What’s New in Helicobacter Pylori Therapy Waqar Qureshi, MD, Professor of Medicine, Clinical Chief of Gastroenterology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas
OUTCOMES OF H. PYLORI INFECTION Gastric Cancer Environmental Factors Atrophic Gastritis Gastric Ulcer Acute Gastritis Acute-on-Chronic Gastritis Lymphoma Antral Predominant Gastritis Duodenal Ulcer Childhood Mid-life Old Age
H. pylori Causes Peptic ulcer disease (1 in 6) Gastric cancer (1 to 19%) Progressive gastric damage Iron deficiency B12 deficiency Reduced absorption of drugs requiring an acid stomach such as L-dopa & thyroxine
Helicobacter pylori H. pylori is a serious chronic transmissible infectious disease that causes damage to gastric structure and function and is a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. The prevalence of H. pylori is inversely related to the general health and well being of a society. It should be eradicated
WHOM TO TEST Dyspepsia (symptomatic Hp?) Ulcer Disease Gastric cancer Present or past history 1st degree relatives Gastric cancer Family history gastric cancer After endoscopic resection of gastric cancer
Evaluate Hp eradication Family members of infected WHOM TO TEST Plan to start therapy Chronic NSAID therapy Chronic PPI therapy (eg, GERD) Evaluate Hp eradication Family members of infected Patient desires to be tested
Whom to Treat for Hp All with active Hp infection unless there is a compelling reason not to
STEPS IN THERAPY OF Hp Diagnosis Therapy Confirm cure
Hp is an Infectious Disease Hp therapies either succeed or fail There is no partial success Primary causes of failure Resistance to one or more antibiotics Adherence with drug regimen
Scoring “Effective” Treatment Regimens Outcome Success* Excellent: >95% Good: >90% Borderline: 85-89% Unacceptable <84% * Per Protocol: reliably with susceptible strains.
The Present No new therapies approved for more than a decade Old therapies have become relatively ineffective (eg, 70% cure rates) Overall prevalence decreasing but still high in subpopulations (31% in VA population), 70%+ in Hispanic and Asian immigrants.
Current Therapies Clarithromycin based therapy Bismuth based therapy PPI, amox, metronidazole Fluoroqunilone based Rifabutin based Triple Quadruple 7, 10 or 14 days duration
PPI – Amox –Clari Therapy 100 Hong Kong n = 592 80 Taiwan n = 1200 U.S. n = 1255 Europe n = 3752 Korea n = 598 China n = 148 60 ITT Cure Rates (%; 95% CI) 40 Japan n = 1323 20 Results of Recent Trials
Clarithromycin-Containing Regimes Triple therapy (3 drugs) PPI+Amoxicillin+Clarithromycin Concomitant therapy (4 drugs) PPI+Amox+Clari+Metro Sequential therapy (4 drugs) PPI+Amox then PPI+Clari+Metro
Other Common Regimes Triple metronidazole therapy PPI+Amoxicillin+Metronidazole Triple fluroroquinolone therapy PPI+Amoxicillin+Levofloxacin Bismuth Quadruple therapy PPI+Bismuth+Metro+Tetracycline
Empiric Therapies Clarithromycin based: Amoxicillin (1 g), BID Clarithromycin (500 mg), BID Tinidazole (500 mg) or Metronidazole (500 mg) BID PPI (40 mg omeprazole equivalent per dose) BID 14 days Bismuth quadruple therapy: Bismuth subsalicylate 2 tablets QID Tetracycline hydrochloride (500 mg) QID Metronidazole/tinidazole (500 mg) TID PPI twice daily for 14 days (40 mg omeprazole equivalent per dose). Not Doxycycline
Salvage Therapies: After at least 2 failures with different antimicrobials Rifabutin triple therapy (best if susceptibility-based) Rifabutin (150 mg daily), Amoxicillin (1.5 g q.8.h. Pantoprazole 80 mg (or an equivalent PPI) q.8.h. for 14 days, consider adding Bismuth 2 tabs bid High dose PPI-amoxicillin dual therapy PPI (e.g. esomeprazole 40 mg) QID Amoxicillin (750 mg) QID 14 days
Treatment Comparison - Susceptible Strains (PP) - Therapy Days Success Clarithromycin triple therapy 7 94% Clarithromycin triple therapy 14 97% Sequential therapy 10 94% Sequential therapy 14 97% Fluoroquinolone triple 7 <80% Fluoroquinolone triple 10 <90% Fluoroquinolone triple 14 96%
Treatment Comparison – 2 - Susceptible Strains (PP) - Therapy Days Success PPI metronidazole triple 7 94% PPI metronidazole triple 14 97% PPI bismuth tetra metro 7 91% PPI bismuth tetra metro 10 93% PPI bismuth tetra metro 14 >95%
Treatment Comparison - With Resistant Strains (PP) - Therapy Days Success Clarithromycin triple therapy 7 <20% Clarithromycin triple therapy 14 <50% Sequential therapy (dual) 10 <20% Sequential therapy (dual) 14 <20% Fluoroquinolone triple 7 <20% Fluoroquinolone triple 10 <20% Fluoroquinolone triple 14 <50%
7 Day Clari-Triple Rx PP 100 80 Treatment Success (%) 60 40 20 94% 80 Susceptible 60 Treatment Success (%) 40 20 10% Clari Res Triple Rx Dual (PPI +A)
Predict Success for an Individual Patient Prior antibiotic use Previously treated for H. pylori Predict Resistance Treatment outcome (per protocol) All Suscept Clari Resistant Metro Resistant Dual Resistant Regimen 94% 7 day Clari Triple 97% 14 day Clari Triple 95% 10 day Sequential 98+% 14 day Sequential 97+% 14 day Concomitant
Predict Success for an Individual Patient Prior antibiotic use Previously treated for H. pylori Predict Resistance Treatment outcome (per protocol) All Suscept Clari Resistant Metro Resistant Dual Resistant Regimen <20% 94% 7 day Clari Triple 97% <50% 14 day Clari Triple 95% 80% 10 day Sequential 98+% 88% 14 day Sequential 97+% 97% 14 day Concomitant
Predict Success for an Individual Patient Prior antibiotic use Previously treated for H. pylori Predict Resistance Treatment outcome (per protocol) All Suscept Clari Resistant Metro Resistant Dual Resistant Regimen <20% 94% 94% 7 day Clari Triple <50% 97% 97% 14 day Clari Triple 95% 80% 75% 10 day Sequential 98+% 88% 75% 14 day Sequential 97+% 97% 97% 14 day Concomitant
Predict Success for an Individual Patient Prior antibiotic use Previously treated for H. pylori Predict Resistance Treatment outcome (per protocol) All Suscept Clari Resistant Metro Resistant Dual Resistant Regimen <20% 94% 94% <20% 7 day Clari Triple 97% <50% 97% <50% 14 day Clari Triple 95% 80% 75% <20% 10 day Sequential 98+% 88% 75% <20% 14 day Sequential 97+% 97% 97% <50% 14 day Concomitant
Previously treated for H. pylori Bismuth Quadruple Rx Prior antibiotic use Previously treated for H. pylori Predict Resistance Treatment outcome (per protocol) All Suscep Clari Resistant Metro Resistant Dual Resistant Regimen 7 day bismuth quadruple 91% n/a 75% n/a 10 day bismuth quadruple 93% n/a 85% n/a n/a 95% n/a 14 day bismuth quadruple 99%
Bismuth Quadruple “Modified” Amoxicillin 1gm BID Bismuth subsalicylate 2 tablets QID Tetracycline hydrochloride (500 mg) QID Metronidazole (500 mg) TID PPI BID 14 days. Tetracycline is difficult to obtain Doxycycline is not a useful substitute! Helidac (not currently available) Amoxicillin 1gm BID
Bismuth subcitrate 140mg Metronidazole 125mg Tetracycline 125mg 3 tabs QID + a PPI BID e.g. omeprazole 40mg BID
Recommended Empiric Regimens (14 days) Concomitant therapy Bismuth quadruple therapy Currently only Pylera available (give for 14 days) + PPI Do not use doxycycline PPI: always use 40 mg omeprazole or equivalent b.i.d.
Initial Approach 2015 H. pylori infected History of antibiotic use? Previously treated for H. pylori? Treatment naive Treatment naive Prior treatment Failure Prior treatment Failure 14 day concomitant Rx 14 day bismuth quadruple Alternate best local Rx
Treatment Failures Ensure compliance Avoid antibiotics used before (history) Fluoroquinolones Rifabutin PPI – Amoxicillin high dose Susceptibility based: Culture for antimicrobial sensitivities
In particular, don’t use these again Clarithromycin Fluoroquinolones (eg, levofloxacin) Rifabutin PPI + clarithromycin + amoxicillin becomes PPI + amoxicillin
14 day Fluoroquinolone Amoxicillin 1 gram b.i.d. Levo 500 or Moxi 400 once a day PPI b.i.d. 14 days (7 and 10 day = poor results) Can not be used if a fluoroquinolone has been used in the past Best if based on culture and susceptibility testing Miehlke: Helicobacter 2011:16:420
Rifabutin Triple Rx Rifabutin 150 mg once daily (b.i.d.?) Amoxicillin 1.5 g t.i.d. Pantoprazole 80 mg t.i.d. (or equivalent) (Consider adding bismuth 2 tabs b.i.d.) All for 14 days * We need more studies and confirmation Borody: Aliment Pharmacol Ther 2006;23:481.
High Dose PPI-Amox PPI (eg, 40 mg esomeprazole) plus Amoxicillin 750 mg every 6 hours for 14 days.
Choice for a Population Depends on resistance patterns 14 day triple (only when all susceptible) 14 day concomitant 14 day bismuth quadruple (dual resistance) Should yield >90% eradication
Clari-Containing Regimens - Conclusions - High prevalence of clari AND met resistance (high dual resistance) No clari-containing regimen is useful when the is a high prevalence of dual resistance
Keys to Success Use what is effective locally Use it exactly (dose, duration, etc) In treatment failures, base therapy on measured susceptibility testing (Tailored therapy) Confirm cure in all (UBT or Stool)
References