization PS1301 Friday, 12 September.
© 2006 Prentice Hall Business Publishing The Economic Way of Thinking, 11/e Heyne/Boettke/Prychitko “The Economic Way of Thinking” 11 th Edition Chapter.
Happy Constitution Day!. The Basics The Constitution is the highest law in the United States. All other laws come from the Constitution. It says how the.
Democracy is Overrated… Michael Munger Duke University November 7, 2005 X.
The Logic of Politics. Let’s assume people are: 1. self interested 2. rational.
Basic Concepts of Democracy
Origins of Western Democratic Liberalism Social 30-2.
Chapter 1, Section 1 “ If men were angels no government would be necessary. ” --James Madison, Federalist Paper No. 51.
Consider: What do you think are the most important “ends”, or purposes of government? What does government do that it shouldn’t? Homework: Assignment 2.
Chapter Four There are three basic economic questions which must be answered in order to determine the type of economy a nation has.
Economic Philosophy * adpoted from
Why Is Globalization So Controversial?
Class 6 Kant. Immanuel Kant (1724–1804) From Königsberg, Germany.
A New Nation The Articles of Confederation CHAPTER 5, SECTION 1 PAGES
18 | Public Economy Voter Participation and Costs of Elections Special Interest Politics Flaws in the Democratic System of Government.
Lecture 4: Liberty and Democracy: J. S. Mill The Foundations of Modern Social and Political Thought.
The Answer to the Question “What is Enlightenment”
VOTING IN CONGRESS: It’s More Than Just “Yea” or “Nay”
People and Government Chapter 1. Principles of Government Chapter 1 Section 1.
CHARACTERISTICS OF DEMOCRACY. SOME COUNTRIES CALL THEMSELVES DEMOCRATIC BUT THEY REALLY ARE NOT EX. DEMOCRATIC PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF KOREA (OLIGARCHY-COMMUNIST)
Introductions In an Argumentative Essay. What does a good introduction do?  Introduces the topic to the reader and gives some background – be specific.
PIGOU AND COASE The art of political economy. A.C. PIGOU
Preamble In our lives there may come a time when a person or people must break political ties which connected them with the British and other nations,
Social 30 Still Chapter 2. WORDS  Fundamental Rights  Self-Interest  Private Property  Mercantilism  Free Market Economy.
First 10 Amendments to the United States Constitution.
Principles of Government Chapter 1.  What would your lives be like if you had been free to do whatever you wanted without any parental oversight?  How.
Role of Government in a Free Society. Question Slide 1 1.What role should government play in a free society? 2.What should be the measure of whether it.
Introduction to Economics What do you think of when you think of economics?
COMENIUS MEETING THESSALONIKI Common Values
Global II Chapter 17, Section 2 The Enlightenment – Age of Reason READ: pg
3. TURNING STEPS Now we are not christians by being born into a christian family, confirmed, baptised, taking communion, reading your Bible, going to church,
1 Purposes and Origins of Government What is the purpose of government? What is the purpose of government? How is government defined? How is government.
Thomas Hobbes Background on Hobbes A product of the Puritan revolution and the English civil war. Royalist. Opposed to parliamentarianism and.
People and Government. Academic Vocabulary (Key terms): State Nation Sovereignty Government Autocracy Oligarchy Democracy Republic.
Essential Features of a State
Chapter 1 What is Economics?
Locke v Hobbes.
Chapter 1 Section 3 Mr. Plude.
God is not a Deceiver, Truth Criterion & Problem of Error
Presentation transcript:

Coherence and Legitimacy Can a group of people who disagree come to a consensus? How would this work? Why would we believe that the “consensus” is any more than an imperfect choice? Do the choices of majorities tell us anything about “the right thing to do” in the face of disagreement? Is there such a thing as “the majority,” which we just have to discover through voting or some political process? I want…you want…what do we want?

Institutional Design Institutions are the humanly devised rules of the game that shape and direct human interactions. Institutions reduce uncertainty by shrinking the choice set of all of the “players.” If the rules are not formalized, the players spend too much time arguing over the rules, and less time in productive activities. The actual choice of institutions, however, is hard, since there are countless ways of choosing. What makes some institutions better than others? In particular, is democracy a “good” institution? How would we know? What are the alternatives?

Coherence and Legitimacy I Four categories of activity: My money, my consumption: I’m careful and frugal Your money, my consumption: I’m extravagant, but I care about the service and will monitor it My money, your consumption: I will underprovide, though private charity does work more than you might think. And, it is crowded out by public spending. Your money, your consumption: I pay no attention to cost, and I pay no attention to quality of service. Welcome to “DMV World”!

Step back for a moment…. The Fundamental Human Problem (according to Munger) How can we construct or preserve institutions that make individual self-interest not inconsistent with the common good?

Two Approaches Madisonian “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition…” Rousseauvian Transform the self, solve the problem of amour propre. Inscribe the law on the hearts of men. Some preferences are better than others.

Markets and Government Markets, for the most part, focus on individual choice. I get what I want, you get what you want…. Collective processes, backed by government, focus on group choice. You get what you want, and I get what you want, too.

Origins of Markets Differences in endowments Differences in preferences Technical cost conditions (div of labor, economies of scale, increased dexterity, innovations in tool design)

Origins of Government Institutions Disagreement/exchange (B&T) Capture gains from trade by reducing transactions costs Make public goods possible

Origins of Government Institutions What if we all wanted the same thing? Would government even be necessary? It would. Because we do all want the same thing: more…. On disagreement, Charles IV: “My cousin Francis and I are in perfect accord—he wants Milan and so do I.”

“The” Right Thing There may not be any one right thing to do. It depends. It is the nature of collective choices that they are unitary: One defense budget, one standard for pollution, drive on one side of the highway, etc. Asking “What Will We Do?” begs the question. The real question is… Why Do You Think There is a ‘We’? Buchanan and Tullock’s “Two Levels”: Can’t let the majority decide what the majority gets to decide

Madisonian Institutions Markets—Smith’s baker Politics—Federalist #51: Men are not angels Men are not ruled by angels “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition…”

But it is asked how a man can be both free and forced to conform to wills that are not his own. How are the opponents at once free and subject to laws they have not agreed to? I retort that the question is wrongly put. The citizen gives his consent to all the laws, including those which are passed in spite of his opposition, and even those which punish him when he dares to break any of them…. (From The Social Contract) Democracy Unbound….Rousseau

When in the popular assembly a law is proposed, what the people is asked is not exactly whether it approves or rejects the proposal, but whether it is in conformity with the general will, which is their will…. When therefore the opinion that is contrary to my own prevails, this proves neither more nor less than that I was mistaken, and that what I thought to be the general will was not so. If my particular opinion had carried the day I should have achieved the opposite of what was my will; and it is in that case that I should not have been free. Democracy Unbound….

Loyal Opposition? This conception of democracy is logical. The actions of government are driven by the people; the general will is sovereign. Opposition to the general will is treason, and must be punished. No need for two parties: only one general will. All those countries with “Peoples’ Democratic Republic of ___” were not perversions of democracy, but examplars. That is what pure democracy, with no limits on scope, looks like. Cannot be otherwise. Democracy, in and of itself, is an attractive concept that must constitute a recipe for tyranny, unless the scope of collective sovereignty is strictly limited.

Che Guevara’s “Man and Socialism in Cuba” (1965). Society as a whole must become a huge school....We can see the new man who begins to emerge in this period of the building of socialism. His image is as yet unfinished; in fact it will never be finished, since the process advances parallel the development of new economic forms. Discounting those whose lack of education makes them tend toward the solitary road, towards the satisfaction of their ambitions, there are others who, even within this new picture of over-all advances, tend to march in isolation from the accompanying mass. What is more important is that people become more aware every day of the need to incorporate themselves into society and of their own importance as motors of that society