Does Property Transactions Matter in Price Discovery in Real Estate Market: Evidence from the US firm level data William Cheung and James Lei University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Modelling and Measuring Price Discovery in Commodity Markets Isabel Figuerola-Ferretti Jesús Gonzalo Universidad Carlos III de Madrid Business Department.
Advertisements

Value Premium in International REITs ERES Conference 2014 Ytzen van der Werf and Fred Huibers 27 June 2014
On the pulse of the property world Transaction based indices for the UK commercial property market Steven Devaney (University of Aberdeen) Roberto Martinez.
Estimating Equilibrium Real Exchange Rate MSc.Student: Petcu Supervisor:
Turun kauppakorkeakoulu  Turku School of Economics REGIONAL DIFFERENCES IN HOUSING PRICE DYNAMICS: PANEL DATA EVIDENCE European Real Estate Society 19th.
1 Market Efficiency in the Emerging Securitized Real Estate Markets Felix Schindler Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW) Milan, 26 th of June 2010.
Determinants and Dynamics of Dividend Payouts by REITs by Milena Petrova, Syracuse University Andrew Spieler, Hofstra University.
1 The Dynamic Relation of Volatility and Futures Trading under Market Conditions and Changing Sentiments PAUL L. HSUEH Y. ANGELA LIU NICHOLAS R. LEE.
Do Public Real Estate Returns Really Lead Private Market Returns? Elias Oikarinen*, Martin Hoesli**, Camilo Serrano*** 20th European Real Estate Society.
Evidence from REITS Brent W. Ambrose (The Pennsylvania State University), Shaun Bond (University of Cincinnati), & Joseph Ooi (National University of Singapore)
Indirect Real Estate Investments and their Links with Properties, Common Stocks and the Macroeconomy Alexander Schätz European Real Estate Society Conference.
Assessing euro area residential property prices through the lens of key fundamentals* L. Gattini European Central Bank December 2011 * This presentation.
The Role of Financial System in Economic Growth Presented By: Saumil Nihalani.
Discussion of The Examination of R&D Impact on Firm Value By Chuan Yang Hwang Nanyang Technological University.
Risk Premium Puzzle in Real Estate: Are real estate investors overly risk averse? James D. Shilling DePaul University Tien Foo Sing National University.
ERES 2011 The Performance Gap in UK Property Returns Stephen Lee
Comments on “The Intraday Behavior of Information Misreaction across Investor Categories in the Taiwan Options Market” Authors: Chuang-Chang Chang, Pei-Fang.
The Potential for Effective Diversification Strategies Between the UK and Irish Property Markets European Real Estate Society Milan, Italy Terry V. Grissom.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2002 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved Corporate Finance Ross  Westerfield  Jaffe Sixth Edition.
1 1 The Signaling of Short Selling Activity in Australia.
East Asian Equity Markets, Financial Crisis, and the Japanese Currency Stephen Yan-leung Cheung Professor of Finance (Chair) Department of Economics and.
Herding in the UK Real Estate Market Stephen L. Lee Cass Business School, City University London, 106 Bunhill Row, London.
Is Information Risk Priced? Evidence from the Price Discovery of Large Trades Chuan Yang Hwang Nanyang Technological University and Xiaolin Qian Nanyang.
A Presentation for the European Real Estate Society Annual Conference Stockholm, 2009 Qiulin Ke* and Michael White** *Nottingham Trent University, Nottingham.
Chapter 12 Jones, Investments: Analysis and Management
Legal Protection, Equity Dependence and Corporate Investment: Evidence from Around the World NTU International Conference in Finance (Taipei) SFM Conference.
Legal Protection, Equity Dependence and Corporate Investment: Evidence from Around the World YUANTO KUSNADI City University of Hong Kong SHERIDAN TITMAN.
Financial Econometrics II Lecture 2. 2 Up to now: Tests for informational WFE assuming constant expected returns Autocorrelations Variance ratios Time.
Lecture 10 The Capital Asset Pricing Model Expectation, variance, standard error (deviation), covariance, and correlation of returns may be based on.
Do Stock Prices Fully Reflect Information in Accruals and Cash Flows about Future Earnings? ---Richard G.
Public and Private Real Estate: ERES Milan 2010 The Benefits of Public and Private Real Estate Stephen Lee Cass Business School.
Determinants of Credit Default Swap Spread: Evidence from the Japanese Credit Derivative Market.
Real Estate Equities – Real Estate or Equities? Schätz, Alexander and Sebastian, Steffen European Real Estate Society Conference 2009 in Stockholm June.
Impact of Pension Accounting Rule Change on UK Pension Plan Terminations Paul Klumpes, Imperial College Liyan Tang, University of Stirling Mark Whittington,
Doctoral School of Finance and Banking Bucharest Uncovered interest parity and deviations from uncovered interest parity MSc student: Alexandru-Chidesciuc.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2005 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 13 Empirical Evidence on Security Returns.
1 An International Comparative Study on Housing Price and Property Tax Liabilities Sun-Tien Wu, Chun-Hao Yueh The 17th ERES Annual Conference, June 23-26,
The Impact of Fiscal Policy on Residential Investment in France Pamfili Antipa, Christophe Schalck The Macroeconomics of Housing Markets Paris, 3 rd of.
1 Nonspecialized Strategy versus Specialized Strategy : Evidence from the Property-Liability Insurance Industry Lih-Ru Chen National Chengchi University.
The Inflation-Hedging Properties of Real Estate Dr. Michael Voigtländer, Center for Real Estate Economics Stockholm, 26 June 2009.
An empirical study of efficiency of the Austrian residential markets Shanaka Herath, Gunther Maier Research Institute for Spatial and Real Estate Economics.
Real Estate & Planning: Steven Devaney (University of Reading), Qin Xiao (Hull University Business School) and.
The Academy of Economic Studies Bucharest The Faculty of Finance, Insurance, Banking and Stock Exchange DOFIN - Doctoral School of Finance and Banking.
University of Groningen, Department of Economic Geography On real cash flow, credit availa- bility, and Asset price inflation Dennis Schoenmaker and Arno.
The Interaction between the Sub-Market Turnover Ratios and Prices in Taiwan Mei-Ling Chou Taoyuan Innovation Institute of Technology, Taiwan European Real.
1 The Impact of Low Income Home Owners on the Volatility of Housing Markets Peter Westerheide ZEW European Real Estate Society Conference 2009 Stockholm.
The Information Content of Property Derivatives Shaun A. Bond University of Cincinnati Paul Mitchell Paul Mitchell Real Estate Consulting.
M Thomas Is the IPO Pricing Process Efficient? Michelle Lowry G William Schwert (Latest Draft February 2003)
MEASURING PRODUCTION FACTOR CONTRIBUTIONS TO GROWTH: A NOVEL EXPENDITURE-BASED SECTORAL PPP APPROACH Saša Drezgić, PhD University of Rijeka Faculty of.
Investor Sentiment and Price Discovery: Evidence from the Pricing Dynamics between the Futures and Spot Markets SWJTU, Chengdu, 2015 Robin K. Chou National.
Market Efficiency.
Close Enough? Near Arbitrage Aswath Damodaran. Near Arbitrage In near arbitrage, you either have two assets that are very similar but not identical, which.
Assessing the Probability of Bankruptcy with the Merton Approach Relative to Accounting Variables –Evidence from Taiwan and China Mei-Ying Liu Soochow.
Chapter 10 Market Efficiency.
ERES 2009 Conference Stockholm, June 24th Andreas Gohs: An evaluation of the quality of unsmoothing procedures to estimate true market returns from appraisal-based.
Tunneling or Propping: Evidence from Connected Transactions in China By Winnie Peng, K.C. John Wei and Zhishu Yang Presenter: Winnie Peng, HKUST NTUICF,
1 Risk Changes Following Ex-Dates of Stock Splits Shen-Syan Chen National Taiwan University Robin K. Chou National Central University Wan-Chen Lee Ching.
Credit Risk Discovery in the Stock and CDS Market: Who, When and Why Leads? Santiago Forte Lidija Lovreta PhD Candidate ESADE Business School December.
Comparison of Estimation Methods for Agricultural Productivity Yu Sheng ABARES the Superlative vs. the Quantity- based Index Approach August 2015.
Maize Price Differences and Evidence of Spatial Integration in Malawi: The Case of Selected Markets BY LOVEMORE NYONGO ICAS VI: RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL.
E NTE PER LE N UOVE TECNOLOGIE L’ E NERGIA E L’ A MBIENTE The causality between energy consumption and economic growth: A multi-sectoral analysis using.
Women Feel More Pessimistic Than Men: Empirical Evidence From Turkish Consumer Confidence Index IAFFE 2009 Annual Conference, Boston, USA June,
Neil Crosby, Colin Lizieri and Pat McAllister
Nicolai C. Striewe Nico B. Rottke
The relation between equity incentives and misreporting: The role of risk-taking incentives 吴圆圆
Empirical Evidence on Security Returns
Asymmetric price adjustments under ever - increasing costs Evidence from the Retail Gasoline Market in Colombia Marc Hofstetter Jorge Tovar Economics.
The Intra-Industry Information Transfers: Contagion in REIT Privatization Transactions July 6 ERES 2013, Vienna Vivek Sah University of San Diego.
5/5/2019 Financial dependence and industry growth in Europe: Better banks and higher productivity Robert Inklaar and Michael Koetter University of Groningen.
Price Discovery BY Dhanya K A.
Presentation transcript:

Does Property Transactions Matter in Price Discovery in Real Estate Market: Evidence from the US firm level data William Cheung and James Lei University of Macau, Macau China ERES 2014 Bucharest University of Economics

Motivations The results of public market (REITs stock) V.S. private real estate market are mixed. - Hoesli et al. (2013) find that public real estate market leads the private real estate market. - Yavas et al. (2011) find that there are variations across firms within each property type. For any given property category, REIT returns could be leading NAV returns for some firms while NAV returns could be leading REIT returns for some other firms. - Tuluca et al. (2000) find that private market seems to informationally lead the public one. Ross (1987) defined a market as efficient if there is a lack of arbitrage opportunity. Therefore, private real estate market makes itself as a compelling case for efficiency because of illiquidity. Duffie, Malamud, and Manso (2010) find that private information sharing promotes the effect of public information sharing.

Main Findings Significant contributions to price discovery from the private markets. Price discovery from the private markets increase further relative to the public real estate market, when employing transaction windows, as compared to full samples. Impulse response analysis shows that private real estate market converges even faster than public market real estate market around transaction windows. The results are robust to length of transaction windows and property types.

Our Uniqueness A unique dataset of daily property transactions covering 01/02/2001 to 12/31/2013. Synchronized public and private pairs around transaction windows, not by regular calendar days as in the earlier studies in the literature. Estimate long-run relation between public and private real estate markets with respect to information generated by property transactions in the underlying spot market. Unique environment of property markets and transaction data allow us to provide empirical evidences on private and public information sharing.

Contributions We provide a new angle to test the relative contributions to price discovery between public and private real estate markets: the comparison between full samples and transaction windows. Transaction windows matter because either the appraisal-based or transaction-based values of the underlying properties should react to the new information of property transactions and incorporate it into new values. Though public real estate market dominates the price discovery with respect to private real estate market, as stated in literatures, we fill the gap that private real estate market can become informative when transaction windows are taken into account.

Data Source: SNL financial Full samples: from 02 January 2001 to 31 December 2013 Full samples: Property type DiversifiedOfficeHotelIndustrial Number of firms Sample Size 106,80169,66146,76221,245 Number of Transactions 1,1161,

Data Transaction windows: –lead_lag 25 days, based on each transaction date t, we include [ t-25, t+25 ] observations Example 1: there was a property transaction on 04/25/2013 of Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide. To construct the transaction window of lead_lag 25 days, based on 04/25/2013, we include the observations of [ t-25, t+25 ]. Therefore, the transaction window will be from 03/20/2013 to 05/30/2013, only weekdays included. –lead_lag 30 days, based on each transaction date t, we include [ t-30, t+30 ] observations –transaction_date_lag 5 days & lead_lag 25 days, based on each transaction date t, we set t-7 as each new transaction date, denoted as t 7, and include [t 7 -25, t 7 +25] observations Example 2: there was a property transaction on 04/25/2013 of Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide. To construct the transaction window of transaction_date_lag 5 days & lead_lag 25 days, we first lag the transaction date back to 5 days which should be 04/18/2013. Then, based on 04/18/2013, we include the observations of [t 7 -25, t 7 +25]. Therefore, the transaction window will be from 03/13/2013 to 05/23/2013, only weekdays included.

Data Property type DiversifiedOfficeHotelIndustrial Number of firms Sample Size 26,16232,72721,17911,210 Number of Transactions 1,1161, Lead_lag 25 days Lead_lag 30 days Property type DiversifiedOfficeHotelIndustrial Number of firms Sample Size 28,19935,207 23,321 11,935 Number of Transactions 1,1161, Property type DiversifiedOfficeHotelIndustrial Number of firms Sample Size 26,17032,717 21,202 11,188 Number of Transactions 1,1161, Transaction_date_lag 5 days & lead_lag 25 days

Methodology Vector Error Correction Model (VECM) where  Total_return and  NAV are the change of total return index and net asset value (NAV) in period t, respectively, Z = Total_return b NAV is the long-term relationship between total return index and NAV, and are i.i.d. innovations.

Methodology Gonzalo and Granger ratios (common factor loadings) Gonzalo and Granger's (1995) price discovery focus on the error correction process. The model estimates the common factor weights that reflect the permanent contribution to the common factor (efficient price). The common factor weights are derived from each market's error correction coefficients. Superior price discovery is attributed to the market with the higher GG ratio.

Tables of GG Ratios Property type Full sampleLead_lag_25_days Total_retur n NAV Total_retur n NAV Diversified29%71%18%82% Office16%84%11%89% Hotel28%72%19%81% Industrial39%61%6%94% GG ratios between full samples and lead_lag 25 days

Tables of GG Ratios Property type Full sampleLead_lag_30_days Total_retur n NAV Total_retur n NAV Diversified29%71%7%93% Office16%84%25%75% Hotel28%72%23%77% Industrial39%61%18%82% GG ratios between full samples and lead_lag 30 days

Tables of GG Ratios Property type Full sample Transaction_date_lag_5 days & Lead_lag_25 days Total_retur n NAV Total_retur n NAV Diversified29%71%20%80% Office16%84%11.5%88.5% Hotel28%72%22%78% Industrial39%61%28%72% GG ratios between full samples and transaction_date_lag 5 days & lead_lag 25 days

The GG ratios (common factor loadings) of private real estate market increase further relative to public real estate market, when considering transaction windows.

Graphs of Impulse Response of NAV for Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide

The reaction of NAV to shocks of the three transaction windows converges faster than that to shocks of full samples The slopes of the dashed lines are steeper than those of solid lines The distance between two dashed lines becomes narrower than solid lines

Conclusions Consistent with Oikarinen et al. (2011), Hoesli et al. (2012), we find that public and private real estate market exhibit long-term cointegrating relationship We also find that public and private real estate market exhibit long-term cointegrating relationship with samples of transaction windows We test the relative contributions to price discovery between public and private real estate markets around transaction windows and find that the information content in the real estate market increases further, as compared with that of full samples. Private real estate market does matter in price discovery around transaction windows

Robustness – Normalized Co- integrating Vector Property type Full samples Lead_lag 25 days Lead_lag 30 days Transaction_da te_lag_7 days & lead_lag 25 days Diversified Office Hotel Industrial0.127 Comparison of the normalized cointegrating vector between full samples and transaction windows. The normalized cointegrating vector of transaction windows show the robustness.

Robustness – Impulse Response of One Liberty Property Inc

Robustness – Impulse Response of Forest City Enterprises Inc

Robustness – Impulse Response of Kilroy Realty Corporation

Thank you very much for your listening and your comments!