Absolute magnitudes of asteroids and a revision of asteroid albedo estimates from WISE thermal observations. * P. Pravec, A. W. Harris, P. Kušnirák, A.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
National Aeronautics and Space Administration Jet Propulsion Laboratory California Institute of Technology Near-Earth Object Camera NEOCam Amy Mainzer.
Advertisements

Recent Results from NEOWISE Amy Mainzer JPL. WISE 4 imaging channels covering 3 – 25  m 40 cm telescope operating at
Chapter 7 Statistical Data Treatment and Evaluation
Asteroid’s Thermal Models AS3141 Benda Kecil dalam Tata Surya Prodi Astronomi 2007/2008 Budi Dermawan.
Two-parameter Magnitude System for Small Bodies Kuliah AS8140 & AS3141 (Fisika) Benda Kecil [dalam] Tata Surya Prodi Astronomi 2006/2007.
Statistical Analysis of Near Earth Objects By Danielle Bisordi and Kristin Buckley Professor Florescu MA 331 December 3, 2009.
Prediction, Correlation, and Lack of Fit in Regression (§11. 4, 11
Apophis’ tumbling P. Pravec, P. Scheirich, J. Pollock, P. Kušnirák, K. Hornoch, A. Galád, E. Jehin, J. Manfroid, C. Opitom, M. Gillon, J. Oey, J. Vraštil,
832 Karin Shows No Rotational Spectral Variations Clark R. Chapman, B. Enke, W.J. Merline, D. Nesvorný, P. Tamblyn, and E.F. Young Southwest Research Institute.
RHESSI/GOES Observations of the Non-flaring Sun from 2002 to J. McTiernan SSL/UCB.
WISE Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer asteroids Galaxy ULIRGs brown dwarfs WISE will map the sky in infrared light, searching for the nearest and coolest.
Peter Vereš, Juraj Tóth, Leonard Kornoš Search for very close approaching NEAs Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovakia Faculty of mathematics, physics.
Intro to Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences PSYC 1900 Lecture 6: Correlation.
“ Testing the predictive power of semi-analytic models using the Sloan Digital Sky Survey” Juan Esteban González Birmingham, 24/06/08 Collaborators: Cedric.
Relationships Among Variables
Trends in characteristics of small NEA and MBA binaries Petr Pravec Astronomical Institute AS CR, Czech Republic Workshop on Binaries in the Solar System.
Learning and Using MPO PhotoRed Copyright, 2006 © Bdw Publishing Brian D. Warner Palmer Divide Observatory.
Statistical Methods For Engineers ChE 477 (UO Lab) Larry Baxter & Stan Harding Brigham Young University.
McGraw-Hill/IrwinCopyright © 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Chapter 9 Hypothesis Testing.
Inference in practice BPS chapter 16 © 2006 W.H. Freeman and Company.
Daniel Acuña Outline What is it? Statistical significance, sample size, hypothesis support and publication Evidence for publication bias: Due.
BPS - 3rd Ed. Chapter 211 Inference for Regression.
The Estimated Population of Small NEOs Alan Harris MoreData! Inc. Target NEO 2 Washington, DC, July 9, 2013.
Query on Cosmic Dark Energy by Error Analyses of Type Ia Supernova Qiu-he Peng (Depart. of Astronomy, Nanjing University)
Statistical problems in network data analysis: burst searches by narrowband detectors L.Baggio and G.A.Prodi ICRR TokyoUniv.Trento and INFN IGEC time coincidence.
Lecture 12 Statistical Inference (Estimation) Point and Interval estimation By Aziza Munir.
The B-V colors and photometric variability of Nix and Hydra, Pluto’s two small satellites Max Mutchler (STScI) S. Alan Stern (SwRI) Hal Weaver (JHU/APL)
LECTURE 19 THURSDAY, 14 April STA 291 Spring
1 GALEX Angular Correlation Function … or about the Galactic extinction effects.
Chile Sky Background at ESO/la Silla in the Visible and Near IR Leonardo Vanzi -Olivier R. Hainaut European Southern Observatory La Silla - Chile.
Measures of central tendency are statistics that express the most typical or average scores in a distribution These measures are: The Mode The Median.
Near-infrared photometry of Venus Richard W. Schmude, Jr. Gordon State College.
How Standard are Cosmological Standard Candles? Mathew Smith and Collaborators (UCT, ICG, Munich, LCOGT and SDSS-II) SKA Bursary Conference 02/12/2010.
Aldo Dell'Oro INAF- Observatory of Turin Detailed analysis of the signal from asteroids by GAIA and their size estimation Besançon November 6-7, 2003.
Lecture 16 Section 8.1 Objectives: Testing Statistical Hypotheses − Stating hypotheses statements − Type I and II errors − Conducting a hypothesis test.
1 Chapter 9 Hypothesis Testing. 2 Chapter Outline  Developing Null and Alternative Hypothesis  Type I and Type II Errors  Population Mean: Known 
© Copyright McGraw-Hill Correlation and Regression CHAPTER 10.
Is there a relationship between moon phase and birthrate? Finkenthal, N., and Woo, S. Desert View High School, Tucson, Arizona INTRODUCTION: The moon has.
Asteroids Rotation Period Study the photometric curve Rotation period Shape Is it binary? Surface composition spectroscopy.
Primary Rotations of Asteroid Pairs P. Pravec, D. Vokrouhlický, D. Polishook, A. Harris, A. Galád, O. Vaduvescu, F. Pozo, A. Barr, P. Longa, F. Colas,
1 Optical observations of asteroids – and the same for space debris… Dr. D. Koschny European Space Agency Chair of Astronautics, TU Munich Stardust school.
Characteristics of Stars  Parallax is the method used by astronomers to study the distance to relatively nearby stars.  Parallax is the apparent.
Diagnostics – Part II Using statistical tests to check to see if the assumptions we made about the model are realistic.
9.3/9.4 Hypothesis tests concerning a population mean when  is known- Goals Be able to state the test statistic. Be able to define, interpret and calculate.
Multivariate Analysis and Data Reduction. Multivariate Analysis Multivariate analysis tries to find patterns and relationships among multiple dependent.
NICMOS Calibration Challenges in the Ultra Deep Field Rodger Thompson Steward Observatory University of Arizona.
EARTH & SPACE SCIENCE Chapter 30 Stars, Galaxies, and the Universe
Current Works Determined drift during constant velocity test caused by slight rotation which results in gravity affecting accelerometers Analyzed data.
Stars, Galaxies, and the Universe Section 1 Section 1: Characteristics of Stars Preview Key Ideas Analyzing Starlight Stellar Motion Distances to Stars.
What is a reading? It is the single determination of the value of an unknown quantity It is the actual reading taken in an experiment.
Thomas Hackman: Stellar differential rotation1 Detecting stellar differential rotation NORDITA – Solar and stellar dynamo cycles Thomas Hackman,
Binaries among small main-belt asteroids Petr Pravec Astronomical Institute AS CR, Czech Republic Workshop on Binaries Paris-Meudon, 2008 May
An Optical Search for Small Comets R. L. Mutel & J.D. Fix University of Iowa An Optical Search for Small Comets R. L. Mutel & J.D. Fix University of Iowa.
BPS - 5th Ed. Chapter 231 Inference for Regression.
The Population of Near-Earth Asteroids and Current Survey Completion Alan W. Harris MoreData! : The Golden Age of Solar System Exploration Rome,
Interminimum Changes in Global Total Electron Content and Neutral Mass Density John Emmert, Sarah McDonald Space Science Division, Naval Research Lab Anthony.
Critical Appraisal Course for Emergency Medicine Trainees Module 2 Statistics.
Group refractive index ● Method ● Additional runs ● Wavelength distribution ● Systematics ● Results.
Outline Sampling Measurement Descriptive Statistics:
Asteroid 4 Vesta observed from OSIRIS-ROSETTA
Pluto’s thermal lightcurve: SPITZER/MIPS observations
VIRTIS Operations at Lutetia
Hypothesis Tests for a Population Mean,
832 Karin Shows No Rotational Spectral Variations
Star Light Star Bright Desktop Constellations
The Population of Near-Earth Asteroids Revisited
Validating CERES calibration and ADMs Using Data from East Antarctica
Section 1: Characteristics of Stars
Stellar position, distance, and properties
Section 1: Characteristics of Stars
Presentation transcript:

Absolute magnitudes of asteroids and a revision of asteroid albedo estimates from WISE thermal observations. * P. Pravec, A. W. Harris, P. Kušnirák, A. Galád, K. Hornoch Ondřejov Observatory, Czech Republic and More Data! Inc., California Asteroids, Comets, Meteors May 2012, Niigata, Japan * Report on a work for Icarus (paper revision completed, thanks to our reviewers Stephen Wolters and Amy Mainzer for constructive comments}

Asteroid albedos and diameters estimated from thermal models Input data: 1)Infrared measurements of the emitted thermal flux (four passbands 3.4 to 22 μm) 2)Photometric measurements of the reflected light flux (V band) A practice of the asteroid thermal modeling is to estimate the integral optical flux from the asteroid's absolute visual magnitude H and a model of its phase function. The WISE team used H values from the MPCORB catalog. Biases in the catalog H values need to be studied! Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) - The recent most productive thermal IR survey. The WISE team estimated albedos and diameters for > 10 5 asteroids. (Mainzer et al., Astrophys. J. 741, 90, 2011, Astrophys. J. 743, 156, 2011, Masiero et al., Astrophys. J. 741, 68, 2011) (Mainzer et al., Astrophys. J. 743, 156, 2011)

WISE asteroid albedos Mainzer et al. (Astrophys. J. 741, 90, 2011) found a correlation of the estimated WISE albedos with diameter: Below D ~ 30 km, S type asteroids appeared to have systematically higher albedos, the mean albedo was up to ~50% greater at D < 10 km than in the range km. Mainzer et al. suggested that it could be due to selection biases of the visual surveys against lower albedo objects among S types.

Checking catalog H data [Definition: The absolute magnitude, H, of a Solar System object is defined as the apparent magnitude of the object illuminated by the solar light flux at 1 AU and observed from the distance of 1 AU and at zero phase angle.] The catalog H data – a by-product of astrometric observations. Catalog H values are problematic especially for smaller asteroids: Analyses of SDSS asteroid data showed an average offset of mag (Parker et al. 2008, Jurić et al. 2002, Galád 2010 ) for the MPCORB and AstOrb catalogs. Need to analyze a size- (or H-)dependence of the catalog H offset. Control sample: 583 asteroids observed photometrically from Ondřejov, Table Mountain and our other observatories during Absolute errors δH = mag (one-apparition data), the median δH = 0.10 mag. Our observational and H estimation procedure: Use of the Johnson-Cousins VR standard stars (Landolt 1973, 1983, 1992) Rotation of asteroids accounted for -> mean H estimated G estimated, or assumed according to the known taxonomy or orbital group R data converted to V (to get H = H V ) using mean (V-R) for the known taxonomic class or orbital group Biases in our data sample estimated to be not greater than 0.1 mag in mean H.

Bias in the catalog H data The maximum negative offset of the MPCORB H values is about mag at H about 14. (Similar biases in the Pisa AstDyS and JPL Horizons catalogs.) Resulting in the WISE albedos systematically too bright by ~50% at D ~ 5 km (corresp. to H = 14 for S types).

Revised WISE albedos The WISE albedo estimates for 300 asteroids in our sample revised using our accurate H data with the method of Harris and Harris (Icarus 126, 450, 1997). A basic assumption of the method is that the quantity (1 - A v )D 2 is invariant. This conserves the thermal flux measured from the spacecraft, and revises p V and D using updated H value. The null hypothesis of constant albedo is not rejected at a level greater than 3σ in the range D = km for S type asteroids. The mean albedo of S types: = Standard deviation (dispersion) of the sample is The formal mean error of the mean albedo is ± The mean albedo of C types: = (Sample dispersion 0.013, formal error ± ) Result: No prominent change of albedo with size for S type asteroids. The trend of increasing albedo with decreasing size from ~30 downto ~5 km seen in the preliminary WISE albedos appears to be mainly due to the bias in the catalog H data they used.

Bias in the catalog H data – smaller effects A difference between S/S-like and C/C-like asteroids – the latter are systematically higher by ~0.09 mag in the (H MPCORB – H) plot. The “color dispersion” may be because the catalogs computers used a) a single default G (0.15), b) a single default V-R (0.4) for transformation of R or unfiltered magnitudes to V. The H offset, S vs C type dispersion

Bias in the catalog H data – smaller effects High-amplitude asteroids show the catalog H bias stronger by a few 0.01 to 0.1 mag. The small increase of (H catalog – H) with asteroid amplitude – actual reason unknown, but could be a natural consequence of the survey observations more likely to be taken around lightcurve maximum rather than minimum. The H offset, an effect of rotational amplitude

Conclusions Absolute magnitudes of asteroids in orbit catalogs are systematically biased. The bias is H-dependent; the negative offset (H catalog – H) reaches a maximum around H = 14. As a result, the preliminary albedo estimates from WISE observations were overestimated for asteroids smaller than ~30 km. We corrected the bias and found that there is no prominent trend in albedo with size for S type asteroids over the range 5 to 200 km.