Automatic Protocol Format Reverse Engineering through Context-Aware Monitored Execution Zhiqiang Lin 1 Xuxian Jiang 2, Dongyan Xu 1, Xiangyu Zhang 1 1 Purdue University 2 George Mason University February 12 th, 2008 The 15 th Annual Network and Distributed System Security Symposium

Motivation  Protocol reverse engineering  A process to recover protocol specifications  E.g., fields and their relationships  Applications:  Network-based Intrusion detection  Network management  Penetration test  …

Challenges 0x0040: cd f6e e d6c 0x0050: f 312e 300d 0a d 0x0060: e 743a f 312e x0070: 2e d6f x0080: d 0a a 202a 0x0090: 2f2a 0d0a 486f a e x00a0: 342e e37 310d 0a43 6f6e 6e x00b0: 696f 6e3a 204b d 416c d. 0x00c0: 0a0d 0a  Multiple fields in a single message  Non-static size of fields  Complex relationships among protocol fields Sequential Parallel Hierarchical

Challenges HTTP-Request = Request-Line (( general-header | request-header | entity-header ) CRLF)* CRLF [ message-body ] Request-Line = Method SP Request-URI SP HTTP-Version CRLF Parallel Sequential Hierarchical A BNF Specification of HTTP Request (RFC2616)

Related Work  Network Trace  Protocol Informatics  Discoverer [W. Cui et. al. Security’07]  Binary Analysis  Polyglot [J. Caballero et. al. CCS’07]  Automatic Network Protocol Analysis [G. Wondracek et. al. NDSS’08]

Observation 119 int read_header(int sid) { if (sscanf(line, "%[^ ] %[^ ] %[^ ]", conn[sid].dat->in_RequestMethod, conn[sid].dat->in_RequestURI, conn[sid].dat->in_Protocol)!=3) while (strlen(line)>0) { if (strncasecmp(line, "Cookie: ", 8)==0) 155 strncpy(conn[sid].dat->in_Cookie, (char *)&line+8, sizeof(conn[sid].dat->in_Cookie)-1); 156 if (strncasecmp(line, "Host: ", 6)==0) 157 strncpy(conn[sid].dat->in_Host, (char *)&line+6, sizeof(conn[sid].dat->in_Host)-1); … 160 if (strncasecmp(line, "User-Agent: ", 12)==0) 161 strncpy(conn[sid].dat->in_UserAgent, (char *)&line+12, sizeof(conn[sid].dat->in_UserAgent)-1); 162 } } Code snippet in http.c (null-httpd-0.5.0)

AutoFormat -- Basic Idea Execution Context Protocol Fields G E T / n e w s … Context One Field Another Field

System Overview Context-aware Execution Monitor GET /news.html 0 'G' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr 1 'E' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr 2 'T' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr … 24 ‘\n’ main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr … 0 'G' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x1F7F3 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_getword_white 0 'G' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr 1 'E' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr 2 'T' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr … 24 ‘\n’ main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr … 0 'G' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x1F7F3 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_getword_white Log call stackEIP input

Protocol Field Identifier  Analyze log file  Step 1: build protocol field tree from the logged data.  Step 2: refine the tree using three heuristics  Step 3: output the result

Example: Apache log data 0 'G' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr 1 'E' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr 2 'T' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr … 24 ‘\n’ main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x4BA56A2 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core->ap_get_brigade->0x2D2CE->ap_get_brigade->0x2D667 ->apr_brigade_split_line->memchr … 24 '\n' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x >0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core 23 '\r‘ main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x >0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_rgetline_core 0 'G' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x1F7F3 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_getword_white 1 'E' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x1F7F3 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_getword_white 2 'T' main->ap_mpm_run->0x15C57->0x15B38->0x15941->ap_process_connection->ap_run_process_connection 0x1F7F3 ->0xF5A8->ap_read_request->ap_getword_white … GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n\r\n GET

Step 1 -- Building Protocol Field Tree root GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n User−Agent: Wget/ (Red Hat modified)\r\nAccept: */*\r\n…. GET /news.htmlGET HTTP/1.0

Step 1: Building Protocol Field Tree GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n H news.html GET GET /news.html GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n HTTP/1.0\r\n TTP/1.0 / / / news.html H H TTP/1.0

Step 2: Refinement (Tokenization) GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html GET GET /news.html GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html HTTP/1.0 GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n H news.html GET GET /news.html GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n HTTP/1.0\r\n TTP/1.0 / / / news.html H H TTP/1.0

Step 2: Refinement (Redundant Node Deletion) GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html GET GET /news.html GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html HTTP/1.0 GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html GET GET /news.htmlHTTP/1.0\r\n

Step 2: Refinement (Node Insertion) GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html GET GET /news.htmlHTTP/1.0\r\n GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html GET GET /news.htmlHTTP/1.0\r\n

Step 3: Output the Result Parallel & Sequential Hierarchical GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html GET GET /news.html HTTP/1.0\r\n /news.html GET HTTP/1.0\r\n

Evaluation  Implemented on top of Valgrind  Also applies to QEMU, PIN  Benchmark  30 messages with six known protocols and one unknown protocol.  Evaluation Metric  Re: Ratio of exact match |(A ∩ W)| / |W|  A: set of fields identified by AutoFormat  W: set of fields identified by Wireshark

Overall Result Re(F) = 88.5% Re(H) = 98.0% Re(P) = 100.0% Re=93.4% Re(F): Re for finest-grained fields Re(H): Re for hierarchical fields Re(P): Re for parallel fields

Experimental Result – Slapper Worm Nested data structure declaration Compiler inserted gap

Discussion  Dynamic Trace Dependency  Byte granularity  Protocol State Machine  Obfuscated binaries

Conclusion  AutoFormat  A tool for automatic protocol format extraction.  Key insight  A protocol implementation is programmed to recognize the protocol format and usually contains protocol field-specific execution context, and we can actually leverage such context to infer the hierarchical structure of protocol fields, and even get their BNF structures.

Thank you For more information: {zlin, dxu, Q & A