Tsunami Evaluation Coalition: Progress to Date. Background OCHA, WHO, ALNAP Secretariat + DANIDA, USAID Level 1 Purpose: To promote a sector wide approach.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

1 Preliminary Consultative Meeting on Building a Global Network of NGOs for Community Resilience to Disasters, Geveva, October Global Platform for.

Advertisements

Aid Accountability and Transparency: Indonesia’s Experience

Africa is still facing significant development challenges Institutional capacity to adequately improve livelihoods of Africas citizens Systematic pan-African.

Strengthening statistical capacity in support of progress towards the Internationally Agreed Development Goals in countries of South Asia United Nations.

Report on Group One on Integrated Work Programme Martin Owor Assistant Commissioner Head of Disaster Devision Office of the Prime Minister Uganda 23 November.

Ministry of Labor and Social Policy SOCIAL POLICY COUNCILS Dragica Vlaović-VasiljevićSophia, 2-6th July 2007 Dragica Vlaović-VasiljevićSophia, 2-6th July.

Guidance Note on Joint Programming

Delivering as One UN Albania October 2009 – Kigali.

ENHANCING AID EFFECTIVENESS

World Meteorological Organization Working together in weather, climate and water WMO OMM WMO GFCS Governance proposal Process of development.

UN Channels and Mechanisms for Development Cooperation and the Role of Emerging Donors Cheile Gradistei, 18 September 2008 Daniel Hanspach Emerging Donors.

“ONE UN”: Delivering as One at the Country Level.

© GEO Secretariat Capacity Building Committee experience of resource mobilisation Alan EDWARDS EUROPEAN COMMISSION Research Directorate General Environment.

Commonwealth Local Government Forum Freeport, Bahamas, May 13, 2009 Tim Kehoe Local Government and Aid Effectiveness.

Support to the Development of Greenfield investments in Lithuania “Marketing and promotion of the industrial parks” Training session leader: Paul Baker,

The Current Debate on the Post-2015 Development Agenda Assistant Secretary-General Thomas Gass December 2014.

Core Values  Progression – progress breeds success - Promoting learning and career progression for individuals - Facilitating progression of the workforce.

Comprehensive M&E Systems

Performance Reviews - ZAMBIA Fifth IHP+ Country Health Teams Meeting Aligning for better results in changing environments 2-5 December 2014, Sokha Angkor.

Tsunami Evaluation Coalition 8-Aug-15 The Tsunami Evaluation Coalition: What Worked and What Did Not? European Evaluation Society 2006.

TEC Initial Findings v040 8-Aug-15 Initial findings from the TEC.

Global Lessons: First 4-6 months of the Tsunami Response.

On models of donor support and good practices Council for People's Development and Governance Regional Workshop on CSOs and Aid Effectiveness, Ha Noi,

STRENGTHENING the AFRICA ENVIRONMENT INFORMATION NETWORK An AMCEN initiative A framework to support development planning processes and increase access.

What do they do and how do they do it?. Presentation  History, structure and governance  Main areas of work  Achievements  Challenges  Lessons learnt.

1 An Overview of R&D Budgeting in Korea Symposium on International Comparison of the Budget Cycle in Research Development and Innovation Policies Madrid,

Disaster risk reduction – How did we get here?

Organically evolving CBC opportunities and areas of work INTOSAI Capacity Building Committee - Meeting in Lima, Peru 9-11 September 2014.

High-level forum on strategic planning for statistics: Bishkek, May 2006 Why statistics? Why strategic planning? Presentation by PARIS21 Secretariat.

1 Donor coordination and effectiveness of aid to agriculture Effectiveness in Aid to Agriculture Czech action to strengthen food security Glopolis / FoRS.

Coordination and Net Working on DRR Rapid Emergency Assessment and Coordination Team (REACT) Bishkek November, 2009.

Time to act on the Future of Europe …

1 Joint humanitarian impact evaluation: options paper Tony Beck 25 th ALNAP Meeting, London, 18 th November 2009 Commissioned by the Evaluation and Studies.

12-Oct-15 The Tsunami Evaluation Coalition. 12-Oct-15 The Tsunami Evaluation Coalition (TEC) January 2005: Several agencies discussed with ALNAP how to.

A Review of the Standing Committee of Caribbean Statisticians (SCCS) as a Mechanism for Statistical Development and Harmonisation The Second Meeting of.

February 21, JAS Consultation between the Government of Tanzania and Development Partners February 21, 2006 Courtyard Hotel, Dar es Salaam.

PACIFIC AID EFFECTIVENESS PRINCIPLES. Purpose of Presentation Provide an overview of Pacific Principles on Aid Effectiveness Provide an overview of Pacific.

Tsunami Evaluation Coalition (TEC): An Introduction.

Africa is still facing significant development challenges ● Institutional capacity to adequately improve livelihoods of Africa’s citizens ● Systematic.

WaterLinks A regional network for implementing Water Operators Partnerships (WOPs) in the Asia-Pacific Region.

The Next Stage for Results in Africa. Context 2005 Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness 2006 Mutual Learning Events Uganda & Burkina Faso 2007 Hanoi.

Regional humanitarian networks ALNAP Biannual Meeting Madrid, 3 rd June.

Trade Union Training on employment policies with a focus on youth employment 11 July, 2007 Turin, Italy.

Caribbean Telecommunications Union. 6th Caribbean Internet Forum (CIF), Port of Spain, October Caribbean Telecommunications Union Caribbean Internet.

DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION FRAMEWORK Presentation by Ministry of Finance 10 December 2013.

IAP meeting, Incheon, August 2009 First session of the Committee on Disaster Risk Reduction, March 2009 ESCAP Tsunami Regional Trust Fund.

Regional Gender Community of Practice Meeting Yerevan, October, 2007 Erika Kvapilova, Programme Specialist, UNIFEM CEE Office Bratislava.

Vision: A strong and capable civil society, cooperating and responsive to Cambodia’s development challenges Host of the 2nd Global Assembly for CSO Development.

Vito Cistulli - FAO -1 Damascus, 2 July 2008 FAO Assistance to Member Countries and the Changing Aid Environment.

Pacific Regional Joint Preparatory Meeting for the

September 8, 2015 Update Housing Committee September 8, 2015 Neighborhood Revitalization Plan for Dallas.

Jela Tvrdonova, The EU priorities:  Use the Leader approach for introducing innovation in the thematic axis  better governance at the local level.

Joint Assistance Strategy for Tanzania (JAST) Poverty Policy Week Creative and Hard Work, the Key to Fighting Poverty Presentation by the Ministry of Finance.

Global Partnership for Enhanced Social Accountability (GPESA) December 19, 2011 World Bank.

On Track with APF Uganda Debriefing Meeeting 13 April 2010 The Hague, Netherlands Welcome!

the coalition against corruption The Tsunami and Beyond – Preventing Corruption in Humanitarian Relief Presentation at ALNAP Bi-annual.

Paris, Accra, Busan. Paris Declaration of 2005 Provides foundation for aid effectiveness agenda. Introduces aid effectiveness principles which remain.

Towards a Sector Wide Approach (SWAp) for water sector in Lesotho Prepared by T.W. Sepamo Principal Engineer Water and Sanitation. Prepared for EUWI –

Bangladesh Joint Country Assistance Evaluation: Assessing Total ODA at the Country Level Presentation to OECD DAC November 2006 Bruce Murray Director General.

People that Deliver Improving health outcomes by promoting sustainable workforce excellence in health supply chain management A multi-stakeholder, cross-program.

Prinath Dias Former RCA Focal Person.  A little history  The policies behind the achievements  Some thoughts for the future.

Assessments ASSESSMENTS. Assessments The Rationale and Purpose for Assessments.

Peacebuilding Priority Plan Heads of Mission

Capacity-building Initiative for Transparency

Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) Asian Financial Crisis Response Trust Fund Review Overview of Progress 6/28/2006.

UN Support to SDG implementation in Seychelles.

KEEPING A DEVELOPMENT FOCUS: THE CHALLENGES IN ENSURING POLICY COHERENCE FOR DEVELOPMENT: A UGANDA’S PERSPECTIVE Presented by: Pius Bigirimana, Permanent.

Statistics Governance and Quality Assurance: the Experience of FAO

Follow us: June 15-16, 2017 Steering Committee Meeting Summary of Conclusions and Action Items Follow.

Primary Health Care Improvement Global Stakeholder Meting, Geneva

Presentation transcript:

Tsunami Evaluation Coalition: Progress to Date

Background OCHA, WHO, ALNAP Secretariat + DANIDA, USAID Level 1 Purpose: To promote a sector wide approach to evaluations of tsunami response in order to optimise sector wide learning Aims 1.To enhance coordination through the establishment of an ‘evaluation coalition’ 2.To increase comparability & reduce unnecessary duplication 3.To strengthen policy level as well as operational evaluation and learning 4.To increase and strengthen learning opportunities Level 2 Purpose: To develop and test procedures for future timely establishment of an evaluation coordination mechanism (coalition) that could facilitate such an approach

Concept Paper (Geneva Feb 2005) Developing a Sectorwide Approach for Evaluation Tsunami Assistance 1. Map (ALNAP Full & Observer Members = 500 +; handout) 2. Options for way forward (Lessons from previous joint evaluations)

OPTION 1: INFORMAL FRAMEWORK Key concept: Harmonisation & rationalisation Key features: Sharing ToR; avoiding duplication; sharing evaluative reports OPTION 2: ‘COMMON EVALUATION FRAMEWORK’ Key concepts: Comparability for increased lesson learning Improved quality Key features: CEF (common issues & questions) Active facilitation by OCHA & ALNAP Secretariat OPTION 3: FORMAL FRAMEWORK Key concepts: Comparability for increased lesson learning Greater robustness & rigour of final evaluations Key features: CEF Core Management Group (CMG) OPTION 4: SYSTEMWIDE EVALUATION Key concepts: Optimised coordination & sectorwide learning Key features (eg): SC & Project Mgmt Committee Core ‘Study Teams’ One overall ToR for evaluation Regional ‘Expert Panel’

INTEGRATED FRAMEWORK OPTION 1: Concepts & features OPTION 2: CEF OPTION 3: CMG OPTION 4: eg, thematic study teams; regional expert panel

Meeting Agreements 1.To constitute an ‘evaluation coalition’ 2.ALNAP Secretariat: coordinating mechanism 3.End of Year Synthesis Report 4.Longer term Study

1. To constitute an ‘evaluation coalition’ (Core Management Group & four Guiding Principles) Sharing Lesson learning Accountability Mutual support & transparency: such that potentially negative findings are seen to present opportunities for improved policy & practice 2. ALNAP Secretariat: coordinating mechanism Evaluation map Evaluation map Online Forum Online Forum End-of-Year Synthesis Report (RHA 2005) End-of-Year Synthesis Report (RHA 2005)

3. End of Year Synthesis Report (emergency & initial recovery) 1.Findings & learning from individual evaluation reports (coalition) 2.Multi-agency, ‘thematic’ evaluations on cross-cutting issues of priority interest Coordination Coordination Needs assessment Needs assessment Local / regional capacities Local / regional capacities Funding / fundraising (incl role of media) Funding / fundraising (incl role of media) Civil-military axis Civil-military axis Others Others 4. Longer term Study

Synthesis Report Individual agency evaluations (own mgmt and/or sectoral) Multi- agency thematic evaluations Individual agency evaluations (thematic) Common Framework/s Core Management Group ALNAP Secretariat / Coalition Coordinator Online Forum Evaluation Map Longer term Study E – V – A – L – U – A – T – I – O – N C – O – A – L – I – T – I – O – N Evaluation Coalition: Current Structure & Activities

How Jointly is ‘Joint’? DAC Evaluation Network Study: 11 typologies Decentralised multi- partner: Joint activities focus on establishing common frameworks. Implementation is decentralised – ie, devolved to different partners in the evaluations (IDP Synthesis Study) Stratified multi-partner: Partners enter on the understanding of some stratification of their respective roles (eg, lead agency + others in group)

Agencies Involved to Date Donor UN Agencies Intl NGOs DANIDAFAO (DEC) USAIDOCHA(IWG) SIDAUNDP CIDAUNICEF MFA-Netherlands(UNFPA) DC-Ireland

Total Evaluation Activity to Date Concrete plans:35 Total activities:44 Evaluations:26 (12 ‘traditional’; 7 ‘joint’; 6 real-time) Reviews:11 (5 ‘learning reviews’; 2 ‘after action’) Other:8 (various including surveys, research projects & monitoring visits) Joint:Thematic evaluations + IWG (World Vision Intl, Oxfam GB, Care) WHO, SEARO + HAC coordinated by OCHA Geographical emphasis: Indonesia, India, Thailand, Sri Lanka

Next Steps CMG: 14th April CMG: 14th April Writing of CFs & ToR: April – May Writing of CFs & ToR: April – May ALNAP Biannual: June ALNAP Biannual: June Evaluation research: July – early Oct Evaluation research: July – early Oct Synthesis: Dec/Jan Synthesis: Dec/Jan Publication: Jan/Feb (later for RHA) Publication: Jan/Feb (later for RHA)