Students’ experiences of ability grouping – disaffection, polarisation and the construction of failure.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Effects of different types of praise on primary pupils.
Advertisements

The experiences of students in junior cycle Emer Smyth, Allison Dunne, Merike Darmody, Selina McCoy.
How does collaborative group work affect science learning?
Ofsted ITE Inspection Briefing PCET trainees, ex-MMU PCET trainees, Course Team Leaders, Mentors and Quality Managers.
Increasing students’ motivational efforts in mathematics.
Pupil voice: comfortable and uncomfortable for teachers.
Gender inequality in the primary classroom: can interactive whiteboards help?
What makes a successful transition from Primary to Secondary School? What makes a successful transition from Primary to Secondary School ?
Primary teachers as readers. Key issue addressed by the study  This study set out to explore: –primary teachers’ personal reading habits and their perceptions.
Benefits of pupils mentoring student teachers. Key issue addressed by the study  The study looked at a school-university project where pupils acted as.
Closing the progress gap. Key issues addressed by the study This study explored: – approaches to closing the gap for disadvantaged pupils –effective leadership.
Quality First Teaching In Any Subject From Good to Outstanding
Pupil grouping – Any system of grouping pupils together – whether within a school, a pupil cohort, a class or a lesson Streaming – A system of grouping.
Crampton OFSTED “The school vision is evident everywhere and mutual respect and success for all are at the heart of the school’s work”.
The role of communication in co-operative learning.
Student views about homework Toby Leonard Eleanor Scott Jessica Hollis Nima Habibzadeh Lauren Danbury Alice Ward.
Labelling and anti-school subcultures LOs: I can describe what labelling is. I can explain how labelling can affect a student’s educational achievement.
The impact of peer- assisted sentence- combining teaching on primary pupils’ writing.
The impact of IWBs on literacy and numeracy teaching in primary schools Professor Steven Higgins School of Education Durham University
How does classroom discussion and questioning affect students’ learning?
Improving the quality of talk to support pupil learning.
History: what do students think?. Key issue addressed by the study   This study aimed to: – –reveal the ideas about history which young people bring.
Growth Mindsets.
Planning for challenge. Key issues addressed by the study This study explored:This study explored: –the extent to which pupils are challenged in their.
Does ICT help reduce teacher workload?. Key issue addressed by the study  The study, part of a larger evaluation, explored –what difference computers,
Key issue addressed by the study
Removing barriers to literacy. Key issue addressed by the study  The study set out to identify factors associated with raising attainment in literacy.
Key strategies for Planning for challenge For further school friendly resources visit For further school friendly resources.
TCN – General Points Not a method for monitoring teaching methods but a means to look at the impact changes in our teaching can have on pupils. Not a method.
Starcross Primary School YEAR 6 SATS MEETING. Aims of the meeting: to inform you about Year 6 SATs to inform you about Year 6 SATs to encourage you to.
Another New Framework Major Changes: No more satisfactory 2 strikes and you are out All criteria changed Very short notice No pre-inspection brief.
Bradfield CE (VA) Primary School School Development Priorities
How classroom talk supports reading comprehension.
Improving standards in learning and teaching: the role of the subject leader in moderating work samples.
Some reflections from Fairlands Middle School Peter Elmy
Improving the quality of collaboration through students’ talk, questioning and thinking during group work.
OFSTED: Parents’ meeting WHAT THE INSPECTORS DIDN’T TELL YOU… OFSTED Inspection 21st-22nd February 2013.
Hertfordshire County Council Science Subject Leader Development Meeting April 5 th 2011.
Improving the quality of talk and questioning to support pupil learning.
Learning about other cultures through music. Key issue addressed by the study  This study explored pupils’ descriptions of their learning after two different.
Differentiating learning in the Literacy classroom.
Enquiry-based science teaching. Key issue addressed by the study  This study explored –the effectiveness of enquiry in supporting the teaching of science.
Lesson observations: evaluating the quality of teaching and learning.
Middle Leadership Programme Day 1: The Effective Middle Leader.
Pupil talk and critical thinking in science and citizenship.
Consulting secondary school pupils about their learning.
Closing the gap in reading. Key issue addressed by the study  This study: – explored the relationship between children’s social economic status and their.
1 SUPPORTING PEDAGOGICAL CHANGE IN NMR SCHOOLS PROJECT Briefing of NMR secondary schools 11 February, 2010 Jean Russell, Graeme Jane, Graham Marshall.
How does classroom discussion affect students’ learning? For further school friendly resources visit
‘Philosophy for Children’: deepening learning. The impact of ‘thinking through philosophy’ on pupils’ learning  The primary children in this Scottish.
History: what do pupils think?. Key issue addressed by the study   This study aimed to: – –reveal the ideas about history which young people bring as.
How does collaborative group work affect science learning?
ItemEnglishMaths National A*-C6661 National boys A*-C6061 National girls A*-C7362 National FSM A*-CNA National boys FSM A*-CNA National girls.
Tudor CEVC Primary School Parents’ Forum – March 2014 How do we best organise the children into classes in the academic year 2014/15?
Improving the quality of pupils’ talk and thinking during group work.
St Luke’s Primary School Westminster Pupil Voice in Primary Science Strategies and Ideas.
Advancing teaching: inspiring able learners every day Meeting the Challenge 14 th November 2012.
Pupils’ Perceptions as they end KS3 Mathematics Sheila Smyth.
Independent learning and the benefits for pupils.
Academic Transfer Lesley Lyon – Secondary Advisor.
How does classroom discussion and questioning affect students’ learning?
Effective Teaching and Learning for Pupils in Low Attaining Groups Máiréad Dunne, Sara Humphreys and Judy Sebba University of Sussex Alan Dyson, Frances.
Aim: To know the difference between informal and formal education
Praising the person or what they do?
OFSTED and the role of Teaching Assistants
Key strategies for planning for challenge
Key issue addressed by the study
Key strategies for Planning for challenge
Key strategies for planning for challenge
A thinking skills approach to learning maths (CAME)
Presentation transcript:

Students’ experiences of ability grouping – disaffection, polarisation and the construction of failure

Key issue addressed by the study  This small scale study investigated the ways in which students’ attitudes towards, and achievement in mathematics were influenced by ability grouping as they moved from Year 8 into Year 9.

Two approaches to grouping pupils –Streaming – separating children into groups by global ability and teaching them in the same class for all subjects –Setting – separating children into different groups by ability for individual subjects

Grouping and teachers’ practice  Ability grouping: –appears to signal to teachers that it is appropriate to use less different teaching strategies than they use with mixed ability classes  Mixed ability grouping: –results in students being given more ‘open tasks’ which can be tackled at a variety of levels.

Grouping and students’ attainment?  Setting provides a slight gain in attainment for top set pupils; but  Students in the lower sets can become disaffected as teachers tend to enter whole groups in the same tier for GCSE, limiting chances of achieving higher grades

Pupils’ perceptions of being in the top set  Students in the top sets characterised their mathematical experience as fast, procedural and pressured: –“I want to get a good mark, but I don’t want to be put in the top set again. It’s too hard, and I won’t learn anything” (Girl) –All eight set 1 girls wanted to move down –Six out of eight set 1 boys were also unhappy

Pupils’ perceptions of being in the lower set  Negative experiences included: –Dissatisfaction with pace –Teachers expectations –Prospects of movement between sets –Self esteem “Sir treats us like babies…makes us copy stuff off the board, puts up all the answers like we don’t know anything… we’re not going to learn from that…we’ve got to think for ourselves” (Set 6 girls)

What did the authors conclude?  Ability grouping “creates academic success and failure through a system where students ‘have to be that good’ or ‘have to be that bad’”  Between class ability grouping may produce an underestimation of the capabilities of weaker students and the setting of overly challenging patterns of study for the most able.

Who were the children in the study?  843 children surveyed across year 8 and 9  from 42 classes in 6 secondary schools

How was the information gathered?  120 hours of lesson observation (10 hours per school per year);  a confidential questionnaire administered to all students in May/June of both years to gain understanding of students’ attitudes and beliefs in mathematics;  interviews with six pairs of students from each school at the end of Year 9: a pair of girls and one of boys from each of the top, middle and one of the lower sets, and with students from a comparable range of attainment in the mixed ability schools; and  students’ GCSE results, together with the value-added element (as from key stage 3) for each school.

How can teachers use the evidence in this study?  The researchers suggest that ability grouping leads to students in the weaker sets not being appropriately challenged  You may wish to discuss with a colleague effective strategies you have used to create challenge for less able students.  The researchers found that some students in both the lower and top sets had negative views about their experiences.  Could you find out about your students’ perceptions of their learning and use these findings to inform your teaching?

How can school leaders use the evidence in this study?  The researchers found that teachers used a narrower range of teaching strategies in groups set by ability than in mixed ability groups  You might want to audit the range of teaching strategies used in your school. How can you widen the range of teaching strategies used with different groups?  The researchers found that ability grouping can create academic failure for some students.  You may wish to discuss with your leadership team the extent to which ability grouping is used in your school. Is it possible to gather data showing its impact on students achievement?

Follow-up reading  Study reference: Boaler, J., William, D. & Brown, M. (2000) British Educational Research Journal, 26 (5) pp Avaliable at:  Summary available at: grouping/FriOct / grouping/FriOct / grouping/FriOct /

Feedback  Did you find this useful?  What did you like?  What didn’t you like? Any feedback on this Research Bite would be much appreciated. Please your feedback to: