Observation in BaBar of a narrow resonance in the D + s  0 system at 2317 MeV Roger Barlow Manchester University For the B A B AR Collaboration.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Phi-Psi, Feb.-Mar., 2006, S.Uehara1 Experimental studies of charmonia in two-photon collisions at Belle S.Uehara (KEK) for the Belle Collaboration e +
Advertisements

1 Charged Z’s at Ruslan Chistov (ITEP, Moscow) Representing the Belle Collaboration Quarkonium Working Group Workshop (Nara, NWU, December 2-5/2008) ●
Determination of the J PC of the X(3872) (Reviews of BN800) S.L. Olsen & S.K. Choi Apr, 2005 Belle General Meeting.
Excited Charm and K0sK0s Resonance Production at ZEUS V. Aushev For the ZEUS Collaboration XXXIX International Symposium on Multiparticle Dynamics ''Gold.
Measurement of non BB Decays of Y(4S) to Y(1S)     and Y(2S)     Silvano Tosi Università & INFN Genova.
Measurements of sin2  from B-Factories Masahiro Morii Harvard University The BABAR Collaboration BEACH 2002, Vancouver, June 25-29, 2002.
August 12, 2000DPF Search for B +  K + l + l - and B 0  K* 0 l + l - Theoretical predictions and experimental status Analysis methods Signal.
S-Waves & the extraction of  s Sheldon Stone FPCP 2010, Torino, Italy, May 2010.
Study of B  D S ( * )  D*  *   and D ( * ) (4  )   at CLEO Jianchun Wang Syracuse University Representing The CLEO Collaboration DPF 2000 Aug 9.
Radia 1 group Mtg, 05/10/2006 D S Selection Loose cut on D s Mbc, Introduction At the 4170, the  * was proven to decay mostly into D * D *, DD *, and.
Sep. 29, 2006 Henry Band - U. of Wisconsin 1 Hadronic Charm Decays From B Factories Henry Band University of Wisconsin 11th International Conference on.
16 May 2002Paul Dauncey - BaBar1 Measurements of CP asymmetries and branching fractions in B 0   +  ,  K +  ,  K + K  Paul Dauncey Imperial College,
1 Measurement of f D + via D +   + Sheldon Stone, Syracuse University  D o D o, D o  K -  + K-K- K+K+ ++  K-K- K+K+ “I charm you, by my once-commended.
DPF Victor Pavlunin on behalf of the CLEO Collaboration DPF-2006 Results from four CLEO Y (5S) analyses:  Exclusive B s and B Reconstruction at.
Evidence for Narrow D s  0 and D s   0 states Jianchun Wang 05/09/03 Directly involved: Dave Cinabro Selina Li Sheldon Stone Jon Urheim Jianchun Wang.
New Particles at BELLE Beauty 2005 Assisi Spectroscopy and new Particles F. Mandl There is an impressive list of new particles in the charm sector discovered.
Pinning down the J PC values of the X(3872) K. Miyabayashi for S.K. Choi & S.L. Olsen Feb, 2005 Belle Analysis & Software Meeting.
Hot Topics from BaBar Fabrizio Bianchi INFN, Torino (on behalf of the BaBar Collaboration) Direct CP Violation in (hep-ex/ ) Observation of and search.
16 April 2005 APS 2005 Search for exclusive two body decays of B→D s * h at Belle Luminda Kulasiri University of Cincinnati Outline Motivation Results.
Τ ± → π ± π + π - π 0 ν τ decays at BaBar Tim West, Jong Yi, Roger Barlow The University of Manchester Carsten Hast, SLAC IOP HEP meeting Warwick, 12 th.
12/14/021 Measurements of the Branching Fractions and Helicity Amplitudes in B  D*  Decays Authors: Guangpei Chen, Roy A. Briere Intended for: PRD (RC)
B decays to charm hadrons at Belle M.-C. Chang Fu Jen Catholic University (On behalf of Belle Collaboration) European Physical Society HEP2007 International.
1 BaBar Collaboration Randall Sobie Institute for Particle Physics University of Victoria.
Sergio Grancagnolo Activity Summary 9 Jan work in BaBar The apparatus Physics with BaBar Data analysis.
Discovery of D sJ (2463) + (part II) JC Wang CLEO Meeting 06/20/03 Authors Dave Cinabro Selina Li Sheldon Stone Jon Urheim Jianchun Wang Committees Roy.
B Production and Decay at DØ Brad Abbott University of Oklahoma BEACH 2004 June 28-July 3.
Analysis work by: Marina Artuso Sheldon Stone Jianchun Wang CBX note available: /homes/cleo/sls/dompi.ps Study of B  D   Jianchun Wang 05/12/00.
Study of e + e  collisions with a hard initial state photon at BaBar Michel Davier (LAL-Orsay) for the BaBar collaboration TM.
Analysis work by: Rachid Ayad Sheldon Stone Jianchun Wang CBX note available: /homes/cleo/sls/ds4pi.ps Status of B  D  (4  )   analysis Jianchun.
Measurement of B (D + →μ + ν μ ) and the Pseudoscalar Decay Constant f D at CLEO István Dankó Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute representing the CLEO Collaboration.
Resonances in decay for 400fb -1 DC Meeting April 10th, 2006 J.Brodzicka, H.Palka INP Kraków J.Brodzicka, H.Palka INP Kraków B +  D 0 D 0 K + B +  D.
Low-x Wshop, , Prague Jan Hladký, Exotic Anti-Charm Baryon State 1 Evidence for a Narrow Exotic Anti-Charmed Baryon State *) Jan Hladký, Institute.
Charmonium Production at BaBar Jamie Boyd University of Bristol Photon 2003, Frascati 7 th -11 th April 2003 On behalf of the Collaboration.
Charmed Meson Spectroscopy Robert K. Kutschke Fermilab HQL04 June 4, 2004.
Rare B  baryon decays Jana Thayer University of Rochester CLEO Collaboration EPS 2003 July 19, 2003 Motivation Baryon production in B decays Semileptonic.
cc spectroscopy at elle S.L.Olsen Hawaii QWG 2004 Worksop IHEP Beijing _.
Kalanand Mishra April 27, Branching Ratio Measurements of Decays D 0  π - π + π 0, D 0  K - K + π 0 Relative to D 0  K - π + π 0 Giampiero Mancinelli,
New Observations on Light Hadron Spectroscopy at BESIII Yanping HUANG For BESIII Collaboration Institute of High Energy Physics (IHEP) ICHEP2010, Paris,
Andrzej Bożek (IFJ PAN, Kraków) B hadron decays to open charm production in B-factories BEACH B hadron decays to open charm at B-factories A.Bożek.
New hadrons BaBar Maurizio Lo Vetere University of Genova & INFN Representing the Collaboration Particles and Nuclei International Conference.
P.Pakhlov ITEP, Moscow (for Belle collaboration) e+e- collision from  to  Novosibirsk, BINP, 2006.
Scalar and pseudoscalar mesons at BESII Xiaoyan SHEN (Representing BES Collaboration) Institute of High Energy Physics, CAS, China Charm06, June 5-7, 2006,
New Resonances at Belle Jolanta Brodzicka INP Kraków, for the Belle Collaboration ICFP 2005 October 4 th, 2005 Taiwan Outline  ‘ old’ X(3872) properties.
Φ→Ψ, BINP, Novosibirsk.2011P. Pakhlov Phys. Lett. B702, 139 (2011) Charged charmonium-like states as rescattering effects in B  D sJ D (*) P. Pakhlov.
Mitchell Naisbit University of Manchester A study of the decay using the BaBar detector Mitchell Naisbit – Elba.
Matthew Martin Johns Hopkins University for the CDF collaboration andBranching Ratios from Flavor Physics & CP Violation Ecole Polytechnique, Paris, France.
Andrzej Bożek (IFJ PAN, Kraków) B hadron decays to open charm production in B-factories BEACH B hadron decays to open charm production in B-factories.
Kalanand Mishra June 29, Branching Ratio Measurements of Decays D 0  π - π + π 0, D 0  K - K + π 0 Relative to D 0  K - π + π 0 Giampiero Mancinelli,
1 Hadron Spectroscopy at BABAR BY Usha Mallik (University of Iowa) Representing The BaBar Collaboration The International Light-Cone Workshop July 7, 2005.
Light Hadron Spectroscopy at BESIII Haolai TIAN (On behalf of the BESIII Collaboration) Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing 23rd Rencontre de Blois.
E. Robutti Enrico Robutti I.N.F.N. Genova HEP 2003 Europhysics Conference July 17-23, Aachen, Germany Recent BABAR results in Charmonium and Charm Spectroscopy.
1 Recent Results on J/  Decays Shuangshi FANG Representing BES Collaboration Institute of High Energy Physics, CAS International Conference on QCD and.
Charm Mixing and D Dalitz analysis at BESIII SUN Shengsen Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing (for BESIII Collaboration) 37 th International Conference.
Baryon Spectroscopy and Decays using the Belle Detector John Yelton University of Florida I review recent results on charmed baryon decay,
Paper Committee: Moneti(chair?), Danko, Ehrlich, Galik 1 OCT 21, 2006.
D. Bettoni - The Panda experiment 1 Charmonium Spectroscopy The charmonium system has often been called the positronium of QCD. Non relativistic potential.
Observation of the DsJ(2463)Dspo & Confirmation of the DsJ(2317)Dspo
Introduction to DsJ Analysis and D(*)D(*) reconstruction at CDF
DsJ* ‘s & charmed strange baryons at Belle
B  at B-factories Guglielmo De Nardo Universita’ and INFN Napoli
University of Minnesota on behalf of the CLEO Collaboration
Pentaquark Searches and DsJ Studies in BaBar
Charmed Baryon Spectroscopy and Decays using the Belle Detector
Study of excited baryons at BESII
Study of e+e- pp process using initial state radiation with BaBar
e+e−→ J/ D(*)D(*) & ψ(4160) → DD
Study of e+e collisions with a hard initial state photon at BaBar
New States Containing Charm at BABAR
New Spectroscopy with Charm quarks at B factories.
Observation of non-BBar decays of (4S)p+p- (1S, 2S)
Presentation transcript:

Observation in BaBar of a narrow resonance in the D + s  0 system at 2317 MeV Roger Barlow Manchester University For the B A B AR Collaboration

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 2 Data fb -1 On and off  (4S) Search for D + s and   : Require –  3 tracks –  2 photons over 100 MeV –FW moments H 2 /H 0 <0.9

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 3   selection Both E  > 100 MeV   fit probability >1% Neither  shared with another   candidate Peak and sidebands

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 4 selection(1) Kaon id from DIRC & dE/dx via Neural network Vertex fit P>0.1% Peaks from D + (1869) D + s (1970) D *+ (2010)  D 0  + D+D+ D+sD+s D* +

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 5 M(K + K - )<1.84 GeV M(K + K - )  M(  ) or M(K  )  M(K*)  or K* decays with |Cos  h |>0.5 p*(K + K -  +  0 )>2.5 GeV Signal and sidebands shown 80K D + s in signal region selection(2) D+sD+s D+D+

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 6 The signal Large (unexpected) peak in D + s   mass at 2.32 GeV Named as D* sJ (2317) + Small spike from D* + s just on kinematic limit ? D + sJ (2317)

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 7 Check# 1 Monte Carlo Reproduces D + s  but no D* sJ (2317) + D+D+ D+sD+s

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 8 Check# 2 Sidebands  0  sidebands No signal present M(K + K -  +  0 ) from sidebands in yellow D + s  sidebands

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 9 Check# 3 Different D + s decays Seen in both D + s   and D + s  K*K Also in D + s  K + K -     at the same mass D + sJ (2317)

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 10 Check# 4 Reflections Particle ID? –Take events: reassign K as . –No sign of D + or D 0 or D* D* + s (2112)  D + s  + extra  No: Antiselecting M(D + s  2112) enhances peak at 2317

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 11 Properties#1 p* dependence Signal enhanced at high p* As expected from e + e  c  c production (Momentum of D* + sJ (2317) in CMS)

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 12 Properties#2 Mass Take p*>3.5 GeV Gaussian + polynomial Peak at  0.4 MeV 1267  53 signal events Systematic uncertainty below 3 MeV

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 13 Properties#3 Width Single Gaussian Standard Deviation 8.6  0.4 MeV MC (revised) predicts 7.5  0.3 MeV Measurement of D + s  K + K -  +  0 gives 6.7  0.1 MeV Observed width compatible with our mass resolution  10 MeV

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 14 Properties#4 Angular Distribution Plot helicity angle of   in D* + sJ (2317) frame Correct for efficiency Consistent with being flat: Suggests J=0. (Or unpolarised and J=anything)

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 15 Properties#5 Other modes Not seen in –D + s  –D* + s (2112)  –D + s  –D + s    –D + s     D* + s (2112)

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 16 Comment on D + s    Care needed! Peaks at D s  0 (2317) and D s  (2112) combine to give reflection with M(D s  0  )  2460 No peak at 2317 But new peak appears at 2460 Enhanced when M(D + s  )  2112=M(D* + s )

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 17 Interpretation A c  s state: D* s Below threshold for DK, D*K D s  decay violates isospin, hence narrow Parity conservation  J P =0 +, 1 -,2 + … 0 + plausible from Cos  distribution L=1 radial excitation. But other L=1 states (1 + and 2 + ) are at 2536, 2573 Q  q potential models predict 0 + at M= << 2480 Either re-think theory or include hybrid

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 18 Confirmation Confirmed by CLEO and BELLE Mass and width and decay modes consistent. CLEO also claim D* + s (2463) in D* + s (2112)  0

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 19 The Peak in D* + s   BaBar There is a peak at 2.46 GeV Some of it is a reflection of the How much is still under study. Great care is required. Even if this peak is a resonance, it cannot account for all the 2317 signal CLEO There is a peak at GeV Some, but not all of it, is a reflection of the 2317 Some of the 2317 is a reflection of the 2463 If it exists, careful extraction of yields, masses and widths is needed. Work in progress…

Roger Barlow: FPCP Paris 2003Slide 20 Conclusions BaBar has observed an unexpected narrow resonance: the D* + sJ (2317) Decays to D + s   Spin-parity compatible with 0 + Confirmed by CLEO and BELLE