High Efficiency Evaporator Coils for Medium Temperature Cases Dustin Bailey, Engineer PECI Jan 5, 2010.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Add Doors to Open Multi-deck Cases: Provisional UES RTF Meeting August 30,
Advertisements

GrocerSmart 4.0 redesign -request for rtf input- February 25, 2010.
Transformer De-Energizing & Dairy Plate Heat Exchanger Standard Protocol Proposal Presentation to the RTF February 20, 2013.
MENG 547 LECTURE 3 By Dr. O Phillips Agboola. C OMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL BUILDING ENERGY AUDIT Why do we audit Commercial/Industrial buildings Important.
Grocery Store Measures
School Measure Proposals for Small and Rural Utilities.
Evaluation of Energy Savings for Strip Curtains Presented To RTF Scott Moore PECI Sr. Engineer June 2, 2009.
Out-Of-Compliance Grocery UES Measure Recommendations Regional Technical Forum June 17, 2014.
NEEM Manufactured Homes Field Test Results David Baylon, Ecotope.
Utility Analysis. Baseline Electricity Analysis  Understanding and documenting current energy use is called developing a baseline. Developing a baseline:
Grocery Measure: LEDs for Reach-In Display Cases Regional Technical Forum July 21 st, 2015 Mohit Singh-Chhabra.
Energy Valve Delta T Manager
LED Case Lighting With and Without Motion Sensors Michele Friedrich – Sr. Engineer PECI 1/5/2010.
Floating Head Pressure for Refrigeration Single Compressor Systems Michele Friedrich, PE – Sr. Engineer Dustin Bailey – Engineer PECI 11/2/2010.
PORTLAND ENERGY CONSERVATION, INC. Findings for: LED lighting for NEW cases January 1, 2008.
Regional Technical Forum July 1st, 2008 Presented by Ryan Fedie and Jamie Anthony Portland Energy Conservation, Inc.
Today’s “Game Plan” Two Trial-Runs of a new deemed measure review process – Deemed measure analysis and review Developed by … – (consultant, RTF member/staff,
1 Proposed Changes to the RTF’s Heat Pump Specifications Impact on Estimated Deemed Savings and C&R Discount Program Credits.
Night Covers on Open Vertical Cases Provisional UES Proposal Presentation to the Regional Technical Forum August 30,
Implementer’s Group April 2015 Meeting Debrief and Upcoming Meeting Prep April 24, 2015.
Retrofit Doors to Open Vertical Cases Provisional UES Proposal Presentation to the Regional Technical Forum August 30,
Commercial Refrigerators and Freezers
B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N BPA Energy Efficiency Preliminary Strategies for BPA Evaluations March 24, 2008.
Hawke’s Bay Refrigeration
Plans to bring Out-of-Compliance UES Measures back into Compliance: 1. Agricultural Irrigation Hardware UES 2. Agricultural Motors UES Regional Technical.
B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Commercial Windows and Insulation RTF November 2, 2010.
Out-Of-Compliance Grocery UES Measure Recommendations Regional Technical Forum March 18, 2014.
LED Case Lighting in Vertical and Semi-Vertical Open Refrigerated Cases Eric Mullendore – Energy Analyst PECI 6/29/2010.
EnergySmart Grocer Program Evaluation Findings Summary PWP, Inc.
GrocerSmart™ 4.0 RTF Subcommittee Approval of Adherence to Guidelines March 10, 2011.
Grocery Measure: EC Motors for Display Cases Regional Technical Forum July 21 st, 2015 Mohit Singh-Chhabra.
Grocery Measure: EC Motors for Display Cases Regional Technical Forum June 16 th, 2015 Mohit Singh-Chhabra.
Strip Curtains for Refrigerated Walk-in Boxes Michele Friedrich, PE – Sr. Engineer Eric Mullendore – Energy Analyst PECI 8/3/2010.
April, 2002Energy Audits1 April, 2002 Ryan Stroupe, Pacific Energy Center DeAnza College: ES 76 Energy Reliability and Your Organization Energy Auditing.
July 26, 2014 Refrigeration Subcommittee Proposed Revision of Refrigeration Provisional Data Requirements.
Anti-Sweat Heater Control Small Saver UES Measure Regional Technical Forum September 17, 2013.
Deemed Savings Update: ECMs in Display Cases Ben Cartwright PECI January 5, 2009.
1. LOW COST 2. SIMPLE 3. EFFICIENT. EER Energy Efficiency Ratio = Cooling Capacity in Btu / Hr Power Consumption in Watts.
Slide 1 B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Variable Capacity Heat Pump RTF Sub-Committee February 22, 2012 Mira Vowles, P.E., CEM.
EER Analysis Results Regional Technical Forum March 18, 2014.
Applying SEEM Updates, Calibration, and Measure Interaction Decisions to: Single Family Weatherization and HVAC UES Measures Follow-up from August RTF.
New Refrigeration Measures - FHP Status Report- & -Request for Input- September 21, 2010.
Overview of Seventh Plan Approach for EE Measures RTF November 18, 2014.
Slide 1 B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Energy Savings from Electric Water Heaters in Commercial Applications Danielle Gidding.
Arthur Rosenfeld, California Energy Commission Gregory Rosenquist, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory C. Keith Rice, Oak Ridge National Laboratory ARI.
EnergySmart Grocer. 2 BPA background  The Bonneville Power Administration contracted Cascade Energy Engineering, Inc. to evaluate the GrocerSmart audit.
Out-Of-Compliance UES Measure Recommendations Part 1 – November Measures Regional Technical Forum November 19, 2013.
GrocerSmart™ 4.0 RTF Approval of Software and Adherence to RTF Guidelines April 5, 2011.
Measurement and Verification of Refrigeration Measures in 4 Grocery Stores in Pacific County Presented to the Regional Technical Forum August 8 th, 2006.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council New Commercial Building Program Quest Presentation, Discussion and Decision of Proposed Approach to Estimating.
Analysis of Weatherization Measures Savings Methodology and Costs: Updated from 6 th Plan Regional Technical Forum June 1 st, 2010.
Grocery Store Issues RTF April 10, Need Recommendations PECI: Energy Smart Grocer Program Savings method for interactive measures Savings method.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council A Look At The Council’s Conservation Planning Methodology and Assumptions A Look At The Council’s Conservation.
Out-Of-Compliance Grocery UES Measure Recommendations Regional Technical Forum July 15, 2014.
Grocery VSD Measure Deemed Savings Reid Hart, PE & Ken Anderson September 28, 2010.
GrocerSmart TM Energy Modeling Software -Revision Status Report- & -Request For Input- July 13, 2010.
PNW RoofTop Unit Working Group - RTUG – RTU Savings Research Project Phase 3 December 15, 2009.
Regional Technical Forum Recommissioning commercial retail facilities: A whole building approach to energy savings April 7th, 2009 Presented by: Jeremy.
Slide 1 B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Variable Capacity Heat Pump Sub-Committee Road-Mapping Session BPA Energy Efficiency.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Energy Smart Grocer Update & Revisions RTF May 2007.
Hawaiienergy.com Graceson Ghen. hawaiienergy.com  Hawaii’s energy conservation and efficiency program  Administered by Leidos Engineering, LLC under.
GrocerSmart™ 4.0 RTF Approval of Software and Adherence to RTF Guidelines April 5, 2011.
Best practice small scale commercial refrigeration, optimisation strategies and simple maintenance Michael Bellstedt, Minus40 Pty Ltd.
DNV GL © 2016 SAFER, SMARTER, GREENER DNV GL © 2016 HVAC 3 Quality Maintenance Program Year Impact Evaluation.
New Refrigeration Measures -Status Report- & -Request for Input- September 13, 2010.
ANTONIO CORRADINI & M M VALMIKI, AESC MAY 26, 2016 High Efficiency PMSM Fan Assemblies for Refrigerated Case Evaporators - Abstract.
Regional Technical Forum May 27, 2008 Presented by Ryan Fedie and Jamie Anthony Portland Energy Conservation, Inc.
ANTONIO CORRADINI & M M VALMIKI, AESC JUNE 30, 2016 PMSM Fan Assemblies for Refrigerated Case Evaporators – Abstract Update.
HVAC-4 Deemed Measures Uncertainty Study, Year 2
Focus on Energy 2017 Program Overview
Presentation transcript:

High Efficiency Evaporator Coils for Medium Temperature Cases Dustin Bailey, Engineer PECI Jan 5, 2010

Acknowledgements We would like to thank the following utilities for support BPA PSE AVISTA

Purpose Deemed measure approval for upgrading evaporator coils from standard to high efficiency in new MT cases. Upgrading the coils provides savings independent of other component measures. Energy savings should be deemed based off total case load going to compressor system, independent of climate zones.

Agenda Background Description of Measure Compressor System Interaction Auxiliary Load Sensitivity Energy Savings Adjustments for Energy Savings Unitized Energy Savings Floating Suction Interactivity Energy Savings and Payback Measure Life Terms and Conditions Conclusion

Background - Measure Description Current measures are for complete case replacement. This causes the following problems: ◦only one baseline condition can get savings as defined as a “standard case” ◦efficient evaporator coil savings are often ignored Proposing measure for high efficiency evaporator coils for the critical case independent of other case component measures Modeled in eQUEST using the PECI GrocerSmart model as the template

Background - Efficient Coil Description of Proposed Scenario An efficient coil has more area than a standard coil allowing for the same heat transfer with a lower ΔT ◦Q=U*A*ΔT An efficient coil allows the suction group temp of the compressor rack to rise 3 deg F Depending on the type of product in the case, efficient coils allow for varying increases of saturated suction temperature (SST). 3 deg F is the smallest average increase and was chosen to be conservative.

Compressor Discharge Compressor Suction Background - Compressor System Energy Gap By allowing the SST of the compressor to rise, the power the compressor must exert is reduced. Energy savings is calculated for a multiplex system as shown below:

Background - MT Refrigeration System

Background - Model Data Description of Pre and Post Scenario Savings = 13,000 kWh Case Data for Baseline Case Type SST at Evap, deg F Coil Inlet Delta T (SST Supply TD), deg F Case Data for Proposed Case Type SST at Evap, deg F Coil Inlet Delta T (SST Supply TD), deg F MT_ProduceMulti-deck2812MT_ProduceMulti-deck2812 MT_Dairy2Multi-deck247MT_Dairy2Multi-deck247 MT_Dairy1Multi-deck247MT_Dairy1Multi-deck247 MT_Melon BakeryMulti-deck2110 MT_Melon BakeryMulti-deck2110 MT_Deli PastaMulti-deck2110 MT_Deli PastaMulti-deck2110 MT_Meat2Multi-deck2011MT_Meat2Multi-deck2011 MT_Meat3Multi-deck2011MT_Meat3Multi-deck2011 MT_Serv DeliMulti-deck2010 MT_Serv DeliMulti-deck2010 MT_Meat1Single-deck2011MT_Meat1Single-deck2011 MT_FishMulti-deck1611 Critical Case MT_FishMulti-deck198 Compressors14964,000 kWhCompressors17951,000 kWh

Background - Auxiliary Sensitivity Description of Baseline Different baselines with different auxiliary loads: ◦Lamp (T12, T8, LED) ◦Doors (Door, No Door, Efficient Door (no/low ASH)) ◦Evaporator Motors (SP, ECM, PSC) Conclusion: Since savings was independent of different baselines, T8 ND-ECM was chosen to be the representative case as it is a common retrofit case Base LineSavings LED D ECM12,792 LED D PSC12,811 LED D SP12,813 LED ED ECM12,790 LED ND ECM13,068 T8 D ECM12,928 T8 D PSC12,970 T8 D SP12,975 T8 ED ECM12,922 T8 ND ECM13,148 T12 D ECM12,965 T12 D PSC12,990 T12 D SP13,002 T12 ED ECM12,966 T12 ND ECM13,224 Average Motor Effect Average Door Effect Average Lighting Effect LED D LED ECM D ECM 0.28%1.92%1.37%

Adjustments for Energy Savings By increasing the SST of the critical load, the power of the compressor will decrease resulting in system energy savings. Key assumptions ◦The compressor set point (suction group set point) is 2 deg F less than needed by the critical case ◦Efficient coils will decrease the TD by 3 degrees (averaged data from various manufacturers) ◦Floating suction control is present on 26.9% of all refrigeration systems, and 21% (conservative) of the MT cases have doors (EnergySmart audit data) ◦Results were modeled using eQUEST with T8 ND ECM on the critical case in the PECI GrocerSmart Model

Unitized Energy Savings Before Floating Suction Interactivity Reduction of Suction Load (Btu/h) Reduction Ratio Reduction of Refrig Mass Flow (lb/hr) Reduction Ratio Reduction of Comp Power (kW) Reduction Ratio 4, , , ,149 1, Compressor power scaling with the reduction of suction load Weather ZoneEnergy Savings/ Suction Load (kWh/MBH) Boise, ID38.41 Pocatello, ID38.23 Billings, MT38.67 Portland, OR39.57 Burns, OR38.26 Seattle, WA39.24 Yakima, WA38.90 Spokane, WA38.61 Average38.74 Standard Dev0.48 % Dev1.2% Savings for various weather zones in the PNW without floating suction control

Floating Suction Interactivity Floating suction reduces available energy savings from the efficient coil measure Base Line Savings for Systems w/ FS With Doors3,664 kWh No Doors9,934 kWh Effect of doors on the evaporator savings for a multiplex system with floating suction control.

Energy Savings and Payback Total system MBH difficult to quantify Quantify saving per linear foot of total display case associated with compressor group Using GrocerSmart model as the prototypical grocery store: T8 ND-ECM model: – Assuming $0.10 per kWh this results in a savings of $2.75/ln ft of total system case length Cost data was collected from a variety of manuf for the coil upgrade and adjusted according to copper commodity prices –The conservative estimate for cost is $42.5/ ln ft EnergySmart audit data shows that the median number of cases replaced is 82 ft for a cost of $3,485 –Therefore, the typical store’s simple payback period can be calculated:

Typical Case Replacement Lengths Payback is proportional to the length of case replaced with HE coils and case length can vary from store to store.

Measure Life Assumptions Measure Life/Effective Useful Life is assumed to be the same as evaporator motors which have a life of 15 years ◦Southern California Edison 1, PG&E 2 and BPA 3 program all use 15 year measure life for ECMs » 1 Energy Savings Potential for Commercial Refrigeration Equipment. June U. S. Department of Energy. Arthur D. Little. p 5-51 » 2 CALMAC Protocols, Appendix F, Effective Useful Live Values for Major Energy Efficiency Measures, September 2000 » 3 Council Plan 1996; 15 year EUL used for all Retrofit HVAC Systems & Controls including motor retrofits

Must replace an existing medium temperature evaporator standard coil with a high efficiency coil on the critical case(s) to result in a compressor suction group saturated suction temperature rise of at least 3 degrees. This is done through case replacement and several cases may need to be replaced to ensure the resulting critical case(s)’ coil(s) are replaced. A design review is required by the program to confirm the which cases must be replaced. The savings of this measure are independent of other case component measures and those measures may be claimed separately. If several suction groups exist this measure may be applied to each individually. Terms and Conditions

Conclusion Measure provides large opportunity for savings through more efficient operation of a refrigeration compressor system Efficient evaporators coils must be in the critical case The calculated savings is for a multiplex system with a rise of 3 degrees of SST Floating suction controls reduce available energy savings efficient evap coils factored into the unitized energy savings Cost variability—based on the total length of the critical case replaced Requesting approval for high efficiency evaporator coils for medium temperature cases as a measure