Assessment …..Finding a middle way Quality Assuring Assessment : A Local Authority view.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Being explicit about learning Focusing feedback on improvement Gathering evidence of learning Handing on responsibility for learning Participation Dialogue.
Advertisements

Planning for Learning and Teaching, Assessment and Moderation
Aberdeen City Council 2008 IMPROVEMENT CONFERENCE 1st APRIL 2009.
Curriculum for Excellence Aberdeen City November 2008.
School Based Assessment and Reporting Unit Curriculum Directorate
Fox Covert Primary School
Moderation as part of learning, teaching and assessment Transforming lives through learning George M Sinclair.
Head of Learning: Job description
Head teacher Performance Management
A Curriculum for Excellence Holyrood R. C. Sec
What is moderation and why should we moderate?
© Myra Young Assessment All rights reserved. Provided for the use of participants in AM circles in North Lanarkshire Council.
3 to 18 Curriculum Early Level - pre-school to P1 First Level – P2 to end of P4 Second Level – P5 to P7 Third and Fourth Level – S1- S3. Many pupils will.
Transforming lives through learning Assessing Progress and Achievement Professional Learning Resource Scottish Learning Festival September 2014.
1 ASSESSMENT: THE SCOTTISH PERSPECTIVE ‘Assessment is for Learning’ Carolyn Hutchinson Qualifications, Assessment and Curriculum Scottish Executive Education.
Moving forward with Curriculum for Excellence Phil Denning HMI.
British Nutrition Foundation Conference Update from Learning Teaching Scotland (LTS) Liz Nicoll – Development Officer Health & Wellbeing September 2010.
© NACE 2012 Aspiration Ability & Achievement Dyhead, Dawn a Chyrhaeddiad Leading and Managing for More Able and Talented Pupils.
Transforming lives through learning Profiling and Profiles Sheila Quigley.
Building the Curriculum 5 BHS Parents 18 May. What is Building the Curriculum 5 about? For many years teachers have been concerned that assessment has.
© Myra Young Assessment All rights reserved. Provided for the use of participants in AM circles in North Lanarkshire Council.
Curriculum for Excellence Primary School Leadership Conferences
In Crookfur Primary School.  5-14 Assessment  Standardised Test information  Gathered assessment information termly  Target Setting  Skills planner.
February 2005SEED AifL1 ASSESSMENT IN SCOTLAND: ‘ASSESSMENT IS FOR LEARNING’ Formative Assessment in a Coherent System.
Monitoring and Tracking Progress and Achievement in the context of 5
The Education Adjustment Program Profile – Revised.
DOES LEADERSHIP MAKE A DIFFERENCE? 1 The importance of school leadership on the quality of schools and the achievements of pupils:
Curriculum for Excellence: Delivering More Choices and More Chances for Scotland’s Young People Suzanne Rennie Scottish Government.
Building Our Curriculum
Overall Teacher Judgements
© Myra Young Assessment All rights reserved. Provided for the use of participants in AM circles in North Lanarkshire Council.
Transforming lives through learning Profiling 3-18.
Curriculum and Assessment in Northern Ireland
Improving Assessment, Improving Learning Ken Greer, Executive Director (Education), Fife Council CEM Conference, Glasgow 24 th March 2011 Implementing.
Transforming lives through learning Arts and culture education ‘Content and outcomes in Scotland‘ Education Scotland September 2013.
October ISIS – Cluster Moderation Assessment and moderation in CfE is a process, not an event! Aims of the morning: To further inform participants in the.
Transforming lives through learning Curriculum Expectations Sadie Cushley HMIE Feb 2014.
Transforming lives through learningDocument title Edinburgh Learning Festival May 2015 The Broad General Education – From Good to Great Planning, documenting.
Preparing for Inspection Nov 2013 Primary QIO team.
Transforming lives through learning Evaluating and improving our curriculum S1-S3 This resource provides a clear and concise.
Our Curriculum Journey Duloch Primary and Nursery Our Curriculum Journey Duloch Primary and Nursery.
Raising standards, improving lives The use of assessment to improve learning: the evidence 15 September Jacqueline White HMI National Adviser for Assessment.
Workshops to support the implementation of the new languages syllabuses in Years 7-10.
Transforming lives through learning Sheila Quigley Development Officer Assessment, Qualifications, Quality assurance & Moderation
George Smuga 21/22 October, 2008 Seo e Feuch e Professional Adviser, Curriculum Division, Scottish Government.
‘The best way to predict the future is to invent it’ Teacher assessment and MCP ‘The best way to predict the future is to invent it’ Presentation to Dorset.
Teacher-led assessment (TA) Implications for qualifications and assessment?
The National Improvement Framework - vision
Profiles Key Principles. What is a profile? A profile is a snapshot of a child or young person’s best achievements at a given point in time. It is one.
The Literacy and Numeracy Secretariat Le Secrétariat de la littératie et de la numératie October – octobre 2007 The School Effectiveness Framework A Collegial.
© Crown copyright 2008 Subject Leaders’ Development Meeting Spring 2009.
Transforming lives through learning
Curriculum for Excellence update Current developments Trialling Response to feedback Exemplification and guidance Refinement and revision Recognition.
The School Effectiveness Framework
Assessment Information Evening 17 th September 2015.
Community Authority An LAs Perspective on Monitoring and Assessment Sandra LoveMary Devine Head of Service (Quality)Quality Manager.
National Improvement Framework for Scottish Education.
The Literacy and Numeracy Secretariat Le Secrétariat de la littératie et de la numératie October – octobre 2007 The School Effectiveness Framework A Collegial.
Advancing teaching: inspiring able learners every day Meeting the Challenge 14 th November 2012.
‘Education has for its purpose not the imparting of particular knowledge but the strengthening of mental faculties’ (Kant c1770)
Strategic Improvement Plan Inverclyde Council Education Services Establishment Name: St Ninian’s Primary Head of Establishment: Mary Reilly Date:September.
April 2016 Marie Keen Quality Improvement Officer – Early Years
Raising standards improving lives The revised Learning and Skills Common Inspection Framework: AELP 2011.
Strategic Improvement Plan Inverclyde Council Education Services Establishment Name: St Columba’s High School Head of Establishment: Jim Docherty Date:June.
Building Our Curriculum Louise Turnbull Head Teacher Livingston Village Primary School All for the children, for all of the children!
EDU704 – Assessment and Evaluation
Self-Evaluation Cycle for Governing Bodies
Raising Aspirations in Science Education
The MODERATION cycle.
The National and Local context
Presentation transcript:

Assessment …..Finding a middle way Quality Assuring Assessment : A Local Authority view

Fife Context  Second/third biggest LA (55,000 pupils)  Lean Management  Largest schools in Scotland to the smallest  Focus on Attainment and Quality Improvement  Increase in 5-14 for the last 7 years  Increase in SQA in the last 2 years  Personalised e-assessment (4 years); PIPS (10 years)  A focus on Tracking and Monitoring (E1)

National Context – what is in place  National Debate, AIFL, 4 Capacities  National Collection of 5-14 results discontinued  Curriculum Framework  Skills for learning, life and work  Assessment Framework  Outcomes and Experiences  Commencement of NAR within GLOW  BTC 5 and BTC 3 condensed

National Context – what is not yet in place  Success Criteria/standards/milestones of progress  Clarity on progression pathways  National approach to moderation that will lead to consistent, valid and reliable judgements  Clear Reporting Processes  Confidence that our OECD results will improve  Clarity on the qualifications performance criteria (Senior Phase)  Clarity on the way success will be measured at a pupil/school/LA level particularly in the senior phase

Strategy Energy, Enthusiasm, Enablement, Enrichment  Purpose - agreeing the philosophy  Principles - agreeing the outcomes  Pragmatism - agreeing the actions/timescales

Enablement  Head Teachers leading strategic groups at all levels  Power Point presentations with notes  Reflective questions  An assessment plan outlining actions and timescales and outcomes  Suggested activities with resources for use with school staff and across the cluster

Purpose  Accelerating the learning of individual pupils  Assuring learners and Accountability to interested third parties  Access to further learning opportunities.  Accrediting and Awarding learning against a national and, if possible, international benchmark.

Assessment for Learning Learners learn best when...  they understand clearly what they are trying to learn, and what is expected of them  they are given feedback about the quality of their work and what they can do to make it better  they are given advice about how to go about making improvements  they are fully involved in deciding what needs to be done next, and who can give them help if they need it

Assessment as learning  Share learning intentions, success criteria, Learning Goals  Learning through dialogue and self and peer assessment, effective questioning  Metacognition- Learners become aware of how they learn.  Learners participate more in the process of learning.

Assessment of learning Judgments about pupils’ learning and progress need to be dependable. This means that:  they are VALID (based on sound criteria)  they are RELIABLE (accuracy of assessment and practice)  and they are COMPARABLE (they stand up when compared to judgments in other departments or schools).

Principles  Assessment should be valid  Assessment should be reliable and consistent  Assessment information should be explicit, accessible and transparent  Assessment should be inclusive and equitable  Assessment should be an integral part of curriculum design relating directly to the O’s and E’s  Assessment should be manageable  Assessment should promote improvements in learning by providing timely feedback  CPD in Assessment should be planned for

Polarised views  “Teacher assessment is unfair because it is unreliable and biased”  “Exams are simply snapshots and are unrepresentative of the work that has really been done”

Trusting teachers’ judgement Harlen 2005 “The findings of the review by no means constitute a ringing endorsement of teachers’ assessment; there was evidence of low reliability and bias in teachers’ judgements”

Assessment Hypothesis The best teachers will make the best judgments about pupils’ achievements and what next steps they need to do to take to improve further.

Use of assessment information WE DO WANT:  Validity, Reliability  Predictability  Public and professional confidence in our assessment system  Clarity for learners and their parents in the way assessment is reported  Clear impact on pupils progress

Use of assessment Information WE DO NOT WANT:  League tables  A blame culture  Increased teacher workload  Constant high stakes testing which limits creativity in the curriculum

Personalised E-assessment  Does NOT replace teachers’ judgement  Does NOT replace all the other assessment information  Does Not lead to a blame culture  Does NOT reduce creativity in the classroom  Does significantly reduce teacher work load  Improves reliability and validity assessment of judgements  Provides diagnostic information on pupils progress, class, year, school, LA

Assessment: which matters most? 1.Economy/Society 2.LA 3.School 4.Teacher 5.Parents 6.Pupil

Diagnostic – multi level  Macro diagnostic – what you do with schools and cohorts (E1)  Micro diagnostic – what you do with pupil information (E1)

More deprivedLess deprived Macro diagnostic

Q: does this relationship persist across years?

Macro diagnostic

More deprived Less deprived

Micro diagnostic

Goodhart’s Law When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.

Teacher reliability  How should reliability be assessed – By looking at the internal consistency of judgements? – By looking at the link to external assessments? – By comparing over time? – By comparing one teacher with others?  Facets model within Rasch measurement

Personalised E- assessment Summative test (Std Grade/ Highers) Teachers/pupils Assessment (with moderation) Later success – job, degree, salary etc Assessment: Predictive validity

Finding the Middle Ground  AIFL  Communicating clearly with parents, Reporting  Defining the standards/success criteria (child development)  Personalised e-assessment  Meaningful Moderation (reliable, valid)  Senior Phase- assessment systems and qualifications systems are contiguous  Sensitive but serious accountability - analysing the LA/school/teacher effect

Pragmatism: We need to 1.Actively promote AIFL strategies 2.Know what success looks like 3.Have effective policy on the use of assessment information 4.Reduce teacher workload but improve the reliability and validity of the assessment system 5.Communicate clearly with parents 6.Measure what we value and celebrate progress 7.Ensure that pace and challenge are not dissipated 8.Adapt personalised e-assessments to CFE outcomes 9.Be clear on what we mean by moderation 10.Ensure that assessment systems and qualification systems cohere

Pragmatism : KISS principle Application Higher order thinking skills challenge breadth HOW WELL HOW MUCH LEARNERS’ RATE OF PROGRESS A new language (BTC5)

Pragmatism – Action Plan  Draft reporting template will be disseminated for consultation (June)  Communication strategy for parents is developed (June)  Timetable for the phasing out of 5-14 assessments (June)  A Fife Success Criteria (the standards) will be developed for Numeracy and Literacy  The Implementation plan for moderation and embedding AIFL strategies,  E- assssment – All our schools for May/June 2011 in Reading, and Numeracy is established. P1,3,5,7,S2/3  A draft Curriculum and Assessment/ Qualification paper supporting the Senior Phase and the revised SQA framework to be developed (October)

Appeal: Finding a middle way Support Leadership Accountability for Children’s development