Critical Social Theory “People with opinions. Where do they come from. These days it seems like a natural fact. What we think changes how we act” The Gang.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Karl Marx & Friedrich Engels Sociology 100
Advertisements

Theoretical Issues: Structure and Agency
Theories of Knowledge Knowledge is Justified-True-Belief Person, S, knows a proposition, y, iff: Y is true; S believes y; Y is justified for S. (Note:
… crucial to an understanding of political economy …
Being and Time A Brief Summary.
Anselm On the Existence of God. “Nor do I seek to understand so that I can believe, but rather I believe so that I can understand. For I believe this.
The Challenge of Cultural Relativism
Chapter 1 Critical Thinking.
Marx, Capital (1867). The physicist either observes natural processes where they occur in their most significant form, and are least affected by disturbing.
The wealth of societies in which the capitalist mode of production prevails appears as an «immense collection of commodities»; the individual commodity.
Weber ‘Objective Possibility and Adequate Causation in Historical Explanation’.
SOC Lecture 4 Karl Marx. Last week Durkheim on history as a social process largely independent of the individuals who enact it. ‘Forced division.
The Problem of Induction Reading: ‘The Problem of Induction’ by W. Salmon.
Chapter Three Building and Testing Theory. Building Theory Human Nature –Determinism: assumes that human behavior is governed by forces beyond individual.
Marx (and Engels!) LSJ 362 Fall Karl Marx ( ) Lived at time of great social transformations in Europe Active in 1840’s political movement.
Introduction to Ethics Lecture 9 The Challenge of Cultural Relativism By David Kelsey.
ES 3219: Early Years Education, Week 2: Marx and the Commodification of Education Simon Boxley, 2009.
Marxism: Introduction Basic Questions:  Is money (or the economic relations we are in) the most important determinant in our life? our achievements;
Critical Social Theory “Enlightenment is man’s release from his self-incurred tutelage. … Sapere Aude! ‘Have the courage to use your own reason!’—that.
Karl Marx German-Jewish family converted to Christianity. Studies Law and Philosophy in Bonn and Berlin Dialectical Materialism.Influenced by.
Marx & Modernity: Mind, Culture & Activity ( ) A talk by Andy Blunden, 16 February 2011.
Is goodness without God good enough?
WALTER BENJAMIN : THE WORK OF ART IN THE AGE OF MECHANICAL REPRODUCTION “The authenticity of a thing is the essence of all that is transmissible from its.
RESEARCH IN EDUCATION Chapter I. Explanations about the Universe Power of the gods Religious authority Challenge to religious dogma Metacognition: Thinking.
Marxist Criticism. Georg Hegel ( ): The human mind begins with a thesis ( say, past tense in English is “-ed” ) that may produce an antithesis.
INTRODUCTION TO MARXISM. In order to understand his criticism, you need to understand the conditions that he lived in Long hours, low pay Periodic unemployment.
KNOWLEDGE What is it? How does it differ from belief? What is the relationship between knowledge and truth? These are the concerns of epistemology How.
Lit Crit Round Two: Marxist and Feminist Lit Crit
MIDTERM EXAMINATION THE MIDTERM EXAMINATION WILL BE ON FRIDAY, MAY 2, IN THIS CLASSROOM, STARTING AT 1:00 P.M. BRING A BLUE BOOK. THE EXAM WILL COVER:
Chapter 3: Knowledge Kant’s Revolution Introducing Philosophy, 10th edition Robert C. Solomon, Kathleen Higgins, and Clancy Martin.
Marxist Literary Criticism Lord of the Flies
LOGIC AND ONTOLOGY Both logic and ontology are important areas of philosophy covering large, diverse, and active research projects. These two areas overlap.
Philosophy 2803 – Health Ethics Andrew Latus. Introduction Ethics Study of right and wrong/good and bad A Branch of Philosophy Central Question = “How.
Marx & Engels Economic & Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 The German Ideology The Communist Manifesto.
Introduction to Ethics Lecture 9 The Challenge of Cultural Relativism By David Kelsey.
Introduction to theoretical perspectives Marxism.
Critical Thinking. Critical thinkers use reasons to back up their claims. What is a claim? ◦ A claim is a statement that is either true or false. It must.
STRUCTURALISM IN SOCIOLOGY “the belief that phenomena of human life are not intelligible except through their interrelations. These relations constitute.
Karl Marx The Foundation of Critical Criminology.
Critical Theory and Philosophy “The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point, however, is to change it” Marx, Theses on.
Critical Social Theory “[O]ur age is … the age of enlightenment, and to criticism everything must submit” Kant, Critique of Pure Reason.
Critical Social Theory
Friedrich Engels & Karl Marx
Environments of simulacra The virtual has become a place that we constantly refer to, an environment that lacks the dimensionality of an on-the-ground.
Philosophy An introduction. What is philosophy? Ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle said that philosophy is ‘the science which considers truth’
Critical Theory and Philosophy “The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point, however, is to change it” Marx, Theses on.
The Art About Statements Chapter 8 “Say what you mean and mean what you say” By Alexandra Swindell Class Four Philosophical Questions.
Bertrand Russell ( ) From The Problems of Philosophy (1912)  Truth & Falsehood  Knowledge, Error, & Probable Opinion  The Limits of Philosophical.
Base and Superstructure (Marxism). Base and Superstructure form a synthetic pair explicitly or implicitly common to all socialisms but due as such to.
PP216 “If commodities could speak, they would say this: our use-value may interest men, but it does not belong to us as objects. What does belong to us.
Relativism. “Cultural Relativism” William Graham Sumner Account of the origin of the notions of “true” and “right” Account of the origin of the notions.
Capitalism  Massive and unprecedented increase in wealth  Great increase of the world population and health benefits  Development of science, culture.
Philosophy of Science Lars-Göran Johansson Department of philosophy, Uppsala University
1 Lesson 7: Arguments SOCI Thinking Critically about Social Issues Spring 2012.
Lecture Rousseau & Marxism. Enlightenment versus Romanticism zKant on Enlightenment: Man’s emergence from his self-imposed immaturity. Immaturity is the.
The philosophy of Ayn Rand…. Objectivism Ayn Rand is quoted as saying, “I had to originate a philosophical framework of my own, because my basic view.
Lit Crit Round Two: Marxist and Feminist Lit ~define Marxist Lit Crit ~define “false consciousness” ~define “ideology” ~define “reification” ~define “patriarchy”
Marx World Literature Mr. Brennan. Myth & Power How can religion be used to legitimize power? How can religion be used to keep an individual or group.
CRITICAL APPROACHES TO LITERATURE Literary Theory.
PSIR401 German Ideology.
Ethics and Values for Professionals Chapter 2: Ethical Relativism
Karl Marx ( ) born in Trier, Germany He developed a method of analysis called dialectical materialism, in which the clash of historical forces.
SOCIOL 316: Critical Theories of Schooling
One Sociological Theory of Society, Social Life and History
Lecture 2 Classical Marxism.
Marx and Louis Althusser
Reasoning about Reasoning
Karl Marx, Capital, Volume 1
SPEECH110 C.ShoreFall 2015 East San Gabriel Valley, ROP
The Capital by Karl Marx
Presentation transcript:

Critical Social Theory “People with opinions. Where do they come from. These days it seems like a natural fact. What we think changes how we act” The Gang of Four

2 Two conceptions of ideology “The mode of production of material life conditions the social, political and intellectual life process in general. It is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness” (‘Preface’ 45) “The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas … [Each ruling class] present its interests as the common interest of all the members of society” (German Ideology ).

3 Marx and Engels: ideology Both conception share the following features: 1) “The premises from which we start are not arbitrary; they are no dogmas … They are the real individuals, their actions and their material conditions of life. … The first fact to be established, then, is the physical organization of these individuals” (German Ideology 107) What is the significance of this starting point for analysis compared with that of Kant and other philosophers?

4 Marx and Engels: ideology The starting point for Marx’s analysis is with the given material conditions (natural bases) and work through the modifications resulting from man’s actions. Contrast with the philosophical analyses offered by Marx and Engels’ contemporaries: “In direct contrast to German Philosophy, which descends from heaven to earth, here one ascends from earth to heaven. … One does not set out from what men say, imagine or conceive nor from man as he is … imagined” ( )

5 Marx and Engels: ideology 2) Both conception of ideology are committed to the view that it is the material base that conditions the superstructure. Superstructure (legal, political, religious) ↑ Base (relations of production)

6 Philosophical Implications Consider the first conception of ideology: “Conceiving, thinking …appear here as the direct result of their material behaviour” (German Ideology, 111) Does this view commit us to the position that for each mode of man’s material behaviour there is a corresponding set of beliefs, which may not be ‘true’ in a different mode of material behaviour?

7 Ideology and relativism So in the case of ideology, under one mode of material behaviour, the proposition “there are natural slaves” is held true but is held to be false under another mode. The above view is a form of relativism How plausible is relativism?

8 Relativism What is relativism? Relativism (roughly): there are no objective truths Argument: 1. X believes that S is true 2. Y believes that S is false 3. Therefore, there is no objective way to decide whether S is true or false Is this argument valid?

9 Philosophical Implications: ideology In each epoch, beliefs about values, and social relations appear like natural facts. These beliefs systematically misrepresent social reality—the analogy to an upside down image in a camera obscura (German Ideology, 111) How does ideology, which distort social reality, affect the autonomy of individuals? Undermines the autonomy of individuals

10 Philosophical Implications: ideology and the ‘correct’ view Second, if it is the case that for each historical period, there is one set of dominant beliefs, and those beliefs systematically distort social reality, can we ever get to social reality as it really is? Marx and the end of ideology: “This whole appearance, that the rule of a certain class is only the rule of certain ideas, comes to a natural end, of course, as soon as class rule in general ceases to be the form in which society is organized” (49)

11 Analysis of Commodity as ideology critique It is the task of criticism to reveal the real relations—ideology critique What is a commodity? “The commodity is, first of all, an external object, a thing which through its qualities satisfies human needs of whatever kind” (Capital 220)

12 Commodity Commodities are also exchanged What property do commodities have that allow them to be exchanged? Value, which belongs to the thing. What is this ‘value’?

13 Commodity For Marx, what needs examination is precisely why commodities appear to us to have ‘value’—which is not part of its physical properties—and also as things that have independent existence. In other words, what is the ‘reality’ of commodity exchange?

14 Commodity Key terms: use-value, exchange-value, labour, qualitative, quantitative Use-value ( ): individuals find in objects various features which satisfy their needs. These physical features are the bases of use- value. Use-values are realised, emerge, in use or in consumption As use values, commodities are qualitative different (222)

15 Commodity Exchange value: central feature of commodities. “If commodities could speak, they would say this: our use value may interest men, but it does not belong to us as objects. What does belong to us as objects, however, is our value. Our own intercourse as commodities proves it. We relate to each other merely as exchange-values” (Capital 243).

16 Commodity Commodities can be exchanged for one another; the value of the exchange is quantitative—5 bushels of wheat for 3 chords of wood. Exchange value render diverse things equivalent. What makes such diverse things equivalent? The labour that went into producing the different objects.

17 Commodity and Labour But isn’t the labour that went into the production of these objects as diverse as the objects themselves? Consider the labour of a tailor and a watch maker. Are they not different? So what allows for the exchange of commodities? “Human labour in the abstract” (222) or “homogeneous human labour” (223)—an abstract notion and not specific productive activities

18 Commodity and Labour If labour is the value-forming substance, then it should be the case that the more labour required (the more labour-time required), then the article should be more valuable. But is that so? Marx and the idea of ‘productivity’: one has to consider “the conditions of production normal for a given period with average degree of skill and intensity of labour prevalent in the society” (223). That is, the labour time “socially necessary” for the production of the commodity (224).

19 Summary and Implications of Marx’s analysis 1) What is the substance of value of a commodity? 2) What is the measure of its magnitude? Answers:1) labour; 2) labour-time 1) Use-value: an item can be a use-value without being a value. Why? 2) An article can be a use- value without being a commodity. Why? Answers: 1) no labour involved—natural resources; 2) no social use value (225), i.e. not exchanged

20 Commodity exchange The exchange relation then consists of the exchange of different articles that relate to one another in a quantitative manner. These relations between commodities appear to be independent of us; they appear to have a life of its own. That’s the next step.