ISO/IEC JTC1/SC7 WG42 Upcoming NWIP for IS Architecture Evaluation Invitation to IEEE for Early Informal Comments at WICSA 2011 Workshop on Standards for (software) Architecture 24 June 2011 Steven W. Mitchell, US TAG Lockheed Martin Fellow

Agenda ISO/IEC – Architecture Evaluation Forward Plan Actors and Use Cases Consolidated Activities Preliminary Conceptual Architecture Conformance Concept IEEE Feedback Missed or Erroneous Use Cases Missing Architectural Concepts Other Comments and Suggestions

Plan for Architecture Evaluation Overview of IS NWIP Schedule Extended Process (4 years from NWIP to IS) July 2011 NWIP going out for ballot Nov 2011 prepare WD1 May 2012 prepare WD NWIP Ballot Will Be Accompanied by Annotated Outline including key diagrams

IS Outline Table of Contents

IS Users

42030 Use Case Model

IS Architecture Quality Use Cases

IS Architecture Description Quality Use Cases

IS Concerns and Inference Use Cases

IS Decision Use Cases

IS Process Use Cases

Consolidated activities Assess Architecture Assess Implications of Findings Review the Findings Frame the Problem Communica te Results Determine the Analysis Techniques and Tools Assess Findings Collect and Understand Required Info time Manage AE (Plan, Monitor, Assess, Control, Learn) Develop Recom mendati ons Determine Evaluation Critera

IS Architecture Description Evaluation

IS Architecture Evaluation

Conformance Concept The requirements in this International Standard are contained in Clauses 6, 7 and 8. An Architecture Evaluation conforms to this International Standard if it satisfies the requirements of Clauses 6 and 7. An Architecture Review Method conforms to this International Standard if it satisfies the requirements of Clause 7 A Software Product delivering capabilities of Architecture Evaluation conforms to this International Standard if it satisfies the requirements of Clause 8.

IEEE Feedback Missing or Erroneous Use Cases Missing Architectural Concepts Other Comments and Suggestions

Thank You For Your Comments and Suggestions!