Thermal Duality: Nemesis of Black Holes? Mike Hewitt Canterbury Christ Church University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Nuts and Bolts of Inflation Richard Barrett. Dark Energy SeminarGlasgow 29/11/2003 Inflation What is inflation? What is dark energy? Why was inflation.
Advertisements

Gerard t Hooft Spinoza Institute, Utrecht University Utrecht University and.
F. Debbasch (LERMA-ERGA Université Paris 6) and M. Bustamante, C. Chevalier, Y. Ollivier Statistical Physics and relativistic gravity ( )
ICHEP conference, Paris, 22/07/10. Emergence Current Paradigm FUNDAMENTAL FORCES: carried by elementary particles.
Summing planar diagrams
Dark Energy and Quantum Gravity Dark Energy and Quantum Gravity Enikő Regős Enikő Regős.
Black Hole Evaporation, Unitarity, and Final State Projection Daniel Gottesman Perimeter Institute.
The Fate of the Universe. The cosmological principle The simplest universes is: Homogenous – the same everywhere you go Isotropic – the same in all directions.
Gerard ’t Hooft Dublin November 13, 2007 Utrecht University on.
3rd International Workshop On High Energy Physics In The LHC Era.
Dark Energy and Void Evolution Dark Energy and Void Evolution Enikő Regős Enikő Regős.
Gerard ’t Hooft Spinoza Institute Utrecht University CMI, Chennai, 20 November 2009 arXiv:
Quantum Tunneling of Thin Wall Matthew C. Johnson, in collaboration with Anthony Aguirre.
Holographic Dark Energy Preety Sidhu 5 May Black Holes and Entropy Black holes are “maximal entropy objects” Entropy of a black hole proportional.
Planar diagrams in light-cone gauge hep-th/ M. Kruczenski Purdue University Based on:
Remarkable power of Einstein’s equation Gary Horowitz UC Santa Barbara Gary Horowitz UC Santa Barbara.
The 2d gravity coupled to a dilaton field with the action This action ( CGHS ) arises in a low-energy asymptotic of string theory models and in certain.
Galileo Galilei Colloquium, Pisa, March 3, 2006 Gerard ’t Hooft Utrecht University.
Unexpected Connections in Physics: From Superconductors to Black Holes Talk online: sachdev.physics.harvard.edu Talk online: sachdev.physics.harvard.edu.
BLACK HOLES AS INFORMATION SCRAMBLERS How information survives falling into a black hole Master thesis Wilke van der Schee Supervised by prof. Gerard ’t.
Physics 361 Principles of Modern Physics Lecture 3.
CERN Colloquium, 28/04/11. Matter and Forces Current Paradigm FUNDAMENTAL FORCES: carried by elementary particles.
A CRITICAL POINT IN A ADS/QCD MODEL Wu, Shang-Yu (NCTU) in collaboration with He, Song, Yang, Yi and Yuan, Pei-Hung , to appear in JHEP
The Quantum Space-Time Juan Maldacena Institute for Advanced Study 25 th Solvay Conference October 2011.
Entropy localization and distribution in the Hawking radiation Horacio Casini CONICET-Intituto Balseiro – Centro Atómico Bariloche.
Lamb shift in Schwarzschild spacetime Wenting Zhou & Hongwei Yu Department of Physics, Hunan Normal University, Changsha, Hunan, China.
Forming Nonsingular Black Holes from Dust Collapse by R. Maier (Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Físicas-Rio de Janeiro) I. Damião Soares (Centro Brasileiro.
Holographic Description of Quantum Black Hole on a Computer Yoshifumi Hyakutake (Ibaraki Univ.) Collaboration with M. Hanada ( YITP, Kyoto ), G. Ishiki.
Cosmological ideas from string theory
Louisville March 22, 2006 Andrew Chamblin Memorial An AdS Thermal Properties of Strongly Coupled Gauge Theories with Fundamental Matter from Gauge/Gravity.
Stabilizing moduli with flux in brane gas cosmology Jin Young Kim (Kunsan National Univ.) CosPA 2009, Melbourne Based on arXiv: [hep-th]; PRD 78,
Quantum Black Holes and Relativistic Heavy Ions D. Kharzeev BNL 21st Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics, Breckenridge, February 5-11, 2005 based on DK.
Black Holes, Entropy, and Information Gary Horowitz UCSB.
“Einstein Gravity in Higher Dimensions”, Jerusalem, Feb., 2007.
“Models of Gravity in Higher Dimensions”, Bremen, Aug , 2008.
Shear viscosity of a highly excited string and black hole membrane paradigm Yuya Sasai Helsinki Institute of Physics and Department of Physics University.
The false vacuum bubble : - formation and evolution - in collaboration with Chul H. Lee(Hanyang), Wonwoo Lee, Siyong Nam, and Chanyong Park (CQUeST) Based.
General Relativity and the Expanding Universe Allan Johnston 4/4/06.
Black Holes Formation Spacetime Curved spacetime Event horizon Seeing black holes Demo: 1L Gravity Well - Black Hole.
Unifying the Geometry of General Relativity with the Virtual Particle Nature of Quantum Electrodynamics John R. Laubenstein IWPD Research Center Naperville,
On Fuzzball conjecture Seiji Terashima (YITP, Kyoto) based on the work (PRD (2008), arXiv: ) in collaboration with Noriaki Ogawa (YITP)
Black hole For large enough masses, as far as we know, nothing is stiff enough to stop the collapse. It continues down to a singularity: a defect in space.
General Relativity Physics Honours 2008 A/Prof. Geraint F. Lewis Rm 560, A29 Lecture Notes 10.
The fast life of holographic mesons Aninda Sinha Perimeter Institute, Canada. with Robert Myers arXiv:0802.nnnn Quark Matter 2008, Jaipur, India.
General Relativity Physics Honours 2008 A/Prof. Geraint F. Lewis Rm 560, A29 Lecture Notes 9.
Quantum Black Holes, Strong Fields, and Relativistic Heavy Ions D. Kharzeev “Understanding confinement”, May 16-21, 2005.
General Relativity and Cosmology The End of Absolute Space Cosmological Principle Black Holes CBMR and Big Bang.
Holographic QCD in the medium
Thermalization of Gauge Theory and Gravitational Collapse Shu Lin SUNY-Stony Brook SL, E. Shuryak. arXiv: [hep-th]
Holographic Description of Quantum Black Hole on a Computer Yoshifumi Hyakutake (Ibaraki Univ.) Collaboration with M. Hanada ( YITP, Kyoto ), G. Ishiki.
1 Bhupendra Nath Tiwari IIT Kanpur in collaboration with T. Sarkar & G. Sengupta. Thermodynamic Geometry and BTZ black holes This talk is mainly based.
The effect of Gravity on Equation of State Hyeong-Chan Kim (KNUT) FRP Workshop on String Theory and Cosmology 2015, Chungju, Korea, Nov ,
The Fate of the Universe. The fate depends on the rate of expansion and the density Density greater than critical value – gravity will halt expansion.
Causality constraints on graviton three point functions Juan Maldacena Based on: Camanho, Edelstein, JM., Zhiboedov. arXiv:
Based on Phys. Rev. D 92, (R) (2015) 中科大交叉学科理论研究中心
Gauge/gravity duality in Einstein-dilaton theory Chanyong Park Workshop on String theory and cosmology (Pusan, ) Ref. S. Kulkarni,
New Insights into Quantum Gravity from Holography Gary Horowitz UC Santa Barbara with N. Engelhardt ( , and in progress)
Gravity on Matter Equation of State and the Unruh temperature Hyeong-Chan Kim (KNUT) 2016 FRP workshop on String theory and cosmology Seoul, Korea, June.
Quantum Mechanical Models for Near Extremal Black Holes
Equation of State and Unruh temperature
Origin of Hawking radiation
Origin of Hawking radiation and firewalls
Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Korea
Relativity H7: General relativity.
Solutions of black hole interior, information paradox and the shape of singularities Haolin Lu.
dark matter Properties stable non-relativistic non-baryonic
Based on the work submitted to EPJC
Non Singular Origin of the Universe and its Present Va-cuum Energy Density, IJMPA & Honorable Mention in Gravity Research Foundation Competition for 2011,
Global Defects near Black Holes
Graviton Emission in The Bulk from a Higher Dimensional Black Hole
Presentation transcript:

Thermal Duality: Nemesis of Black Holes? Mike Hewitt Canterbury Christ Church University

What is the thermalon? Condensate that forms at the Hagedorn transition. Euclidean single wrapping mode – related to the thermal path integral for a single string by modular invariance. The thermalon mode will be interpreted as a deformation of the vacuum, in thermal equilibrium with normal vacuum. The thermalon is not a normal propagating state – rather, a macroscopic order parameter for mixing long string states with the field vacuum, entangling the external field state with long strings.

Thermalon and gravity

Gravito-thermal interaction The thermalon is part of the gravity sector in string theory. Gravity becomes part of a ‘gravito-thermal’ interaction. The condensate that forms at the Hagedorn transition behaves as part of the gravity sector. Thermal duality implies a possibility of the thermalon producing gravitational vacuum polarization. This may limit the strength of gravity, preventing the formation of black holes – a novel macroscopic effect.

Why is this significant? String theory does not work in 4 dimensions without a gravity regulator – more below. With a regulator, it may become like QCD, with gravitationally free strings confined to a bag of a different phase. The heterotic gravity regulator is generic in dimension, and avoids black hole formation and related information paradoxes. The heterotic regulator may generalise to other string models.

Scaling behaviour vs dimension

Holographic principle

Problem of strings in 4 dimensions An attractive feature of string theory is that it naturally includes gravitons and has finite amplitudes for graviton scattering in the critical dimension. High energy scattering is intermediated by an infinite spectrum of free string states. However, string theory as a theory of quantum gravity does not really work as advertised in 4 dimensions, as high energy collisions would form black holes rather than demonstrate string scattering amplitudes or the production of long string states.

Free string spectrum

…operators

String radial scale

It appears that most string states would collapse behind event horizons. However, the fixed nature of the value for the transition temperature from the winding mode implies that the free spectrum is somehow preserved when gravity is turned on. This supports a bag model interpretation for string states in 4 dimensions (hadron analogy).

Thermal duality – to the rescue?

Thermalon weak field solutions

Accelerating Wall Solution

Note the negative energy density close to the horizon Source is zero at Red Shifted Source (Seen from infinity)

Area Difference across the Wall This can be described by a ‘warp factor’ w:

Gravity Regulator proposal

Adiabatic (constant area) condition

Critical acceleration

Convexity

Generalisation Note the generic nature of the conditions, which can be abstracted from the heterotic context, and may apply across M space. The differential geometry applies in all uncompactified dimensions. The mechanism for heterotic strings relies on the self-dual nature of the thermalon. Although the thermalon is not self- dual for non-heterotic strings, thermal duality may still apply to the string sector (T duality in Euclidean time).

Non-heterotic case Mertens, Verschelde & Zakharov obtained similar results for the Rindler solution stress tensor for thermalons in type II string models. [ arXiv: ] Although these models do not have explicit thermal duality, this behaviour is related to the T duality of the torus diagram.

The conjecture also implies that (some generalisation of) thermal duality also provides a gravitational regulator for 11 dimensional supergravity.

Gravity regulator properties Critical surface conditions are a string regularised version of a Penrose trapped surface (infinite tension limit). Horizons are defined globally but trapped surfaces (and thermalon traps) are defined locally by these geometric conditions. Heuristically the critical gravity condition for conversion is equivalent to the condition that the Newtonian gravity (in local centre of mass frame) between any two objects is limited by the string tension. Mutual nature of effect between two interacting bodies is shown by the symmetry of the ‘Newtonian’ effective criterion for the gravitational regulator – may also hold throughout M space.

Transition

Transition Process The following slide shows a possible transition processes for formation of a thermalon region and absorption of infalling matter. The infalling matter has a relativistic velocity relative to the interior.

Encounter process Diagrams:

Conversion timescales

Conversion from Minkowski space? Suppose a planar thermalon trap crosses a wall of matter in Minkowski space. The wall of matter cannot be converted to a thermalon excitation because of the warp factor that would be produced. Agrees with intuition about conservation of energy. Conversion is not possible in Minkowski space.

Particle absorption Consider next a thermalon front geometry with a salient (previous diagram). Could this be produced by a thermalon trap absorbing a particle in Minkowski space? An expanding wave-front bounds a convex region in a Minkowski background. This is inconsistent with a locally constant area. Thus, although traps associated with Rindler frames are everywhere in Minkowski space, these cannot gain energy by recruiting particles.

Ball solution Thermal duality implies that gravitational gradients are expelled around the self-dual point. This is similar to the Meissner effect in superconductors. [MH arxiv ] Gravitational polarization gives a screening mechanism which restricts the gravitational source to the boundary of a (fully developed) thermalon region.

Hyperbolic spatial geometry in the interior makes the volume and information content proportional to surface area. String excitations are gravitationally free in the interior – like quarks in hadrons. Should resolve string state problem in 4 dimensions.

Hot objects

Naturalness of the thermalon ball A thermalon deformation however naturally and stably meets this matching condition for temperature and surface gravity as it is tied to the location of high static gravitational acceleration. Here a ‘standing wave’ thermalon excitation can ride the gravitational field.

Black holes and M theory

Evaporating Black Hole Note the causal disconnection between the original information and late Hawking radiation. Monogamy of entanglement prevents reconciliation of ‘lost’ and ‘found’ information.

Black hole evaporation paradoxes General problem – getting information out from a photon trap – without propagating information faster than light (outside the light cone). A resort to quantum mechanics for a resolution does not seem to work –inconsistent with the principles of quantum information theory Braunstein - Pirandola theorems – the conventional picture of black hole evaporation appears to be inconsistent with unitarity [ arXiv: ].

Unitarity problems [B-P] Theorem 1: A contradiction exists between: 1.a) completely unitarily evaporating black holes, 1.b) a freely falling observer notices nothing special until they pass well within a large black hole's horizon, and 1.c) the black hole interior Hilbert space dimensionality may be well approximated as the exponential of the Bekenstein Hawking entropy.

Theorem 2: A contradiction exists between: 2.a) completely unitarily evaporating black holes, 2.b) large black holes are described by local physics (no signals faster than light) and 2.c) externally, a large black hole should resemble its classical theoretical counterpart (aside from its slow evaporation).

Holographic problem

Resolution? This model may resolve ‘firewall paradoxes’ by removing the horizon, and providing a physically motivated firewall to store the information content of a collapsing object. The ‘firewall’ here would be formed by string bremsstrahlung during gravitational collapse. The firewall would be stable - there is no black hole, and the interior space has been crushed so there is nowhere else for the energy and information to go except outward by Hawking evaporation.

Conclusions Because of thermal duality, string models may have a vacuum polarization mechanism which limits the strength of gravity. The criterion for this to be effective is based on the area of accelerating surfaces, not the tidal Riemannian curvature. This effect would occur at, and only at, sites of extreme gravitational collapse. Collapsing objects would form hot holograms, rather than black holes. This would resolve the firewall paradox: firewalls are real, but black holes are not. Resolve the black hole information problem: there would be no black holes to compromise quantum information.