Full strength of (weak) Cluster lensing

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Dark energy workshop Copenhagen Aug Why the SNLS ? Questions to be addressed: -Can the intrinsic scatter in the Hubble diagram be further reduced?
Advertisements

UCL’s interests: photo-z, mass-obs calibration, systematics Granada, Sep 2010 Ofer Lahav, University College London Ofer Lahav, Stephanie Jouvel, Ole Host.
Cosmological constraints from estimates of M gas -M tot -c in X-ray luminous clusters S. Ettori (INAF/OA Bologna) with F. Gastaldello, M. Meneghetti, I.
ASIAA Research Highlights and Prospects with HSC Keiichi Umetsu, ASIAA SAC HSC Science Workshop
Nuclei of Early-type Dwarf Galaxies: Are They Progenitors of Ultracompact Dwarf Galaxies? Paudel, S., Lisker, T., Janz, J. 2010, ApJ, 724, L64 Park, Hong.
CLASH: Cluster Lensing And Supernova survey with Hubble An HST Multi-Cycle Treasury Program designed to place new constraints on the fundamental components.
CLASH: Cluster Lensing And Supernova survey with Hubble ACS Parallels WFC3 Parallels 6 arcmin. = 2.2 z=0.5 Footprints of HST Cameras: ACS FOV in.
First X-Ray Results from the Optically Selected Red Sequence Cluster Survey (RCS) at Z ~ 1 Amalia K. Hicks, Erica Ellingson, Howard Yee, Tesla Jeltema,
Weak-Lensing selected, X-ray confirmed Clusters and the AGN closest to them Dara Norman NOAO/CTIO 2006 November 6-8 Boston Collaborators: Deep Lens Survey.
AGN and Quasar Clustering at z= : Results from the DEEP2 + AEGIS Surveys Alison Coil Hubble Fellow University of Arizona Chandra Science Workshop.
The Sunyaev-Zel’dovich effect The Sunyaev-Zel’dovich effect AMI day, 2011 September 30 Mark Birkinshaw University of Bristol.
First Results from an HST/ACS Snapshot Survey of Intermediate Redshift, Intermediate X-ray Luminosity Clusters of Galaxies: Early Type Galaxies and Weak.
On the Distribution of Dark Matter in Clusters of Galaxies David J Sand Chandra Fellows Symposium 2005.
Discovery of Galaxy Clusters Around Redshift 1 Deborah Haarsma, Calvin GLCW, June 1, 2007.
The Structure Formation Cookbook 1. Initial Conditions: A Theory for the Origin of Density Perturbations in the Early Universe Primordial Inflation: initial.
Statistical Properties of Radio Galaxies in the local Universe Yen-Ting Lin Princeton University Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile Yue Shen, Michael.
Relating Mass and Light in the COSMOS Field J.E. Taylor, R.J. Massey ( California Institute of Technology), J. Rhodes ( Jet Propulsion Laboratory) & the.
X-ray Source-Galaxy Angular Cross-Correlation function in the COSMOS Field Takamitsu Miyaji, Richard E. Griffiths (Carnegie Mellon Univ.) COSMOS XMM-Newton.
Angular clustering and halo occupation properties of COSMOS galaxies Cristiano Porciani.
Luminosity & color of galaxies in clusters sarah m. hansen university of chicago with erin s. sheldon (nyu) risa h. wechsler (stanford)
EMerlin lenses and starbursts from the widest-area Herschel and SCUBA-2 surveys Stephen Serjeant, July 17th 2007.
Statistics of the Weak-lensing Convergence Field Sheng Wang Brookhaven National Laboratory Columbia University Collaborators: Zoltán Haiman, Morgan May,
THE STRUCTURE OF COLD DARK MATTER HALOS J. Navarro, C. Frenk, S. White 2097 citations to NFW paper to date.
MODELING INTRACLUSTER MEDIUM AND DARK MATTER IN GALAXY CLUSTERS Elena Rasia Dipartimento di Astronomia Università di Padova Padova, April 9th, 2002.
GIANT TO DWARF RATIO OF RED-SEQUENCE GALAXY CLUSTERS Abhishesh N Adhikari Mentor-Jim Annis Fermilab IPM / SDSS August 8, 2007.
Through a Lens, Darkly: An Innovative Hubble Survey to Study the Dark Universe Marc Postman Space Telescope Science Institute HotSci August 2010 MACS
The Science Case for the Dark Energy Survey James Annis For the DES Collaboration.
HSCWLWG (March 17, 2009) Mass Density Profiles of Strong Lensing Clusters Keiichi Umetsu (ASIAA, LeCosPA/NTU)
How to start an AGN: the role of host galaxy environment Rachel Gilmour (ESO Chile & IfA, Edinburgh) Philip Best (Edinburgh), Omar Almaini & Meghan Gray.
Peter Capak Associate Research Scientist IPAC/Caltech.
Properties of Barred Galaxies in SDSS DR7 - OPEN KIAS SUMMER INSTITUTE - Gwang-Ho Lee, Changbom Park, Myung Gyoon Lee & Yun-Young Choi 0. Abstract We investigate.
Cluster Strong Lensing Neal Dalal IAS. Cluster Strong Lensing Images of background galaxies strongly distorted by potential of foreground massive cluster.
Observational Constraints on Galaxy Clusters and DM Dynamics Doron Lemze Tel-Aviv University / Johns Hopkins University Collaborators : Tom Broadhurst,
1 st Subaru Intl. Conference Subaru Weak Lensing Study of Merging Clusters of Galaxies Reference: Okabe & Umetsu 2008, PASJ in press (astro-ph/ )
Constraining Dark Energy with Cluster Strong Lensing Priyamvada Natarajan Yale University Collaborators: Eric Jullo (JPL), Jean-Paul Kneib (OAMP), Anson.
Cosmological studies with Weak Lensing Peak statistics Zuhui Fan Dept. of Astronomy, Peking University.
Constraining cluster abundances using weak lensing Håkon Dahle Institute of Theoretical Astrophysics, University of Oslo.
Full strength of (weak) Cluster lensing Advisors: Tom Broadhurst, Yoel Rephaeli Collaborators: Keiichi Umetsu, Narciso Benitez, Dan Coe, Holland Ford,
Feb/19/2008 A Demography of Galaxies in Galaxy Clusters with the Spectro-photometric Density Measurement. Joo Heon Yoon 윤주헌 Sukyoung Yi 이석영 Yoon et al.
1 VVDS: Towards a complete census of star formation at 1.4
Hot gas in galaxy pairs Olga Melnyk. It is known that the dark matter is concentrated in individual haloes of galaxies and is located in the volume of.
Testing the Shear Ratio Test: (More) Cosmology from Lensing in the COSMOS Field James Taylor University of Waterloo (Waterloo, Ontario, Canada) DUEL Edinburgh,
SUNYAEV-ZELDOVICH EFFECT. OUTLINE  What is SZE  What Can we learn from SZE  SZE Cluster Surveys  Experimental Issues  SZ Surveys are coming: What.
Cosmological Constraints from the maxBCG Cluster Sample Eduardo Rozo October 12, 2006 In collaboration with: Risa Wechsler, Benjamin Koester, Timothy McKay,
Surveying the Universe with SNAP Tim McKay University of Michigan Department of Physics Seattle AAS Meeting: 1/03 For the SNAP collaboration.
The Environmental Effect on the UV Color-Magnitude Relation of Early-type Galaxies Hwihyun Kim Journal Club 10/24/2008 Schawinski et al. 2007, ApJS 173,
The masses and shapes of dark matter halos from galaxy- galaxy lensing in the CFHTLS Henk Hoekstra Mike Hudson Ludo van Waerbeke Yannick Mellier Laura.
The Structure Formation Cookbook 1. Initial Conditions: A Theory for the Origin of Density Perturbations in the Early Universe Primordial Inflation: initial.
Gravitational Lensing Analysis of CLASH clusters Adi HD 10/2011.
Constraining Cosmography with Cluster Lenses Jean-Paul Kneib Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Marseille.
Array for Microwave Background Anisotropy AMiBA SZ Science AMiBA Team NTU Physics Figure 4. Simulated AMiBA deep surveys of a 1deg 2 field (no primary.
Luminosity Functions from the 6dFGS Heath Jones ANU/AAO.
Probing the faint end of the quasar luminosity function in the COSMOS field Hiroyuki Ikeda (Ehime Univ.) Tohru Nagao, Kenta Matsuoka, Taniguchi Yoshiaki,
CLASH/HST photoz estimation: the challenges & their quality Stephanie Jouvel, Ofer Lahav, Ole Host.
Cosmic shear and intrinsic alignments Rachel Mandelbaum April 2, 2007 Collaborators: Christopher Hirata (IAS), Mustapha Ishak (UT Dallas), Uros Seljak.
Observational Test of Halo Model: an empirical approach Mehri Torki Bob Nichol.
The SN Ia Rate In 0.5
Strong Lensing Surveys and Statistics Dan Maoz. zqzq Survey strategies: Search among source population for lensed cases or Search behind potential lenses.
HeCS-SZ: An MMT/Hectospec Survey of SZ-selected Clusters Ken Rines (Western Washington University), Margaret Geller (SAO), Antonaldo Diaferio (Torino),
Andrii Elyiv and XMM-LSS collaboration The correlation function analysis of AGN in the XMM-LSS survey.
Elinor Medezinski Johns Hopkins University Galaxy Galaxy Lensing in CLASH clusters.
Investigating dark matter halos of galaxies from the COMBO-17 survey Martina Kleinheinrich (Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, Heidelberg) & Hans-Walter.
Cluster Lenses & High Redshift Clusters (MACS) A Status Report Jean-Paul KNEIB Observatoire Astronomique Marseille Provence, Marseille, France H. Ebeling,
COSMIC MAGNIFICATION the other weak lensing signal Jes Ford UBC graduate student In collaboration with: Ludovic Van Waerbeke COSMOS 2010 Jes Ford Jason.
Photometric redshift for clusters through A1689 and simulation studies Stephanie Jouvel, Ofer Lahav, Ole Host.
Towards the first detection using SPT polarisation
Advisors: Tom Broadhurst, Yoel Rephaeli
Some issues in cluster cosmology
Subaru Weak Lensing Study of Seven Merging Clusters of Galaxies
Galaxy Cluster Mass from Spectroscopic Magnification Measurements
Presentation transcript:

Full strength of (weak) Cluster lensing Elinor Medezinski Tel Aviv University Medezinski et al. 2007, Broadhurst et al. 2008, Medezinski et al. 2009, Medezinski et al. 2010 (in prep) Advisors: Tom Broadhurst, Yoel Rephaeli Collaborators: Keiichi Umetsu, Narciso Benitez, Dan Coe, Holland Ford, Masamune Oguri

Color-magnitude, A1689 (Medezinski et al. 2007) E/SO sequence galaxies Three galaxy samples Red – background. (redder than sequence) Blue – faint background. (determine by comparing WL signal to red) Green – cluster +background Set magnitude limit to 26.5 to avoid incompleteness (Medezinski et al. 2007) Red Blue

New approach - Color-Color B,R,z’ for A370 V,R,z’ for RXJ1347 g’,r’,i’ for A1703 (Medezinski et al. 2009) Galaxy number density map 4 Density peaks – different galaxy populations A370

Average radius in Color-Color space Color code = distance from cluster center Blue = low mean radius – cluster galaxies A370

Sample selection in Color-Color Red – background Blue – background Green – cluster +~background Pink – foreground +background

Weak lensing profiles “Dilution” method gT profiles – rising background signal ~zero for green – diluted by unlensed cluster members A370 Red – background Blue – background Green – cluster +~background Pink – foreground +background Weak lensing measured using IMCAT (Umetsu & Broadhurst 2008, Umetsu, Medezinski et al. 2010) “Dilution” method Cluster membership – almost ~100% for entire radius range, →green sample is comprised mostly of cluster.

Foreground contamination Density profiles – foreground shows homogeneous distribution, like background, unlike cluster which is concentrated. A370 Red – background Blue – background Green – cluster +~background Pink – foreground +background gT profiles – foreground also shows diluted signal relative to background

Dilution in other work Oguri et al. 2009 Diluted by a factor of ~2 in the center Leads to underestimated Einstein radius Leads to underestimated Cvir A1703

2D Mass reconstruction + Round, ~relaxed massive clusters Weak-lensing galaxy # density Round, ~relaxed massive clusters Broadhurst et al. 2008

NFW fits give high concentrations (Cvir=rvir/rs) Broadhurst et al. 2008 gT-profiles agree NFW fits give high concentrations (Cvir=rvir/rs) than expected by ΛCDM N-body simulations Use magnification to check consistency of gT results

NFW parameters Cvir-Mvir comparison with other studies and ΛCDM 4σ discrepancy with ΛCDM, even considering orientation and selection bias (Hennawi et al 2007, Oguri & Blanford et al. 2009)

Luminosity & M/L profiles A1689 A1703 A370 RXJ1347-11 Cluster luminosity – “g-weighted” flux to get cluster flux Flux  Luminosity Linear fit M/L goes down in the outskirts – morphology-density related effect (Dressler 1980)

M/L profiles M/L goes down in the center – luminous BCGs M/L goes down in the outskirts –morphology-density relation (Dressler 1980) A1689 A1703 A370 RXJ1347-11

Cluster Luminosity Function – A1689 Flat faint-end, no upturn

Lensing distance vs. redshift: Weak lensing strength vs. redshift test of cosmology using WL distortions (Medezinski et al. 2010 in prep) In the weak limit, Lensing distance vs. redshift:

Weak lensing samples Select background galaxy samples –”red”, “blue”, “green” and “dropouts” and measure their lensing profile Red – background Blue – background Green – background Pink – background (high-z dropouts) A370

Fit background WL distortion profile with power law: Bright Red – background Blue – background Green – background Pink – background (high-z dropouts) Fit background WL distortion profile with power law: Find amplitude ai for other samples, with same power law Faint

COSMOS Redshifts 30-band wide field (2 sq. deg.) survey (Capak et al. 2007) Photometric redshifts catalog (Ilbert et al. 2009) mean redshift in color-color space Same selection samples

Results: Faint Bright gT amplitude vs. redshift overlaid on the lensing distance – redshift curves A370 ZwCl0024-17 RXJ1347-11

Summary Developed new scheme to resolve cluster/foreground/background selected in color-color space and better determine weak lensing profiles. Determined light profiles & radial luminosity functions of A1689, A1703, A370, RXJ1347 reliably, with no need to resolve the cluster sequence based on color. Found flat luminosity function, with no need for far-field counts for background subtraction. Constructed M/L profiles to the virial radius, showing physical behavior of DM to light distributions, dropping to the center of cluster, and also dropping to the outskirts. Deduced high NFW concentrations, contradicting ΛCDM simulation expectation values. Use weak lensing distortions to constrain the lensing distance – redshift relation. Future work: Obtain photo-z’s using more colors for consistency checks. Extend to other clusters (CL0024 submitted Umetsu et al. 2009, MACS sample) using existing Subaru. Combine w/ strong-lensing from HST/ACS (Zitrin et al. 2009) – Hubble MCT proposal accepted!! – 25 clusters with 525 orbits. Constrain mass distribution by combining X-ray and SZ from Chandra and Amiba (Amiba paper - Umetsu et al. 2009).