The Almighty…Darwin? Alexis Tillett-Saks Beloit College In no other aspect do science and religion clash more fiercely than in the debate between creationism.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Evolution Evolution or Creation? 2 The Genesis Story (King James Version) In the beginning God created heaven and earth. Day 1: And God said, Let there.
Advertisements

Believing Where We Cannot Prove Philip Kitcher
The Design Argument Richard Dawkins – ( ) Richard Dawkins, FRS, FRSL (born 26 March 1941) is a British ethologist, evolutionary biologist and popular.
Genesis on a laptop God’s operations from the beginning.
a) AO1 – Knowledge and Understanding Explain in detail Use technical terms (and explain them) Include quotations Link back to the question Make sure your.
Exploration of Viewpoints of Teaching Biological Origins in Relation to Requiring that Evolution Creationism and Intelligent Design be included in Science.
Pebble in the Pond: Beginning A Dialogue on Science & Religion.
Section 2 Introduction-1
Religion in Public School: Unification or Separation Position 1: For Religious Freedom in Schools.
Robert Root-Bernstein and Donald L. McEachron in Applying Anthropology (2012:6-14)
Lincoln-Douglas Debate An Examination of Values. OBJECTIVES: The student will 1. Demonstrate understanding of the concepts that underlie Lincoln-Douglas.
Penn and Teller video  KjlFtU KjlFtU
Nora Davies. Evolution successfully explains the origins of life. It is the foundation of biology and is a building block for whole new types of agricultural,
Genesis and Science Genesis and Science. Recap Outline the creation story. 4KU.
Evolution, Creationism, and Intelligent Design Where does it fit in public schools?
An presentation by Rachel M. Klaus. The fact is, we both have the same evidence. Both groups, Evolution and Creation, don’t see that it is not a matter.
Martin Dankert and Aaron Hale. INTASC STANDARD Standard #5: Application of Content  The teacher understands how to connect concepts and use differing.
The Importance of Teaching Evolution in Public Schools By: Angie Bicher.
Freedom of Religion PowerPoint Presentation
The Evidence Explained. Learning Intentions: By the end of the lesson you will be able to… 1.Explain in detail at least two piece of evidence to support.
Evolution  To understand the theory of evolution, and to evaluate the evidence this is based on Thursday, August 27, 2015.
Chapter 19: Civil Liberties: First Amendment Freedoms Section 2
The Cosmological Argument (Causation or ‘first cause’ theory)
Ch Freedom of Religion: Student Rights at school.
THE ARGUMENTATIVE ESSAY Mr.Wilson – LMAC - English.
Ross Arnold, Winter 2015 Lakeside institute of Theology Responding to the New Atheists March 13, 2015.
Religious Liberty Found in the Constitution US History.
Evolution Education in America By Alex Fletcher. Historical Perspective  Rise of evolution education:  Birth of Evangelical creationism:
DOCUMENTARY BY BEN STEIN *WAS THE DOCTOR IN OSMOSIS JONES *PLAYED DR. NEWMAN IN THE MASK *PLAYED RUGG IN CASPER * HOST OF WIN BEN STEIN’S MONEY Expelled.
Elementary School Science: Emphasizing the Basics Presented by Frank H. Osborne, Ph. D. © 2015 EMSE 3123 Math and Science in Elem. Ed.
Creation: An Educational Perspective By Dr. Norman Geisler.
Which one of these animals is a fish? Evolution is known as "the unifying theory of biology" What does that mean?
Human Rights This concept lies at the heart of the United States political system and enables citizens and noncitizens to worship, speak, read and write.
Perspectives  After his auto accident, Richard’s memory loss is believed to be caused by damage to his brain’s hippocampus.
Was Darwin Wrong?. NO HOWEVER …. While Darwin was correct with his theory of natural selection – he was wrong about other ideas.
By Kyle Efken  Evolution is a huge scientific break through that explains much about the diversity of life on Earth.  It has opened new realms in the.
Speech Unit III: Intro to Debate!
EVOLUTION Which one of these animals is a fish? Evolution is known as "the unifying theory of biology" What does that mean?
The First Amendment: Freedom of Religion “Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”
THE ARGUMENTATIVE OR PERSUASIVE ESSAY Mr.Wilson – LMAC - English.
The word science comes from the Latin "scientia," meaning knowledge. Scientific Theories are not "tentative ideas" or "hunches". The word "theory" is often.
CREATION Genesis 1:1-2. In a broad sense, I would like to hear you reconcile creationism and the scientific evidence out there concerning such things.
EVOLUTIONARY THEORY AS A TEACHING TOOL IN UNDERGRADUATE SCIENCE COURSES FOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION MAJORS: SCIENTIFIC INQUIRY VERSUS INTELLIGNET DESIGN “THEORY”
First Amendment: Freedom of Religion We will look at each of these clauses of the First Amendment, the controversy and power struggles surrounding them.
Chapter 19: Civil Liberties: First Amendment Freedoms Section 2.
What Evolution is... And is Not.
Unalienable Rights and Freedom of Religion. Bill of Rights The first ten amendments of the Constitution. The Bill of Rights were added to the constitution.
Teaching Science Amidst Controversy Robert C. Newman Abstracts of Powerpoint Talks - newmanlib.ibri.org -newmanlib.ibri.org.
Ch. 13 sec 2 FREEDOM OF RELIGION Objective; Describe the parts of the First Amendment that guarantee religious freedom.
Freedom of Religion “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof… “Congress shall make.
What Rights Does the Bill of Rights Protect? Essential Question.
Approaches to Area Studies 1: A Preliminary Step for a Systematic Research I25022 Yoo Kyeong Wan.
Ethical theories tend to suggest a set of principles or rules than all human beings are bound by. Utilitarianism – the greatest good for the greatest.
Susan Epperson, et. al v. Arkansas. BACKGROUND Arkansas passes “anti-evolution” statute in 1928 Applies to teachers in state supported schools or universities.
The Longstanding Debate: Teaching Evolution in Public Schools.
POL 303 Week 2 Teaching Intelligent Design in the Public Schools Check this A+ tutorial guideline at
First Amendment Freedoms
C C is for Church. Religion in Education “a balancing act”
The scope and focus of the Research
First Amendment Freedoms
Science, Evolution, and Creationism
EVOLUTION Which one of these animals is a fish?
Dawkins’ The God Delusion: A Public Debate
I. RELIGION IN THE SCHOOLS
Is this statement meaningful?
..
Department of Environmental Sciences The University of Montana-Western
Pre-public exam revision
Misconception Three: Students should be taught “both sides” aka “The Equal Time” Argument Assumes there are only two sides Based on Christian (i.e. Biblical)
Professional Ethics Exercise Questions.
Presentation transcript:

The Almighty…Darwin? Alexis Tillett-Saks Beloit College In no other aspect do science and religion clash more fiercely than in the debate between creationism and evolution. It has been a philosophical debate ever since Darwin awed the world in the nineteenth century with his in-depth explanation of how we came to be. As religion continuously becomes more intertwined with American politics, the theory of origin debate moves into the realm of public education. What should our schools be teaching in the classroom: creationism or evolution? Is there a common ground that can be reached without violating the Establishment Clause that also respects the beliefs of our nation’s most popular religion? Religion has become more and more synonymous with politics over the last decade. With such hot topics as abortion, homosexuality, and stem cell research, the clash between religion and science has been at the forefront of our nation’s most severe political split in over a century. As thousands of young impressionable minds pour through public school doors every weekday, what should be taught when they sit at their desks, evolution or creationism? Evolutionists believe that there is no factual evidence that supports creationism. Therefore, it is not logical to teach it as a scientific theory; it is only based on faith and so should be taught in a classroom that expressly states its purpose as religious and not scientific. According to evolutionists, their theory is solely based on experimental evidence, which is what makes it a science and the only legitimate theory to be taught in our schools. The argument for evolution being taught in schools is not just approached from the scientific standpoint, but also a constitutional perspective. The Establishment Clause explicitly states that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion,” and so taxes cannot support a public school where any form of religion is taught. However, creationists argue the Establishment Clause from an "accommodationist” perspective, which states that as long as a classroom does not make any clear biases towards a particular religion, it is acceptable to teach religious theory. As evolution can not be proven, it is still only a theory like creationism. Creationists also believe the scientific debate between the two theories is tangible and relevant. Therefore a classroom should have to offer both sides of the debate. Neither one has been proven to the point of disproving the other. It is not necessarily from a religious standpoint that creationism be taught, but as a method to encourage students to be able to critically evaluate science and discover for themselves which point of view they find more convincing. Abstract Introduction -Both strive for a strong public education system. -Evolutionists strive to maintain the separation of church and state put forth in the Establishment Clause. -Evolutionists want to establish their belief not as a theory, but as fact. -Neither side considers abandoning their theory where each is respectively taught. -Creationists explain that evolution is simply a theory comparable to creationism. -Creationists interpret the Establishment Clause as meaning no single religion can be favored over another. Interests -Further judicial review should be conducted to determine whether creationism can be taught in a manner that does not breach separation of church and state in the public science classroom. -Public school boards should determine whether teaching both theories undermine the legitimacy of scientific fact, and in turn creates confusion for the students. -Studies should be conducted on both theories to see which one has more common ground with the field of science. -A survey should be done to determine what theory is more popular amongst Americans. Objective Criteria -Allow creationism to be taught but only in classes designated as “Religious Studies” classes. -Have teachers focus on evolution, but present the fact that there are a large portion of people who disagree with it. -Define evolution not as a scientific fact, but as an unproven theory. -Allow teachers to teach creationism, but cut federal funding to those schools. -Hold after-school lectures on creationism where students can choose to learn about the theory if they choose. -Let either each state, district, school, or teacher decide for themselves what they would like to teach. -Have some teachers in a school teach creationism while some teach evolution and let the student decide which class they would like to attend. Options REFERENCES Abramson, Paul. Creationism.org. 6 Feb Chavez, Miguel. The Unofficial Stephen Jay Gould Archive. 10 Jan Feb Dawkins, Richard. The Blind Watchmaker. New York: Norton, (For a full list of references, send request to: