Using Multi-Criteria Analysis in NCAP Water Projects : Context-Sensitive Practice with MCA-WEAP Bill Dougherty, SEI-Boston 9-13 May 2005 Akosomba, Ghana.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Conclusions and Recommendations

Advertisements

Linking A snapshot of challenges & opportunities for food security & sovereignty in West Africa Meredith Kushnir, REAP-Canada, Presentation for Dig In!

Food Security, Climate Adaptation and DRR Geneva, 18 June 2009.

Click to edit Master title style Adaption Tools for a Developed Agricultural Economy Judy Lawrence Director, New Zealand Climate Change Office Ministry.

Irrigated Agriculture Sector in South Asia Challenges and Potential Soft Solutions Mani Manivasakan Practice Leader Rural Water.

ActionAid: background and priorities on Investment in agriculture Presentation at the FAO Investment Days Rome 17 December 2014.

Ecosystem-based adaptation helps to build the resilience of natural habitat and communities to climate change impacts and thereby reduce their vulnerability.

Sustainable Regional Water Resource Management By: Tucson Regional Water Coalition and Southern Arizona Leadership Council.

Mozambique Workplan Eduardo Baixo May 2005 Akosombo, Ghana.

Pathleen Titus CARDI Representative , St Kitts and Nevis

™. What mechanisms and incentives can be created to encourage regional knowledge sharing and interaction through Platform? Climate Change Community Fostering.

2. Fisheries management and the Ecosystem approach

Integrating Drought Risk Management into Local Planning Framework Zhenghong Tang Community and Regional Planning Program University of Nebraska-Lincoln.

Increasing productivity and resilience Messages and project examples.

Strengthening farmer organisations to use technology to increase and sustain agricultural growth. Francois Laureys – Lead Advisor Agriculture

 Dr. Ibrahim Togola The challenges of African Energy Policy in the 2010 Berlin,14th June 2010.

 Country Context and status of National Communication  National climate change priorities, socio-economic scenarios and the driving forces  Climate.

A business case to reduce rural poverty through targeted investments in water in sub-Saharan Africa WWF5 Session How can food market measures boost.

Okanagan Basin Conservation Programs (SOSCP and OCCP) 80+ organizations (government and non-government) working together to achieve shared conservation.

Mainstreaming human mobility in adaptation to climate change policies and actions TADDESSE BEKELE FANTA ETHIOPIA.

Mangroves for the Future promoting investment in coastal ecosystem conservation.

Demands, Supplies & Priorities. Demand Sectors Irrigation Livestock Mining Industrial Commercial Ecosystems Domestic Total Water Demand Major Cities.

The Gambia: Low-Carbon high resilience infrastructure for sustainable development Ms. Fatou Ndey Gaye Minister of Forestry and the Environment,

Adapting to Droughts Among Poor Rural Households in Semi-arid Nigeria: Influencing Factors and Enhancing Opportunities Dabi, D., Nyong, A., Adepetu, A.,

FAO NAMA learning tool to support NAMA preparation in agriculture

National Policy and Strategy for Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries 15 March, 2004.

Hazards Risk Management Course Revision Project Update George Haddow June 2012.

GHANA Developing CSA within the National Agriculture Sector Investment Plan while reinforcing inter-sectoral consistency: progress, bottlenecks and support.

Linking current vulnerability with WEAP Bill Dougherty, SEI-Boston 9-13 May 2005 Akosomba, Ghana.

Decision making process / basic options assessment Mercury Storage and Disposal LAC Two Countries Project Gustavo Solórzano Ochoa, Consultan t Montevideo,

Providing Gender and Equity Balance in the NAPCC on Agriculture SUMAN SAHAI Gender and Economic Policy Discussion Forum, Inst. of Social Studies Trust.

Defining and Measuring the Development Dividend Meeting of the Expert Task Force of the IISD Development Dividend Project March 27-28, 2006 Vancouver Aaron.

NIGERIA Developing CSA within the NAIP while reinforcing inter-sectoral consistency: progress, bottlenecks and support needs With technical facilitation.

Seventh framework programme CAPACITIES specific programme Activities of international cooperation Coordination Support Action - Grant agreement no.:

Overview of Climate-Smart Agriculture for livestock production and livelihood in West Africa.

INVESTMENTS NEEDED TO SCALE- UP AGRO-ECOLOGY PRESENTED AT RIO+20 Wilfred Miga PELUM ASSOCIATION REGIONAL SECRETARIAT 15 th June 2012.

. (AIACC AF-14 ). Balgis Elasha and Bill Dougherty 1 Higher Council for Environment &Natural Resources 2 Stockholm Environmental Institute-Boston (SEI_B)

PARTNERSHIPS IN SUPPORT OF CAADP Progress Report Brief Progress Report AUC Page 1 of 14.

1 Summary of Vulnerability Assessment & Farming System Change under the Second National Communication to the UNFCCC Ministry of Environment and Tourism.

Comments on National Climate Change Response White Paper.

Sustainable Regional Water Resource Management By: Tucson Regional Water Coalition and Southern Arizona Leadership Council SUMBER:

Country CBA Project :Sri Lanka A study to economically evaluate possible adaptation measures for climate vulnerabilities in paddy and Other Field Crops.

Vulnerability and Adaptation of Water Resources to Climate Change in Egypt Dr. Dia Eldin Elquosy

AIACC Project AF14: Strategies for Increasing Community Resilience in Sudan: Lessons for Climate Change Adaptation  A joint project of the Sudan Higher.

Rosemary Vargas-Lundius Senior Research Coordinator Office of Strategy and Knowledge Management, IFAD CARITAS WORKING GROUP MEETING FOR ANTI-POVERTY CAMPAIGN.

Cooperating Partners Presentation October 12, 2006 Integrated Regional Water Management Plan (IRWMP) B S Strategies and Objectives C ANTA ARBARA OUNTY.

Global public policy network on water management Water and Climate Change Adaptation – Key Messages for COP-15 gppn.

Piloting Community-Based Adaptation Activities: Early Experiences in Bangladesh Angie Dazé and Ahsan Uddin Ahmed Adaptation Day at CoP11 Sunday, December.

Innovative and effective approaches to climate change: Experiences from the Global Climate Change Alliance Brussels 12 th -14 th September 2012 Thematic.

Objective 1: To increase resilience of smallholder production systems Output -Integrated crop-livestock systems developed to improve productivity, profitability.

Current and future work of the Adaptation Committee in the area of adaptation technologies Workshop on technologies for adaptation Bonn, Germany, 4 March.

IDENTIFICATION OF INNOVATIVE APPROACHES TO AAS. Dan Kisauzi 20 th June 2013 Dolphine Suites Kampala, Uganda.

Training on Safe Hospitals in Disasters Module 3: Action Planning for “Safe Hospitals”

IADB REGIONAL POLICY DIALOGUE June 25-26, Presented by : Ronald Jackson, Director General, ODPEM, Jamaica.

Transforming rural livelihoods and landscapes: sustainable improvements to incomes, food security and the environment Trevor Nicholls, CEO CABI Global.

INTER-AMERICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK Infrastructure and Environment Department (INE) Environment, Rural Development and Natural Disasters Division (RND) Agriculture,

Global public policy network on water management Bridging the Water and Climate Agendas 3 rd November, Barcelona Climate Change Negotiations, Room TEJO,

Rain for Life Jal Bhagirathi Foundation. About JBFAbout JBF Vision JBF works towards creating water security and promoting sanitation, sustained by responsive.

WEAP + Training Workshop: An Overview Netherlands Climate Assistance Program Bill Dougherty, SEI-Boston 9-13 May 2005 Akosomba, Ghana.

Honduras’ experience on NAP

Exercise Module 2b Assessing Climate Change Business Opportunities

Criteria for Assessing MHPSS Proposals Submitted through the CAP, CERF and HRF Funding Mechanisms to the Protection Cluster.

Climate Change Elements of the SADC Regional Agricultural Policy (RAP)

Zambia National Climate Change Response Strategy (NCCRS)

Bill Dougherty, SEI-Boston 9-13 May 2005 Akosomba, Ghana

Climate Change Elements of the SADC Regional Agricultural Policy (RAP)

CDD & Local Economic Development (LED) March 2018

LA06 Assessment of Impacts and Adaptation Measures for the Water Resources Sector Due to Extreme Events Under Climate Change Conditions. REGIONAL PROJECT.

Outcomes of the International Conference on Water Scarcity and Drought: “the path to climate change adaptation”

AGRICULTURE AND NAPA IN TANZANIA

Presentation transcript:

Using Multi-Criteria Analysis in NCAP Water Projects : Context-Sensitive Practice with MCA-WEAP Bill Dougherty, SEI-Boston 9-13 May 2005 Akosomba, Ghana

Overview Time: 3 hours +/- Aim: to help you become “expert navigators” of MCA-WEAP Outputs: a prioritized list of adaptation initiatives Plenary: Discussion of individual group results

Approach Split up into small groups of 2-3 Focus on previous watershed as vulnerable Consider 6 stakeholder types Consider 6 adaptation initiatives Choose 4 criteria from a list of criteria Assign criteria scores based on individual group discussions Use MCA-WEAP to calculate final scores and rankings (low, central, high)

Vulnerability Focus Type: watershed (I.e., region) Ecological zone: semi-arid (in Country N) Current climate hazards: more frequent single-year droughts, prolonged seasonal rainfall shortages Sensitivity of the region to the climate hazards: ???

Stakeholder Types Smallholders (<0.1 hectares per family) Pastorlists (goats & sheep) Traders (buyers/sellers) Agricultural extension workers Authority figures (local politicians or tribal leaders) One additional type

Adaptation Initiatives (consider all) Large dam Series of small dams Food storage silos Groundwater recharge boreholes More efficient water harvesting techniques using modern technology Capacity strengthening programs for enhancing traditional water management practices

Evaluation Criteria (choose only 4) Facilitate tourism Leads to greater water access Increase land productivity Represents new modern technology Strengthens local capacity for water management Maximizes use of traditional knowledge Stabilizes watershed population Enables community control of water prices Conducive to privatization Leads to greater exploitation of natural resources Promotes environmental security

Overall MCA-WEAP Tips Keep in mind that the model is still a Beta version Have a pad of paper handy and note any suggestions you might have as you work

Vulnerability Module Tips None

Stakeholder Module Tips Specify only 2 people per type Be brief

Initiative Module Tips For each of the 6 initiatives: identify 1 objective, List 3 essential activities, Provide a clear rationale for how the initiatives would increase resilience of region regarding climate change (2 sentences)

Criteria Module Tips Try to choose your 4 criteria so that they span the criteria types available in MCA- WEAP Insert low, central, and high scores - spend some time in discussing appropriate values

Weighting Module Tips Standardize the raw criteria scores first After weighting and assigning stakeholder consensus, review and confirm or change

Ranking Module Tips Review final scores first Review rankings Are the rankings different depending on the type of score? What does this mean?