1.WHAT DOES CAPE TOWN MEAN FOR CANADA?  U.S. Rating Agencies analyzed Air Canada EETC 2013-1 Issue of Series A, B and C Aircraft Notes and Critical Importance.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Bankruptcy Legal Research Guide. Table of Contents Slides I. Introduction …… II. Secondary Sources ………11-36.
Advertisements

PPSA SKILLS SESSION PPSA and Leases of Personal Property by Andrew McFarlane.
Fall 2013 Adjustment of State and Municipal Debt Under Chapter 9 the Bankruptcy Code J. Robert Stoll Mayer Brown LLP Visiting Professor University of Belgrade.
Ouch! That Really Hurts! Bankruptcy “Clawbacks” – Preferences and Fraudulent Transfers By Michael R. Stewart, Stephen M. Mertz and Colin F. Dougherty First.
Copyright © 2004 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited CANADIAN BUSINESS AND THE LAW Second Edition by Dorothy Duplessis Steven Enman Shannon.
Article XXXVI – Signature, ratification, acceptance, approval or accession 1. – This Protocol shall be open for signature in Berlin on 9 March 2012 by.
Aircraft Fractional Ownership in Aruba From a financing perspective.
Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. v. W. Hugh Meyer & Associates, Inc., 864 F.2d 371 (5th Cir. 1989)
1 Cape Town Convention and Aircraft Protocol in Canada Jean Surette Senior Policy Advisor, Air Policy Transport Canada April 29, 2013.
1 Secured Transactions Assignment 7 Treatment of Secured Creditors in Bankruptcy.
Bankruptcy of the purchaser and enforceability of retention of title vis-à-vis its receivership International Insolvency Law Conference Nottingham Law.
RATIFICATION OF THE CAPE TOWN CONVENTION AND ITS AIRCRAFT PROTOCOL IN CANADA (11 YEARS, 4 MONTHS AND 16 DAYS!) SEMINAR ON THE CAPE TOWN CONVENTION AND.
Development of the discharge procedure for secured creditors’ claims in insolvency proceeding.
The insolvency provisions: historical and economic perspectives Kristin van Zwieten John Collier Fellow in Law, Trinity Hall, Cambridge.
BY TODD MEIERHENRY DEBT ISSUES CONTINUING DISCLOSURE SUBMISSION IN EMMA.
Enforcing Security Interests in Brazil March 2009.
World Bank/KenGen Workshop on CDM Project Methodologies and Preparation October 3 & 4, 2006 CDM Contracting and Legal Issues.
Chapter 27 Secured Transactions and E-Filing
Chapter 17: Leases The lease contract Capitalization Evolution of lease accounting Economic consequences of lease capitalization.
Patty Bartlett Logan County Treasurer / Public Trustee.
MODEL IMPLEMENTING IDERA REGULATION SUMMARY POWERPOINT FIRST EDITION NOVEMBER 2014.
Foreign economic activity participants Foreign economic activity participants – a legal entity or an individual registered as individual entrepreneurs.
Copyright © 2008 by West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning Chapter 23 Nature and Form of Sales Contracts Twomey Jennings Anderson’s.
 Fifth Third Bank | All Rights Reserved Vessel Financing Choices for Ferry Operators.
Cut through Meora Teitler, ADV.. What is a cut through clause? A cut- through clause allows a party not in privity with the reinsurer to have rights against.
Arbitration Agreements Single Premium Credit Insurance.
Mechanic’s Lien DENIZE & SARAH. WHAT IS A MECHANIC’S LIEN  A Mechanic’s Lien is a security interest in the title to property for the benefit of those.
Year 15: Nonprofit Transfer Strategies for Expiring LIHTC Properties Supportive Housing Network of New York May 5, 2009 Presenters: Gregory Griffin, Director,
Secured Transactions Assignment 2
Holland + Knight Assignment and Assumption or Novation?: Cape Town Convention Implications for the Unwary Drafter AIRCRAFT FINANCING SUBCOMMITTEE 2008.
Exploring the Luxembourg Rail Protocol Martin J Fleetwood – Partner Secretary, Rail Working Group.
2008 CUSLI Annual Conference April 18-19, 2008 The World's Longest Undefended Border: Gateway or Checkpoint? Partners in Protection: Consistent with Canada’s.
Overview - FASB Exposure Draft Leases (Topic 840) February 2, 2011 Douglas Boedeker, CPA, CMA
Protecting Aircraft Assets Following Default Integrated Aviation Finance School. Jackson Chow & Judy Tan, 12 January 2015, Shenzhen.
Business Law Chapter 14: Negotiable Instruments, Securities and Secured Transactions.
Legal Issues Framework Ravi NATH RNClegal/ Rajinder Narain & Co. t: t: f: f: c:
Copyright © 2014 Holland & Knight LLP. All Rights Reserved Legal opinion, standards and practices and the Cape Town Convention 8 September 2015 Cape Town.
November 2010 William Ho – Partner Jackson Chow – Senior Foreign Registered Lawyer William KK Ho & Co The statements contained herein are based on good.
Chapter 9: The Uniform Commercial Code
Financing Principles Chapter 14 Zaharopoulos. 3 Financing Instruments 1. Mortgage 2. Deed of Trust 3. Carryback, Installment, Land Contract, Contract.
Copyright ©2006 by West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning Chapter 7 International Law Its Legal, Ethical, and Global Environment.
Chapter 23 NATURE AND FORM OF SALES. 2Introduction Contracts for the sale of services and real estate are governed by the common law. Contracts for the.
Legal Framework Analysis for Municipal Financing Brad Johnson President Resource Mobilization Advisors
How to Manage Assets and Risk from a Legal Perspective William KK Ho & Co. Jackson Chow, 30 October 2012, Hong Kong.
What The Charter Says. Guarantee of Rights and Freedoms 1. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the rights and freedoms set out in it.
CHAPTER 25 SECURED TRANSACTIONS: ATTACHMENT AND PERFECTION DAVIDSON, KNOWLES & FORSYTHE Business Law: Cases and Principles in the Legal Environment (8.
PRESENTATION TO THE NCOP ON THE CONVENTION ON INTERNATIONAL INTERESTS IN MOBILE EQUIPMENT BILL, MARCH 2007.
Forms of Business and Formation of Partnerships Chapter 37.
Copyright © 2004 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited CANADIAN BUSINESS AND THE LAW Second Edition by Dorothy Duplessis Steven Enman Shannon.
Risk Management for Lessors Paul Dwyer Head of Risk.
1 CXS490 Ozone Protections Program Factsheet
C ODE E NFORCEMENT IN THE A GE OF F ORECLOSURE Craig E. Leen City Attorney City of Coral Gables Abandoned Real Property and Squatters Ordinances.
Task Force on Banking Crisis Resolution Procedures Assonime-CEPS-Unicredit Task Force on Banking Crisis Resolution Procedures Key issues in bank crisis.
FINANCING TECHNIQUES: SHORT TERM. UNSECURED CREDIT I. UNSECURED CREDIT A. How is it provided? line of credit promissory note that can be rolled over B.
2016 INSOLVENCY AND RESTRUCTURING FORUM VESTING ORDERS Robert G. MacKeigan, Q.C., Stewart McKelvey John D. Stringer, Q.C., McInnes Cooper.
Class Unification of Law - Uniform Law (Rechtsvereinheitlichung) Summer term 2015.
Class Unification of Law - Uniform Law (Rechtsvereinheitlichung) Summer term 2015.
Foreign Air Operator Validation & Surveillance Course
Legislative developments reflecting recent trends in ship finance
Agency, distributorship and franchising contracts in the United Arab Emirates IDI Annual Meeting, 13 June 2009, Barcelona
Real Estate Loan Workouts: What Lenders and Borrowers Both Want and Need ABA Section of Business Law (Real Estate Financing Subcommittee) 2009 Spring.
Second ICAO Meeting on Air Cargo Development in Africa
Municipal revenue securitization
Fraudulent Transfers Governed by the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act.
Global aircraft trading system (GATS) Modernizing aircraft transfers
< Making it easier to obtain credit > Possible reform of secured transactions regimes based on the UNCITRAL Model Law – Key Principles Jae Sung LEE.
Mortgage A mortgage is the transfer of interest in specific immovable property for the purpose of securing the payment of money advanced or to be advanced.
Global aircraft trading system (GATS) Modernizing aircraft transfers
Global aircraft trading system (GATS) Modernizing aircraft transfers
Cape Town Convention Academic Project – 8th Conference 10th and 11th September 2019 Oceanair Insolvency: US Ch 15 – Alternative A in a Secondary Insolvency.
Presentation transcript:

1.WHAT DOES CAPE TOWN MEAN FOR CANADA?  U.S. Rating Agencies analyzed Air Canada EETC Issue of Series A, B and C Aircraft Notes and Critical Importance of Cape Town to Their Ratings: 1

1.WHAT DOES CAPE TOWN MEAN FOR CANADA? A. Fitch Ratings: “Importantly, Canada has adopted CTC in the manner that is intended to be most favorable to EETC holders in a potential default with all the key declarations including: (i) Alternative A, which essentially ‘exports Section 1110’ into foreign jurisdictions with the same 60-day stay period following an insolvency event (ii) self-help remedies, (iii) an Irrevocable De- Registration and Export Request Authorization (IDERA) registration, which obligates AC and the Canadian government to assist creditors in the deregistration and export of the aircraft, and (iv) choice of law. CTC Alternative A also requires AC to maintain and preserve the aircraft and its value in accordance with the financing agreement during the 60-day stay period, which is an additional enhancement over Section 1110 … Fitch views the creditor protection provided by CTC Alternative A in Canada to be the same as the legal protection provided by Section 1110 in the U.S. The CTC has yet to be tested in Canadian courts, which adds some uncertainty, but Fitch does not view this as a significant concern in Canada given the reliability of its legal system. However, it could be an issue in other CTC jurisdictions along with the political risk inherent in some countries. The general insolvency regime in Canada is strong, with case law precedent from AC’s 2003 CCAA filing in favor of the aircraft lessor.” 1 _______________ 1. Press Release, 24 April

1.WHAT DOES CAPE TOWN MEAN FOR CANADA? (CONT’D) B. Moody’s Investors Service: “These EETCs differ from traditional EETCs in that 1) the security interest is subject to the Cape Town Treaty that became part of Canadian law on 1 April 2013, rather than Section1110 of the US Bankruptcy Code … We believe Canada’s adoption of the Cape Town Convention provides a comparable level of protection to that found in transactions governed by Section 1110 given the form of Canada’s adoption (Alternative A) and the country’s historical record of complying with its federal and provincial laws and obligations under international treaties … Our approach to Cape Town in this transaction should not be construed as a precedent for other transactions issued in other jurisdictions; the specifics of the adoption of Cape Town can differ by jurisdiction and are an important consideration in our ratings assessment … 3

1.WHAT DOES CAPE TOWN MEAN FOR CANADA? (CONT’D) The ratings assignment reflects our belief that the Government of Canada and the 10 of its 13 provinces and territories that have adopted Cape Town will honor the parameters of Cape Town that became part of Canadian and provincial and territorial law on 1 April Canada has now adopted the most creditor friendly elements of Cape Town, including Article VIII of the protocol (choice of law), Article XI (Alternative A) and Article XIII (de- registration and export request or IDERA). Cape Town’s Alternative A mirrors the terms of Section 1110 of the US Bankruptcy Code. Canada’s adoption provides for a 60 calendar day period for the mortgagee, lessee or conditional buyer of an aircraft or aircraft engine to affirm its obligations under an aircraft or engine financing, lease or CSA under a default scenario for such mortgagee, lessee or conditional buyer. Additionally, the operator is required to preserve the condition of the aircraft or engine pursuant to the terms of the underlying agreements during the 60 day period. This is an enhancement not found in Section If the airline affirms its obligations, delinquent installments, if any, under each financing plus accrued interest must be paid and the company would need to remain current on all future payments due pursuant to the CSAs. We believe that the provisions of Cape Town that are now part of Canadian, and applicable, provincial and territorial law will function as planned, such that secured parties with international interests so registered in the Cape Town registry (The International Registry) can expect to recover their aircraft and or engine assets under a default scenario where the operator no longer would like to use the aircraft or engine assets or attempts to maintain use without making contractual payments.” 2 _______________ 2. Pre-Sale Report, April 24,

1.WHAT DOES CAPE TOWN MEAN FOR CANADA? (CONT’D) “The ratings of the Certificates consider the credit quality of Air Canada … The ratings also reflect Moody’s opinion of … the international interests (security interests) recognized by the Cape Town Convention … Any combination of future changes in the underlying credit quality or ratings of Air Canada … court rulings or changes to Canadian law that weaken or remove Cape Town or Alternative A could cause Moody’s to change its ratings of the Certificates …” 3 _______________ 3. Press Release, April 24,

1.WHAT DOES CAPE TOWN MEAN FOR CANADA? (CONT’D) C.Standard & Poor’s: “The pass-through certificates benefit from legal protections afforded by Article XI, Alternative A, of the Protocol to the Cape Town Convention on International Interests in Mobile Equipment, as adopted in Canada. Alternative A is similar to Section 1110 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code … The Cape Town Convention went into effect in Canada on April 1, 2013, and has not yet been applied by the Canadian courts. Accordingly there is not precedent determining how the Cape Town Convention would be enforced by the courts of Canada. However, consistent with our generally positive view of the Canadian legal system, our analysis assumes that Canadian courts will interpret the statutory provisions that implement the Cape Town Convention in a manner that will give effect to the protections afforded by Cape Town Convention and the related protocol. Our analysis, therefore, anticipates that in a scenario where the loan trustee seeks to exercise its remedies under the conditional sale agreements or the equipment notes, as applicable, in the case of an insolvency related event of Air Canada …, that the legal protections afforded by Article XI, Alternative A of the Protocol to the Cape Town Convention will be available.” 4 _______________ 4. Press Release, April 24,